Proposals for closing projects

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Requests and proposals Proposals for closing projects Archive 
Shortcut:
PCP
WM:PCP
This page lists current proposals to close or delete a project hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation. It is subject to the current closing projects policy.

Prior policy proposals:

Instructions:

  1. Before making a proposal for closing a project, please familiarize yourself with the applicable policy.
  2. List your proposal on a separate subpage.
  3. You can use the {{Closing project proposal}} template when making a request. Make sure that you add valid reasons (see policy) why the project is no longer useful to the Wikimedia Foundation, links to where the project is currently working at, and links to any discussions prior to its being listed on this page.
  4. Do not forget to warn the project itself and/or its language community in Wikimedia in the best possible way and add a link to it in the proposal. Proposals with no fair warnings to the projects will be ignored.
  5. These pages are for community input into the Language committee and Board's final decision. Providing reasons after your votes is encouraged and appreciated.

If this is not the first time a project has been nominated for closure, please compare prior discussions to the current situation and circumstances. Experience shows that repeating a failed proposal doesn't work.

Please note that closing a project does not necessarily mean deleting it completely and removing it from the SiteMatrix. The project will be locked for editing and other actions, except by stewards and system administrators. Appropriate content may be merged into another existing Wikimedia project, or content having potential for use in a future Wikimedia project may be imported to the Incubator, along with its contribution history. Alternatively, it may be exported to a non-Wikimedia host subject to GFDL and CC-BY-SA licenses. Potentially useful content is retained long enough to allow migration to happen. Any proposal to actually delete a project should clearly state that intent.

  • Archive (for archived discussions removed from this page)

Contents

Comment

The new Closing projects policy has been adopted by the Language committee and approved by the Board.
Warning: A local announcement on the wiki in question must be added as well.


[edit] Please add new requests to the END of the table below.


Proposal Request date Status
Kazakh Wikibooks 2 20-Jul-2011 Under review by LangCom and/or Board with proposed outcome: close
Hebrew Wikinews - 2nd request 31-Aug-2011 Under review by LangCom and/or Board with proposed outcome: keep
Bosnian Wikinews - 2nd proposal 21-Sep-2011 Under review by LangCom and/or Board with proposed outcome: keep
wikipedia ten 04-Oct-2011 accepted
nzwikimedia 02-Jan-2012 Community discussion is in progress.
Romany wikipedia 12-Jan-2012 Community discussion is in progress.
[edit] Recently closed proposals
Language Project Request date For Against Score Status
Amharic Wikiquote 2010011111 January 2010 3 9 -6 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Twi Wikipedia 2010011616 January 2010 9 21 -12 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Kirundi Wikipedia 2010011818 January 2010 10 17 -7 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Fiji Wikipedia 2010012222 January 2010 17 18 -1 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Luxembourgish Wiktionary 2010031010 March 2010 8 13 -5 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Māori Wiktionary 2010042121 April 2010 5 11 -6 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Sotho Wikipedia 2010042222 April 2010 0 10 -10 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Fulan Wikipedia 201006022 June 2010 5 9 -4 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Old English Wikibooks 2010101010 October 2010 6 8 -2 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Kazakh Wikibooks 2010102222 October 2010 7 3 +4 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Kyrgyz Wikiquote 2010102727 October 2010 4 1 +3 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Kannada Wikiquote 2010102727 October 2010 4 16 -12 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Faroese Wikisource 201011044 November 2010 4 5 -1 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Moldovan Wikipedia 2011012424 January 2011 10 4 +6 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Uzbek Wikibooks 2011031616 March 2011 0 0 0 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Kashmiri Wiktionary 2011033131 March 2011 0 0 0 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Belarusian Wikibooks 2011042121 April 2011 1 4 -3 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Min-Nan Wikisource 2007071616 July 2007 0 0 0 Discussion was closed (New policy in place).
Project Request date Result
Xitsonga Wikipedia 18-Jul-2011 Rejected, project is kept open.
Scots Wikipædia 21-Aug-2011 Rejected, project is kept open.
Inuktitut Wikipedia 2 01-Jul-2011 Rejected, project is kept open.
Asturianu Wikibooks 02-Jul-2011 Approved.
Old English Wikipedia 03-Jul-2011 Rejected, project is kept open.
Acehnese Wikipedia (4) 15-Oct-2011 Rejected, project is kept open.
Fiji Wikipedia 2 05-Nov-2011 Rejected, project is kept open.
Other closed proposals are listed on Proposals for closing projects/Archive.

Votes confirmation is a measure developed by Irpen. He proposed that only votes from people who already had registered account in any of the Wikimedia projects by the time when the discussion started are taken into consideration. To verify or "confirm" the vote, according to his proposition each user should write his Meta account username on his talkpage in local project, take the diff link of this edit and place it on his userpage here in Meta. After that all votes by this user in discussions which started after this user's registration in local project are considered "confirmed".

If votes confirmation was not used for some discussion all non-anonymous votes are considered confirmed. Note that there is no need to write two values ("total (confirmed)") into this table in such a case.

Personal tools
Variants
Actions
Navigation
Community
Beyond the Web
Print/export
Toolbox