Talk:Spam blacklist

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
(Redirected from WM:SBL)
Jump to: navigation, search
Requests and proposals Spam blacklist Archives (current)→
The associated page is used by the MediaWiki Spam Blacklist extension, and lists regular expressions which cannot be used in URLs in any page in Wikimedia Foundation projects (as well as many external wikis). Any meta administrator can edit the spam blacklist; either manually or with SBHandler. For more information on what the spam blacklist is for, and the processes used here, please see Spam blacklist/About.
Proposed additions
Please provide evidence of spamming on several wikis and prior blacklisting on at least one. Spam that only affects a single project should go to that project's local blacklist. Exceptions include malicious domains and URL redirector/shortener services. Please follow this format. Please check back after submitting your report, there could be questions regarding your request.
Proposed removals
Please check our list of requests which repeatedly get declined. Typically, we do not remove domains from the spam blacklist in response to site-owners' requests. Instead, we de-blacklist sites when trusted, high-volume editors request the use of blacklisted links because of their value in support of our projects. Please consider whether requesting whitelisting on a specific wiki for a specific use is more appropriate - that is very often the case.
Other discussion
Troubleshooting and problems - If there is an error in the blacklist (i.e. a regex error) which is causing problems, please raise the issue here.
Discussion - Meta-discussion concerning the operation of the blacklist and related pages, and communication among the spam blacklist team.
#wikimedia-external-linksconnect - Real-time IRC chat for co-ordination of activities related to maintenance of the blacklist.

Please sign your posts with ~~~~ after your comment. This leaves a signature and timestamp so conversations are easier to follow.


Completed requests are marked as {{added}}/{{removed}} or {{declined}}, and are generally archived quickly. Additions and removals are logged · current log 2014/09.

Projects
Information
List of all projects
Overviews
Reports
Wikimedia Embassy
Project portals
Country portals
Tools
Spam blacklist
Title blacklist
Vandalism reports
Closure of wikis
Interwiki map
Requests
Permissions
Bot flags
Logos
New languages
New projects
Username changes
Usurpation request
Translations
Speedy deletions
[edit]

snippet for logging
{{sbl-log|10050187#{{subst:anchorencode:SectionNameHere}}}}


Proposed additions[edit]

Symbol comment vote.svg This section is for proposing that a website be blacklisted; add new entries at the bottom of the section, using the basic URL so that there is no link (example.com, not http://www.example.com). Provide links demonstrating widespread spamming by multiple users on multiple wikis. Completed requests will be marked as {{added}} or {{declined}} and archived.

flaturl.com[edit]



URL shortener. MER-C (talk) 08:09, 21 September 2014 (UTC)

Added Added -- — billinghurst sDrewth 10:30, 21 September 2014 (UTC)

my.rs[edit]



URL shortener. MER-C (talk) 11:10, 30 September 2014 (UTC)

Added Added --Glaisher (talk) 11:12, 30 September 2014 (UTC)

Proposed additions (Bot reported)[edit]

Symbol comment vote.svg This section is for domains which have been added to multiple wikis as observed by a bot.

These are automated reports, please check the records and the link thoroughly, it may report good links! For some more info, see Spam blacklist/Help#COIBot_reports. Reports will automatically be archived by the bot when they get stale (less than 5 links reported, which have not been edited in the last 7 days, and where the last editor is COIBot).

Sysops
  • If the report contains links to less than 5 wikis, then only add it when it is really spam
  • Otherwise just revert the link-additions, and close the report; closed reports will be reopened when spamming continues
  • To close a report, change the LinkStatus template to closed ({{LinkStatus|closed}})
  • Please place any notes in the discussion section below the HTML comment

COIBot[edit]

The LinkWatchers report domains meeting the following criteria:

  • When a user mainly adds this link, and the link has not been used too much, and this user adds the link to more than 2 wikis
  • When a user mainly adds links on one server, and links on the server have not been used too much, and this user adds the links to more than 2 wikis
  • If ALL links are added by IPs, and the link is added to more than 1 wiki
  • If a small range of IPs have a preference for this link (but it may also have been added by other users), and the link is added to more than 1 wiki.
COIBot's currently open XWiki reports
List Last update By Site IP R Last user Last link addition User Link User - Link User - Link - Wikis Link - Wikis

Proposed removals[edit]

Symbol comment vote.svg This section is for proposing that a website be unlisted; please add new entries at the bottom of the section.

Remember to provide the specific domain blacklisted, links to the articles they are used in or useful to, and arguments in favour of unlisting. Completed requests will be marked as {{removed}} or {{declined}} and archived.

See also /recurring requests for repeatedly proposed (and refused) removals.

Notes:

  • The addition or removal of a domain from the blacklist is not a vote; please do not bold the first words in statements.
  • This page is for the removal of domains from the global blacklist, not for removal of domains from the blacklists of individual wikis. For those requests please take your discussion to the pertinent wiki, where such requests would be made at Mediawiki talk:Spam-blacklist at that wiki. Search spamlists — remember to enter any relevant language code

pro-d.ru[edit]



fall.pro-d.ru is a fan site of the game The Fall: Last Days of Gaia, there are no other sites in this 2nd level domain. The site got blacklisted because of the way too broad regex \bpro-(?!(goroda|speleo)).*?\.ru\b (originally \bpro-*?\.ru\b) which blocks all domains in .ru zone that start with "pro-". Effectively it blocks every Russian site that has "professional" or "about" it its name.

We can look to making changes. That said, not sure that fan sites are welcome in the Wikipedias. I know that enWP specifically excludes them. It would be good to have some feedback from ruWP about the proposal to remove, as, from memory, it was a problematic spam time.  — billinghurst sDrewth 08:38, 11 July 2014 (UTC)

tezukainenglish.com[edit]



This is fan-run website that works in conjunction with the official (Japanese) Tezuka website. It has been a reliable source since at least 2007. The website recently underwent some reconstruction, but it appears that an IP who sourced the characters and relevant part for Wikipedia, many years ago, was the reason to Blacklist it in August 2014. Please remove it from the blacklist. ChrisGualtieri (talk) 19:11, 5 September 2014 (UTC)

Fan sites are not authoritative, see w:en:Wikipedia:External links. This domain was added due to a spambot repeatedly trying to add the url, and I see no reason to remove it with the recent history.  — billinghurst sDrewth 09:28, 6 September 2014 (UTC)
That reasoning does not make any sense when the Wikiproject has been content with such links for 7 years and that it has official approval from the Tezuka operators. Seems quite arbitrary and I have not seen evidence of recent abuse. Could you provide that? ChrisGualtieri (talk) 15:54, 8 September 2014 (UTC)
You can also look for local whitelisting if you want this to be used at English Wikipedia - en:WT:SWL. --Glaisher (talk) 16:20, 8 September 2014 (UTC)
Has this been an issue on any other Wiki other than Enwiki? I think I was the last person to actually add the link back in last year. The entire blacklisting seems to have been done because of an account that actually appears to be by an IP that points to a prominent A&M editor who is known for using IP addresses. If the issue is from 7 years ago, asking for a reason other than "bot flagged" be given here. ChrisGualtieri (talk) 21:51, 11 September 2014 (UTC)
When it was blocked ... it was attempted to be added by spambots crosswiki. It was attempted to be added by spambots crosswiki. It was attempted to be added by spambots crosswiki. That was said above, and I am not certain how to say it any more simply.
Much of this is jargon to me and I didn't understand where or what was being attempted. I thought my addition some months ago was being used to blacklist the site, but I guess it was some spammer attempting to flood it? I never seen this - but I guess its resolved. Thanks. ChrisGualtieri (talk) 04:08, 13 September 2014 (UTC)

g.co[edit]



Please remove g.co. It is used for internal google links, and it is used on thousands of articles on English Wikipedia. There is no acceptable reason to block such a heavily used external link without wide discussion. - Floydian (talk) 14:50, 8 September 2014 (UTC)

Removed Removed as this link is heavily used on hundreds of pages xwiki and will prevent many valid edits. Moreover, it's only a shortener for Google's websites. --Glaisher (talk) 14:59, 8 September 2014 (UTC)
Thank you :) Now I just have to revert a few thousand edits by cyberbot![1] - Floydian (talk) 15:10, 8 September 2014 (UTC)
I commented earlier on this link - although it is specific for google services, it is still a redirect (meaning that you don't always know where you go, and also that one could use that inappropriately). Although I agree that this is one of the less sensitive redirect services, I'd still advice that Wikipedia should get rid of them (I would consider an expansion bot on them). Then re-consider; on en.wikipedia, en:WP:ELNEVER prohibits their use - they cannot be (or are not) used to shorten the google.com/url?-'search-engine-internal-statistics'-redirect, right? --Dirk Beetstra T C (en: U, T) 09:24, 9 September 2014 (UTC)

barcosbarcelona.com[edit]



This is blocked by a dedicated regex (i.e. \bbarcosbarcelona\.com\b), but this deny me to complete the translation of the en:voy article into the new it:voy one. Can it be removed since is the official website of Alquiler de Yates en Mallorca? Thanks, --Andyrom75 (talk) 09:38, 25 September 2014 (UTC)

The link has been problematic for over 2 years, about 3 years ago. I would suggest to ask for local whitelisting on the it.wikivoyage, it is only of interest to wikivoyage articles (and only to those that exist), not to the hundreds of other wikis. (This boils down again to the age-old problem for which an already long due overhaul of the Spam blacklist is needed (and suggested years ago on Bugzilla): what is really spam on wikipedia/wiktionary/wikiversity is not necessarily spam on wikivoyage (swap wiki-types around as desired), a wikisubfarm-wide-blacklist/whitelist system or other systems could solve that). --Dirk Beetstra T C (en: U, T) 11:22, 25 September 2014 (UTC)
The means of this addition is simply spam, and that level of abuse probably should not given credibility and be on our blacklist. There are consequences for that sort of action.  — billinghurst sDrewth 12:35, 25 September 2014 (UTC)

Troubleshooting and problems[edit]

Symbol comment vote.svg This section is for comments related to problems with the blacklist (such as incorrect syntax or entries not being blocked), or problems saving a page because of a blacklisted link. This is not the section to request that an entry be unlisted (see Proposed removals above).

SBHandler broken[edit]

SBHandler seems to be broken - both Glaisher and I had problems that it stops after the closing of the thread on this page, but before the actual blacklisting. Do we have someone knowledgeable who can look into why this does not work? --Dirk Beetstra T C (en: U, T) 04:08, 30 April 2014 (UTC)

User:Erwin - pinging you as the developer. --Dirk Beetstra T C (en: U, T) 04:16, 30 April 2014 (UTC)

FYI when you created this section with the name "SBHandler", you prevented SBHandler from being loaded at all (see MediaWiki:Gadget-SBHandler.js "Guard against double inclusions"). Of course, changing the heading won't fix the original issue you mentioned. But at least it will load now. PiRSquared17 (talk) 15:30, 18 June 2014 (UTC)

Closed Closed

Discussion[edit]

Symbol comment vote.svg This section is for discussion of Spam blacklist issues among other users.