Talk:Requests for comment/Activity levels of advanced administrative rights holders: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
fix enwikt |
|||
| Line 86: | Line 86: | ||
=== Wiktionaries === |
=== Wiktionaries === |
||
* '''cs.wiktionary''' policy: removal after 6 months without logged action |
* '''cs.wiktionary''' policy: removal after 6 months without logged action |
||
* '''en.wiktionary''' policy: removal by vote. |
|||
* '''fr.wiktionary''' policy: removal after 1-2 years without any activity ([[wikt:fr:WT:Prise de décision/Retrait des fonctions d'administrateur et de bot|policy]]) |
* '''fr.wiktionary''' policy: removal after 1-2 years without any activity ([[wikt:fr:WT:Prise de décision/Retrait des fonctions d'administrateur et de bot|policy]]) |
||
* '''ja.wiktionary''' Administrators are re-elected or de-sysop'ed annually ([[:ja:wikt:Wiktionary:管理者|policy]]). Automatic removal may take place after 3-month inactivity with no local edits, though it is rarely enforced ([[ja:wikt:Wiktionary:管理者権限の返上|policy]]). |
* '''ja.wiktionary''' Administrators are re-elected or de-sysop'ed annually ([[:ja:wikt:Wiktionary:管理者|policy]]). Automatic removal may take place after 3-month inactivity with no local edits, though it is rarely enforced ([[ja:wikt:Wiktionary:管理者権限の返上|policy]]). |
||
| Line 122: | Line 123: | ||
===Wiktionaries=== |
===Wiktionaries=== |
||
* '''de.wiktionary''' has no inactivity policy |
* '''de.wiktionary''' has no inactivity policy |
||
* '''en.wiktionary'''—has a list of inactive admins, but doesn't de-sysop routinely; occasionally holds a vote for an individual. |
|||
* '''fa.wiktionary''' has no inactivity policy |
* '''fa.wiktionary''' has no inactivity policy |
||
* '''vi.wiktionary''' has no formal removal process. Administrators are [[wikt:vi:Wiktionary:Bảo quản viên#Những người bảo quản hiện nay|tracked by last edit]]. |
* '''vi.wiktionary''' has no formal removal process. Administrators are [[wikt:vi:Wiktionary:Bảo quản viên#Những người bảo quản hiện nay|tracked by last edit]]. |
||
Revision as of 07:17, 25 April 2013
Compiled list of wikis with admin review processes
 | Admins and other rights holders on these wikis would not be affected by this proposal. This list of examples is incomplete.
Please add relevant wikis and if possible a link to the relevant page at that wiki, the specific detail is interesting for comparison, though not required. |
Special provision rights
- Stewards — yearly confirmation
- Checkusers — 12 month activity requirement
- Oversight — 12 month activity requirement
- Global sysops – 6 month logged GS action requirement
Multilingual projects
- Commons – De-adminship
- Meta – Meta:Administrators/Removal
- Incubator – incubator:I:A#Administrators: removal after 12 months of nearly no logs/edits
- Wikidata's inactivity policy will be finalized in July or August 2013; for conduct-related issues it has d:WD:RfRemoval.
Wikibooks
- cs.wikibooks policy: removal after 6 months without logged action
- en.wikibooks - Deadminship
- es.wikibooks - Inactivity policy (any administrator, bureaucrat, checkuser or oversighter which has gone inactive for a continued period of two years will have all permissions removed. Inactivity is no edits and no log actions for that 2 years period)
- vi.wikibooks has a recall process for inactive administrators. However, only one user has ever been given permanent rights; the rest are given temporary rights by Meta stewards.
- sv.wikibooks - Inactivity policy, one year.
Wikinews
- Wikinewses with Arbitration Committees: currently only en
- zh.wikinews has inactivity removal policy for administrators and bureaucrats inactive for 6 months, and continued to be absent 1 month after notification.
- cs.wikinews policy: removal after 6 months without logged action
- el.wikinews no policy so far with no inactive sysops either.
Wikipedias
- Wikipedias with Arbitration Committees: cs, de, en, fi, fr, ko, nl, pl, ru, th, uk
- als.wikipedia policy: removal after 1 year of inactivity
- ar.wikipedia policy: removal after 6 months of inactivity (but the admin must be informed before removal).
- bar.wikipedia policy: removal after 1 year of inactivity
- cs.wikipedia policy: removal after half year without logged action
- da.wikipedia policy: removal after 6+1 months of inactivity
- de.wikipedia policy: removal after 1 year of inactivity and 90 days after notification. In addition, there is a re-election process: If 25 editors within three months, or 50 within six months, sign that they feel an admin should stand for re-election, the admin has the choice of either standing for re-election or standing down.
- en.wikipedia has its own removal process outside of ArbCom: w:en:Wikipedia:Inactive administrators
- For Checkusers and Oversighters, there is a minimum activity expectation that is reviewed quarterly. The main reason for removal of Checkuser or Oversight permission is inactivity.
- eo.wikipedia: 1 year since last contribution (not necessarily administrative), must first be announced on the village pump and the administrator's talk page. eo:Vikipedio:Administrantoj#Maladministrantigo
- es.wikipedia fewer than fifty administrative actions for a period of two years (policy link).
- fa.wikipedia 1 year of inactivity
- fi.wikipedia 1 year of inactivity, own request or community vote (60% approval to remove adminship).
- fr.wikipedia policy: suspended status after six months of inactivity, removal after one more year.
- frr.wikipedia policy: removal after 6 months of inactivity upon discussion and de-sysop voting (no automatic de-sysoping)
- it.wikipedia annual reconfirmations, removal after six months with no use
- ja.wikipedia 3-month inactivity with no local edits and no sysop actions. (policy)
- ksh.wikipedia policy: removal after 1 year of inactivity
- ms.wikipedia policy: removal after 1 year of inactivity (notice must be given before removal).
- nl.wikipedia
- Sysops: annual reconfirmation, automatic removal if less than 250 edits are made in the past 12 months.
- Arbitration committee: Each year all 7 positions (in two groups each six months) are up for election. Old members would need to be re-elected the same way as new candidates.
- Checkusers: Chosen by the arbitration committee for infinitive time. The arbitration committee can also decide to revoke the checkuser rights.
- Oversight: nl-wiki does not have own oversight users.
- Bureaucrats: Bureaucrats rights are revoked when the bureaucrats sysop rights are revoked.
- no.wikipedia All admins/crats are re-elected or desysoped every 24 months.
- pl.wikipedia: sysops only: removal after 1 year of inactivity, with two weeks' notice
- pt.wikipedia: policy: removal after 6 months of inactivity, with one weeks' notice
- ro.wikipedia Sysops and bureaucrats are revoked if inactive for over a year.
- ru.wikipedia Sysop access may be revoked if less than 100 edits and 25 sysop actions are made during last 6 months
- simple.wikipedia policy: removal at end of calendar year if <100 administrative actions or edits
- sk.wikipedia sk:Wikipédia:Pravidlá/Pravidlo_o_správcoch#Nez.C3.A1ujem_o_v.C3.BDkon_funkcie 4 mounths without user edit or admin action
- sv.wikipedia has a formal process maintained every three months for admins/crats/CU/OS, which is a part of the re-election-process for all users once a year.
- sr.wikipedia If an administrator within one year doesn't make any logged action for which he or she needs sysop tools, sysop rights will be removed automatically.
- vi.wikipedia has a seldom-used recall process but no automatic removal process for inactive administrators. Administrators are listed as inactive after one year without edits.
- zh.wikipedia has inactivity removal policy for administrators and bureaucrats inactive for 6 months, and continued to be absent 1 month after notification.
Wikiquotes
- en.wikiquote has no automatic review of inactivity, but has a Vote of Confidence process.
- cs.wikiquote policy: removal after 6 months without logged action
- de.wikiquote policy: removal after one year of inactivity and no response within 2 weeks after notification
Wikisources
- en.wikisource annual confirmation process s:en:Wikisource:Restricted access policy
- cs.wikisource policy: removal after 6 months without logged action
- sv.wikisource has a continous procedure (a bot is every week updating a page) for all local userrights, bots and autopatrollers are included.
- pl.wikisource removal after 12 months of inactivity s:pl:Wikiźródła:Odbieranie uprawnień
Wikiversities
Wikivoyages
- en.wikivoyage has automatic removal by bureaucrats after 2 years. voy:en:Wikivoyage:Administrators
- es.wikivoyage has inactivity removal policy after 1 year. Inactivity is no edits and no log actions (policy link).
Wiktionaries
- cs.wiktionary policy: removal after 6 months without logged action
- en.wiktionary policy: removal by vote.
- fr.wiktionary policy: removal after 1-2 years without any activity (policy)
- ja.wiktionary Administrators are re-elected or de-sysop'ed annually (policy). Automatic removal may take place after 3-month inactivity with no local edits, though it is rarely enforced (policy).
- pt.wiktionary inactive administrators loose their rights after 6 months with less than 10 edits per month. The user can request their tools back without the need of a new vote if they wish to return to activity (policy).
Compiled list of wikis without admin review processes
| Admins and other rights holders on these wikis probably would be affected by this proposal. This list of examples is incomplete. Please correct any errors. |
Multilingual projects
- outreach has no inactivity policy, though bureaucrats can desysop.
- testwiki had an inactivity policy, but it was repealed. Although testwiki and test2wiki are technically under the aegis of the stewards, they most likely should not be affected by a global inactivity policy.
Wikibooks
- de.wikibooks - has a list of inactive admins, but doesn't de-sysop; a vote regarding an individual is possible, though.
- fa.wikibooks has no inactivity policy
Wikinews
- fa.wikinews has no inactivity policy
Wikipedias
- Most or all of the very small Wikipedias
- bg.wikipedia - policy has been only under discussion, but not voted. All purposes of removing the rights of unactive admins were rejected by the community.
- hsb.wikipedia - has no such policy
- lb.wikipedia
- nds.wikipedia
- pfl.wikipedia
Wikiquotes
- en.wikiquote has no inactivity policy, but has a Vote of Confidence process.
- es.wikiquote has no deadminship process nor tracking of activity.
- fa.wikiquote has no inactivity policy
- nl.wikiquote has no inactivity policy; no review process; no formal de-admin process
Wikisources
- fa.wikisource has no inactivity policy
Wiktionaries
- de.wiktionary has no inactivity policy
- fa.wiktionary has no inactivity policy
- vi.wiktionary has no formal removal process. Administrators are tracked by last edit.
Wikiversities
- de.wikiversity tolerates admin inactivity expressly.
- en.wikiversity has no inactivity policy
- pt.wikiversity tolerates admin inactivity but has no formal policy, is moving to make it explicit in response to this RfC.
Wikivoyages
- ru.wikivoyage has no inactivity policy
Mark for translation
I'd like to mark some of this page (at least the "Proposal" section) for translation. It would help more people to understand what is being proposed. Any objections? PiRSquared17 (talk) 19:05, 20 April 2013 (UTC)
- Maybe on a subpage? Marking a page for translation which is also edited constantly in other (the comment) sections is a bit annoying, IMHO, because the page will then always have a notice of having been changed etc. --MF-W 19:23, 20 April 2013 (UTC)
- Good idea. I'll try to do that. PiRSquared17 (talk) 19:23, 20 April 2013 (UTC)