Category talk:Demo

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

List, for comparison with the category:

South Holland, the most crowded province


Related Changes:

They are the same, except that the changes in both image pages are not on the Related Changes page for this list page.

Categories miss a major feature of lists: removal of a page from the category is not detected without having all these pages in advance on one's watchlist. For a list one can look in the page history.

Also categories cannot list non-existing pages.

In particular for the English Wikipedia another disadvantage of categories is that they are often not in mirror sites; sometimes they are, but only the editable parts.