Jump to content

Automatic outdents on discussion pages (Community Wishlist/W289/en)

Long-term opportunity
From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
This page is a translated version of the page Automatic outdents on discussion pages (Community Wishlist/W289) and the translation is 100% complete.

View all wishes.

Description

On discussion forums, one may reply to posts, which are then indented (with a colon at the beginning of each line) underneath the comment being replied to. In longer discussions, it may be difficult to fit all the indented comments on one screen, where some take use of templates that arrange for outdents that continue from the indented comments (e.g. Template:Outdent here on Meta-Wiki).

It's a little awkward to use these templates, especially when using the visual editor. There are also many different screens that read discussions (computer screens, cell phones). It would therefore be nice to have outdents be automatically placed where the screen doesn't entirely make room for a comment. This would also make it easier for contributors that aren't entirely familiar with indents and outdents to not place them in the wrong spot. Indents are beginning to get better, as they are automatically placed when using the visual discussion tool (default, I believe?).

Some concerns are that the outdents have to place the text in the right place, that it is clear which comment is being replied to, and that other templates and media are considered when placing the outdents.

Assigned focus area

Unassigned

Type of wish
Feature request
Tags
Affected users

Editors and others that discuss and/or read discussions

Other details
  • Created: 20:02, 15 September 2024
  • Last updated: 21:56, 10 October 2025
  • Author: EdoAug (talk)
Voting

This wish currently has 2 supporters. Voting for this wish is open until it is completed.

Supporters of this wish
Support EdoAug (talk) 20:02, 15 September 2024
Support W368: Fix the issues breaking the Reply tool is also about this by calling for the issues in the Reply tool, which does auto-indentation, to be fixed and then that to be made the way to reply to posts instead of wikitext editing. Doing so would implement automatic outdents and I don't see another or better way for implementing this wish other than that (if so that should be specified in a new wish or here). Prototyperspective (talk) 13:44, 22 October 2025