Jump to content

反向(逆向)部分封禁 (Community Wishlist/W353/zh)

Near-term opportunity
From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
This page is a translated version of the page Community Wishlist/W353 and the translation is 89% complete.
Outdated translations are marked like this.

View all wishes.

Description

问题:有些情况下,某些用户应该被封禁,但对于特定页面/命名空间可以例外。潜在的用户案例包括:

  • 仲裁委员会(ArbCom)案件——这些案件通常涉及有问题的用户,这些用户有时会在案件开设期间的某些时间段内被封禁;但他们仍然应该被允許对自己的案件发表评论。
  • 获得第二次机会的用户——如果一个被封禁为破坏性账号的用户请求解封,那么我们有时会给予他们第二次机会:向我们展示你能改善某篇文章,我们就会解封你。不幸的是,用户唯一可以做到这一点的地方是他们自己的讨论页。如果我们能给用户一个子页面进行操作,这将使这一过程更为简单。
  • 关于解封的讨论——有时,我们会在用户自己的讨论页之外的地方进行这样的讨论,比如管理员布告版。如果用户能直接在这些地方回应,将会更加方便。
  • 有时,管理员认为被封禁的用户对于正在进行的讨论至关重要,并会将该用户在其讨论页上的评论复制到公共讨论中。在这种情况下,如果用户能直接在讨论中回复,将会更加便捷。
  • 已证明不适合参与项目空间工作的编辑者(例如模板、维基百科等),但仍然能够编辑條目。

提议的解决方案:由于我们已有部分封禁工具,为什么不允许管理员配置设置,封禁XXX页面以外所有编辑(类似反向复选框),而不是现在的(仅封禁XXX页面)。即,反向部分封禁,设置全站封禁的例外,而不是当前封禁的页面。这将是部分封禁工具的一个附加功能。

Assigned focus area

Unassigned

Type of wish
Feature request
Tags
Affected users

管理员与被封禁用户

Phabricator tasks
Other details
  • Created: 21:05, 17 January 2025
  • Last updated: 19:37, 11 October 2025
  • Author: Barkeep49 (talk)
Voting

This wish currently has 3 supporters. Voting for this wish is open until it is completed.

Supporters of this wish
Support Pppery (talk) 15:56, 10 October 2025
Support This is one where I think it depends on how difficult it would be to implement. Desirable, but not worth a really major investment if the current implementation has kind of painted us into a corner. Jmabel (talk) 07:39, 5 December 2025
Support The points from my proposal over a year ago here still stand. SHB2000 (talk) 02:46, 10 January 2026