EU policy/2018 European Parliament vote
For more information on the proposed law itself, see Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market
This is a project page to determine what action is required on the part of the Wikipedia community regarding the Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market and our response to it (if any). A blog post by the Wikimedia Foundation legal team, copied below, outlines the legal understanding. The Wikimedia Foundation has additionally produced two statements on the EU directive proposal:
- Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees Statement Opposing the EU Copyright Package
- Wikimedia Foundation Statement: How the EU copyright proposal will hurt the web and Wikipedia
The Wikimedia Foundation is going to support whatever action the community decides to take.
June 29th 2018
Below is a copy of a post, made by the General Counsel of the Wikimedia Foundation Eileen B. Hershenov. Versions are available in other languages at the link.
A proposed new copyright package in the European Union is a threat to our fundamental right to freely share information. The time to speak out is now.
By Eileen B. Hershenov
Wikimedia is an integral part of a large movement of civil society stakeholders, technologists, creators, and human rights defenders, who all recognize the importance of a free and open web for culture, progress, and democracy. Our movement is working to promote freedom online for the benefit of all. Our efforts in this public policy realm are all the more important in an era of increasing restrictions on free speech and free access to knowledge across the globe, which directly threaten the mission and vision of Wikimedia and its projects, such as Wikipedia.
This is why we strongly oppose the proposed EU Copyright Directives and urge the Members of the European Parliament to reconsider proceeding with the version recently adopted by the Legal Affairs Committee. We are concerned because these flawed proposals hurt everyone’s rights to freedom of expression and Europe’s ability to improve the welfare of its citizens online.
Next week, we expect the European Parliament to vote in plenary on whether to proceed with the version adopted by the Committee. If the Members of the European Parliament reject it, there will be another opportunity to fix much of the current proposal’s broken requirements. Now may be the last opportunity to improve the directive.
We oppose this EU copyright package because of its detrimental effects on internet freedom, access to knowledge, and collaboration online. We believe that:
- The requirement for platforms to implement upload filters is a serious threat for freedom of expression and privacy. Our foundational vision depends on the free exchange of knowledge across the entirety of the web, and beyond the boundaries of the Wikimedia projects.
- A new exclusive right allowing press publishers to restrict the use of news snippets will make it more difficult to access and share information about current events in the world, making it harder for Wikipedia contributors to find citations for articles online.
- The proposal does not support user rights, is missing strong safeguards for the public domain, and does not create exceptions that would truly empower people to participate in research and culture.
We believe that enactment of this copyright package will significantly decrease in the amount of content that will be freely accessible to all across the globe. The costs involved in preemptively filtering content that may violate broad conceptions of copyright are likely also to lead to concentration of content determinations in a small number of large platforms.
The Wikimedia movement has opposed the flawed proposal for copyright reform since the first disappointing draft was first presented almost two years ago, after initially encouraging preparatory steps. Early on, we warned about the implications of imposing upload filters and called for urgently needed safeguards for the public domain. More recently, we wrote about the negative effects of mandatory automatic content detection on collaboration and freedom of expression.
Wikimedia communities around the world have been actively opposing the EU copyright package. In May, German and Bulgarian Wikipedia communities ran banners opposing Article 13 of the copyright proposal. Several European Wikimedia user organizations, including Wikimedia chapters in France, Estonia, Germany, Denmark, and Spain, took part in a Day of Action against the copyright package on June 12, writing blog posts and tweeting under the hashtag #SaveYourInternet. The German chapter has even organized an event in the streets of Berlin and more language communities are currently debating how to engage.
The proposal is a serious threat to our mission as it fails to truly modernize copyright and ensure the law keeps up with reality. Wikimedia can only achieve its mission when everyone is able to share information freely and contribute to the collection of knowledge on Wikipedia and its sister projects, and when we support such freedom and openness. The copyright proposal conflicts with that mission.
Although Wikimedia operates non-commercial websites, which may benefit from exemptions in certain parts of the EU copyright package, our overarching mission is heavily dependent on a free and open internet ecosystem.
We strongly urge the European Parliament to reject this bad copyright package in the vote next week and reconsider the opportunity to create a balanced and forward-looking law. It’s not too late: you can help stop this bad proposal. Take action by contacting your Member of European Parliament at changecopyright.org, and spread the word in your circles and on social media!
Eileen B. Hershenov, General Counsel
Other positions - Wikimedia Chapters
- Wir lassen uns das freie Netz nicht nehmen! (June 20, 2018)
- La riforma UE sul copyright mette a repentaglio la libertà di informazione e di panorama: salviamo il web che tutti amiamo! (June 21, 2018)
- Wikimedia Polska Board resolution (June 19, 2018)
Other positions - English-speaking world
- Electronic Frontier Foundation (April 10th, 2018) *— Electronic Frontier Foundation, a well known Internet civil liberties organization from the U.S.
- Liberties (Oct 16, 2017) — Civil Liberties Union for Europe (a German NGO) open letter with many signatories
- Mozilla — Call MEPs to reject article 13; from the Mozilla Foundation, best known for their role in creating the Firefox browser
- Create Refresh — The Creators Network, a graphical page on the opposition with individual profiles and social media links
- European Digital Rights (EDRi) coalition: see June 20 press release, strategic information, and a guest editorial from Wikimedia general counsel
- Creative Commons, known for the free-use licenses seen all over the web, made statements on March 28, March 29 and June 20
- Julia Reda (Pirate Party Germany) — Julia Reda, German MEP and an outspoken opponent of the proposal
What you can do
- Add concrete resources here, who to call, who to write to, etc...
Take action by contacting your Member of European Parliament via changecopyright.org, and spread the word in your circles and on social media! The hashtag #SaveYourInternet can be used on social media. See also SaveYourInternet.eu.
- Discussion of a neutrally worded banner on EN WP.
As of noon UTC July 2, 2018 there is strong numerical consensus for banner option 1 and 3. And consensus against "no banner" and option 2.
- Option 1
- Option 3
- Please add further comments and questions on this legislation below