Grants:Project/Rapid/LGBT/Wiki Loves Pride Featured Picture drive 2016

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
statuswithdrawn
LGBT/Wiki Loves Pride Featured Picture drive
Extend the regular WM-LGBT+ Wiki Loves Pride campaign with a drive for high quality photographs from Pride events and other LGBT+ cultural related images released to Wikimedia Commons and encourage a jump in the numbers of LGBT+ cultural related photographs nominated for Featured Picture on all Wikimedia projects.
targetWikimedia Commons and all language Wikipedias with Featured Picture projects.
start date1 August November
start year2016
end date31 January October
end year2017
budget (local currency)600
budget (USD)600
grant typeIndividual
non-profit statusNot incorporated
grantee
contact(s)• Fæ• Funcrunch
organization (if applicable)• Wikimedia LGBT+
website (if applicable)LGBT
join
endorse


Project Goal[edit]

Brighton Pride 2013 (9431939102).jpg
Brighton Pride photograph uploaded as part of the LGBT Free Media Collective campaign.
  1. Add to the highest quality LGBT+ photographs on Wikimedia Commons and improve content through high quality illustration of Wikipedia articles.
  2. Attract new contributors on Commons and Wikipedia projects on LGBT+ related topics, including those with a passion for LGBT+ subjects and high quality photography.
  3. Engage existing contributors in better use of LGBT+ related images and increase awareness of the need for, and to test methods to, achieve a representative subject diversity in highest quality Wikimedia project articles and media.

Project Plan[edit]

Activities[edit]

The prize campaign will be organized by a small panel of WM-LGBT+ volunteers, who will organize notices and handle the qualification of candidate photographs being submitted. The prize campaign is targeted at independent photographers with previously unreleased photographs to nominate. Though this may include professionals, the prize recognizes the work of photographers rather than institutions and existing archives.

1. What content will the contest focus on, and why is it important to your community?
The competition is to encourage and reward the release of new LGBT+ culture related photographs and have more LGBT+ related images being nominated for Featured Picture. Though the Commons:LGBT Free Media Collective campaign and the Wiki Loves Pride campaign have resulted in a significant collection of LGBT+ photographs, none has yet achieved Featured Picture (FP) status. Having photographs recognized as Featured, gives the benefit of gaining wide recognition by being able to be featured as Picture of The Day on the main page of Wikimedia Commons and recognized automatically in other places, such as the English Wikipedia Signpost newsletter.

2. How will you let people know about the contest?
Central and site notices, along with announcements on Wikimedia email groups, twitter streams, Facebook groups and explanation/discussion on the Wikimedia Commons Village Pump should any detailed questions arise.

3. How will you judge the contest and award prizes?
Featured Pictures have existing nomination criteria and guidelines on each project and will remain independent of WM-LGBT+. A WM-LGBT+ volunteer panel will advise the candidate on whether a photograph has a sufficiently clear LGBT+ theme to be eligible in the competition, before the candidate proceeds with the FP nomination. Being recognized as a candidate in the competition will not change the local FP criteria that applies to all photographs.

The prizes are awarded on a first past the post system. As the most technically challenging criteria for FP is on Wikimedia Commons, there will be two prizes for first and second past the post ($200 and $100), then three prizes for different language Wikipedias. Photographers will be limited to one prize and each Wikipedia FP system will be eligible for one prize. At the time of this proposal, Featured Picture candidate pages exist in 43 different language Wikipedias.

The prizes are not retroactive, so to be eligible photographs must have been first uploaded to Wikimedia Commons after the competition starts, though the photographs may have been taken at past events or be of historic interest but not previously released. A maximum of two photographs from any photographer will be considered eligible, while those photographs are active in any Featured Pictures process.

Further detailed rules for the competition are at Rules.

4. For photo contests, what is the strategy to get images used on projects?
Featured Pictures by their nature tend to be widely used after they are recognized, and WM-LGBT+ volunteers will be both tracking usage and seeking out the most relevant Wikipedia articles to benefit from the new images.

Impact[edit]

Measures with target figures in brackets:

  1. Engagement will be measured by:
    1. counting the number of photographers coming forward, [10 photographers]
    2. estimating participation in Featured Picture discussion [20 volunteers] and
    3. estimating the numbers of Wikipedia article editors reusing and illustrating articles with all new images that the competition will attract, not only those that achieved Featured Picture status. [20 volunteers]
  2. Direct impact will be measured by the number of new LGBT+ related photos uploaded to Wikimedia Commons that can be counted against the competition. [at least 40 new high quality photographs]
  3. Overall impact by counting the increase in the number of high quality LGBT+ photographs used on Wikimedia projects, which ties in with the Wiki99 campaign itself having a goal to increase the quality of LGBT+ articles. [100 transclusions]
  4. External impact will be gauged by tracking public engagement on twitter, blogs and the press, as well as discovering where the newly released photographs are reused. [3 significant references]

Resources[edit]

The WM-LGBT+ user group has no direct resources but can draw on the goodwill of our network of Wikimedians with an interest in increasing the quality of LGBT+ subjects on Wikimedia projects.

The financial resources needed to run the competition are:

  • The prize fund of $600.
  • There may be standard fees associated with currency changes and transfer costs of prizes from US dollars.

Related links and notices[edit]

Endorsements[edit]

Community members are encouraged to endorse your project request here!

  • Support Support Gamaliel (talk) 14:08, 28 June 2016 (UTC)
  • Support Support. I will alert WikiProject LGBT Studies on en:wp. Funcrunch (talk) 15:52, 28 June 2016 (UTC)
    Thanks! (talk) 19:10, 30 June 2016 (UTC)
  • Support Support In my experience, our featured pictures are primarily landscapes and nature, animals, architecture, places, or static portraits of individual people. Featured pictures of groups of people and/or events involving a significant number of people are rare. Narrow that down to coverage of LGBT groups, people, and events, and you'd be hard pressed to find anything that's FP or FP-worthy. I think it would be great to encourage high quality photographic coverage of LGBT people, events, and lifestyle, and a contest with prizes would certainly attract some high-quality/FP-worthy entries. INeverCry 20:17, 30 June 2016 (UTC)
  • Support Support Fits well with other activities in the movement. I will post about this to the Swedish event. Ainali (talk) 13:36, 1 July 2016 (UTC)
  • Support Support Agree with the comments above. --Steinsplitter (talk) 13:33, 2 July 2016 (UTC)
  • Support Support Freddy2001 talk 15:18, 4 July 2016 (UTC)
  • Oppose Oppose Je suis fortement opposé à ce projet. La promotion de divers communautarismes n'est pas bienvenue et n'a pas sa place sur "Commons". Brandir l'étendard de son homosexualité est aussi inadmissible et inapproprié que brandir l'étendard de l'homophobie. Sinon, je vais créer Wiki Aime les Nains, Wiki Aime les Blonds et, bien sûr, Wiki Loves Heterosexuals. --Jebulon (talk) 18:59, 4 July 2016 (UTC)
If you wish to create a Wiki Loves Heterosexuals proposal, nobody is stopping you. This proposal aims to address the lack of Featured Pictures with clear LGBT+ cultural themes, and is not intended as a political platform. Thanks (talk) 19:51, 4 July 2016 (UTC)
As you know, I have nothing against LGBT themes in "Commons", and especially in FPC. But I think this site is not made for an illustration of any community organized activism. There is only one community here: the community of "commoners".--Jebulon (talk) 19:50, 5 July 2016 (UTC)
  • Support Support There is a clear content gap which needs many more events and projects like this. Satdeep Gill (talk) 21:36, 5 July 2016 (UTC)
  • Oppose Oppose WMF should not fund competitions that discriminate people/subjects on the basis of overt sexuality. The Featured Picture forums are unsuitable for judging photographic competitions. The "first past the post" system of awarding a prize is highly likely to be problematic. See talk for more details. -- Colin (talk) 10:00, 7 July 2016 (UTC)
    • How about a proof of concept of the idea as a monthly Commons:Photo challenge? --Dschwen (talk) 22:52, 9 July 2016 (UTC)
      • Commons:Photo challenge/2014 - June - Wiki Loves Pride 2014 had 50 nominations from only 7 users, and only 15 people voted. The PC has become more popular since then (Main Page advert helps) but still that was the lowest level for contributions/voting-enthusiasm, and the quality of images was not imo particularly high. There have been repeated calls from one or two individuals to repeat it, but I have resisted those as we have absolutely no shortage of topics for PC (both about people and about other things) so why recycle any previous (unsuccessful) topic for the two themes we run each month? I'm sure a more heavily advertised LGBT Photo Challenge could be more successful, and perhaps PC could be used if done as an additional challenge that month (or over two months, even). -- Colin (talk) 09:01, 10 July 2016 (UTC)