Requests for comment/Global ban for 2018년

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
The following request for comments is closed. Closed for failing to meet nominator requirements (Global bans#Obtaining consensus for a global ban: have at least 500 edits globally (on all Wikimedia wikis)., as of closing time, nominator has 30 edits across all wikis. Also, the nominator did not notify community where the user has edited. — regards, Revi 13:07, 27 February 2018 (UTC)


This person signed up for the end of 2017.

As you can see from this, at first it was blocked for a month with simple vandalism.
But, Look at this, you can see behavior that annoys certain users, and eventually they have been blocked for a long time. It does not end here.
Look at this. The user has created a user discussion to ask the specific user to sue. This may appear to be a threat that is prohibited by wmf:Terms_of_Use, and Korean Wikipedia prohibits legal threats with wikipedia:ko:백:법적 위협 금지. In violation of both of these provisions, in the Korean Wikipedia, has been permanently blocked.
Also, in Wikimedia Commons, as you can see in commons:User talk:2018년, by continuing uploads in violation of copyright, snooping certain users, using profanity, and pulling the work of a wiki other than the WMF wiki, Despite receiving a warning from revi, it continued, eventually being permanently blocked.
And look at this. This user says it in the Korean WMF wikis I'm unfair / Please block certain user

Therefore, I am requesting global ban in the sense that it meets all the requirements of Global bans and intimidates and annoys users both inside and outside WMF wikis.-Ldmsys (talk) 02:26, 27 February 2018 (UTC)


죄송합니다. 제가 몰라서 그랬으니 한번만 제발 봐주세요. 마이킴님께도 진정으로 사과드립니다. 다시는 위갤 안하래요. --2018년 (talk) 03:18, 27 February 2018 (UTC)

He says: Sorry. please forgive me. I really apologize to Mykim5902 (Mykim5902 is the user who threatened to sue 2018), please note he wrote "fu**" in edit summary -Ldmsys (talk) 03:46, 27 February 2018 (UTC)
  • Do we really need it? Global bans says... "Merely meeting the above minimum criteria does not mean that a global ban is required". Global bans are warranted for more serious case like...
    • Harassing or threatening contributors to the projects, on- or off-wiki.
    • Serious on-wiki fraud or identity theft that is not simple abuse of multiple accounts.
    • Inappropriate use of user rights with access to private information, such as CheckUser or Oversight.
    • Violations of the privacy policy or other official Wikimedia policies.
    • Persistent cross-wiki copyright violation
While 2018년 satisfies Global bans#Criteria for global bans criteria - 1. they show same problematic behavior @ kowiki and commons, 2. few admins (including me and few others on Commons, and other admins on kowiki) have told them about their wrongdoings, and 3. they are indef-blocked on commons and ko (two wikis) for their behavior, that does not mean they should be banned. (By the way, "indefinite block" does not mean it is "permanent" - they can be unblocked if they are able to prove they have learned their mistakes (I'm not saying he did.) — regards, Revi 13:05, 27 February 2018 (UTC)