Jump to content

Talk:Community Wishlist/W395

Add topic
From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Latest comment: 8 months ago by Prototyperspective in topic Declining

Received your wish on integrating Wikimedia Commons with NewPipe

[edit]

Thank you for submitting this wish! You know the process by now, we’ll first check internally to identify the PM or team best suited to check it.

Once we’ve done that, we’ll get back to you with an update. Appreciate your continued dedication and all the thoughtful wishes you’ve been sharing.

--ARamadan-WMF (talk) 17:43, 17 June 2025 (UTC)Reply

Declining

[edit]

Hi @Prototyperspective

As far as I can tell this is a project for NewPipe itself rather than for Commons, so not something we can do via the community wishlist

CParle (WMF) (talk) 11:45, 18 June 2025 (UTC)Reply

This is not true. Thus, please unarchive this wish. It's not true because:
  • The Wishlist isn't just for the WMF but also for volunteer developers. This is also clear from the info at the main page Contributors may support and comment on focus areas, which will then be adopted by Wikimedia Foundation teams, Community Tech, affiliates, or volunteer developers.
  • NewPipe is an open source app to which developers here can also contribute to. Wikimedians may see value in adding support for Commons to that app so after reading the proposal or in general may want to code that.
Prototyperspective (talk) 11:50, 18 June 2025 (UTC)Reply
The first sentence on the main page is
"The Community Wishlist is a forum for Wikimedia project contributors to share ideas or "Wishes" to improve our product and technology, and then collaborate with each other and the Wikimedia Foundation to prioritize and solve these opportunities together."
NewPipe is not our product and technology. I really don't think it makes sense to have wishes for non-wikimedia software on the wikimedia community wishlist. As you point out there's already an issue raised about this in the NewPipeExtractor repo CParle (WMF) (talk) 12:32, 18 June 2025 (UTC)Reply
  • The Community Wishlist is a forum for Wikimedia project contributors to share ideas or "Wishes" to improve our product and technology That may be a way to quickly describe it but it doesn't even fit all wishes anyway since many wishes are more about the creation of new technology products. Giving people the ability to Consume audio & video content on Commons in some native mobile app with various partly-mentioned features is an improvement to our product though. Also, Wikimedia uses several software that wasn't developed by WMF/Wikimedia community and it's still our technology since it's technology we use and NewPipe would become such too if this wish is implemented. And in any case, it doesn't make sense to exclude reasonable wishes that are about making Wikimedia content more useful and accessible for no good reason, e.g. that paragraph could be changed or be considered not as a definition but as a brief short intro (and this wish does still fit it so that's not needed).
  • and then collaborate with each other and the Wikimedia Foundation to prioritize and solve these opportunities together. This does neither say that the Wikimedia Foundation a) would collaborate with all wishes if they get implemented nor that b) the WMF would do so via coding. Also together there can also include open source developers, e.g. where some things are implemented by WMF and some by volunteer open source developers.
  • One could add some clarification to the top of the wish, explaining for example that the WMF – which currently also doesn't work on the Commons app – won't work on this issue and/or that NewPipe is currently not a software used by / developed by Wikimedia.
Prototyperspective (talk) 16:45, 18 June 2025 (UTC)Reply
@CParle (WMF) and JWheeler-WMF: please unarchive this wish (one could add a note to the top) for the reasons above. Prototyperspective (talk) 13:42, 27 June 2025 (UTC)Reply
I can see where you're coming from, and I appreciate your dedication to Commons, but this wish does not belong here. NewPipe is a completely different project. We use debian and php and elasticsearch, but we don't use the Community wishlist to suggest updates to them - and we wouldn't request an update to Commons on the NewPipe issues list. CParle (WMF) (talk) 14:37, 27 June 2025 (UTC)Reply
If a change to debian or php or elasticsearch is needed for some Wikimedia thing, then I don't see why it wouldn't fit into this Wishlist. However, there probably isn't any such thing. This is useful to freely call attention to Wikimedia movement's needed technical work. If there was some issue with the Commons API that makes apps like NewPipe break then NewPipe devs could very well report the issue on Commons after creating an issue about the problem in the repo which could e.g. be set to status Blocked or Waiting if the technical changes are needed at the external project. Moreover, the Commons API and an open source app developed by volunteers all over the world aren't necessarily comparable. Wikimedians may be or get involved with its development and instead of say building a new Commons videos app, efficiently add the functionality to an already-existing already-successful app. Prototyperspective (talk) 15:07, 27 June 2025 (UTC)Reply
We would request an update to Commons on the NewPipe issue list if NewPipe was using Commons and the update is needed / makes sense. Please unarchive. Volunteers could make a pull-request there and then NewPipe can check whether they want to add the media support for the site like for FramaTube & the CCC media server. I think it's misinterpreted what an issue here would imply/mean and if there was an issue with elasticsearch that limits Wikimedia projects then apart from the option of using something else or developing something quite similar from scratch there could be a valid reasonable case for making an improvement to elasticsearch if that would bring benefit to Wikimedia. Prototyperspective (talk) 23:41, 26 September 2025 (UTC)Reply
@CParle (WMF): the wish has none of the decline-reasons set and I think it's because there is no sufficient/valid one. Have you considered what I wrote above such as If a change to debian or php or elasticsearch is needed for some Wikimedia thing, then I don't see why it wouldn't fit into this Wishlist. – such a wish could be about the functionality one is looking for but would have to be done e.g. in elasticsearch to be implemented or ask for switching the software used or like here ask for something to be added to the used software to enable a new functionality in Wikimedia. I think this is a wish that is a community opportunity – NewPipe on its frontpage lists the services (YouTube, Bandcamp, etc) one can use with it with a note encouraging more to be added with "And more to come!" where volunteers here could develop a pull-request that adds this to the app. This is much like a wish for a new app (it's just that this is like a module to an existing app) – in the wishlist there even is a wish about that, W14: Wiktionary mobile app .
@MusikAnimal (WMF): could you also take a look? I don't think this is an invalid wish but merely a community opportunity. Prototyperspective (talk) 23:09, 18 December 2025 (UTC)Reply
Is there any technical issue with debian or php or elasticsearch that impedes Wikimedia functionality? Or is there no other software project Wikimedia contributors (volunteers or employees) have so far contributed to to get some problem fixed or some feature implemented? If there is none, that still doesn't mean it's not sth within scope.
Not declining the wish does not imply endorsement. Adding support for Commons to an open source app with support for various comparable media platforms is a reasonable valid wish the community could have and that concerns Wikimedia and is of interest to them (and arguably of NewPipe too and if not they could just reject such a pull request despite that they invite users to 'add more' supported platforms and the Commons issue there remains open). I disagree with the closing and it would be great if the status could be changed. Prototyperspective (talk) 21:14, 12 February 2026 (UTC)Reply

External input

[edit]

FYI I posted this wish to the NewPipe subreddit here: https://www.reddit.com/r/NewPipe/comments/1l883pp/proposal_to_add_support_for_wikimedia_commons_350/ (at the time at 23 upvotes posted 12 days ago). Prototyperspective (talk) 10:22, 22 June 2025 (UTC)Reply