User talk:Wai Wai~metawiki

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki

Wai Wai, thank you for fixing the introduction paragraph to the help:Editing page. I believe that the person who nuked the editing overview was rude. When I reverted, I attempted to keep all content active. I moved it to it's appropriate location. I did not simply revert. Im sorry if I appeared rude.

A tabled, wordy explanation of the wikitext does not belong on that page. I agree that mine was poor, but it was more in spirit of the page's intention. This should print to 1 page. The long wikitext table just doesn't work for that. CAn we work to find a format that would work?


Hey AaronPeterson,
It would be nice if you could sign your comment next time. To sign your comment, simply type --~~~~, the system will auto-generate the signature. Thank you.

Yes, it may look rude to throw away all previous work, and replace with a new one for no good reason.

>I did not simply revert. Im sorry if I appeared rude. That's alright. You may simply miss the previous good version. :)

Why do we confine ourselves to 1 page at max? If one needs to have something handy in print for easy reference, Help:Reference card has done its job.

Second it has been longer than 1 page already without the table.

Third since this is just a quick starter guide, there are many other related and specific topics they may need to read further on. A print of the Help:Editing print the names of the links which are useless on paper.

Fourth, so the only thing left which may be worth printing is the Editing Basics. However I don't think newbies or any experienced wiki editors need to keep refencing this on paper.

As to which format one should choose to explain the most frequently used wiki, 2 formats have been suggested so far:

  1. a simple cheatsheet
  2. table (that is what I'm doing)

As to cheatsheet, someone complains it may not be useful to newbie as it is still too simple to understand, not to say the plain version offered by you.

I think understandability is in higher priority over size. This page was once very large (maybe about 4-6 months ago), as compared to the current version.

What do you think?
--Wai Wai 19:01, 28 July 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Your account will be renamed[edit]

04:19, 18 March 2015 (UTC)

Renamed[edit]

20:44, 21 April 2015 (UTC)