BiDi workgroup/bugzilla/02248

BiDi workgroup ?
subpages talks
BiDi wiki links
FAQ   To-do
Participants ^e

bugzilla:02248 – "Wrong treating of the first line of a long template parameter"
bugzilla:03983 – "BiDi: please assure a high degree of fexibility / maintainability of the template syntax with respect to RTL"
BiDi workgroup/bugzilla/02248 e
BiDi workgroup/bugzilla/02248/template e
BiDi workgroup/bugzilla/02248/calls e

arguments against bugzilla:02248

With bugzilla:02248

'''ltr:'''<br />
<div dir="ltr" />
{{User:Gangleri/tests/BiDi/list 01/template
|DIRCONT={{{DIRCONT}}}
|DIRMARKCONT={{{DIRMARKCONT}}}
|DIRGUI={{{DIRGUI}}}
|DIRMARKGUI={{{DIRMARKGUI}}}
|BIDICONTTITLE=كار دست خود دادن
|BIDICONTUSER=thecontributor
|BIDICONTTALK=Talk
|BIDIGUIBLOCK=block
|BIDIGUIDIFF=diff
|BIDIGUIHIST=hist
|BIDIGUITIME=03:42
|BIDICONTSUMMARY=interwiki Adding: af, an, ar, ast, be, bg, br, bs, ca, cs, cy, da, de, el, en, eo, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fiu-vro, fr, fy, ga, gd, gl, he, hr, ht, hu, ia, id, io, is, it, ja, ka, kw, la, lb, li, lt, lv, mi, mk, ms, mt, nah, nds, nl, nn, no, oc, os, pl,
}}
</div>
<div dir="rtl" />
'''rtl:'''<br />
{{User:Gangleri/tests/BiDi/list 01/template
|DIRCONT={{{DIRCONT}}}
|DIRMARKCONT={{{DIRMARKCONT}}}
|DIRGUI={{{DIRGUI}}}
|DIRMARKGUI={{{DIRMARKGUI}}}
|BIDICONTTITLE=كار دست خود دادن
|BIDICONTUSER=thecontributor
|BIDICONTTALK=Talk
|BIDIGUIBLOCK=block
|BIDIGUIDIFF=diff
|BIDIGUIHIST=hist
|BIDIGUITIME=03:42
|BIDICONTSUMMARY=interwiki Adding: af, an, ar, ast, be, bg, br, bs, ca, cs, cy, da, de, el, en, eo, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fiu-vro, fr, fy, ga, gd, gl, he, hr, ht, hu, ia, id, io, is, it, ja, ka, kw, la, lb, li, lt, lv, mi, mk, ms, mt, nah, nds, nl, nn, no, oc, os, pl,
}}
</div>

generates:
ltr:

• (diff) (hist) . . {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}كار دست خود دادن; {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}03:42 . . {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}thecontributor {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}(Talk | block){{{DIRMARKGUI}}} {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}(interwiki Adding: af, an, ar, ast, be, bg, br, bs, ca, cs, cy, da, de, el, en, eo, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fiu-vro, fr, fy, ga, gd, gl, he, hr, ht, hu, ia, id, io, is, it, ja, ka, kw, la, lb, li, lt, lv, mi, mk, ms, mt, nah, nds, nl, nn, no, oc, os, pl,){{{DIRMARKGUI}}}

rtl:

• (diff) (hist) . . {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}كار دست خود دادن; {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}03:42 . . {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}thecontributor {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}(Talk | block){{{DIRMARKGUI}}} {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}(interwiki Adding: af, an, ar, ast, be, bg, br, bs, ca, cs, cy, da, de, el, en, eo, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fiu-vro, fr, fy, ga, gd, gl, he, hr, ht, hu, ia, id, io, is, it, ja, ka, kw, la, lb, li, lt, lv, mi, mk, ms, mt, nah, nds, nl, nn, no, oc, os, pl,){{{DIRMARKGUI}}}

Without bugzilla:02248

'''ltr:'''<br />
<div dir="ltr" />
{{User:Gangleri/tests/BiDi/list 01/template|DIRCONT={{{DIRCONT}}}|DIRMARKCONT={{{DIRMARKCONT}}}|DIRGUI={{{DIRGUI}}}|DIRMARKGUI={{{DIRMARKGUI}}}|BIDICONTTITLE=كار دست خود دادن|BIDICONTUSER=thecontributor|BIDICONTTALK=Talk|BIDIGUIBLOCK=block|BIDIGUIDIFF=diff|BIDIGUIHIST=hist|BIDIGUITIME=03:42|BIDICONTSUMMARY=interwiki Adding: af, an, ar, ast, be, bg, br, bs, ca, cs, cy, da, de, el, en, eo, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fiu-vro, fr, fy, ga, gd, gl, he, hr, ht, hu, ia, id, io, is, it, ja, ka, kw, la, lb, li, lt, lv, mi, mk, ms, mt, nah, nds, nl, nn, no, oc, os, pl,}}
</div>
<div dir="rtl" />
'''rtl:'''<br />
{{User:Gangleri/tests/BiDi/list 01/template|DIRCONT={{{DIRCONT}}}|DIRMARKCONT={{{DIRMARKCONT}}}|DIRGUI={{{DIRGUI}}}|DIRMARKGUI={{{DIRMARKGUI}}}|BIDICONTTITLE=كار دست خود دادن|BIDICONTUSER=thecontributor|BIDICONTTALK=Talk|BIDIGUIBLOCK=block|BIDIGUIDIFF=diff|BIDIGUIHIST=hist|BIDIGUITIME=03:42|BIDICONTSUMMARY=interwiki Adding: af, an, ar, ast, be, bg, br, bs, ca, cs, cy, da, de, el, en, eo, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fiu-vro, fr, fy, ga, gd, gl, he, hr, ht, hu, ia, id, io, is, it, ja, ka, kw, la, lb, li, lt, lv, mi, mk, ms, mt, nah, nds, nl, nn, no, oc, os, pl,}}
</div>

generates:
ltr:

• (diff) (hist) . . {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}كار دست خود دادن; {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}03:42 . . {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}thecontributor {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}(Talk | block){{{DIRMARKGUI}}} {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}(interwiki Adding: af, an, ar, ast, be, bg, br, bs, ca, cs, cy, da, de, el, en, eo, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fiu-vro, fr, fy, ga, gd, gl, he, hr, ht, hu, ia, id, io, is, it, ja, ka, kw, la, lb, li, lt, lv, mi, mk, ms, mt, nah, nds, nl, nn, no, oc, os, pl,){{{DIRMARKGUI}}}

rtl:

• (diff) (hist) . . {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}كار دست خود دادن; {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}03:42 . . {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}thecontributor {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}(Talk | block){{{DIRMARKGUI}}} {{{DIRMARKGUI}}}(interwiki Adding: af, an, ar, ast, be, bg, br, bs, ca, cs, cy, da, de, el, en, eo, es, et, eu, fa, fi, fiu-vro, fr, fy, ga, gd, gl, he, hr, ht, hu, ia, id, io, is, it, ja, ka, kw, la, lb, li, lt, lv, mi, mk, ms, mt, nah, nds, nl, nn, no, oc, os, pl,){{{DIRMARKGUI}}}

Comments

The generated code is identical. However editing the section Without bugzilla:02248 is much more difficult.

just edit that section; insert some characters here and there

then resize the browser window

If you ask what group of people is affected the answer is

at least all contributors to all Wiktionaries.

Best regards Gangleri | Th | T 17:09, 19 January 2006 (UTC)

To-do

Is there an error in wrapping around? Gangleri | Th | T 17:09, 19 January 2006 (UTC)