Talk:Wikimedia Hong Kong/Membership/會員費

Add topic
From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki


請問會費是如何釐定的呢?只是參考其他同類組織和合乎現實?為何不是根據財政預算而釐定呢? 再者,我也不知道同類組織是甚麼組織呢。--Denniswong 09:05, 9 May 2006 (UTC)Reply

同類組織是指維基媒體基金會的地區組織(Wikimedia XXX 那些),可參考Wikimedia chapters。 -- Kevinhksouth 15:53, 9 May 2006 (UTC)Reply
但是別國(尤其是歐洲)的生活消費水平相對較高,直接比較是否不大好呢?又,別國的wikimedia組織又是如何釐定他們的會費呢? -- Denniswong 02:53, 10 May 2006 (UTC)Reply


Denniswong也有道理, 貴會可以先做一個財政預算案出來嗎? 眾人也希望 貴組織能夠收支平行, 若果如今沒財政數據出示, 會員只能考慮自己的付出, 假如看過預算支出的必須, 也可能同意再高一點會費的. 反過來說, 免收會費, 多點香港維基人入會, 不是更好嗎, 至於春茗或開會活動的開支, 用者自付便可以了. 結論是, 財政方面請多一點透明度, 讓大家一起來監察, 不是更好嗎 --AHLAI6316 04:28, 10 May 2006 (UTC)Reply

Group Membership[edit]

What kind of group is eligible for Group Membership? HenryLi 20:59, 10 June 2006 (UTC)Reply

Any age limit?[edit]

Could a pupil from primary school join the association and is the pupil eligible for student membership? HenryLi 21:03, 10 June 2006 (UTC)Reply


一般個人會員每年要付$150會不會過高?香港有些人的工資只有每月港幣四、五千元,$150對他們來說是大數目,會到這些人加入協會造成妨礙。請注意我們是非牟利機構,收入不宜多於支出太多。TYC 18:13, 17 June 2006 (UTC)Reply

According to surveys in CWMC 2006, Hong Kong has the youngest Wikimedian population in the world. Thus after taking in the price indices as reference, the membership fee should be further decreased to suit the income of members. As for myself, if the yearly fee is HK$150 I wouldn't join the WMHK. --Deryck Chan 09:53, 28 August 2006 (UTC)Reply

What do you mean by The Foundation?[edit]

Quote: The Foundation is set up for the long term development...

  • Do you mean that there is a seperate foundation which manages the fund? Or do you mean the fund itself?
  • The term long term development is very vague. Can you provide examples for how the fund can be used? Advertising? Exhibitions? Travelling expenses?

--Hillgentleman 05:10, 23 November 2006 (UTC)Reply

Where is the justification for the Foundation Fee?[edit]

Where is the justification for the Foundation Fee?--Hillgentleman|User Talk 10:18, 16 December 2006 (UTC)Reply


初步討論結果 Initial discussion results[edit]


  • 入會費HK$30至$40,年費約HK$30至$60
  • 有建議指可以為學生提供優惠
  • 討論結果的費用較其他同類組織低得多

According to the discussion on Feburary to April, the sugggestions of Individual Membership Fee are:

  • Entry fee of HKD$30-40. Annual membership fee of HKD$30-60.
  • Raised idea of offering a discount for students
  • Resulting fees are much lower than comparable associations

同類組織參考 Comparison with other associations[edit]

  • 中華民國 (台灣):年費約HK$250,團體約HK$1250
  • 德國:年費約HK$215,學生約HK$110
  • 法國:年費約HK$315,學生約HK$135
  • ROC (Taiwan): Annual fee HKD$250, group member HKD$1250
  • Germany: Annual fee HKD$215, students HKD$110
  • France: Annual fee HKD$315, Students HKD$135

最新建議 Latest Suggestion[edit]

  • 個人會員:
    • 一般會員
      • 基金費(入會費)HK$50,年費HK$150
    • 學生會員 (持有效之香港中學或大專院校之學生證者)
      • 基金費(入會費)HK$50,年費HK$75
  • 團體會員:基金費(入會費)HK$500,年費HK$1500
  • 以上建議的費用較合乎現實之餘,仍較其他同類組織為低
  • Individual Member:
    • Regular Member:
      • Entry Fee HKD$50, Annual Fee HKD$150
    • Student Member (Student Card Holder of Hong Kong Secondary Schools or Tertiary Insititutes)
      • Entry Fee HKD$50, Annual Fee HKD$75
    • Group Member: Entry Fee HKD$500, Annual Fee HKD$1500
  • Suggested fees are more reasonable, yet they are still lower than comparable associations