Wikimedia CEE Hub/Governance models

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki

Visualising different governance models for the CEE Hub. This is an experimental page and is not an official document of any kind.

The guiding principles for selecting a model are:

  • Governance shouldn't assign an unfair weight to a single language or community
  • Established communities should not make up the majority of votes
    • This refers to the primary mission of the CEE Hub to support communities that are not yet on the same level as the more established ones
    • This also refers to the 2030 Wikimedia strategy aspect of subsidiarity, where the communities affected by decisions on a higher level have a meaningful voice in those processes
  • The model should be feasible in terms of the selection process for a person to have a mandate from a certain community and be implemented in time for the CEE Meeting 2023
  • The model should allow for a consensus-driven process at the CEE Meeting 2023 to take place, i.e. with at least 75% being in favour of decisions

Model A[edit]

  1. Each country with a distinct separate language has 1 vote no matter the number of affiliates OR
  2. each majority language of a country without an affiliate has 1 vote; OR
  3. every language without a majority in one country has one vote; and
  4. partnership projects in the CEE have one vote - who are served or are supported by CEE Hub
    1. Partnership projects would be formally recognised by the CEE Hub at the annual meeting

The lists below show the languages/projects with a vote and who is supposed to faciliate the process to define a language/project delegate for the Wikimedia CEE Meeting. The participation in the CEE Hub is based on activity of the communities and a track record of engaging with the CEE region through projects like CEE Spring, WikiGap, etc., or participating in the CEE Meeting.

The process of establishing a mandate for a certain language / Wikimedia projects is yet to be outlined.

Languages (33)[edit]

  • Estonian
    • Wikimedia Estonia
  • Latvian
    • Wikimedians from Latvia
  • Lithuanian
    • Lithuanian Wikimedia projects
  • Polish
    • Wikimedia Poland
  • Czech
    • Wikimedia Czechia
  • Slovakian
    • Wikimedians of Slovakia
  • German
    • Wikimedia Austria
    • Wikimedia Germany
    • Wikimedia Switzerland
    • Wikimedia Italy (South Tyrol)
  • Hungarian
    • Wikimedia Hungary
  • Maltese
    • Wikimedia Community Malta
  • Slovene
    • Wikipedians of Slovenia User Group
  • Croatian
    • Croatian Wikimedia projects
  • Bosnian
    • Bosnian Wikimedia projects
    • Wikimedians of Republic of Srpska (unclear)
  • Montenegrin
    • Montenegrin Wikimedia projects
  • Serbian
    • Wikimedia Serbia
    • Wikimedians of Republic of Srpska
  • Serbocroatian
    • Serbocroatian Wikimedia projects
  • Macedonian
    • Shared Knowledge
    • GLAM Macedonia User Group
  • Albanian
    • Wikimedians of Albanian Language User Group
    • Wikimedia Community User Group Albania
  • Greek
    • Wikimedia Community User Group Greece
    • Cyprus Wikimedia communities
  • Romanian
    • Wikimedians of Romania and Moldova User Group
  • Ukrainian
    • Wikimedia Ukraine
  • Bulgarian
    • Bulgarian Wikimedia projects
  • Turkish
    • Wikimedia Community User Group Turkey
    • Cyprus Wikimedia communities
  • Belarussian (including Taraškievica orthography)
    • Wikimedia Community User Group Belarus
  • Georgian
    • Wikimedia UG Georgia
  • Armenian
    • Wikimedia Armenia
  • Western Armenian
    • Wikimedians of Western Armenian Language User Group
  • Azeri
    • Azerbaijani Wikimedians User Group
  • Bashkir
    • Wikimedians of Bashkortostan User Group
  • Tatar
    • Wikimedians of Tatar Language User Group
  • Erzya
    • Wikimedians of Erzya language User Group
  • Esperanto
    • Esperanto and Free Knowledge
  • Kazakh
    • Wikimedia Community of Kazakh language User Group
  • Russian
    • Wikimedia Russia
    • Don Wikimedians User Group
    • Wikipedians of North Caucasus User Group
    • Wikimedia Community of Saint Petersburg User Group
    • North-West Russia Wiki-Historians User Group

Partner projects (1)[edit]

  • Wikimedia LGBT+
    • CEE group of Wikimedia LGBT+

Potential voting communities[edit]

  • Aromanian
    • Aromanian Wikimedia projects
  • Crimean Tatar
    • Crimean Tatar Wikimedia projects
  • Voro
    • Voro Wikimedia projects
  • Sorbian
    • Upper Sorbian Wikimedia projects
    • Lower Sorbian Wikimedia projects

Potential partner projects[edit]

  • Turkic languages
    • Wikimedians of Turkic Languages User Group
  • Wikidata
  • Commons
  • Sakha
    • Sakha Wikimedian projects

Model B[edit]

  • Every Wikimedia project in a CEE language has one vote
    • The vote is organised by the processes already established within each Wikimedia project
    • A certain level of activity is probably required to be considered, with possible exceptions for minority languages

An analysis of the number of votes per language is currently being conducted.