Meta:Requests for CheckUser information

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
(Redirected from RFCU)
Jump to: navigation, search
Requests and proposals Requests for CheckUser information on Meta-Wiki (for other wikis please go to here) Archives (current)→
This page allows you to request CheckUser information on Meta.
Procedure
  • Please read the CheckUser policy before asking for a check.
  • When adding new requests, please use the {{checkuser}} template to list the user names in question and {{checkip}} for IP adresses, which simplifies investigation.
  • List your request at the bottom of the "Requests for Meta-Wiki only" heading.
  • When asking for a check we need to know:
    • why do you believe that the accounts are related (please present evidence for that with the help of diffs, etc.),
    • why, if the accounts are related, they are being used abusively, in violation of policy; and
    • why a block or other measures can't be justified without the need of technical evidence.
Important
Checkuser icons
These indicators are used by CheckUsers and stewards for easier skimming of their notes, actions and comments.
{{Confirmed}}: Confirmed Confirmed {{MoreInfo}}: MoreInfo Additional information needed
{{Likely}}: Likely Likely {{Deferred}}: Deferred Deferred to
{{Possible}}: Possible Possible {{Completed}}: Completed Completed
{{Unlikely}}: Unlikely Unlikely {{TakeNote}}: Note Note:
{{Unrelated}}: Unrelated Unrelated {{Doing}}: Symbol wait.svg Doing...
{{Inconclusive}}: Inconclusive Inconclusive {{StaleIP}}: Stale Stale
{{Declined}}: Declined Declined {{Fishing}}: Fishing CheckUser is not for fishing
{{Pixiedust}}: Pixiedust CheckUser is not magic pixie dust {{8ball}}: 8ball The CheckUser Magic 8-Ball says
{{Duck}}: Duck It looks like a duck to me {{Crystalball}}: Crystalball CheckUser is not a crystal ball


Requests for Meta-Wiki only[edit]

Pelayo Calderón[edit]

Status:    Not done

See Wikimedia_Forum#Help_with_spurious_checkuser_verification.--GZWDer (talk) 06:43, 19 July 2015 (UTC)

I reject the request for three reasons:
  • a check can prove two users are sockpuppets but it cannot prove they are not;
  • it would be pretty easy to fool a check based on a single-day edits;
  • the original check at es.wiki has been done more than a year ago, some kind of abuse of multiple accounts might cease in a year.
--Vituzzu (talk) 19:30, 19 July 2015 (UTC)
Hi Vituzzu, I have to agree with your denial. A meta-only checkuser is rather useless, as what I'm looking for is simply a "global" checkuser. I want any of my records, in any project, to be compared with those of Pelayo Calderón, as s/he and me are simply not the same person. Best regards --Discasto (talk) 21:23, 19 July 2015 (UTC)
I wouldn't think any other kind of check would work but I'm giving this answer as a local checkuser here at meta. Other requests should be handled elsewhere, honestly I'm not sure where but still not here. --Vituzzu (talk) 11:31, 20 July 2015 (UTC)

See also[edit]