Requests for comment/Scope issues and copyright violations on Kyrgyz Wikibooks

The following request for comments is closed. Closing as inactive; no contributions since September 2022. --SHB2000 (t • c) 05:16, 16 October 2024 (UTC)

I count 61 pages in mainspace on this wiki: b:ky:.

Main page
b:ky:Библия - there appears to be a partially completed translation of the Bible here. While I have nothing against the Bible, this seems to be more appropriate on Wikisource, that is, if there are no copyright issues. This comes out to 34 pages plus the index page = 35.
Nonsense pages - b:ky:"Жаз жыты"
Possible copyvio - b:ky:Бухгалтердик эсеп: Окуу куралы, b:ky:Бухгалтерия сырлары: Маалымдуу үйрөнүү окуу куралы, b:ky:Даанышман ойлор: афоризмдер, макал-лакаптар b:ky:Финансы, акча жүгүртүү жана кредит: Окуу китеби,

maybe b:ky:Улуттун жоголгон байлыгы

b:ky:Акча, насыя, банктар - based on another book
b:ky:Апендинин жоруктарынан 502 тамаша, b:ky:Арзуу, b:ky:Жеңижок ырлар жыйнагы b:ky:Мухаммед пайгамбардын баяны, b:ky:Мени бакыт аралынан издебе, b:ky:Улуу сөздөн бир сабак - original composition? I'm not familiar with Wikibooks but where is the line between educational value and not being a webhost?
b:ky:Жолойдун бешиги, b:ky:Карылардан калган сөз - maybe legitimate, might be an essay
b:ky:Информатиканын башталыштарын окутуу, b:ky:Мыкты инсандар, b:ky:Ли Куан Ю, b:ky:Кыргыз тилинин азыркы абалы, b:ky:Тагдыр жана тасма, b:ky:Электрондук почта - legitimate articles (and the only reason this project is not being proposed for closure at the moment)
b:ky:Кызыл-Ой, b:ky:Операциялык системалар, b:ky:Тиркемелерди программалоо интерфейси - written like Wikipedia articles
b:ky:Омокеев Улукбек - list page

There are no admins and there was a spam page that was left untagged for weeks that I had deleted. Rs chen 7754 22:14, 30 July 2022 (UTC)

I was going to originally propose this wiki for closure, but there are 6 unquestionably legitimate pages, so I wanted to get other thoughts on that first. However, 43 of the 61 pages are not legitimate. --Rs chen 7754 23:01, 30 July 2022 (UTC)

Moved to RFC, notification: [1] . --Rs chen 7754 18:24, 13 September 2022 (UTC)