Universal Code of Conduct/Research - Other Wiki projects
 | Voting period for the Universal Code of Conduct Coordinating Committee (U4C) is open through 9 May 2024. Read the information on the voting page on Meta-wiki to learn more about voting and voter eligibility. |
The research methodology is similar to that of one used for Wikipedia projects with one exception. For projects other than Wikipedia we compared the behavioural policies of projects with the Wikimedia Terms of Use and assigned ratings accordingly. Thus, a project with a uniqueness rating of 3 implies that the project has developed at least one unique policy pertinent to its community practices in addition to following the Wikimedia Terms of Use, a uniqueness rating of 2 means that the project has adopted conduct policies from the Wikimedia Terms of Use, but has modified the content to make it more suitable to fit their cultural practices, a uniqueness rating of 1 signifies that the policies of the project are very similar to that of the policies listed in Wikimedia Terms of Use, and lastly a uniqueness rating of 0 indicates that only limited work has been done on the project with respect to developing conduct policies.
Commons[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy Page | 2 = a combination of original and translated policies | |
| Blocking Policy | |||
| Protection Policy | |||
| Administrators/ De-Adminship | |||
| Paid contribution disclosure policy | |||
| Translation administrators/ Policy | |||
| Signatures | |||
| Username Policy | |||
| Use of gender neutral language | |||
| Guidelines | Assume good faith | ||
| Ownership of pages and files | |||
| Talk page guidelines | |||
| User-specific galleries, templates, and categories | |||
| Vandalism | |||
| Rollback | |||
| Patrol | |||
| Nudity | |||
| Photographs of identifiable people |
Wikidata[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy page English | 2 = a combination of original and translated policies | |
| Alternate accounts | |||
| Assume good faith | |||
| Autobiography | |||
| Blocking Policy | |||
| Editing Restrictions | |||
| IP Block Exemption | |||
| No personal Attacks | |||
| Use common sense | |||
| Living People | |||
| Behavioural policy draft |
MediaWiki[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Code of conduct for Wikimedia technical spaces | 2 = a combination of original and translated policies | |
| Code of conduct/FAQ | |||
| Expected behaviour | |||
| Phabricator Etiquette | Phaphricator policies | ||
| Remedies available to users who disagree with Wikimedia Foundation's technical decisions | |||
| Bugzilla Etiquette | Not a Wiki page |
Meta[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy page | 2 = a combination of original and translated policies | |
| Urbanity | |||
| Incivility | |||
| Etiquette | |||
| Guidelines | Dispute Resolution | ||
| Source of conflict | |||
| What mediation is not | |||
| Apology | |||
| Mediation | Draft for possible mediation framework | ||
| Edit war | |||
| Essays | Consensus | The page says - expresses the point of view of some Wikimedians but not widely supported. | |
| Neutral point of view | Interesting- how this is a strong policy on some projects but mere an essay on meta. |
Wikispecies[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy page | 0 = Completely separate structure and content | |
| Biographies of living people | Policy specific to Wikispecies does not exist. The page says the project follows Wikimedia Foundation's resolution on this policy. | ||
| Bot policy | |||
| Draft policy proposal | No original research |
Wiktionary[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy page | The page is not active anymore. Also, this is a draft proposal. It is unofficial, and it is unknown whether it is widely accepted by Wiktionary editors. | 0 = No or little work done on policies |
Wikisource[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy page | 3 = completely separate structure and content | |
| Policies | Blocking policy | Blocking policy lists Vandalism, Excessive reverts, Personal attacks, posting personal details, disruption, etc as possibe reasons for a user getting blocked. | |
| Protection policy | This policy encapsulates policies like malicious edits, edit wars, copyright violations etc. | ||
| Guidelines | Image guidelines |
Wikibooks[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy page | 1 = very similar policy names and content to Wikimedia Terms of Use | |
| Policies | No personal attacks | ||
| Be civil | |||
| Neutral point of view | |||
| Profanity | |||
| Guidelines | Do not bite newcomers | ||
| Be bold | |||
| Draft | Etiquette |
Wikinews[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy page | 3 = completely separate structure and content | |
| Neutral point of view | |||
| Conflict of interest | |||
| Dispute resolution | |||
| Don't disrupt Wikinews to illustrate a point | |||
| Fair use policy | |||
| Username policy | |||
| Image use policy | |||
| Three revert rule | |||
| Guidelines | Etiquette |
Wikiquote[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Official policies | Policy Page | 3 = completely separate structure and content |
| Polices | Neutral point of view | ||
| Image use policy | |||
| Username policy | |||
| Blocking policy | |||
| Guidelines | Assume good faith | ||
| Draft Policies | No personal attacks | ||
| Please do not bite newcomers | |||
| Directly points to Wikipedia policies | Signatures | ||
| Offensive material | This policy is a content guideline on Wikipedia |
Wikivoyage[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Policies | Policy page | The page says that Wikivoyage is subject to all global Wikimedia policies in addition to the policies listed here. | 1 = very similar policy names and content to Wikimedia Terms of Use |
| Be fair | |||
| Avoid negative reviews | |||
| Consensus | |||
| Edit War | |||
| Community portal |
Wikiversity[edit]
| Policy/Guidelines | Policy Links | Policy Specific Comments | Project Uniqueness Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Existing polices | Policy page | 1 = very similar policy names and content to Wikimedia Terms of Use | |
| Assume good faith | |||
| Civility | |||
| Proposed Policies | Username Policy | ||
| Respect people | |||
| No legal threats | |||
| Guidelines | Talkpage guidelines |