User:Der-Wir-Ing/upvote-overview
Statement 1: The Movement Charter should be based on the principle of decentralisation and self-management
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/1
Statement 2: The Movement Charter should enact the right to self-governance of projects
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/2
Statement 3: Subsidiarity should be a guiding principle for the Wikimedia Movement
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/3
Statement 4: The Movement Charter should formalise the principal of subsidiarity
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/4
Statement 5: It is important that the Wikimedia Movement continues to have a single strong organisation at its core
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/5
Statement 6: The Movement Charter should limit the role of the Wikimedia Foundation to 'keep the servers running' and perform some legal duties, such as guarding the trademarks
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/6
Statement 7: The Foundation's role other than that of an fiscal host, should be granted explicitly by the Global Council
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/7
Statement 8: The Wikimedia Movement should be a decentralized movement
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/8
Statement 9: Guidelines on support for Decentralization
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/9
Statement 10: The Wikimedia Movement should be a democratic movement
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/10
Statement 11: Wikimedia organizations will all have a democratic governance
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/11
Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/12
Statement13: The Movement Charter should include our principles
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/13
Statement 14: The Movement Charter should ensure equity in decision making
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/14
Statement 15: The Movement Charter should define Roles and Responsibilities
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/15
Statement 16: The Committee must differentiate goals and principles
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/16
Statement 17: The Movement must recognize the importance of technologies and tools
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/17
Statement 18: The Charter should include transparency requirements on the Foundation and affiliates
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/18
Statement 19: The Movement charter should clearly impose transparency on some instances in the movement (such as the BoT and the Affcom)
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/19
Statement 20: The Charter should open the path for new forms of knowledge representation inside Wikimedia projects
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/20
Statement 21: The WMF should use its communication channels to promote language, content and project diversity
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/21
Statement 21a: The Charter should promote evidence-based governance.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/21a
Statement 21b: The Charter should aim to set up the movement for growth.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/21b
Statement 21c: The Charter should reaffirm the editorial integrity and independence of the editor communities.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/21c
Statement 22: The Movement Charter should establish a Global Council
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/22
Statement 23: The Movement Charter should specify the governance framework for the Wikimedia Movement
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/23
Statement 24: The Global Council should be largely elected on the basis of regional elections where Wikimedians vote for members to represent their geographical area
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/24
Statement 25: It is vital that the Global Council reflects the gender balance of the population, not the gender balance of Wikimedia volunteers
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/25
Statement 26: The election of the Global Council should balance representation of the electorate as a whole, and representation of (small) communities and affiliates
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/26
Statement 27: The Global Council should be a counter voice to the Wikimedia Foundation
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/27
Statement 28: The Global Council shall have the ability to manage assets
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/28
Statement 29: The Global Council should be a legal entity
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/29
Statement 30: The Movement Charter must provide guidelines on the "Structure of Global Council"
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/30
Statement 31: The Foundation must seek advice and opinion from the Global Council about its major decision, including but not limited to the choice of its CEO
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/31
Statement 32: The Foundation and the Global Council must have clearly defined roles
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/32
Statement 33: The charter will be the founding document of a new governance structure, incl. descriptions of roles and responsibilities of (old and new) movement entities.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/33
Statement 34: The Global Council should eventually become the governing body of a new international Wikimedia organization.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/34
Statement 35: The Drafting Committee should decide which governance model the group will work towards before discussing the content of the charter in detail.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/35
Statement 36: The creation of Regional and Thematic Hubs must wait until the Global Council is there to approve them
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/36
Statement 37: The WMF should allocate a massive budget to make our projects technologically better
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/37
Statement 38: The communities should get real access to resources for support.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/38
Statement 39: The Movement Charter should spell out a fair way of allocating resources
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/39
Statement 40: The Movement Charter should pave the way for a chapter with a small office in every country
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/40
Statement 41: The Movement Charter should specify the right for Chapter to raise funds using the Wikipedia and other marks, including banners on Wikipedia pages directed at people residing in their locality
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/41
Statement 42: The Movement Charter should specify the right for Chapters to determine themselves how to spend the money they raised
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/42
Statement 43: The Movement must provide adequate administrative support for affiliates small-in-size
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/43
Statement 44: The Charter should provide guidelines for creation and functioning of Affiliates, local Chapters
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/44
Statement 45: The Movement Charter should recommend a percentage of Wikimedia Movement money to allocate to Wikimedia community organizations
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/45
Statement 46: The Movement Charter should empower independent Wikimedia community evaluation and reporting of Wikimedia Movement finances
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/46
Statement 47: The Movement Charter should send most Wikimedia Movement money into lower and middle income countries
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/47
Statement 48: WMF should allocate funding for administration and operational expenses of Affiliates
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/48
Statement 49: The Movement Charter should confirm that the donations to the Wikimedia Movement belong to the Wikimedia volunteer community
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/49
Statement 50: The Movement Charter should hold movement actors to account
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/50
Statement 51: The Charter should define the rights and limits of all the stakeholders clearly
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/51
Statement 52: The Movement charter should name some specific key roles and stakeholders so that they can be held accountable in need
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/52
Statement 53: The Movement Charter should focus on the relations between the different entities of the Wikiverse
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/53
Statement 54: The Movement Charter should identify formal Communication Channels and a Central Calendar
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/54
Statement 55: The Movement shall give due attention to under-recognized communities
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/55
Statement 56: The Movement Charter should empower volunteers
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/56
Statement 57: The Movement Charter should specify the rights of the volunteer editors
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/57
Statement 58: The Movement Charter should specify the right to communication in all languages
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/58
Statement 59: The Movement Charter should specify the right to local support for localization of templates and gadgets
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/59
Statement 60: The Wikimedia Movement should be a social movement for change and improvement of the lives of volunteer editors, and promote their mental health
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/60
Statement 61: The Movement Charter should provide pathways for dealing with oppression
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/61
Statement 62: The Movement Charter should be inclusive for neurodivergent people
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/62
Statement 63: The Movement Charter should mention Universal Code of Conduct (UCoC)
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/63
Statement 64: The Movement shall make due effort protecting the well-being of its volunteers
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/64
Statement 65: The Movement must provide support for the development of technologies we use by groups or individuals other than the Foundation
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/65
Statement 66: The Charter shall not limit the way each affiliate is organized
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/66
Statement 67: The Movement charter should clarify the boundaries between volunteering and employment, and protect volunteers from being overused in "non-volunteer" work
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/67
Statement 68: The Charter should include no claims to the effect that merely contributing to a Wikimedia project makes a person a member of, or supporter of, any 'movement'
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/68
Statement 69: The Movement Charter should define who its constituents are
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/69
Statement 70: There should be regulation in joining as well as holding a leadership role in affiliate organizations at a given time
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/70
Statement 71: The Membership in the board must also be financially rewarded
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/71
Statement 72: The Movement Charter should be developed in an open, iterative, consultative, participatory and transparent proces
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/72
Statement 73: The Committee may draft specific recommendations alongside of, but not within the Charter
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/73
Statement 74: The committee should have a draft ready for movement ratification within 6 months
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/74
Statement 75: Meta-Wiki should be the only official place for discussion and decision of the Movement Charter
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/75
Statement 76: Movement Charter drafting should be carried out publicly, with as little back-channel communication as possible
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/76
Statement 77: The committee should seek feedback about the Charter also from affiliates' members, donors and readers
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/77
Statement 78: The Committee may seek reviews and advices from others, including experts outside of the movement
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/78
Statement 79: Ensuring regional diversity in the drafting process is more important than ensuring participation from all projects beyond the Wikipedias
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/79
Statement 80: If the drafting and ratification process takes longer than expected, having a Global Council created within a year is more important than having a Charter fully ratified
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/80
Statement 81: The Charter may be drafted, proposed and ratified in parts, not necessarily all at once.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/81
Statement 82: The Drafting Committee should prioritise community engagement, drafting iterations, and translations, even if it requires more time to "do it right"
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/82
Statement 83: The drafting committee should develop the Charter as part of an ongoing conversation with the movement
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/83
Statement 84: The drafting committee should balance the interests of the large communities with the needs of the small groups
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/84
Statement 85: The Drafting Committee should publish monthly reports about recent progress, failures and next steps to take
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/85
Statement 86: The Drafting Committee should work hard in an efficient way to get a good draft as soon as possible and only then propose the draft
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/86
Statement 87: The Drafting Committee should make soon a rough draft, publish it, get feedback, improve and repeat the process
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/87
Statement 88: As part of the drafting process, the Committee should consult with partner organizations from the free knowledge movement
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/88
Statement 89: The drafting process should start with the important negotiations about who makes decisions and how they will be made in the future.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/89
Statement 90: The process should include strong, innovative methods of participatory policy development.
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/90
Statement 91: The Movement Charter should be ratified by all constituents
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/91
Statement 92: The Movement Charter should ensure ratification has confirmation from all core groups, including: editors, projects, affiliates, Board of Trustees
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/92
Statement 93: Communities should be given the space to implement the Movement Charter in a manner suitable to their own local context
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/93
Statement 94: The Movement Charter should be amendable
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/94
Statement 95: The Charter should be a relatively short text focusing on values and principles, leaving the implementation details to policies created by the Global Council
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/95
Statement 96: The language of the Movement Charter should be simple
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/96
Statement 97: The Movement Charter should be written in simple English with translations
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/97
Statement 98: The Movement charter should be detailed and not be a high level document that will allow different interpretations of one thing and its opposite
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/98
Statement 99: The Charter shall be as concise as possibly
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/99
Statement 100: The Charter shall focus on high-level ideas, not implementations
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/100
Statement 101: The Movement Charter as a "Resource Document"
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/101
Statement 102: The Movement Charter must be elaborate but not very specific making it easy to adopt
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/102
Statement 103: Special focus on language & translations of the Movement Charter
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/103
Statement 104: The Movement Charter must follow "Decentralization in focus & review"
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/104
Statement 105: The movement charter should have clear guidelines on scope, budget, timeline, success markers, risks & resources
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/105
Statement 106: The Movement Charter should have information on Oversight, OKRs, and Roles & Responsibilities
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/106
Statement 107: The Movement Charter should have guidelines on meetings, reviews & approvals
[edit]Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/107