User:Der-Wir-Ing/upvote-overview

Statement 1: The Movement Charter should be based on the principle of decentralisation and self-management

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/1

Statement 2: The Movement Charter should enact the right to self-governance of projects

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/2

Statement 3: Subsidiarity should be a guiding principle for the Wikimedia Movement

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/3

Statement 4: The Movement Charter should formalise the principal of subsidiarity

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/4

Statement 5: It is important that the Wikimedia Movement continues to have a single strong organisation at its core

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/5

Statement 6: The Movement Charter should limit the role of the Wikimedia Foundation to 'keep the servers running' and perform some legal duties, such as guarding the trademarks

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/6

Statement 7: The Foundation's role other than that of an fiscal host, should be granted explicitly by the Global Council

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/7

Statement 8: The Wikimedia Movement should be a decentralized movement

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/8

Statement 9: Guidelines on support for Decentralization

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/9

Statement 10: The Wikimedia Movement should be a democratic movement

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/10

Statement 11: Wikimedia organizations will all have a democratic governance

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/11

Statement 12: The Movement Charter should include the WMF’s values

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/12

Statement13: The Movement Charter should include our principles

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/13

Statement 14: The Movement Charter should ensure equity in decision making

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/14

Statement 15: The Movement Charter should define Roles and Responsibilities

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/15

Statement 16: The Committee must differentiate goals and principles

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/16

Statement 17: The Movement must recognize the importance of technologies and tools

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/17

Statement 18: The Charter should include transparency requirements on the Foundation and affiliates

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/18

Statement 19: The Movement charter should clearly impose transparency on some instances in the movement (such as the BoT and the Affcom)

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/19

Statement 20: The Charter should open the path for new forms of knowledge representation inside Wikimedia projects

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/20

Statement 21: The WMF should use its communication channels to promote language, content and project diversity

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/21

Statement 21a: The Charter should promote evidence-based governance.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/21a

Statement 21b: The Charter should aim to set up the movement for growth.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/21b

Statement 21c: The Charter should reaffirm the editorial integrity and independence of the editor communities.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/21c

Statement 22: The Movement Charter should establish a Global Council

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/22

Statement 23: The Movement Charter should specify the governance framework for the Wikimedia Movement

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/23

Statement 24: The Global Council should be largely elected on the basis of regional elections where Wikimedians vote for members to represent their geographical area

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/24

Statement 25: It is vital that the Global Council reflects the gender balance of the population, not the gender balance of Wikimedia volunteers

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/25

Statement 26: The election of the Global Council should balance representation of the electorate as a whole, and representation of (small) communities and affiliates

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/26

Statement 27: The Global Council should be a counter voice to the Wikimedia Foundation

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/27

Statement 28: The Global Council shall have the ability to manage assets

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/28

Statement 29: The Global Council should be a legal entity

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/29

Statement 30: The Movement Charter must provide guidelines on the "Structure of Global Council"

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/30

Statement 31: The Foundation must seek advice and opinion from the Global Council about its major decision, including but not limited to the choice of its CEO

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/31

Statement 32: The Foundation and the Global Council must have clearly defined roles

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/32

Statement 33: The charter will be the founding document of a new governance structure, incl. descriptions of roles and responsibilities of (old and new) movement entities.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/33

Statement 34: The Global Council should eventually become the governing body of a new international Wikimedia organization.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/34

Statement 35: The Drafting Committee should decide which governance model the group will work towards before discussing the content of the charter in detail.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/35

Statement 36: The creation of Regional and Thematic Hubs must wait until the Global Council is there to approve them

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/36

Statement 37: The WMF should allocate a massive budget to make our projects technologically better

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/37

Statement 38: The communities should get real access to resources for support.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/38

Statement 39: The Movement Charter should spell out a fair way of allocating resources

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/39

Statement 40: The Movement Charter should pave the way for a chapter with a small office in every country

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/40

Statement 41: The Movement Charter should specify the right for Chapter to raise funds using the Wikipedia and other marks, including banners on Wikipedia pages directed at people residing in their locality

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/41

Statement 42: The Movement Charter should specify the right for Chapters to determine themselves how to spend the money they raised

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/42

Statement 43: The Movement must provide adequate administrative support for affiliates small-in-size

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/43

Statement 44: The Charter should provide guidelines for creation and functioning of Affiliates, local Chapters

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/44

Statement 45: The Movement Charter should recommend a percentage of Wikimedia Movement money to allocate to Wikimedia community organizations

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/45

Statement 46: The Movement Charter should empower independent Wikimedia community evaluation and reporting of Wikimedia Movement finances

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/46

Statement 47: The Movement Charter should send most Wikimedia Movement money into lower and middle income countries

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/47

Statement 48: WMF should allocate funding for administration and operational expenses of Affiliates

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/48

Statement 49: The Movement Charter should confirm that the donations to the Wikimedia Movement belong to the Wikimedia volunteer community

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/49

Statement 50: The Movement Charter should hold movement actors to account

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/50

Statement 51: The Charter should define the rights and limits of all the stakeholders clearly

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/51

Statement 52: The Movement charter should name some specific key roles and stakeholders so that they can be held accountable in need

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/52

Statement 53: The Movement Charter should focus on the relations between the different entities of the Wikiverse

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/53

Statement 54: The Movement Charter should identify formal Communication Channels and a Central Calendar

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/54

Statement 55: The Movement shall give due attention to under-recognized communities

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/55

Statement 56: The Movement Charter should empower volunteers

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/56

Statement 57: The Movement Charter should specify the rights of the volunteer editors

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/57

Statement 58: The Movement Charter should specify the right to communication in all languages

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/58

Statement 59: The Movement Charter should specify the right to local support for localization of templates and gadgets

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/59

Statement 60: The Wikimedia Movement should be a social movement for change and improvement of the lives of volunteer editors, and promote their mental health

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/60

Statement 61: The Movement Charter should provide pathways for dealing with oppression

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/61

Statement 62: The Movement Charter should be inclusive for neurodivergent people

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/62

Statement 63: The Movement Charter should mention Universal Code of Conduct (UCoC)

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/63

Statement 64: The Movement shall make due effort protecting the well-being of its volunteers

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/64

Statement 65: The Movement must provide support for the development of technologies we use by groups or individuals other than the Foundation

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/65

Statement 66: The Charter shall not limit the way each affiliate is organized

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/66

Statement 67: The Movement charter should clarify the boundaries between volunteering and employment, and protect volunteers from being overused in "non-volunteer" work

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/67

Statement 68: The Charter should include no claims to the effect that merely contributing to a Wikimedia project makes a person a member of, or supporter of, any 'movement'

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/68

Statement 69: The Movement Charter should define who its constituents are

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/69

Statement 70: There should be regulation in joining as well as holding a leadership role in affiliate organizations at a given time

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/70

Statement 71: The Membership in the board must also be financially rewarded

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/71

Statement 72: The Movement Charter should be developed in an open, iterative, consultative, participatory and transparent proces

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/72

Statement 73: The Committee may draft specific recommendations alongside of, but not within the Charter

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/73

Statement 74: The committee should have a draft ready for movement ratification within 6 months

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/74

Statement 75: Meta-Wiki should be the only official place for discussion and decision of the Movement Charter

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/75

Statement 76: Movement Charter drafting should be carried out publicly, with as little back-channel communication as possible

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/76

Statement 77: The committee should seek feedback about the Charter also from affiliates' members, donors and readers

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/77

Statement 78: The Committee may seek reviews and advices from others, including experts outside of the movement

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/78

Statement 79: Ensuring regional diversity in the drafting process is more important than ensuring participation from all projects beyond the Wikipedias

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/79

Statement 80: If the drafting and ratification process takes longer than expected, having a Global Council created within a year is more important than having a Charter fully ratified

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/80

Statement 81: The Charter may be drafted, proposed and ratified in parts, not necessarily all at once.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/81

Statement 82: The Drafting Committee should prioritise community engagement, drafting iterations, and translations, even if it requires more time to "do it right"

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/82

Statement 83: The drafting committee should develop the Charter as part of an ongoing conversation with the movement

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/83

Statement 84: The drafting committee should balance the interests of the large communities with the needs of the small groups

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/84

Statement 85: The Drafting Committee should publish monthly reports about recent progress, failures and next steps to take

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/85

Statement 86: The Drafting Committee should work hard in an efficient way to get a good draft as soon as possible and only then propose the draft

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/86

Statement 87: The Drafting Committee should make soon a rough draft, publish it, get feedback, improve and repeat the process

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/87

Statement 88: As part of the drafting process, the Committee should consult with partner organizations from the free knowledge movement

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/88

Statement 89: The drafting process should start with the important negotiations about who makes decisions and how they will be made in the future.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/89

Statement 90: The process should include strong, innovative methods of participatory policy development.

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/90

Statement 91: The Movement Charter should be ratified by all constituents

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/91

Statement 92: The Movement Charter should ensure ratification has confirmation from all core groups, including: editors, projects, affiliates, Board of Trustees

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/92

Statement 93: Communities should be given the space to implement the Movement Charter in a manner suitable to their own local context

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/93

Statement 94: The Movement Charter should be amendable

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/94

Statement 95: The Charter should be a relatively short text focusing on values and principles, leaving the implementation details to policies created by the Global Council

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/95

Statement 96: The language of the Movement Charter should be simple

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/96

Statement 97: The Movement Charter should be written in simple English with translations

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/97

Statement 98: The Movement charter should be detailed and not be a high level document that will allow different interpretations of one thing and its opposite

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/98

Statement 99: The Charter shall be as concise as possibly

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/99

Statement 100: The Charter shall focus on high-level ideas, not implementations

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/100

Statement 101: The Movement Charter as a "Resource Document"

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/101

Statement 102: The Movement Charter must be elaborate but not very specific making it easy to adopt

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/102

Statement 103: Special focus on language & translations of the Movement Charter

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/103

Statement 104: The Movement Charter must follow "Decentralization in focus & review"

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/104

Statement 105: The movement charter should have clear guidelines on scope, budget, timeline, success markers, risks & resources

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/105

Statement 106: The Movement Charter should have information on Oversight, OKRs, and Roles & Responsibilities

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/106

Statement 107: The Movement Charter should have guidelines on meetings, reviews & approvals

Movement Charter/Drafting Committee/Election Compass Statements/107