Jump to content

User talk:Holapaco77/Archive 6

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Latest comment: 1 year ago by ZandDev in topic Entry removal from TOW Page

TOTW candidates

Hello! I would like to clarify some things regarding your votes on the TOTW candidates page:

1) Voting against a certain article declaring it "too short" is counterproductive, since the TOTW criteria state that ideal candidates are short and may be stubs.

2) You can't argue against every enterprise for it being WP:PROMO. If the article is well referenced, objective, encyclopedic, and doesn't imply a conflict of interest, then it's all good to go.

3) Regarding the w:Movement for the officiality of the Asturian language proposal, it's referenced in Spanish, English, and Catalan.

4) Regarding the w:es:Glotofagia proposal, it's in 13 languages already, yet not English, Portuguese, Swedish, etc. which some translators tend to work in.

5) Then again, there are decisions you didn't justify, such as voting against Tucking, Starbuck Unions, or Huia Jahnke. It would be nice to know what's wrong with them.

Have a nice day! --Brunnaiz (talk) 12:04, 17 September 2022 (UTC)

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-38

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-39

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-41

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-42

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-43

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-44

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-45

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-46

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-47

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-48

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2022-49

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-02

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-03

Entry removal from TOW Page

(English)

I've noticed that you've recently unlisted a number of removable candidates from the Candidates for Translation of the week list.
At the same time, it would be necessary to list the removed entities on the following page: Translation of the week/Removed for the current year, or here Translation of the week/Removed/Archive/<year> for the past years, in chronological order of removal (i.e. you remove an item and add it on top).

(Italian)

Ho notato che recentemente hai tolto dall'elenco numerosi candidati dalla lista dei candidati per la Traduzione della settimana.
Contemporaneamente sarebbe necessario elencare gli elementi rimossi nella seguente pagina: Translation of the week/Removed pe l'anno corrente, oppure qui Translation of the week/Removed/Archive/<anno> per gli anni passati, in ordine cronologico di rimozione (cioè si rimuove e si aggiunge in cima).

ZandDev (talk) 21:38, 25 January 2023 (UTC)

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-06

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-07

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-08

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-09

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-10

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-11

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-12

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-13

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-16

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-17

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-18

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-19

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-20

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-22

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-23

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-24

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-26

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-27

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-29

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-30

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-31

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-32

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-33

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-34

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-35

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-36

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-37

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-38

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-42

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-43

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-44

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-45

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-46

Wikipedia translation of the week: 2023-47