WMDE Technical Wishes/Geoinformation/Nearby articles

Edit links
From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki

Description[edit]

Within the topic “Better support for Geoinformation” the Technical Wishes team aimed to implement some improvements to Kartographer. To find out what kind of improvements are desired, a survey on international wikis using Kartographer and the German-speaking community was conducted in March 2022. The most popular request was the display of nearby articles on a map, next to the use of QIDs from Wikidata to add a marker to a map. The detailed results of the survey are published here. This feature was also requested in this year's Community Wishlist Survey 2022 run by the Wikimedia Foundation, where it also found numerous supporters.

This additional feature makes it possible to display geographically close articles on a Kartographer map. It offers an additional way of reading Wikipedia, where articles are geographically related to each other and may be explored as such.

Status[edit]

  • Deploy the feature to pilot wikis
    • Green tickY October 12, 2022: German-language, Catalan and Hebrew Wikipedia, and English Wikivoyage
    • Green tickY October 27, 2022: German-language Wikivoyage
    • Green tickY November 9, 2022: Russian-language Wikipedia
  • Green tickY March 2023: deploy clusters for nearby articles and a "reload results" button to the wikis above
  • Green tickY March 2023: "show nearby articles" works in mobile view
  • Deploy the feature to more wikis
    • Green tickY April 11, 2023: all remaining wikis which are not using the Wikivoyage feature "Explore nearby destinations"
      • Green tickY May 2, 2023: enable for the mobile view
    • Green tickY May 24, 2023: replace the Wikivoyage feature "Explore nearby destinations" to reduce the amount of code to be maintained, and a similar user experience across all wikis

How it works[edit]

In full-screen mode, each Kartographer map has a button labelled “Show nearby articles” at the bottom of the map. It can be used to show up to 300 geographically close articles. The nearby articles are generated from the wiki the reader is currently at.

Nearby articles are displayed on the map as gray circles. This way, they are clearly distinguishable from the markers that have been manually added by the creator of the map. Both kinds of markers are shown on the map at the same time.

  • The show nearby articles feature in a Kartographer map
  • The image shows the section of a Kartographer map from Monte Carlo. On the map, there are several grey circles. Those are the nearby articles. One circle shows a pop-up with a title, a description and an image. This is what happens when you click on a grey marker. Also on the map is a red marker with an icon in it. This marker does not indicate a nearby article, it was added manually to this map.
    Nearby articles are displayed as gray circles. When you click on a circle, a pop-up shows up with the title, a description, and a picture of the article. In this image, there is also a red marker with an icon. These markers were added manually.
  • This screenshot shows the "show nearby articles" button at the bottom of the map. This example also shows a cluster of two nearby articles and the reload button at the top of the map.
    This screenshot shows the "show nearby articles" button at the bottom of the map. This example also shows a cluster of two nearby articles and the reload button at the top of the map.

Clicking on the marker of a nearby article opens a pop-up containing the title, a brief description and an image of the article. Clicking on the title will take you from the map view to the article itself. If the article is linked to an entry on Wikidata, the pop-up displays a brief description from Wikidata. The image originates from the article itself and is provided by the MediaWiki extension PageImages, which also powers the images for the page preview pop-ups.

Multiple pins at the same location are clustered into groups when zooming out and unclustered when zooming in. A "reload results" button appears when you zoom in or out, or when you move on the map.

The search for the nearby articles is performed by CirrusSearch, combined with the "nearcoord:" search feature of the GeoData extension. While CirrusSearch prioritizes the articles according to their relevance, "nearcoord:" determines articles whose coordinates lie within the specified surrounding search radius. The coordinates of articles are defined with the help of the GeoData extension. This way, the top 300 relevant nearby articles are found and are given a marker on the map.

Wikivoyage[edit]

In Kartographer maps on Wikivoyage, there was already a similar feature displaying nearby articles. This feature and the one developed by the Technical Wishes Team did exist in parallel for testing purposes.

  • "Explore nearby destinations" feature on Wikivoyage
  • Explore nearby destinations button in the upper left corner of a map
    Explore nearby destinations button in the upper left corner of a map
  • Explore nearby destinations feature activated
    Explore nearby destinations feature activated

Comparison of the Wikivoyage feature and the new feature[edit]

Wikivoyage feature

“Explore nearby destinations”

New feature

“Show nearby articles”

What it looks like

Nearby articles are displayed as gray pin markers.

When you click on it, you see:

  • title with link
  • image

Nearby articles are displayed as gray circles.

When you click on it, you see:

  • title with link
  • image
  • description from Wikidata
Availability on Wikivoyage
  • 9 Wikivoyages are using this feature (T333821)
  • This feature requires the "Wikivoyage mode" of Kartographer
 on all wikis using Kartographer
How the nearby articles are defined There is one list per wiki that includes all destinations. This list needs to be updated manually.

Updates of that list rely on other structures on the wiki, e.g., certain templates.

Nearby articles are defined automatically, from all articles of the wiki.

CirrusSearch is used to prioritize the articles according to their relevance. The search feature "nearcoord:" from the GeoData extension determines articles whose coordinates lie within the specified surrounding search radius.

How to turn it on with the icon underneath the zoom controls with a button labelled “show nearby articles” at the bottom
What happens when the nearby mode is activated?
  • The map automatically zooms out.
  • Manually set markers are hidden. You can select the layers containing the manual markers to show them again.
  • In the area you're looking at, you see all the articles that have been defined manually for this wiki.
  • When you move the area or zoom in/out, the results reload automatically.
  • No automatic zooming: The section of the map doesn't change.
  • Manually set markers are still shown.
  • In the area you're looking at, you see up to 300 articles.
  • When you move the area or zoom in/out, you can reload results with the button “reload results”.
Works on the embedded map in the article page ✅ yes ⛔ no, the feature only works on full size maps

(For performance reasons, it's only possible to interact with embedded maps on Wikivoyage.)

Works on mobile ✅ yes ✅ yes



Notes[edit]

At first glance, the new feature is somewhat resembling the Special:Nearby page, which displays articles that are geographically close to the reader's location. Here, too, the wish was repeatedly expressed that the articles should be displayed on a map instead of in a linear list. Since the special page and the new feature are different MediaWiki features, the new functionality of “Show nearby articles” in Kartographer generated maps cannot simply be transferred to the special page.

Links[edit]

Feedback[edit]

Comments, questions, and suggestions about this feature are welcome on the discussion page!

Retrieved from "https://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=WMDE_Technical_Wishes/Geoinformation/Nearby_articles&oldid=25071407"