Add topic
From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki

Closing process[edit]

Is there any conclusion about the process to follow to close (I don't see any conclusion in Talk:Stewards/confirm/2010#Planning_the_2011_confirmations)? The only sure thing I see is that we already have an election committee (and now stewards can decide :-) ). --Nemo 12:35, 13 February 2011 (UTC)Reply

Confirmations - closing discussion for stewards[edit]

This section is for steward discussion only. Please do not comment in this box unless you are a steward. Other community members, please discuss in a separate section.

After considering the comments and discussions, ElectCom has come up with the following results on the annual re-confirmation of existing Stewards. All stewards are welcome to comment on the results below.

Name Result Comments
Andre Engels Confirmed Opposes are on anger management issues not related to steward actions and are duly noted. The ElectCom has decided that Andre should be reconfirmed for the term as he was active enough per policy.
Avraham Confirmed Nihil obstat
Bastique Confirmed Nihil obstat
Darkoneko Confirmed Nihil obstat
DerHexer Confirmed Opposition is on the use of oversight tool in jawiki, which is found to be within the policies.
Dferg Confirmed Nihil obstat, sole objection seems to be out of misunderstanding of the steward's role and was retracted.
Dungodung Confirmed Opposition was based on a comment on WizardOfOz's meta cratship request. The action was within the policies and not counted as a misuse of the tools.
Erwin Confirmed Nihil obstat
guillom Confirmed Ottava's objection is noted but not counted against confirmation, as it is on a personal level and not related to steward work guillom has performed.
J.delanoy Confirmed Nihil obstat
Jusjih Confirmed Nihil obstat
Jyothis Confirmed Nihil obstat
Kylu Resigned Nihil obstat, but Kylu has decided that it is time to step down from the Steward role. ElectCom would like to thank Kylu for the time and effort.
Laaknor Confirmed Ottava's opposition on desysop issue is noted, but weighing in the details, ElectCom has decided to reconfirm.
Leinad Confirmed Nihil obstat
M7 Confirmed Opposition on the non-steward actions were not counted against the confirmation.
Magister Mathematicae Confirmed Oppositions without definitive proof and non-steward activities were not counted against the confirmation.
Mardetanha Confirmed Nihil obstat, sole objection was revoked by the user
Mav Confirmed Objections related non-steward activities or objections without reasoning were not counted against the confirmation.
Melos Confirmed Nihil obstat
Mercy Confirmed Nihil obstat
Millosh Confirmed Objection is on inactivity. Millosh has performed the minimum actions per policy and is hence reconfirmed.
Nick1915 Confirmed Nihil obstat, Mayur's objection was struck.
Pathoschild Confirmed Objections raised are not related to steward actions and was not counted against the confirmation.
Rdsmith4 Not confirmed Not active per policy and we would like to thank Rdsmith4 for his work.
Shanel Confirmed Nihil obstat
Shizhao Confirmed Confirm, accusations against him are not backed up by proof, and are not related to steward actions.
Sj Resigned Nihil obstat, but Sj has decided to step down. We thank Sj for his contributions in the role.
Thogo Confirmed Thogo will be restored to the post once his term in OC ends. Objections against Thogo was were not counted against the confirmation as it was not found to be backed by evidences.
Wutsje Confirmed Objections are not steward activity related and not counted against the confirmation.


Stewards (both old and new) may express their questions, concerns or agreement to the results below.

Done Confirmations are officially closed and the results implemented. We thank everyone for their participation and their hard work for the project. --Jyothis 19:27, 11 March 2011 (UTC)Reply