Wikimedia Foundation Board noticeboard
- For details of the Board's role and processes, see the Board Handbook.
- Threads older than 90 days will be automatically archived by ArchiverBot.
2026-2027 WMF Annual Plan
[edit]Hello, we are already in the fourth week of the new WMF fiscal year. Has the Board announced the finalized 2026-2027 WMF Annual Plan? By the way, there remain unanswered questions and comments on the draft plan's talk page. ↠Pine (✉) 19:49, 23 July 2026 (UTC)
- Hi @LLosa (WMF): can you please explain what is (not) going on here? The Annual Plan should have been finalized and published around the 1st of July. Also, almost three weeks have passed since I posed the question above, and no one from the staff or Board has responded. The Annual Plan is one of the Board's most important responsibilities, a finalized version should have been published in a timely way, and there should not be multiple unanswered questions on the Annual Plan talk page. ↠Pine (✉) 20:07, 12 August 2026 (UTC)
- Hello, sorry for the delay in getting back to you. The plan was approved by the board and is being implemented with regular progress reported in the Foundation bulletin - here, here and here. The resolution that approved the annual plan will be published on Foundation wiki in the next few days and the annual plan itself has been updated.
- The delay happened because of a combination of staffs' annual leave and that a lot of the same people involved in these updates also having responsibilities at Wikimania, which happened slightly earlier than most years this year. On your questions on the annual plan talk page, as they span different areas of work, different Foundation teams will come back to them.
- Community and And Affiliate Liaison to the Board Victoria (talk) 14:54, 14 August 2026 (UTC)
- @Victoria: thanks very much for following up. I would suggest that next year there be more focus on ensuring regular staff engagement where needed on the Annual Plan discussion page and that the finalized plan be published within 1 week of ratification by the Board. From a governance perspective, Wikimania is far less important than the Annual Plan and annual budget, and I suggest that next year staff be prioritized first to Annual Plan and annual budget work, and only after the necessary work has been done would staff spend time on lower priority tasks like Wikimania. If the Annual Plan and annual budget work had been almost completely done by the end of June with only minor changes needed before publication then there would be multiple weeks of buffer time between the end of Annual Plan and Wikimania, instead of what seems to have happened here with spillover work post July 1 causing conflicts with Wikimania needs. Additionally, I suggest that staff who are involved with annual plan and annual budget work not be allowed to take annual leave around the time that this critical work is happening, perhaps by blocking such leave between mid-June and early July for those staff. ↠Pine (✉) 20:59, 15 August 2026 (UTC)
- I must say that the Board is not involved in the operational decisions - it's not our place to tell staff what to do (or not). Victoria (talk) 08:58, 18 August 2026 (UTC)
- I wish certain Board members would stop claiming this. It is your place to tell the CEO what to do. In fact, it's your fiduciary duty to supervise the CEO and ensure they're doing their job correctly. Making sure the CEO puts out the financials on time is the Trustees' responsibility. It's not a big deal that it's a little late once, but it is a big deal if the trustees, or some of them, think that supervision is someone else's job. Everything that happens at the WMF is the trustees' responsibility. The buck stops with the trustees. It says so in the bylaws. (It's on my userpage as a reminder to all.) Levivich (talk) 11:30, 18 August 2026 (UTC)
- @Victoria: thank you for sharing your opinion. However, in my opinion financial and operational planning, including publishing high quality plans and budgets in timely ways, should be mandatory requirements of the CEO's job. If the CEO fails to meet the expectations of the job, whether in financial planning or any other way, then the Board should hold the CEO accountable. And I would find it troubling if the Board does not consider a Board responsibility to be holding the CEO accountable for CEO failures to fulfill their job description. For an approximately $500,000 per year compensation package, I would expect a CEO to be consistent and exemplary at producing and publishing budgets and plans in timely ways. Let me now ask a few more more questions: is there a job description of the CEO, and if yes then where is it published, and if not then will the Board please publish it promptly? And what is the Board's normal practice for evaluating the CEO's performance? Thanks, ༄ᨒ𖠰 Pine (✉) 19:38, 22 August 2026 (UTC)
- Former auditcom chair here: the Annual Plan page on meta should be updated once the vote happens to indicate it was approved, and which version was referenced. An 8 week delay is a lot for there to be any uncertainty about the outcome.
- I see that while minutes and resolutions used to be published "within 5 weeks" of a meeting (already a long time), this was loosened in 2022 to "usually at the next board meeting", which seems too lax for comfort.
- Part of the issue is downstream of high transparency: the approval step has become sufficiently pro-forma that the draft plan on Meta, after a few iterations, is already treated as final. But as the most time-consuming and substantive decision process each year, the process should be tied up with a bow. –SJ talk 12:40, 23 August 2026 (UTC)
- Hey @Sj (and others)! Yes, you're right. It took too long to publish the Annual Plan resolution and we will work to do it earlier next year. MaciejNadzikiewicz-WMF/Nadzik (talk) 17:19, 26 August 2026 (UTC)
- @MaciejNadzikiewicz-WMF: thank you. Please also see the requests above to publish the CEO's job description, and for a request to describe the Board's normal practice for evaluating the CEO's performance. If Victoria or someone else will respond to those, that's fine. Thanks, ༄ᨒ𖠰 Pine (✉) 06:40, 28 August 2026 (UTC)
- Hey @Pine, the CEO job description was published when we announced the search in May last year; you can find it on the WMF's website. I hope this helps! MaciejNadzikiewicz-WMF/Nadzik (talk) 08:39, 28 August 2026 (UTC)
- @Nadzik: thank you. What is the Board's normal practice for evaluating the CEO's performance? ༄ᨒ𖠰 Pine (✉) 03:14, 10 October 2026 (UTC)
- Providing guidance to the CEO is one of the key board responsibilities. As part of that, we have an annual process (aligned with the Foundation's fiscal year, so July to June) to discuss goals and results. The main motivation is to ensure that the CEO and the board are aligned and have a shared understanding of the priorities, so that both can do their job well and partner effectively. It also informs compensation decisions.
- The process is led by the executive committee of the board. We begin by discussing with the CEO what are the most important things to focus on, and ask her to propose a first draft of the goals. We then work together on the draft, reaching a final version with the Executive Committee, and presenting it to the full board (in executive session). This is the stage we are in now: a first draft was presented to the board in the last regular meeting (in July, at Wikimania) and the final version is planned for the next one (in December).
- As Bernadette joined the Foundation in January 2026, this is the first cycle we are going through this process with her. Such processes are generally agreed with each CEO, so there are likely some changes compared with what we did with Maryana. We also decided to take more time than usual to discuss the goals, in order to give Bernadette enough time to get to know Wikimedia: as we know, this is a rather complex place, and onboarding takes more time than a normal workplace. - LLosa (WMF) (talk) 19:38, 20 October 2026 (UTC)
- @LLosa (WMF): thanks for sharing that framework. My concern that most prompted my line of questions here relates to the handling of the 2026-2027 Annual Plan. I mentioned some of my observations also to User:KCollins-WMF when she kindly agreed to have a brief hallway discussion with me at WikiConference North America. Please note how many sections did not get responses from staff or otherwise seem to be loose ends on the talk page, such as "Report from the Community Insights survey", "Engagement and inclusion survey", "Education programs", "GLAM programs", "How to rank priorities in the plan", "Explain diversification of revenue", "To much focus on end users", "Code quality & task closure metrics", "Establish local Endowments", "Move WikiProject functions to Categories", "Some notes", "Guided tours", and probably I would find more if I continue searching through the page. If the community was invited to put substantial time into reviewing the plan then I would expect WMF to also devote substantial time to responding to comments, before the plan is finalized. I view engaging with the process as essential to good governance, and essential to the CEO's job. I would hope that there will be some frank communications with the CEO about this year's Annual Plan process, including why there are so many loose ends on that talk page months after the plan has been finalized. According to Victoria's response above there would be responses from staff, but I don't see much actual effort being put into this even after Victoria's post. And as has already been noted, there was a lengthy delay between the Board's ratification of the Plan and the publication of revisions for the finalized plan. And I do not want to hear all of these issues casually dismissed as excusable because this is the current CEO's first year on the job. WMF has been doing Annual Plans for a long time, and the current CEO is new to the Wikimedia Foundation but she is not a novice executive. To be blunt, I expected far better, and I hope that the Board did too and will be discussing this with the CEO. ༄ᨒ𖠰 Pine (✉) 04:01, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
- I must say that the Board is not involved in the operational decisions - it's not our place to tell staff what to do (or not). Victoria (talk) 08:58, 18 August 2026 (UTC)
- @Victoria: thanks very much for following up. I would suggest that next year there be more focus on ensuring regular staff engagement where needed on the Annual Plan discussion page and that the finalized plan be published within 1 week of ratification by the Board. From a governance perspective, Wikimania is far less important than the Annual Plan and annual budget, and I suggest that next year staff be prioritized first to Annual Plan and annual budget work, and only after the necessary work has been done would staff spend time on lower priority tasks like Wikimania. If the Annual Plan and annual budget work had been almost completely done by the end of June with only minor changes needed before publication then there would be multiple weeks of buffer time between the end of Annual Plan and Wikimania, instead of what seems to have happened here with spillover work post July 1 causing conflicts with Wikimania needs. Additionally, I suggest that staff who are involved with annual plan and annual budget work not be allowed to take annual leave around the time that this critical work is happening, perhaps by blocking such leave between mid-June and early July for those staff. ↠Pine (✉) 20:59, 15 August 2026 (UTC)
June and July board meeting outcomes
[edit]The Board met recently in June and July, with the meetings approximately 4 weeks apart. In June, the Board approved the FY2026-2027 Annual Plan and Budget. You can read more about that here. The Board also updated the Product and Technology Committee membership.
In July, the Board met on Monday, July 20 before Wikimania. You can read more about the Board's reflections on Wikimania here.
During the Board meeting, the Board approved several resolutions, including approving the June Board meeting minutes. We also renewed terms for Kathy Collins and Mayree Clark. Kathy will be starting her second term, which will go into effect December 31, 2026-January 1, 2030. Mayree was finishing the term of Esra'a Al Shafei and will now begin a full three-year term which will go into effect December 31, 2026 - January 1, 2030.
This meeting was also Raju Narisetti's last meeting and we thanked him for his nine years as a Trustee. Raju has played many important roles on the Board, including Vice Chair of the Board and Chairing committees like the Governance Committee and the former Talent and Culture Committee, and leading the recruitment of two CEOs. Mayree Clark will now become a Vice Chair and Maciej Nadzikiewicz will chair the Governance Committee for the remainder of the year. The Board updated its committee compositions to reflect these changes.
During the meeting, we discussed several strategic issues, including the Movement Ecosystem pilot as well as an update from the neutral point of view working group. During Wikimania, the Board also had informal meetings with the Global Resource Distribution Committee (GRDC) and the Affiliations Committee (AffCom) to hear about their ongoing work.
The Board will meet again in September to hear more about the revised Movement Ecosystem work. - LLosa (WMF) (talk) 15:14, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
- "This year’s budget is set for expenses at $240M and revenue at $230M" ... woah, is that the first time ever (or in like 20 years) that expenses > revenue? That seems like kind of a big deal? Last year's budget was $208.5M. Why did the Board increase the budget by $31.5M if revenue is only expected to increase by $21.5M? What do we need to buy now that we never bought before that is important enough to justify $10M in deficit spending? Levivich (talk) 17:02, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
- Isn’t the $10M the reserve to be able to fund new strategic initiatives to face traffic drops that could be design during the year to be able to fund them without tapping into other planned expenses ? It’s documented in Wikimedia Foundation Annual Plan/2026-2027/Budget Overview in Working Capital Reserve. As it would be considered as CAPEX it makes sense for it not to be part of the usual revenue/spendings balance. Though it should be better isolated in the budget I agree. schiste (talk) 18:46, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
- A $10M off-budget capex in one year? What are they gonna do, launch a satellite? 😁 Or is this to fund a CBA with +$20k benefits for ~500 FTEs? Levivich (talk) 20:50, 21 August 2026 (UTC)
- If you want to build an actual GPU Cluster, you would take a good dent into that envelope. Same to invest in Enterprise to deploy new products. Having that pocket doesn’t change investment capacities (a budget is a projection) but it does signal to staff at the very least that any sizeable investment they may need, if it’s within the goal, could be funded on top of the +15% budget growth. schiste (talk) 10:33, 22 August 2026 (UTC)
- A $10M off-budget capex in one year? What are they gonna do, launch a satellite? 😁 Or is this to fund a CBA with +$20k benefits for ~500 FTEs? Levivich (talk) 20:50, 21 August 2026 (UTC)
- Isn’t the $10M the reserve to be able to fund new strategic initiatives to face traffic drops that could be design during the year to be able to fund them without tapping into other planned expenses ? It’s documented in Wikimedia Foundation Annual Plan/2026-2027/Budget Overview in Working Capital Reserve. As it would be considered as CAPEX it makes sense for it not to be part of the usual revenue/spendings balance. Though it should be better isolated in the budget I agree. schiste (talk) 18:46, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
Thanks, I left a comment at Talk:Updating the ecosystem of Wikimedia organizations/Recognition and Funding for Movement Organizations. This is probably the single most important thing the board will get done in this term, and I'm concerned that it's just carrying on as a bureaucratic exercise with tweaks here and there but without a direction. Nemo 07:17, 21 August 2026 (UTC)
- Agreed that this is the most impactful decision being made in the next few months, along the lines of making the movement more robust to change and able to experiment broadly. –SJ talk 11:59, 23 August 2026 (UTC)
- Hi @LLosa (WMF): earlier in the year you agreed to try my suggestion that the Board publish agendas in advance of its meetings. Were those agendas published in advance for the June and July meetings, and if so, would you please share where they were published? Thanks, ༄ᨒ𖠰 Pine (✉) 05:58, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
- crickets Kowal2701 (talk) 20:10, 2 September 2026 (UTC)
- @Pine, indeed they weren't. We agreed to publish them in advance, but somehow that was missed. They have been published now together with the remaining past agendas that were missing - thanks for pointing that out. We maintain the plan to publish the agenda of the next regular board meeting (December) in advance of the meeting (one week or so before); it will probably include movement ecosystem and board selections as main points (which are currently or have been recently been in consultation), in addition to the routine December appointments. - LLosa (WMF) (talk) 11:49, 4 September 2026 (UTC)
- @LLosa (WMF): thank you. Some years ago when the Board was planning upcoming meetings and agendas became available, there were also advance email announcements to wikimediaannounce-l, such as "[Wikimedia Announcements] Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees December 2023 meeting agenda" and "[Wikimedia Announcements] Board of Trustees November 2018 meeting agenda". It would be nice to re-establish this practice, although I will understand if the Board wishes to use some other method for sending push announcements given that email traffic on the associated Wikimedia-l list these days mostly seems to be event announcements and I am not sure that list is viewed as a global village pump equivalent. Perhaps agendas could be published to that list but also announced on this Board noticeboard, and on the Wikimedia Forum. These methods for publications are all suggestions only, and I would be fine with the Board delegating to the WMF Communications and/or Legal teams how best to share announcements of upcoming WMF Board agendas. In whichever way the agenda announcements are shared, I suggest that the same methods be used for publishing Board meeting minutes and associated notes, such as User:Antanana did when she was chair and which I appreciated. Thanks again, ༄ᨒ𖠰 Pine (✉) 04:13, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
"Oversight and long-time direction"
[edit](message by Llosa reposted by Fram from User talk:BMeehan-WMF on 7 September)
The Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees respects the decision made by eligible staff in today's U.S. union election, which was a timely process that helped ensure that all voters had the opportunity to participate meaningfully in a decision that affects them.
The next phase is collective bargaining, and the Foundation will engage in good-faith conversations with the union to reach an agreement. Our hope is that both parties will come to the bargaining table with proposals that advance the Wikimedia mission of making free knowledge accessible to the world. At a time when we face significant changes in how readers engage with our content, the need to grow and retain contributors and to preserve public trust in Wikipedia and its sister projects, it is especially important that we find ways to work together to evolve, adapt, and respond to a world that is presenting our projects with significant challenges.
The Board will continue to provide oversight and long-term direction to Foundation leadership as this work proceeds. We will remain focused on the health of the Foundation and the movement, the well-being of all Foundation staff, and the long-term sustainability of Wikimedia’s projects and communities. - LLosa (WMF) (talk) 23:21, 3 September 2026 (UTC)
- As far as I can tell from all communication (or lack thereof) I have seen from the BoT in this situation, there has been no "oversight and long-term direction" from the BoT here at all, and the BoT was blindsided by the WMF management (assuming they weren't complicit) and did nothing substantial about this once they found out.
- Is there any evidence (onwiki, or in published meeting records or something similar) of this "oversight and long-time direction" wrt unionization? All I have seen is deflection, weak excuses, unfulfilled promises, delays, silence, and either vapid or negative interactions with editors. But you are more than welcome to provide evidence here to prove me wrong. Fram (talk) 10:39, 7 September 2026 (UTC)
- To echo this, it rings especially hollow given the 'scandal' could've been avoided had the board actually been fulfilling its duty in "provid[ing] oversight and long-term direction" wrt the Foundation's response to the union drive (at least I hope this was the case, if it's not then we have bigger problems). There appears to have been zero accountability for any of this, why is it so hard to say "we messed up, here's what we'll do differently in future" Kowal2701 (talk) 21:05, 9 September 2026 (UTC)
- why is it so hard to say "we messed up, here's what we'll do differently in future" Because they don't think they messed up, they just screwed up and miserably failed to succeed with their union-busting agenda. ~2026-43134-44 (talk) 02:30, 11 September 2026 (UTC)
- To echo this, it rings especially hollow given the 'scandal' could've been avoided had the board actually been fulfilling its duty in "provid[ing] oversight and long-term direction" wrt the Foundation's response to the union drive (at least I hope this was the case, if it's not then we have bigger problems). There appears to have been zero accountability for any of this, why is it so hard to say "we messed up, here's what we'll do differently in future" Kowal2701 (talk) 21:05, 9 September 2026 (UTC)
- It seems the board is not doing much actually. Writing these empty slop messages while completely ignoring the community is not going to help the board's reputation Ita140188 (talk) 14:00, 9 September 2026 (UTC)
- Board members refusing to answer questions about the hiring of Littler Mendelson should resign, or be forced out. Their silence is complicity in the failed union-busting attempt. Shame on them all. ~2026-43134-44 (talk) 03:06, 15 September 2026 (UTC)
FYI, the answer is in April
[edit]Jimbo answered: Attorneys at Littler were hired in April to help answer questions about the unionization process and prepare the organization for the legal responsibilities that it might require. ~2026-50677-28 (talk) 21:01, 18 September 2026 (UTC)
Updates on the Board elections process
[edit]Hi all! The Board has been receiving feedback on its original elections process proposal since July. Thank you to the many people who participated onwiki, in person, or in direct conversation with Trustees. The feedback was extremely helpful.
Based on this feedback, the Governance Committee has decided that the eligibility criteria approach is not a good fit. Instead, we have developed two potential approaches we can utilise in the future. We are asking for your feedback again to inform our decision about which approach to use, starting with the 2027 selection process. Our goal is to have a process that is predictable and that does not require annual updates, although we recognise there may need to be minor adjustments in the future depending on facts and circumstances and lessons learned from 2027.
From a Board governance perspective, the fundamental requirement is that every trustee strengthens the Board and benefits the Foundation through the experience they bring. The Board oversees a community- and technology-focused nonprofit organization with over 600 staff members across dozens of countries and an annual budget of almost USD$250 million. Every trustee must be able to operate, support and contribute in that environment. In addition, they:
- must be able to work well with others;
- must be able to make informed decisions based on an assessment of the best interests of the Foundation;
- must be able to ask insightful questions;
- must be willing and able to communicate decisions to the community and in other public spaces; and
- they must have the confidence necessary to contribute their opinions and perspectives.
All trustees must also be able to commit to the confidentiality agreement of the Wikimedia Foundation in addition to exercising sound judgment and discretion, as well as managing any potential conflict of interest, both within and outside the Wikimedia Movement. The question is how to design an election process that ensures that every candidate on the final ballot meets that bar while still being a meaningful election where Wikimedians are the ones selecting the winning candidates.
The Board will make a final decision on the revised process at their December 9, 2026 meeting. Please share your feedback on the discussion page of the proposal. Cheers! MaciejNadzikiewicz-WMF/Nadzik (talk) 15:09, 8 October 2026 (UTC)
Requests for comment/The future of Abstract Wikipedia
[edit]Two questions for all board members about the Requests for comment/The future of Abstract Wikipedia:
- In Requests for comment/The future of Abstract Wikipedia#WMF_Board_response, Board members Nadzik and Victoria said on 14 July "we asked to have a report on the topic of Abstract Wikipedia, and we plan to discuss it soon. " and on 16 July "We will share the information from the report publicly. ". At first glance, this report hasn't been posted yet (If I missed it or knew it but forgot, my apologies of course). Are there any updates about this?
- In Requests for comment/The future of Abstract Wikipedia#Waiting for answers, some basic questions have been asked from the WMF people involved with the project. After 2 months and repeated pings, no answer has been given. Can the board perhaps nudge them towards an answer? There are many other open questions, but these ones would be a nice start.
Thanks, Fram. Fram (talk) 15:36, 8 October 2026 (UTC)
- Hey @Fram, thank you for following up. Answering here in my capacity as a Board Community & Affiliate liaison, not a subject matter expert on tech. There’s no new information I can yet share to share; the Board is working with Foundation leadership to learn more about how the work on Abstract Wikipedia is progressing. We will share more when we can. Nadzik (talk) 20:50, 9 October 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks for your swift answer. Why did the board promise us a report "soon" in July, when no such report seems to exist three months later? If the WMF is stalling you, could you please publicly put some pressure on them? No idea why all these things aren't done onwiki, open for everyone to see, so the community can actually what is being said and done instead of having to rely on occasional messages which too often turn out to be incorrect, too optimistic, or just a stalling technique (see e.g. the whole mess with the union busting and the role of the Board in covering things up). You have also failed to answer the second question it seems. Fram (talk) 07:54, 12 October 2026 (UTC)
- Anyone? Fram (talk) 07:42, 21 October 2026 (UTC)
- I must say I'm also curious if, at the very least, a timeline can be shared and what the broader strategy is around community and technical milestones that Abstract should achieve to continue to get funding. I know there was external funding to Abstract, but it has also received funding from the Endowment that I imagine could have been spent more wisely. —Femke 🐦 (talk) 21:50, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
- Thanks for your swift answer. Why did the board promise us a report "soon" in July, when no such report seems to exist three months later? If the WMF is stalling you, could you please publicly put some pressure on them? No idea why all these things aren't done onwiki, open for everyone to see, so the community can actually what is being said and done instead of having to rely on occasional messages which too often turn out to be incorrect, too optimistic, or just a stalling technique (see e.g. the whole mess with the union busting and the role of the Board in covering things up). You have also failed to answer the second question it seems. Fram (talk) 07:54, 12 October 2026 (UTC)
Update
[edit]Abstract Wikipedia became available to Wikimedia communities as a preliminary beta in March 2026. The RfC about the future of Abstract Wikipedia was opened on 14 July 2026.
It made three proposals:
- Pause the rollout and integration into language Wikipedias.
- Publish costs, success and termination criteria, and an independent evaluation.
- Close the project unless an independent review establishes that it can meet published criteria within a defined period.
The requests for more information and evaluation of Abstract Wikipedia in the RfC warrant a considered, evidence-based response. However, these proposals conflict: without a rollout, or with an assessment period that's too short, we can’t fully evaluate the project's feasibility.
The Board will receive ongoing updates about Abstract Wikipedia through the Product and Technology Committee. Ongoing scrutiny remains appropriate. Conclusions about the project’s future will be informed by a measured assessment of its achievements and limitations.
After consultation with the Product and Technology team, the Board has agreed that the deadline for the recommendation on Abstract Wikipedia will be the first half of 2027. Allowing a new project at least a full year to develop with the communities that have decided to participate in the Abstract Wikipedia rollout before assessing its progress is fair and reasonable.
This period gives the project time to test the tools, address technical and practical challenges, and build a participating community. It should also build a stronger evidence base to evaluate the project’s usefulness and prospects. Community and Affiliates Liaison to the Board Victoria (talk) 15:06, 4 November 2026 (UTC)
- You said on 16 July that the board would get a report, and that "We will share the information from the report publicly. Victoria (talk) 08:36, 16 July 2026".
- After a followup question, we got "the Board is working with Foundation leadership to learn more about how the work on Abstract Wikipedia is progressing. We will share more when we can. Nadzik (talk) 20:50, 9 October 2026 (UTC)"
- Now we are presented with your conclusions, but we have, as far as I know, never received anything from that report. Fram (talk) 15:57, 4 November 2026 (UTC)
Office actions regarding controversial files
[edit]Board of Trustees,
I believe you may already be aware of this matter, but I would like to bring it to your attention nonetheless.
The WMF Trust & Safety team asked the community for its input on a controversial file. Community members raised concerns about the file's educational value and the legality of retaining it, as well as concerns about Office actions taken by the Trust & Safety team regarding other controversial files, both related and unrelated to this case, as well as global bans, as well as asking for transparency.
Ultimately, the Trust & Safety team took Office action regarding the file and provided a detailed explanation. However, some questions remain unanswered, particularly those concerning governance: How does the WMF apply Office actions under the COCE policy, and how does it ensure that such actions are consistent with the 2011 resolution on controversial content, which states that "the Wikimedia projects are not censored"? Has the Board been informed of these actions, or has it been consulted about them?
Thanks in advance. ~2026-55860-17 (talk) 13:29, 19 October 2026 (UTC)
Follow-up on the Board’s May 2020 directive to increase Trust & Safety capacity
[edit]Hello Trustees,
In its May 2020 statement on healthy community culture, inclusivity, and safe spaces, the Board directed the Foundation to make additional investments in Trust & Safety capacity. The statement specifically mentioned tools for volunteers and staff, research and clear success metrics, training, consultation with experts, and additional hiring.
I would appreciate a public update on how the Board has monitored implementation of that directive.
The Foundation’s Trust and Safety overview reports that, as of 2022, the staff team had ten full-time members. In February 2021, the Foundation’s Executive Director told Reuters that there were no immediate plans to expand the team. I have not been able to find a public account of subsequent staffing changes or an evaluation of whether the promised increase in capacity improved response times and support for affected contributors.
Could the Board or Foundation please clarify:
- What additional Trust & Safety hiring and capacity investments have been made since May 2020?
- What is the current staffing level and scope of the Trust & Safety team?
- What public metrics are used to assess report volumes, response times, backlogs, language coverage, and support for affected contributors?
- How will the Board report on these measures and address any gaps in future annual plans?
I recognize that Wikimedia relies substantially on community governance, and that some case details must remain confidential. My concern here is institutional capacity and accountability: the Board called for a significant increase in support, but the public information I have found does not make clear what changed or whether the increase has been effective.
Thank you. ~2026-58037-10 (talk) 11:14, 2 November 2026 (UTC)