Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources/Report/AB cycle 2/Insights summary/Spreadsheet

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Name of group TRACK URL Location Location Type Number Participants Summary Statement # Summary Statement
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 9 Our openness avoids issues with Internet encyclopedia projects that have only vetted contributions by approved writers, which can lead to narrow POV and censorship. These projects are possibly respected or authoritative, but not open.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 40 The Wikimedia movement suffers from the "eternal September" problem of having to socialize large numbers of newcomers.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 1 Content: Productivity is growing more if there is excellence in cooperation, than excellence in knowledge.
Australian Community A Australian Community Brisbane various 40 3 An "outbreak of niceness" is required — we need to be more welcoming to new users.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 1 Ensure welcoming protocols.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 6 Without them, none of the others can be achieved to the greatest extent possible.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 7 The underlying reason of growth of the Wikimedia movement is its thriving contributors community. So the sustainable and inclusive community would result in a better and more effective affiliates ecosystem.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 8 Because the health of our community and inclusive communities bring good relations between Wikipedians/Wikimedians and a serene, relaxed, and collaborative atmosphere. So expert wikipedians works quietly, produce good content, people from outside (potential new users) feel happy to attend when there are conflicts
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 9 We can get a global reach but if we keep our digital ambiences as toxic or rejecting new people and thoughts, we won't arrive so far.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 10 I think is the most important. A healthy community assure all diversities (by gender, by language, by culture) & inclusion, participation of expert and new wikipedians, helps to resolve the conflicts, create a serene atmosphere etc.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 11 Without a healthy community, nothing else would work.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 12 I don't think our effort towards a healthy and inclusive community would result in considerable tradeoffs. It might happen that some large affiliate would get lesser fund (in their APG or other grant processes), as more emerging and thriving affiliate would be provided with funds in a pragmatic sense to realize their potential. But it's probability is much since by that time, we would have a bigger budget to meet the overall demand of the affiliates. Other aspects of tradeoff would affect the movement, since the investment in healthy community would definitely pay off in some aspects or the other i.e. spread of the movement, more sustainability etc.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 13 Maybe we will find better ways to communicate, like facebook, what’s app, etc, doesn’t happen on wiki, maybe we can figure that out better.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 14 We can't stop all efforts and do not compromise to have a healthier community any time, today and in the next 15 years. It must be our permanent goal.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 15 Reduce intervention (and need for) while increase prevention
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 3 Newcomers increase and retention.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 3 This could be great in terms of increasing participation and growing new contributors.
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 1 Healthy and inclusive communities are the core of our movement - by further nurturing them, we enable more people to participate in our endeavours and make our movement an integral part of society.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 1 We will have a more welcoming and safe environment for new collaborators, so we can foster a stable growth in the community.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 22 It has to be a friendly and motivating space, where people are motivated to enter and captivated to stay, not insecure, that peers reactions don't demotivate. How to include "different" people, perhaps before was not subject because they were less contributors, but as it grows becomes more sensitive. (María Paz Canales)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 23 One of the virtues of being an online and collaborative source is the real possibility that many can contribute to knowledge, which makes it different from other knowledge produced otherwise. That is one of the biggest values of Wikipedia as a project. (Vladimir Garay)
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 3 Achieving that would deeply change the movement towards a true community.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 4 The Wikimedia movement would make clear that communication culture is paramount which would set an example for other online-communities on the internet.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 5 We would have an important impact on how people perceive the internet as something they can co-create, as a place for sharing knowledge, as something that can empower communities.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 6 The impact would be a motivated and diverse community, enabling newbies an easy start and leading to more editors.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 1 We must take into account and act to expand diversity in the community
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 2 It is necessary to raise the community's ability to deal with different opinions and ideas
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 3 Diversity in the community can increase our ability to deal with people, beliefs and other perceptions
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 5 The range of opinions will be greater - so that they will not be attracted only in one direction - it will neutralize various biases
Australian Community A Australian Community Perth various 40 2 We can only create a trusted source of knowledge if we are a good community.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [1] local wiki 9 1 Communities will remain fundamental to the movement. Investing in the growth of small communities is vital. source
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [2] local wiki 9 11 It's not easy to identify personal attacks from experienced users to newbies. We should work more on this not to lose both kind of contributors.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [3] local wiki 9 12 Wikipedia has a special role for small languages such as Albanian in Europe or many others in the global south. These languages have less development and in those cases the Wikimedia movement takes on a special role in the cultivation and preservation of languages. source
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 1 We can shape new social environment, new type of communities and relations, better world.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 26 Our influence on the world will grow in the future. Wikipedia can be the leading role model of volunteering, shared knowledge and the power of togetherness. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 4 With these themes we are working in the core of our movement creating a friendly space capable of receiving new people that won’t leave in a few months after joining. Besides, we keep a charismatic community where everyone works and stays happily.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 8 Acquainted newcomers: create in-person and virtual support groups in their communities.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 4 This is a way to increase our influence - a broad community increases the ability to influence decision makers. It will reach all sorts of places - in the media and among decision makers
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [4] local wiki 9 13 Wikimedia movement should take on the burden of maintaining and developing small languages by providing a platform for the development of these cultures. source
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 1 In order to follow this theme, we have to emphasise that Code of Conduct and Friendly Space Policy in the community, to provide a healthy environment to the volunteers/newcomers, then they would be more willing to stay in the community and share their knowledge.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 2 By having the inclusive community, the small groups (Minority) can also share their knowledge with the others, and it will increase the quantity and quality of the resources on Wiki.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 3 With more knowledge on Wiki, then Wikipedia can be the platform/database for the knowledge of all mankind.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 23 Collecting different kinds of knowledge is one of our goals in the community. By having a healthy and inclusive community, then we can include different kinds of knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 70 model on how to collaborate
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 75 Protect new and existing editors from other, disruptive and abusive editors
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 1 The most important issue is to find and answer why the number of editors is not growing; then we should focus on solving the main problems preventing people to join Wikimedia projects.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 80 The theme is very ineffective to make the Foundation more influential to the world. It is supposed to make the movement effective. However, the premise seems lacking.; The environment of Wikipedia is still becoming more and more hostile. Newcomers would be intimidated by bureaucratic editors and administrators. More and more long-time editors are leaving the project. Meanwhile, Wikipedia's sister projects do not have the same attention as Wikipedia.; On the plus side, readers matter more, and diversity of readers should make Wikipedia more diverse and welcome. The issue of editors matters more to make the theme very effective. Otherwise, this theme is worthless.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 84 A more inclusive online community
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 89 More inclusive. More fun -> more people
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 93 We'd keep an important source of knowledge alive.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 97 We would make information sharing easier for everyone and this would enable scientific discoveries on a global scale
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 102 People would feel more confident and able while still new members. In other words, they wouldn't feel like noobs.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 107 A healthy community impacts the projects, and these impact the world. It's an indirect impact.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 112 A more complete, neutral, and rich collection of knowledge
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 115 Ideally shape the progression towards a more inclusive society without discrimination, and helping individuals forge genuine social connections and never rely on paying or capitalist systems for knowledge.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 27 I don't think that there will be quite of a difference, unless we emphasize on the recruitment of more volunteers. Ilikeliljon (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 120 more powerful dialoges for our system and Internet in general
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 123 ala coffee clubs changed England & ushered in industrial revolution
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 127 For international community (like United Nations or Council of Europe) and developed nations to improve policy toward more democratic with full respect of rule of law and minorities' rights.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 137 Inclusive
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 142 Continue to do what we do now , new matters will also appear as the times changes. I sooner believe "one has to follow the time"
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 147 While community is certainly important there are two risks to the strategy which should be controlled for. The largest is an explicit threat to individualism. In the end it is individual authors who make individual contributions. Surely guided by their own social experiences within and outside of wikipedia. While building communities is a great tool, and can achieve many important things, we need to specify clearly the individual rights, responsibilities and their protection from community pressure or even violation from community corruption. Surely we will have mechanisms in place to make communities inclusive, balanced and applying of the same criteria to everyone, but we should still implant protections for the individual contributor and their contributions (when within the established wikipedia customs and guidelines.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 153 Transparent and open knowledge accumulation. Instead of Facebook or Baiduk Baike
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 158 This would be helpful to achieve this goal.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 161 I think a community that is healthy can accept divergent points of view in a respectful, helpful way. Health communities are aware of bias and will not be as likely to allow bias to affect their decisions.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 166 Decreasing the toxicity of the Internet
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 171 following this theme Would , to My mind , greatly assist in Creating a Community, all Communities , Global Communities , to appreciate , Respect, tolerate, inspire and build from the microcosm to the macrocosm, macroeconomic, social well being of our communities and diverse socities. ; It would hopefully create an awareness of small and larger communities' demographics. To encompass with understanding, mercy and compassion for All people. ; This would go a long way to include all people, regardless of race, colour, creed, physical or psychological needs. Helping to achieve forums, communitities who CARE about All people. To invite and include all who desire a harmonious and peaceful society and communities.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 176 While I remain skeptical, if it were to occur, the result would be a more active volunteer crew and more impartial, useful results.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 2 More women involved: more than men, they do not tolerate being addressed with depreciation, and leave.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 3 Internet communities (wikis, too) suffer from bad behavior and team bullying. Our wikis could be a light beacon.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 4 Standard education does not include soft skills and communities health. Our wikis could have an inside role.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 5 Set the standards for modern (net) workplace behavior (eliminate workplace bullying and toxicity).
Wikimedia Ghana User Group A Wikimedia Ghana User Group Discussion Ghana Whatsapp 9 1 Wikimedia has an opportunity to make any adjustments they want to make since they going to have communities who would implement them.
Australian Community A Australian Community Adelaide various 40 2 Perceptions of problems in communities affecting D as being unsolvable.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 181 Broaden people's thinking by including articles that cover a broader range of people holding different values, philosophies, and ways of expressing them.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 186 Most Wikimedia projects are a direct reflection of its users and volunteers. If we want to keep to the mission of the project to accumulate all of humanity's knowledge then we need to reflect that in our communities. We can't just be english speaking or only men or only abled people. We must include all visions of this world that we live in so that we can promote inclusivity not only in the Wikimedia projects, but so that it is also reflected in the world we live in. We should be able to promote absolutely no discrimination, obstacles for less abled people, etc. If we follow this theme, it will directly reflect on our world, when people hear that there's no division in gender, socioeconomic status, physical abilities, etc in the Wikimedia projects, it'll be easier for them to imagine a world where that is true as well.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 1 Being a role model for digital societies and their challenges.
WikiConference North America User Group A WikiConference North America User Group Slack Slack 3 2 A truly global movement & Healthy, inclusive communities are, together, the most important goals as, if we aren't truly global and if we aren't healthy/inclusive, then we will become irrelevant and someone else will take our place.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 26 Knowledge is a good, the best we have as human beings. The best of knowledge should be on Wikipedia, unlike other spaces that include the best and the worst. (Guillermo Toro)
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 1 I think that Healthy and inclusive communities is our primary goal; all others depends on it.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 2 I believe Healthy and Inclusive communities are the most important component and the heart of all what we do in the movement.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 3 Without a healthy community, it would be hard to reach any of the other goals
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 191 An inclusive and healthy community would increase the number of editors collaborating on the project, expanding the userbase to the result of a larger amount of constructive content added.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 2 If we follow this theme, the movement has the potential to fulfill the utopian ideals many of us have for it.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 2 Achieving this goal will create a stronger and more expansive community. Editing on Wikimedia projects will be more meaningful and educational. We will accept diversity, and the content will reflect differing points of view and be more neutral. We will have different types of technology so people of all backgrounds can participate at their comfort and ability level. We will include more sources of information that include different types of history (e.g., oral histories) in various cultures. Finally, by achieving Healthy, Inclusive Communities, we will build the world’s first source of collective, inclusive, unbiased human knowledge, an historic achievement for humans.
WikiConference North America User Group A WikiConference North America User Group Slack Slack 3 1 Having a healthy, inclusive community is the top priority. Wikimedia, being a community-driven movement, requires a healthy and inclusive community to be successful. Without a healthy community, none of the other themes will be successful. Harassment, a lack of support for newcomers, and a lack of motivation for long-term contributors is detrimental to sustainability. On the flipside, a healthy, inclusive community will bring and retain people to help make the other themes a reality.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 2 A healthy and inclusive community is the basis for all the work we do in the movement and guarantees a diversity of people and perspectives to be included in the knowledge that we co-create. As a result, the world would have access to a greater depth and breadth of knowledge in our projects.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 1 A toxic environment kills participation, making all the rest of the themes impossible to achieve.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 196 We wll provide an excellent way of making people productive and happy. By people I mean all people who want to contribute, not just the nice sociable folk but also the ones who do not like to much (or any) interaction, people who are otherwise aggressive, people who in the real world as shunned as weird or even people who are considered unfit to do any work. Some of these people find their way in Wikimedia projects and it is up to us to keep them and help them be productive, as well as to be happy due to their creative work. In my experience, even some of the most productive editors are scolded and pushed to stop, even if they do one little, repeating, mistake or ommission.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 5 Healthy and inclusive communities' is the most crucial theme as long as we want a very sustainable and thriving Wikimedia movement. The community or the volunteers are the ones who keep this movement alive. We haven't reached every part of this world in a robust way and many communities are yet to be part of our movement. Since we want to see the movement to be spread across the world more than ever before, we need to have a healthy community that is inclusive as well.
Bengali Community A Bengali Community [5] local wiki 1 If we follow this theme Wikimedia movement will spread across the continents such as Africa, Middle East, South Asia and Latin America where Wikimedia movement is less recognized.
Wikimedia Ghana User Group A Wikimedia Ghana User Group Discussion Ghana Whatsapp 9 4 Healthy, inclusive communities first because a truly global movement will flow from cohesive communities. It'll be easier to get stuff done.
Australian Community A Australian Community Sydney various 40 5 Content, practices and understandings still seem American-centric to users, the Americanization of content and processes seems relevant even now as an issue.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 201
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 1 If this secures the existence of Wikipedia as community-driven project, then people all over the world would have free access to knowledge that could change their lives, make them smarter, hopefully make them give back to others, and eventually make the world a more equal, creative, peaceful and resourceful place.
Australian Community A Australian Community Adelaide various 40 6 We need to improve morale by avoiding internal politics and in-fighting between subsections of the community (e.g. between topical groups of users, or between projects).
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 203 More domain specific and local content, unlimited in depth will make Wikipedia more useful and contributed to.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 208 Probably similar to now, there would just be a wider range of topics (not that it isn't wide now).
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 Wikipedia is already used by so many as a resource, but with great power comes great responsibility. Biases that exist in Wikipedia propagate outward, infecting the world in myriad small ways. To reduce this bias is to reduct that propagation. It's a nudge, in the economic sense of the word - small things leading to big changes.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 217 More and better content from a more diverse group of editors.
Bengali Community A Bengali Community [6] local wiki 2 This theme is the most important one because Healthy, inclusive communities are needed to spread the word of our movement in all languages and cultural communities.
Bengali Community A Bengali Community [7] local wiki 3 To do that we need more focus on the people who has different opinions and we should welcome them. With active participation from all fronts, we could achieve our goal.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 222 Massive, but I'll say that with all the other themes. I see them as different facets of the same goal. An healthy, inclusive community is a growing and adaptable community: if we reach that, we'll automatically gain diversity, expertise, quality, coverage, including communities of experts that right now are scared or ignorant of Wikipedia (at least, from the "inside"). Of course, a inclusive community with a 20-years old interface is crippled. But community is paramount, and we need to take care of that.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 227 This theme is essential and conditional for the impact of the other themes. The impact will be the product of the effectiveness of the program activities that will be executed in this theme and the number of people reached by this program. Activities in this program will reach veteran editors, other editors and numerous new comers in the coming decade. Prepare to measure 'sense of community' in each community every year. Prepare to master 'community management'. Have functionaries assume responsibility for community health.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 232 Wiki communities, like the rest of the internet, suffer from bad behavior and team bullying. Soft skills are important for the survival of people, as human has now strong bond to the global network via technology. Soft skills are or can be cultivated and grown inside Wiki communities. Healthy communities are more productive and survive, when the work product there is not based in the excellence of knowledge but in the excellence of cooperation. This emotional intelligence is rarely cultivated through standard education across the globe but Wikis live on this. Taking care of community health is not good only for wiki communities but also spreads to the planet.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 237 Not allowing public conversation on data amongst celebs, it adds to online harassment and misuse of public/private information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 243 Peace and love
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 248 As the world consumes Wiki content this would bring the world into the community of developing the content.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 546 Encouraging and helping nurture newcomers and veterans with respectful engagement and incentivizing participation with gamification.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 556 Mentoring/Monitoring is necessary. Capacity is for sure, capability has to be learned.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 571 We would be known as a friendly yet rigorous community around the world. We would be able to incorporate knowledge from various communities around the world into Wikimedia. We would have the right infrastructure and processes in place for inviting new voices into our communities. We would have created social traditions and structures that are globally recognized as being an inclusive, international, global environment. This includes social structures to allow for collaboration in technology.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 642 The community would be greatly enhanced as more people would be involved in one of the greatest undertakings in history.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 644 A healthy, inclusive community would attract people from all walks of life: from all geographic locations, all races, all genders, all ages. Bringing in more people means more resources, more thoughts, and more interest in Wikimedia's movement.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 649 My theme is ecology and natural preventive medicine which is important in the current world (sic)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 655 Its my opinion that this is necessary to have an impact at all. We need to be an movement with a strong base, if we want to be able to take in as much knowledge as we aspire to take in. Similarly we need to be open to a large group of the world, if we want to actually find that knowledge and present it.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 660 This will have a strong impact by promoting our movement as an example of a healthy organisation of a movement that people want to join. Or, closer to practice, we would just increase the impact on the world we would otherwise have by increasing number of people and their resources they use on making this impact.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [8] Local wiki 1 We could lead the way in collaborative, online digital humanities.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [9] Local wiki 84 If we follow this, we will be able to cover many projects effectively and on time.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [10] Local wiki 85 The community can only stay healthy, if we stop separating information based on language, and build one wiki.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [11] Local wiki 36 103 If Wikimedia follows the "healthy inclusive communities" theme it can create the utopia that the internet was originally intended to be;(…) more and more people will be drawn into the safe haven of its community, growing stronger and stronger, and together we will be able to tackle whatever the future holds. Together we can help fix the internet. User:Powertothepeople
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [12] Local wiki 36 118 This is '''the most important''' of all [themes]. Wikipedia, like all Wikimedia projects, was conceived as a free, open, decentralized encyclopedia that was, and still is, fully dependent on the community to run it. CreationFox
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [13] Local wiki 5 1 The impact would be positively hugeː making the world a better place. Trizek
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [14] Local wiki 5 5 We'll be just another social network. TigH
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [15] Local wiki 10 24 The utopia 'Healthy, inclusive communities' would contribute to more authors becoming involved in Wikipedia, because fewer authors would turn their backs on the project. We all would have friendly relations. We would meet regularly (some do that already).
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [16] Local wiki 17 43 This theme is essential for Wikipedia. Everyone should be able to contribute with joy. Only like this Wikipedia can grow.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [17] Local wiki 17 44 Wikipedia is made for facilitating access to knowledge for everyone. The more people contribute in the world the more international it becomes. Wikipedia is improvable in many languages. Healthy and inclusive communities are the right way to improve this. The more inclusive Wikipedia is the more balanced and neutral the Wikis will get.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 18 Community health is a major concern. Every Wikipedian have same motive and yet conflicts of interest arise due to difference of opinion. If community health is not taken into consideration, this might create problems in the long run. If we work on community health, in next 15 years we would see: 1) less conflicts of interest

2) better understanding 3) new editors with frequent contributions

Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [18] Local wiki 2 9 If the community works as a team then we will be able to understand about the encyclopedic needs of the world. Community health is important for the success of the movement.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [19] Local wiki 3 If we succeed in having beautiful, healthy, welcoming and inclusive communities we could also be a good political example for others.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [20] Local wiki 7 We should be ready to welcome those who come at our door without any discrimination, but we should not go around to recruit people what wouldn't think to contribute to an encyclopedia by themselves.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [21] Local wiki 62 Wikipedia is exclusive and it should remain so because you have to respect 5 pillars in order to participate. We have to continue to exclude people who want to damage the project, wasting less time on them. On the other side we need to dedicate more time to people who sincerely want to contribute but may have some difficulties. We need to proactively search for new users with targeted campaigns, not at random. Events like edit-a-thons and GLAM projects need to have experienced users involved. Wikimedia Foundation and chapters should be more integrated with the community of editors. (Phyrexian)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [22] Local wiki 70 Some outreach projects do not have great results from the quality point of view. We do not have to reach any particular target, so why should we be scared by the decline in users, articles and edits? Why do we do initiatives that promote an increase in quantity (and not in quality), sometimes allowing promotions? (Carlomartini86)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [23] Local wiki 74 We need valid Wikipedians, who have the sources and study them. (Xinstalker)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [24] Local wiki 78 It's not easy to fight those who manipulate sources. We need precise discussion rules. (Bramfab)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [25] Local wiki 73 86 Good faith does not pay. Good manners are interpreted as weakness. We need to be more welcoming towards anonymous user to make them stay. The community needs turnover. Geoide
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [26] Local wiki 73 87 We need to new contributors but also to defend existing content. New users who are not willing to study topics before contributing must first be put in condition not to damage existing content and then invited to contribute. The more is not always the better. The user decline is because some people don't want to study while those who have studied do not want to interact with less-studied people. (Xinstalker)
Meta B Meta Talk:Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Cycle 2 Local wiki 1 This is a necessary foundation for any of the other themes, but seemingly difficult for the WMF to directly influence.
Meta B Meta [27] Local wiki 2 This theme is more suitable to Wikipedia as the sister projects are not as impactful as Wikipedia, Commons, and Meta-Wiki.
Meta B Meta [28] Local wiki 3 Attracting new readers is easy, but persuading readers to become editors either is not or may vary, depending on projects.
Meta B Meta [29] Local wiki 4 The community will be respected better, if it is considered healthy by others.
Meta B Meta [30] Local wiki 5 Financially, WMF can support activities that promote diversity; organizationally, it can encourage affiliates and partners to promote diversity; publicly, it can use its communication channels to promote diversity.
Meta B Meta [31] Local wiki 56 The description suggests that the theme is just the opposite of what we need - and we need a civil way to quarrel (hard), not a way to make everything "inclusive", "rewarding", and "fun".
Meta B Meta [32] Local wiki 58 Within an environment of disinformation, harassment, and exclusion, there's no progress.
Meta B Meta [33] Local wiki 59 When I think of all of the untapped talent globally—the lost insights in math, science, engineering, literature, comedy, psychology, history—to me, it seems like burning the Library of Alexandria every hour.
Meta B Meta [34] Local wiki 60 We could learn, and then teach, so much more about how to structure factual, polite discourse online at a global scale. We could learn about how to build healthy communities and network them.
Meta B Meta [35] Local wiki 61 Build an open digital commons for the future, ensuring a broader legacy for future generations.
Meta B Meta [36] Local wiki 65 68 Thematic WikiProject could attract more people to contributing, that's why they should be resurrected.
Meta B Meta [37] Local wiki 65 69 The community and/or the readers have to make the contributors feel very clearly that their contribution is appreciated.
Meta B Meta [38] Local wiki 65 70 With sufficient editor participation and translators, we could know better what's happening on various wikis.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 26 This is theme should not be a strategic goal as the healthy community is not our goal to achieve but rather one of the resources we can use for some strategic purpose. So, we should rather focus on some external strategy goals and then decide how to achieve it. The community itself is not our product.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [39] Local wiki 4 1 We have the potential to globalize a cooperative approach to the web. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [40] Local wiki 4 2 We can practice in a radical way an unprecedented associative 2.0 web experience User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [41] Local wiki 4 3 Only the most resilient develop in an unhealthy community, bettering the community will allow more projects and people to contribute and thrive. User:Danilo.mac
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [42] Local wiki 16 3 I don't think that encyclopedia should have an impact on the world, we should describe the world, not impact it. KrzysG
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [43] Local wiki 16 9 Encyclopedia helps to find the common ground amongst us because it defines ideas and facts and helps to not repeat previous errors of our past. NOwiking
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [44] Local wiki 16 23 We need to give special attention to accessibility of Wikipedia, because right now community does too little on this part. Losing of sight should not be a problem for receiving knowledge, we need both our content and visual editor to be accessible to blind people. DonRumata
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [45] Local wiki 16 25 In the world of post-truth Wikipedia should be both independent and accountable (to people) source of verifiable and reliable information about this world. Because of this Wikipedia should be user-friendly for all people. 1677venzel gottorpskij
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [46] Local wiki 16 29 We need to have external monitoring from Wikimedia to the situation with neutrality of information in Wikipedia, systemic biases and other internal problems. 192749н47
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [47] Local wiki 16 30 There should be yearly overview of main language editions and readiness from the global community to involve itself into local activities to prevent having a project turned to a force of government propaganda, establishment of censorship or expulsion of authors because of their ‘non-patriotic’ views. 192749н47
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [48] Local wiki 1 A good environment for newcomers is fundamental if we want to increase significantly the number of active wikipedians, which is the reason for having good introductory courses to Wikipedia.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [49] Telegram 17 We need to make newcomers more aware of the platform, so the experienced users can help them rather than having high expectations of policy implementation. We should also recommend a series of friendly mini-tutorials for the moment an account is created.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [50] local wiki 12 1 Hard to argue againt. It is a pre-condition and absolutely necessary in order to achieve our primary goals. We need more participants in order to increase diversity and the quality of our projects.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [51] Local wiki 1 We can make the world come closer in the pursuit of free sharing knowledge
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [52] Local wiki 7 1 We would have the diversity and quality of our data improved.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [53] Local wiki 34 We need to do the touchy-feely work to build healthy teams. The teams are the ones who deliver the strategic goals. Goals without a healthy community is empty rhetoric. [1]
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [54] Local wiki 8 1 we could be a repository for images around the world, and model how to show good metadata scholarship. Slowking4
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 5 Don't use Meta-wiki for everything. There are other tools.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 7 Wikipedia is not exclusive to Wikimedia, nor vice versa.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 10 Generate mechanisms to eliminate community power discrepancies.
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 3 We need to stop catering to high performance users who are also high maintenance. Despite our best efforts, it is often impossible to integrate them into a healthy and inclusive community, because they make our communities less inclusive and therefore less healthy.

Volunteer work should be easy – support for volunteers needs to be flexible and adaptable. Reducing the the complexity concerning legal and financial processes around grant making or the usage of Wikimedia trademarks would decrease the overhead costs on the side of the WMF, save volunteer time and decrease the hurdle for many volunteers to get involved in first place. We are an online movement and should be careful not to loose the power and strengths that come with that by overinstitutionalizing things in a way the offline world works. As an affiliate organization we are aware that this line is not always easy to draw, but would still encourage to constantly question such developments and where possible favour flexibility over security.

Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 27 The problem with new users interfere with diversification. It is much easier to be included if you are a white man in a white-man environment, but if you are different it costs a lot. (María Paz Canales)
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 3 2 This is not supposed to be the Movement's number one priority, but it is an extremely important theme to work on. It is obviously more important than many other issues: because the community is the Wikimedia's core, and without it, there would no Wikimedia sites in the first place. It is also problematic that the community finds it easier to punish the newcomers than to deal with misbehaviors by experienced users. Another related issue is the communicating on social media (outside of Wikipedia) is making it easier for admins to make coordinated bad decisions which negatively affects the community.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 12 It is the most important theme because it is concerned with the health of all Wikimedia communities, which are the core of Wikiprojects.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 4 It is important as it provides the opportunity for the minority to share their knowledge. Their knowledge is also important to us!
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 29 Behavior with new users is common in this type of community. Certain "paternities" are generated about the work that some do.(Julio Costa)
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 5 At this moment, some Wikipedians feel like that they are excluded from the community, due to the lack of inclusiveness.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 6 It is important to have a healthy environment, so the volunteers will stay , and we as a community can have them contribute to us, and help us grow.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 71 prior condition
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 30 I don't know if this is heresy. There are content that are underrepresented in Wikipedia, but are under-represented in all. The challenge is, how to change this reality? Is the volunteer model the answer to this? There should be no level of centralized participation? If "we want these contents to be there," then could we think of doing it a job? (Vladimir Garay)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 76 The 4 others cannot proceed without healthy and inlusive communities
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 81 This theme is not as important as "The Augmented Age", but it is more important than the other three. The Foundation should always welcome everyone of any occupation, age, sexual orientation, race, gender, etc. It should also welcome experienced, inexperienced, new, retired, semi-retired, etc.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 85 Communities thrive from an open engaging forum that gravitate away from hierarchy
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 90 We need the world to be more inclusive, perhaps to survive as a human race in the future.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 94 Without it the others are meaningless.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 98 This is the most important
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 5 Do not use only English as the main language of the movement. It poses certain difficulties, for example during international meetings. It is therefore necessary to try to diversify the working languages.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 103 Again, it helps new users gain confidence.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 108 Very. Having a toxic community threatens the project's essence.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 116 Most important
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 6 It should have at least two working languages, at least for international events, if it's not possible to use all languages present on Wiki. Or choose 5 major languages: English, French, Spanish, German and Chinese (for example).
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 121 would be good (=rather low priority)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 124 unless people meet & interact, things don't shape up... So, this is key
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 128 This is because social inclusion of all, especially for the vulnerable and minorities is integral for democratic and better well-being of future generation.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 7 Avoid being discourteous. Each contributor should talk correctly and be polite during discussions.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 138 Pretty. It's important to consider as many perspectives as possible when evaluating truth.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 143 I began with this, sorry don't know about the others, yet
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 8 Expand participation in events to the maximum number of contributors and diversify languages during international meetings.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 148 It is most important as it can influence directly individual contributors, especially through ill defined mechanisms and expectations. And it already shows signs of this ill definition. Look at the use of the word "fun", it is ill defined, it is subject to a lot of interpretation and misinterpretation. This attitude especially when coupled with social pressure or even coercion in the form of communities can turn the best of intentions into a road to hell. Extreme caution, and possibly research into constitutions and other forms of organized well being of humans should be advised. There is one thing often quoted about law and government, it sometimes moves with glacial pace, for changes in human relations this is a good thing, not a bad thing. For changes of how wikipedia values individuals and their contributions in relations to groups of individuals (where politics and leadership often emerge) is of critical importance. As can be witnessed by wikipedia's own often turbulent history.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 154 Community is the core of everthing
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 159 Not as important as having accurate information not matter political leanings.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 52 Theme B is a dangerous barrier to inclusiveness. Increasingly both contributors and readers will come to us via external channels or through ever more technological moderation. That reduces our power to influence culture and community among both contributors and readers.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 162 Very important. Without a healthy community, other projects cannot reach their full potential.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 167 I would argue it's the ideological underpinning of three of them (all but augmented age)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 172 I believe they all Co relate to one another. As our bodies are made of many parts, providing different functions, the parts together firm one body working closely and sensitively together.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 53 There will always be tension between quality and inclusiveness. Resolving that is one of the biggest and most interesting challenges.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 177 This is perhaps the most important because without it, Wikipedia will stagnate. As it is right now, a large percentage of the population does not consider Wikipedia to be an objective source, given that its content has been dominated by a clique operating from a leftist political agenda.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 182 Number one. This is a global publication, but editors often become narrow in their focus and try to delete articles involving subjects they have disagreements with.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 187 I believe that all the other four themes will be enriched if we have a diverse community first. It's not about making Wikipedia easy for a specific demographic to use, for example, it's about including everyone so that they themselves will make those ideas possible. So, people who want something more interactive can make that a reality, people who want to include people from countries not included so far will also make that a reality, etc.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 54 Immediate response to problematic edits or vandalism is to remove them on the spot. Would be great to see shift towards trying to figure out what the editors goal is (for example, trying to do something productive like adding a source to an article) and see if we can see past the bad result of their effort and instead help them get to a good result. Assume more good faith, perhaps?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 192 A sizeable number of contributors will allow for more resources to be allocated towards each of the other themes, as a larger number of contributors allows for a larger amount working on specific topics
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 197 This is the most important, as there are clear trends for pushing out users, (unfortunately successful at times), making use of hostile and aggresive stands by people who represent the supposed "good and righteous" users (at least in their opinion). This trend would leave Wikimedia with a conforming 10% of its existing users, with all the negative effects of such one-sided group (not to mention the much smaller participation). Proof of that is the violent pushing out of at least five users of elwiki and continued attempts for another 3-4. Please note that the active users are about 40, so we are talking abourt two digit percentages of the active users.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 204 This is the most important theme. It's required to have any success in the other categories. To be the most respected source of knowledge requires many other types of editors.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 55 This theme works against the other themes. To the degree that we are successful at creating a diverse community other things are harder (it's harder to be a trusted source if we have to engage with a larger variety of of cultures and styles etc.)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 209 It is kind of obvious and a part of the other topics, so it's of lower importance. It's also very similar to "A truly global movement".
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 213 Honestly I can't think of a more important theme than this one. Biased information is incomplete, or even wrong. Without members of the community able to recognise bias, Wikipedia just becomes an echo chamber, at best ignoring and at worst actively damaging minority groups and ideas.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 218 Critical
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 56 It's going to get harder because when you bring more voices into the movement, people will disagree etc. It's balancing, self-fulfilling. If you're not healthy and inclusive and you want to become a trusted source, you need this diversity, you won't be able to be global. They feed off each other.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 223 It's fundamental, because without community we are an empty shell. With a deranged community, we could be another 4chan or Reddit. Or, worse, a non-neutral encyclopedia that poses as neutral. As all online communities, we need to be careful, as we are dangerously vulnerable to trolling, harassment, vandalism, and burn out of our most vulnerable members.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 228 This is number one priority - and please understand that technological solutions will not solve social conflict.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 233 It is the only of the five that can break the movement to pieces and shrink it. Enforcement of power by cultivating a bullying culture on productive editors equals to editor and contribution loss. Our movement can naturally grow on technology, globalness, respect for its good content and participation in the knowledge network. But community health is not self sustainable if not specially taken care of.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 8 We will have to compromise on uniformity. On the monopoly of existing editors
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 238 community
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 244 The only important thing is to love and care about other people
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 249 I'd say this is the third most important. Having a growth of Wikipedia into as much human knowledge as possible can only be done with great communities for each topic.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 9 There is no need to compromise on quality, because there is currently no such a distinct quality. It will be necessary but let go of the patronage that exists today
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 543 Besides "Augmented Age" and the "Knowledge Ecosystem(KE)", its the most important. Even if computers might do most of the work, we still need communication. Someone to tell someone else about the KE, someone to learn from and someone to help accuratly.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 557 Most important, it's key to the success of the others. In order to make the other advancements, you need the workforce to achieve it.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 564 The other themes wouldn't happen without this one.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 10 The renunciation of existing and cumbersome procedures will allow for development towards other communities. At the moment, the vision is very Western
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 643 Very important
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 645 Having a healthy, inclusive community is the top priority. Wikimedia, being a community-driven movement, requires a healthy and inclusive community to be successful. Without a healthy community, none of the other themes will be successful. Harassment, a lack of support for newcomers, and a lack of motivation for long-term contributors is detrimental to sustainability. On the flipside, a healthy, inclusive community will bring and retain people to help make the other themes a reality.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 647 Ecology, climate change, sustainable civilization, prevent diseases with health (sic)
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 7 Current metrics about retention are not precise, therefore we have limited knowledge about real trends in retention; current metrics should be replaced by more deep studies in order to find real reasons for low retention
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 652 A healthy community is important, because without a community there is nothing left to do for any of us. There is probably least amount of space to compromise on this point.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 659 They are all important, but this one to me is the most crucial one for our inside organisation. We would probably not achieve any outstanding impact on other themes if we fail on this one.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [55] Local wiki 2 This theme is the most important, because the community is the critical success factor.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 3 No.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [56] Local wiki 3 With training and leadership, build self-sustaining teams to solve problems.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [57] Local wiki 4 As long as some "old guard", real or imagined, refuses to cooperate or engages in behavior characteristic of ownership, improvements will be stifled and lost, and editors will be turned away.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [58] Local wiki 5 Acknowledge openly that people who are skilled at finding and synthesizing information are not always skilled in social interactions, and vice versa.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [59] Local wiki 64 The concept of "consensus" is at odds with inclusion of new views, because established cliques of editors can make their own overriding "consensus" on any particular decision
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 7 Drop the hierarchy-power control tree model that filters info upwards (focus on true feedback).
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [60] Local wiki 65 Incivility is difficult to define in a way that allows us to draw a clear line; it is better to stay well clear of gray areas
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [61] Local wiki 36 87 All cases of incivility the user encountered were attempts to avoid existing policies and consensus. If one can write an article, one can write a comment explaining the reason for one's edit.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [62] Local wiki 36 104 The most important. Any tool is only as good as those who wield it; if the community is not healthy, Wikimedia will be poisoned from within. User:Powertothepeople
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [63] Local wiki 5 6 Communities are the last protection barrier for projects. Any threat to the community could jeopardize its projects, and more particularly the projects that are already in bad shape. TigH
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [64] Local wiki 13 44 It is essential to ensure a neutral representation of all points of view. Nattes à chat
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [65] Local wiki 13 45 This is an important way to achieve our goals of neutrality and expression of diversity of views. Olimparis
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [66] Local wiki 7 8 All these positive things are no use to me. What does "positive" mean? Healthy is better than sick, alive is better than dead. We don't have to elaborate on that. Regarding the communities there are 2 differenct aspects that are much more interesting. Doesn't such a strategic come down to disempowering the communities? It is obiously not the job of the WMF to perform mircale cures on the communities. And how else can we understand such a shadowless goal? Mr Wales with his "toxic users" comes to my mind straight away. But such target projections are only possible at the price of ignoring real conflicts, contentious issues and peculiarities of the community. A "positive" goal would rather be to search for patterns for strong contradictions within the community (and between communities and between the communities and WMF). But this would not be a goal of the WMF.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [67] Local wiki 7 1 This theme is the most important one strategically. Because only a functioning Wikipedia community can guarantee a future. The prerequisite for this is however not that we all "love" each other (which btw is not possible), but just that the community should be more harmonious for the motivation of the authors.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [68] Local wiki 7 3 In fact the 5 themes sum up our problems, but on the most abstract level. Personally I would have prefered a strategy for the next 5 years instead of 13 years, or rather a strategy for an even shorter period. Actually I think that's what they will be doing, in the sense of maybe en:Operational planning. Personally I see theme 1 as essential and many will agree. But how do you reach this goal? The Foundation will be reserving this and in the end our influence will be zero.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [69] Local wiki 7 10 "Healthy, Inclusive Communities" sounds somehow sectarian. Instead of an encylcopaedia project we are supposed to have a "healthy community"? Was somebody playing a bad joke on us?
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [70] Local wiki 7 11 "Great experience" for every new editor? What terrible language. The important question instead is the power structure of WMF. Even communities that work reasonably well don't have any influence on what the WMF is doing. I'm not suprised that this simple question that has been voiced quite often during the strategy process is not part of it.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 7 Method of editing should be changed in order to get rid of unnecessary technical obstacles and more friendly attitude towards newbies - i.e. resignation from templates or automating them, make editing button more visible, make harder or resign from one-button revert button etc.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [71] Local wiki 7 12 The phrasing is going towards a religious community. Is there a guru in sight?
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [72] Local wiki 7 13 Problematic about the text is that it only adresses positive aspects of the community of 2030. As if there was nothing to fight about in 2030. The problem right now is not that not everyone loves each other, but that we don't have a culture of productive dissent, for example in AIV-discussions. Authors get hurt instead. Furthermore we will still have obsolete articles that are not updated, even with a higher number of editors. So if the goal is wrong, how can the strategy leading there work?
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [73] Local wiki 7 14 I have the impression that with the reference to "health" they are talking about something vaguely positive, but nobody knows what it actually is. But is a community with dissent "sick"? And furthermore, why should that be a concern for the WMF?
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [74] Local wiki 10 22 An important paragraph, but it's not the present reality. And if the whole situation is developing like it is that won't change. To make it real everything should be welcome. Nobody claims that vandalism and insults ought to be endured, but the en:Wikipedia:BOLD, revert, discuss cycle is extremely demotivating. The most important aspect of the text: we are supposed to encourage. But who? And how? If everyone has a different approach and does like he/she always did nothing will change. My proposal: endure changes, be bold, explain changes (summary and user/article discussion pages, reach a consensus). The revert button is useful, but it's not only used to avert damage, but to retain states of things. Which of the 2 is vandalism?
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [75] Local wiki 17 25 For me this is strategically the crucial theme, because only a functioning community can guarantee a future for Wikipedia. A precondition for this is not that we all 'love' each other. This is not possible. But it should work better. Otherwise the motivation of the authors evapores faster than it needs to.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 1 1 I think community health is the most important theme because it is a prerequisite to talk about other themes with the whole community and work to achieve them.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 6 I think Theme A is important because we can’t grow if there is no unity in the community.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 1 If community health is ensured then the rest will happen automatically.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 2 Better community health will ensure sufficient work in all the other aspects.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 5 It is important to maintain harmony in the community so that editor retention stops being an issue.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 6 Focusing on community health is important so that Hindi Wikipedia can have better policy debates.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 13 This theme is important because everything else will not be possible without ensuring good community health.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [76] Local wiki 2 10 This is the most important theme in relation to the other themes because we won't be able to successfully reach our goals.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [77] Local wiki 4 Healthy, inclusive communities is the most important theme because it is the engine/hearth of everything Wikipedia was and should be.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [78] Local wiki 48 Theme A is not important. Users are not born already educated and capable of writing. This theme does not explain how to get new users. Wikipedia world is not just a place in which everyone loves each other. We do need to be inclusive but the sub-themes do not fit.
Meta B Meta [79] Local wiki 7 It is foundational to achieving the other objectives, but is only a means to an end for ultimately supporting improved content.
Meta B Meta [80] Local wiki 8 The world needs the wiki culture, because with more wiki culture, id would be better, a more democratic and forward-looking place.
Meta B Meta [81] Local wiki 9 This is the fundamental issue, that will help all other themes along.
Meta B Meta [82] Local wiki 57 We need to easy editing and contributing as much as possible and set a friendly environment for all people needs.
Meta B Meta [83] Local wiki 62 Deffinitelly the most important. Wikimedia stays on active participants, but Wikimedia is still techy and hostile to certain needs of people.
Meta B Meta [84] Local wiki 63 I don't see what leverage the foundation might have to act on this topic. This theme is of course the most important of the five but means nothing in itself.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 8 The important thing is to break somehow the vicious circle of lack of devoted Wikipedians, who have therefore limited time to take care of newbies, so there is less Wikipedians etc; in order to sort it out stronger technical support is needed for devoted Wikipedians.[8]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 9 Everyone should make examination of conscience as we all contribute to unhealthy culture of our communities, but it probably cannot be forced by any strategy.[9]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 24 This theme is important because the level of newbie-biting is very high and it kills Polish Wikipedia as the user shown on his own experience. [3]
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [85] Local wiki 4 4 This theme is the base for all others, it should have priority over all else. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [86] Local wiki 4 5 A healthy and inclusive community is an essential condition for Wikimedia projects, today and in the road to 2030. User:Joalpe
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [87] Local wiki 16 14 This theme is the top priority, because since we have managed to get the main body of knowledge, the conflicts about different perspectives and approaches are steadily increasing, so we need to resolve them timely to improve user experience. Ivan Pozdeev
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [88] Local wiki 16 27 The rationale for this topic is in the development of ‘closed systems’ and ‘closed data’ − science publications with closed access. This global system of control of knowledge is why we need to support and improve free access to scientific knowledge. Proskynesis
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [89] Local wiki 24 We should focus on themes A & C -- they are core themes, as well as those that require doing more things. The basis of what needs to be done is in the very definition of movement: a group of volunteers tries to gather all the knowledge to make it available to the whole world.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [90] Telegram 16 This issue is very important because the way we treat newcomers will increasingly define the life or death of the site.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [91] Telegram 30 72 The most important issues that the Wikimedia movement must face are those of healthy, inclusive communities and the augmented age. I realize that we need a safer and more friendly space so that people can cooperate with the Foundation's projects, as well as providing new storage and deployment technologies for the new media we are generating as humanity.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [92] Telegram 30 73 I choose a truly global movement and healthy, inclusive communities in the first place. Because without them the rest would be meaningless; those are the starting point for accessing the others.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [93] Telegram 30 74 I agree that theme A is the most important. This point seems to me to be the main one in order to continue.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [94] local wiki 12 2 This is the most important goal as it is an enabler for other goals.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [95] Local wiki 2 This theme is the most important because if we have a strong community, we will have the human resources to do anything, including other themes' work.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [96] Local wiki 7 2 Only a healthy community will commit and progress
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [97] Local wiki 7 3 Inclusiveness means diversity of backgrounds.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [98] Local wiki 7 4 Without healthy community, we won't be able to deliver any other goals.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [99] Local wiki 7 5 Healthy community means the right balance among various groups.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [100] Local wiki 7 49 A healthy community is vital and, apart from being seen as important data source, I think this is the second most important part of strategy. User:Lymantria
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [101] Local wiki 8 2 most important - culture eats strategy for breakfast. without a healthy community, you will not be able to implement other goals. Slowking4
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 7 We should stop excluding the minority. Now some wikipedians think that the Foundation only focuses on North America and Europe, as the Foundation has invested so much money and effort to develop in these regions, and they should include the minority as well.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 8 We should stop admitting that English is the official language in the community. Even though many people in the Community speak English, and communicate in English, there are many languages spoken in the community as well. We should admit that the other languages are also important, and try to encourage people to embrace their own language. (Maybe we can admit that Chinese is one of the official languages as well?)
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 9 We should stop arguing. Arguments will do no good in the whole community, and we can try to work on the issues, instead of arguing and blaming the others. It is very unhealthy for the development of the community.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 72 letting editors stop
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 77 Stop fundng abusive editors and user groups through Wikimania's, conferences, projects
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 82 There have been too much bureaucracy and too much incivility, especially in Wikipedia. The Wikipedia community is working on lessening the bureaucracy and improving civil manners and behaviors. Also, it should stop alienating potential newcomers and start welcoming them. Also, it should stop driving off editors into retirements. ; Also, editors have been criticizing each other too much. Maybe they have been there too long and have been tired of people doing the same old routine behaviors and such, like disruption and incivility.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 86 ban misogyny
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 91 In the languages where contributions are still lacking, the admins need to be focused on the community-shared goals rather than specific personal preferences of what should be done. Should monitor the monitor to make sure that they are not abusing powers, and should train the admins even more than the new members.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 95 I can't think of anything. It would bring life back, which should enhance the others.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 99 We need to stop rejecting content that is not vandalism. To do this, we need to both redefine vandalism and redefine encyclopedic content
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 104 I am a new user, so I don't know much about the Wikimedia community. However, you could lay off a bit on file deletions.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 109 We would need to stop throwing stuff to the wall to see what sticks. We would need to focus.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 117 No this does not require you to do less in other areas. The community should grow independently and not artificially. Offer more, diversify, connect articles better.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 122 no
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 125 none that I can tink
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 129 What I ask to do is to promote accessibility , equal opportunity and human rights defending, and not to limit linguistic diversity and blocking except vandalism.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 139 No.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 144 Don't believe so, generally
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 149 We have become increasingly viewed as gatekeepers, especially in the social and human domains. It is very easy to add science articles to wikipedia, even those with little more than speculative research. It has become increasingly hard to add socially relevant entries to Wikipedia (as if we live in an era of scarcity where to store bits and bytes). Criteria such as notability have been interpreted by humans, rather than by algorithms. I.e. xyz might have lots of search engine searches associated with their name, yet are not take in because of a human induced notability factor. Why? Its not like we are running out of encyclopedia shelf space or we a running out of byte space?! We should reconsider this whole approach. I am very afraid that communities will only serve as more gate-keeping. And creating an artificial scarcity effect. The difference between a small contributor to humankind (say Tatjana Bezjak) and a huge contributor to human kind (say Pablo Picaso) should be in the body and quality of the text explaining their significance and contributions - and not in the fact whether they deserve or not a wikipedia entry (byte counting). The quality of the source is precisely in that it is Alexandria in a way and stores all of the known vetted information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 155 Overfocussing on policy compliance which is understood best by the existing editors which repells new authors. A growing WP should be again the main goal, like before 2006.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 160 Focus on quality of pages not quantity of pages. Review process should improve.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 163 We would need to stop allowing wikilawyering to be used as a shield for protecting biased attitudes.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 168 It may help to focus in on Wikipedia vs. the numerous Wikimedia offshoots
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 173 Contaminating our communities, society and world by overuse of our finite resources, fragile socio economic climate. This includes a fragile eco system on which we all depend I.e. Be more aware of climate change, eco change,
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 178 Yes. As it is, several areas or topics within Wikipedia are dominated by a clique that shared a political agenda that is not objective or inclusive. If you will not allow the general community to have a voice in the decision making, Wikipedia will continue to be considered largely propaganda, and only one segment of the population will find it worthwhile to participate.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 183 Less deletion battles. Articles already deemed to be notable continue to be targets of deletion efforts. If an article survives an AfD, notability should be presumed indefinitely and only extreme circumstances should justify a future deletion.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 188 Stop thinking about the obstacles that face certain demographics. For example, if we want wikipedia to be accessible for vision impaired people, don't worry about all that they will need. Go to them directly and they will tell you all the answers for this problem, they have the tools and they know how to do it. We just need to reach out to them and offer them the space so that these tools will be available for everyone else who might need them.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 193 The way I see it, no other programs would have to be sacrificed for the sake of this one.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 198 Wikimedia Foundation need to stop funding people and organizations who take hostile stand against users. The Foundation must visibly do that and fund people and organizations who care for people and make them welcome. We need to lead in the creation of strong pillars within as many as existing policies possible which will specifically mention that all users are welcome, even if they make frequent mistakes, even if they can contribute in specific ways, even if they do not cite sources, even if they make small stub articles.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 205 Being too anal about rules and guidelines. Administrators and editors lost sight of the spirit of the rules. Misinterpretation of the rules. It has detrimental effects. Kick out editors with a negative influence. Those that are not assuming good faith and reverting.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 210 There are a lot of things that could block our way to inclusivity. It would require a lot less deletionism (a pretty bad thing now) and some reworking, but most of it is being done now.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 214 Until the tools are up to the task of making non coders comfortable contributing, you run the risk of alienating a core group of users.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 219 On English wikipedia, too much effort is spent on deleting content rather than improving or creating content.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 224 Not sure. Less fundraising? ;-)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 229 Radically reduce the size of central organization in favor of local organizations.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 234 Drop the hierarchy-power control tree model.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 239 public discussions on public persons threads.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 241 centralized vetting of sources?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 245 Stay safe
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 250 I don't see any drawbacks by pursuing this one in relation to current or future needs.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 550 I think English, will fuse with other languages, creating some sort of worldwide spoken language. Therefore translations and smaller wikias(compared to the english one), will lose importance and become instint, within approx. 70 years.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 551 I think that technology is something that the Foundation or even Chapters shouldn't be doing alone. If we increase including other communities, we don't need to be creating software and products on our own. We have a huge deficit and can't do it alone.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 560 not that i know of
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 640 Focus less on prevention of vandalism, as with a greater community comes more potential admins who can do that on their own time.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 646 Wikimedia (alongside a lot of other online communities) has a toxic environment in some areas; we need to stop having these environments, and ridding of these should be a top goal.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 653 I think that something like Wikipedia Zero is less important than this in the long run. But tradeoffs are often hard to do. instead I would say spend dedicated and recurring blocks on a focus topic. Lets have a 2-3 month sprint every year or two years and have EVERYONE working on it.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 661 Trolling? Harassment? Edit wars? Personal attacks? Outing? Discrimination? Yes, probably we will have to stop all of these. But our projects will probably become a much better place if we focus on stopping all of these.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [102] Local wiki 13 9 We should abandon using pseudonyms. Many of my bad experiences here have been with anonymous users. There might be users who cannot reveal their real name for a reason, but then they should not be able to hold a high positon here.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [103] Local wiki 6 Monitor and encourage troublemakers to cease and desist, set the entrenched wiki-culture aside, let other ideas to grow into prominence, make the community less rigid and static.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [104] Local wiki 7 Diversity will be more about diverse opinions, small cultures and backgrounds, not about gender gap.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [105] Local wiki 8 Diversity is important, but articles written by people with different backgrounds aren't cohesive and easy to comprehend.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [106] Local wiki 66 "Oppportunity is what we should go for, not equality." Demographic diversity for diversity's sake is pointless.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [107] Local wiki 67 De-prioritize pseudonymity in favor of real names associated with accounts (even if those names are only visible to trusted Checkusers, etc), to prioritize accountability.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [108] Local wiki 68 If we want to change the situation, we have to try something differently. Any particular thing might not help, but nothing will change if we try nothing.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [109] Local wiki 5 7 Strengthen the presence of human and reduce the automation and machine impact so as to make the projects rely more human being communities. TigH
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [110] Local wiki 20 49 Reconsider the secondary sources dogma in order to make room for non-secondary sources. As for now, there are several communities where secondary sources are non-existent. Touam
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [111] Local wiki 20 50 The process of accepting articles should be revised and made more democratic so as in contentious cases discussions should be handled by specialist contributors (Domi1789). However anyone could self-nominate specialist on any topic (Touam).
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [112] Local wiki 20 51 Wikipedia does too much of instantaneity, similarly to social networks, as shows articles related to recent terrorist attacks where sources are not sought for thoroughly. Domi1789
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [113] Local wiki 20 52 We look like social networks "articles" created about the small world of show bizz, TV, singers, footballers, etc. Is this the encyclopedia we want? Domi1789
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [114] Local wiki 20 53 I am wary of the "progress" brought by computers and automation. Domi1789
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [115] Local wiki 17 26 When you stand up for this theme successfully Wikipedia will have more authors. Then you will have more time for other themes, not less.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [116] Local wiki 2 11 We should stop considering the opinion of some people as the opinion of the community.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [117] Local wiki 2 In order to have a healthy community we would have to make clear that haughtiness is not a behavior that pays and stop tolerating it from anyone. In the long run such a change of mind would benefit the projects.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [118] Local wiki 43 We should include only those who come at Wikipedia to write articles by studying sources. Those who come to promote their unsourced ideas, sell their products or discuss without sources are here to destroy the project and should be removed, as well as those who defend them.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [119] Local wiki 68 Users who make many personal attacks should be banned even if they are experienced users. (Bramfab)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [120] Local wiki 75 It's not always easy to identify personal attacks from experienced users to newbies. (Marcok)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [121] Local wiki 77 We could use data mining techniques to identify and report personal attacks. (Bramfab)
Meta B Meta [122] Local wiki 10 Support for community members that we do not yet have is as important as the current users.
Meta B Meta [123] Local wiki 11 Give up the non-productive behaviors that we do because they are easy, and adopt the productive behaviors that we do not do because they are hard, i.e. stop vandal fighting and start community welcoming.
Meta B Meta [124] Local wiki 34 73 Stop treating solo contribution as the only option, and start brainstorming other options, like teamwork. Collaborative contribution may produce better interaction.
Meta B Meta [125] Local wiki 34 74 Stop driving out others, especially experts, and start befriending and collaborating with them.
Meta B Meta [126] Local wiki 34 75 Stop treating online communication as the only method, and start socializing offline more.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [127] Local wiki 4 6 It sometimes seems that the catalyzing of marginalized communities is done from a top down approach, that can infantilize volunteers from those communities and can have weak results in medium and long term. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [128] Local wiki 4 7 The role of WMF should be rethought in some circumstances, it should be measured not only on the basis of it's immediate effect, but on how it generates elements that have strategic benefits to the communities. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [129] Local wiki 4 8 By focusing on this theme we will have to be more complacent with mistakes, not only mistakes made by newbies, but also those made by experienced users. User:Danilo.mac
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [130] Local wiki 16 2 We should abandon the practice of ‘dumb rollbacking’ − rollbacks of non-vandalism made without any comments left on the user’s talk page, because this might be bitter for users. Gorvzavodru
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [131] Local wiki 16 18 I would’ve consider the size of the community as a trade-off in comparison with credibility of information. DonRumata
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [132] Local wiki 16 26 Maybe Wikipedia should become less democratic so that newcomers will have some probation period before they can work in the project and that there is more expertise in relevant fields, especially in politics and science topics. 1677venzel gottorpskij
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [133] Local wiki 25 To gain more newcomers, we should have in mind that nobody is born wise and the long-time wikimedians have to express themselves clearly.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [134] Local wiki 17 47 The priority to English must be stopped because the other languages remain lagged.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [135] Telegram 5 It is true that there must be a common language that allows fluent communications, but it should not be a language imposed to the community.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [136] Telegram 14 There is a lack of agile community response and of specialized mechanisms and protocols to harassment/abuse complaints and internal alerts related to gender issues. There should be a specialized committee to address these issues.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [137] Telegram 18 Tutorials for new users should be improved, because they are not as user-friendly as they should be.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [138] Telegram 19 Some warning templates that are aggressive to many users should be modified (mainly editing test or vandalism templates, since these actions are sometimes made due to ignorance rather than vandalism).
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [139] Telegram 23 The templates texts are received as cryptic messages that slow participation. Some people have commented that they entered on a continous loop because they didn't understand what was asked and finally they abandoned because the experience was too unpleasant.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [140] Telegram 30 35 The main challenges for newcomers are: (1) how to start a new article and (2) how to deal with the community and its infinite standards and impatience.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [141] Telegram 30 36 While we can all edit Wikipedia, it remains as the project of a few people. It is wrong to think so, but I honestly think it isn't an extremely inclusive project.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [142] Local wiki 3 This theme do not have tradeoffs because community work do not takes much time and efforts.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [143] Local wiki 7 6 Stop narrowing the sense of notability.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [144] Local wiki 7 7 Stop trying to import policies and cultural norms between projects.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [145] Local wiki 7 47 Guidelines can be different among projects. My impression is that there are guidelines that may not be understood by all users evenly well. And perhaps the number of guidelines sometimes is growing too high. Users may feel some bureaucracy, which I think is not helpful. User:Lymantria
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [146] Local wiki 7 48 Often new users are discouraged to feel free to add new articles/items because that leads to deletion of their input. Also it can lead to unhealthy situations of different user groups, with different backgrounds and different interests. That does not help to find new users. User:Lymantria
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [147] Local wiki 8 3 we will have to give up being right all the time; we will have to give up biting people in an unhealthy way; we will have to give up exclusivity of "not invented here club". we will have to give up prioritizing vandal fighting and copyright wars. Slowking4
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [148] Local wiki 13 21 The idea of inclusion by the WMF will be counterproductive. Not everyone is able to contribute on a level that is required. Some people clearly do not understand what an encyclopedia is about. Although we are expected to guide these users with patience and experience it's not worth the effort in many cases. If they are deaf to criticism it will take too much effort. Users who can't even write proper Dutch should not be encouraged but rather discouraged from participating. That everybody must be able to particpate? That's just a "pink dream".
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 35 We're well known in the student developer communities & open source world for our projects. Currently, there is ambiguity around how some of our open source software projects are related to Wikipedia. More awareness of our movement, of the values we share and of the fact that contributing to these projects will impact a large ecosystem, will draw newcomers and get them involved.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 1 No separation between identifying between foundation/chapters/volunteers etc. Every individual is equally vital and important and feels as though they can contribute in equal manner.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 2 We don't need to prioritize “fun” or “great”, but hopefully those are things that come out of healthy, safe and inclusive community.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 3 Emerge as a model of decentralised politics, as those still contributing do so as one unit. This allows the Wikimedia projects to grow into comprehensive, multilingual banks of knowledge and resources, covering all areas of the globe. Currently, there are many undervalued voices.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 4 Transparent practices that show why decisions are made (and by who).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 5 Every language Wikipedia has deep information about all notable topic areas, closing the current knowledge gaps by including a truly diverse set of contributors.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 6 In 2030, Wikimedia communities are larger and more representative of the global population. Leadership within the communities has evolved to support and nurture emerging voices and areas of content while maintaining a high quality bar.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [149] local wiki 9 2 Increasing co-operation between communities to be in the same spirit will be ideal. source
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 3 3 A potential tool to help increase community's health could be to unify policies across wikis. These policies should be made as to protect newcomers more thoroughly, and to organize users interactions with each other. Wikimedia should support research on emerging communities around the globe, in order to understand the specific needs of each community. That is because generalized surveys (just as this Strategy discussion is) produce little results.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 9 We cannot let everyone to edit and add to Wikipedia; in the future, some kind of an evaluation system should be adopted to ensure that Wikipedia users are capable of living up to their responsibility.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 10 Should we emphasise the idea of having Friendly Space Policy? Not only for the offline community (Meeting/Conference), but also for the Internet.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 11 Should we also emphasise the diversity of the whole community, to attract the newcomers to join us?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 73 focus on relationships
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 78 Train users to which behaviour is accepted and which not. Make it clear by removing all funding from people who make Wikipedia a bitter place to contribute
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 83 What about changing the word "Healthy"? I don't know which is healthy for the Foundation and its community. Also, making the Foundation "inclusive" isn't easy. ; If "healthy" and "inclusive" are impossible to change, what about common sense? Unfortunately, a universal "common sense" is not easy to define. Multiple cultures define their own "common sense" differently, making their common ground less likely. Perhaps "multicultural" and "diverse" should be added to this theme. Hmm... "diverse" is overrated as communities have been divided as often.; I'm almost out of thoughts for this question. What about "respectful" and "tolerant"? Gotta form a very tolerant community before becoming "respectful". People should tolerate each other's differences, even when they disagree with each other's customs. Also, they should respect each other's viewpoints rather than descend into pointless contests about who's right or wrong.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 87 centering the individual user and facilitating their growth and development as a new wikipedian
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 100 Multi-lingualism is the key to inclusion. We need good bi-lingual (English + native language) wiki-citizens in each language community who can translate needs and trends back and forth across the global community. We need to remain a volunteer movement, but in order to effectively share knowledge we will need to foster the bi-lingual and multi-lingual players in their areas of interest.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 105 Not much that isn't already being done.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 110 The commitment for everyone to promote a healthy community.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 113 Working with educational institutions
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 118 Far, far better ways to interact with other Wiki editors and LIVE, real-time conversations, not awful talk pages.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 130 Mutual cooperative with international organizations especially on human rights and humanitarian issues.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 140 Emphasize the importance of fact. Above all else, truth and objectively empirically true bits of information are of the utmost importance to a -pedia that aims to be the ultimate source of knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 145 see "follow the times" , don´t make plans 13 years ahead, look backwards instead. What and where has anything gone wrong. Learn from that.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 150 Note that communities can pop in and pop put of existence, and individual might be member from 0 to n communities.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 152 Jedna věc je zdravá komunita. To souvisí se snížením počtu osobních útoků, ale i neúcty k práci jednotlivých editorů. Zatím se tato problematika nechávala na komunitách, ty ale zatím nedokázaly tato negativní jevy odstranit. Proto by se mělo pracovat na jejich odstranění. Druhá věc je inkluzivní komunita, která zahrnuje dvě složky: technologickou a společenskou. Je potřeba tvrdě pracovat a konečně dokončit zejdnodušení editovanání (např. na Wikimedia Commons). Kdyby nebylo přispívání do Commons tak časově náročné, je možné, že by přispívalo daleko více lidí, kteří již pracují. Kdyby byla dostupná online literatura (a dnes již existují fulltextové knihovnice), třeba by přispívalo více lidí, kteří již pracují a nemají tolik času, jako když studovali. Dále se dá pracovat s komunitama, aby byly tolerantnější k lidem, kteří si rádi povídají, vzdělávají se, nebo dělají kariéru. Měla by se najít rovnováha mezi množstvím přidaného obsahu z jejich strany a naplnění jejich potřeb. S tím může pomoci WMF.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 156 less policy and bureaucratic talk & action.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 164 Education about how to be a respectful and healthy community member is important. Recognizing and accepting differences is important.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 169 Emphasize the engagement and support of new users, especially those who are not the demographic norm on Wikipedia and out in society at large
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 174 To BELIEVE positive all inclusivs change is possible if we work together
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 179 I am unsure as to answer this one, other than to suggest that you need to allow the Wikipedia community to have more of a voice in decision making. As long as contributors are repeatedly overruled by a clique, only those who agree with the clique's political agenda will find it productive to contribute to the project. I used to contribute far more to Wikipedia than I have lately because I am not going to waste my time working on things only to be overruled by what can only be described as a leftist clique.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 184 Growing
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 189 Let's just remember that the volunteers make the wikimedia projects possible. We just need to let everyone know that they are welcome and that they have knowledge that's vital for the projects. It's not about us helping them, it's about opening Wikimedia's doors to any and all who wish to enter.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 194 Expanding the amount of users editing the project, allowing them to grow to become more adept at work on the project.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 199 Work top to bottom and bottom up at the same time. Issue statements making clear that all and especially the not so "good" users are welcome. Urge users to add to existing policies tolerance in as many places are possible. A very small example in enwiki Verifiability: "Any material lacking a reliable source directly supporting it may be removed and should not be restored without an inline citation to a reliable source" It would be much better to add something like: "If and only if material is deemed to be false, then ...." Otherwise, this important and reasonable policy is abused by a few people removing material just because it is not supported by inline citations and abusing other editors, wiping out their reasonable and useful contributions.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 202 Banning (at least temporarily) those who strongly/repeatedly violate policies. Block vandals
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 206 Punish deletions when it's not a vandalism revert. Deletions can only happen after a net positive of contributions. Allow other sources for things from digital only origins. e.g. fan communities
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 211 Specify it more and augment the concrete changes. Clarify the priority of the rule versus other rules or goals.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 215 I guess the technology needs to support inclusivity.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 220 When I started writing for English wikipedia two years ago, I did not feel welcome, so I stopped, and I know focus on the Swedish and Spanish wikipedias, which were much more welcoming. English wikipedia would improve if there was more focus on improving contributions and new pages created by newcomers rather than simply reversing contributions and deleting new pages that are not yet perfect. I think the English wikipedia would benefit if administrators have to be reelected at regular time intervals as is the requirement on Swedish wikipedia.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 225 Probably we should try to connect all the dots and understand if we have a single, crucial theme that is the gateway of all the others. Or, on the contrary, a bottleneck. Is "healthy, inclusive community" the ring to rule them all? Maybe it is.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 230 Wikipedia is NOT a technology firm. Do more to develop the people of flesh and blood who edit Wikipedia do less to develop software
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 235 Wikipedia communities are workplaces. Moral harassment and mobbing is a strong part of Wiki communities culture. At work this behavior becomes legally unacceptable.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 240 following anti bullying campaign projects to align with wikimedia
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 242 Fewer bans/blocks?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 246 Free knowledge a bed for free electricity
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 251 Just an additional note: Look to bringing on people with the time, such as the disabled, or beneficiaries of universal basic income programs.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 544 Better communication, making sozialising easier. Maybe an App and a Chat/Forum
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 545 Decision-making processes and structures. A community needs to have rules, guidelines, processes, standards, and expectations for it to work well, and I think we need to state this out loud.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 554 Maybe Healthy, [Productive], and inclusive communities. Because if the key is to generate high quality content, and a lot of it, then maybe the goal should be incentivization/rewarding to encourage that.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 641 Greater work to assist new users, so they don't inadvertently do the wrong things
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 648 The correct organization of waste to avoid garbage (sic)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 654 It's a bit unachievable really (Beauty contest level world peace). So maybe we should recognise that ? Create a notion that we will protect, if needed by excluding some people ? Or how we can create spaces for those being excluded?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 657 Just probably add that newcomers may refuse to be mentored, and both newcomers and experienced users may refuse to be a part of any group if they don't want to. Not sure this will make it way stronger, but probably it will make it a bit more inclusive.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [150] Local wiki 9 The word 'connected' should be added to the title of this theme, because a lot of communities remain very separate.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [151] Local wiki 10 The behavior of editors towards other editors may be more important than any edits they make to articles.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [152] Local wiki 11 Build tools to track changes and learn how various policies change the healthiness of our community.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [153] Local wiki 69 Research whether allowing unregistered users to edit helps or harms the community, then consider disallowing unregistered access if the answer is "harm"
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [154] Local wiki 36 117 We really need to put some kind of protective fence around new good-faith users, and restrict those who can react to them to people who are willing to commit to "not biting" newcomers and try and help them rather than just revert them. Kerry Raymond
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [155] Local wiki 5 2 Get wikimedia projects to know each other better. Trizek, Amqui
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [156] Local wiki 5 3 Make projects more inter-connected. Trizek, Amqui
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [157] Local wiki 5 4 Know more about other languages and cultures. Trizek, Amqui
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [158] Local wiki 5 8 Make communities healthier and more inclusive both internally and externally. Amqui
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [159] Local wiki 5 9 Make easier and faster the process for creating new Wikimedia communities, languages, and projects. Amqui
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [160] Local wiki 5 10 Have the MediaWiki strings managed directly by a WMF project instead of a third-party tool, TranslateWiki for now, will tremendously make easier the creation process for new languages. Amqui, Benoît Rochon
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [161] Local wiki 5 19 Ensure that wikis projects are accessible to everyone regardless of wealth and location. Lamiot
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [162] Local wiki 20 54 It would be appropriate, I think, to target the groups of people who are underrepresented within the contributors community and decide where actions need to be taken. Olimparis
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [163] Local wiki 20 55 In my opinion inclusion necessarily implies to improve the design of the site. The current look is not bad, but its look is tailored for a typical Western male audience. Touam
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [164] Local wiki 20 61 We have to put an end to what makes our communities unhealthy: vandalism, which forces our patrollers to perform an exhausting work, a work of Sisyphus. Anglo-norman
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [165] Local wiki 20 62 We should restrict access only to registered contributors, whose administrators have contact information, and if they engage in vandalism, can be suspended or excluded (Anglo-norman) [...] I do not share the idea of restricting Wikipedia to registered users only as assuming good faith seems to me an important pillar of inclusiveness. Nattes à chat
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [166] Local wiki 20 63 A first step can consist in communicating around vandalism, even contacting former known vandals and expose what led them to change. Nattes à chat
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [167] Local wiki 20 64 Against vandalism, it may be necessary to train patrollers and recruit more, have a patrol exercise included in the wikiMOOC curriculum? Nattes à chat
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [168] Local wiki 20 65 Take into account childcare costs in the budget of our events, just like the Art+Feminism campaign did, will allow more women to join us. Nattes à chat
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 20 Partner with institutions that aim to promote civil society and collaborate on strengthening people’s participation in civil society in all different forms, working to create free knowledge and education.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 15 Teach individuals to live in community, especially learn how to discuss without frustrate others.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 18 How to partner: Exploratory talks.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 21 Linux, Mozilla, other world-wide networked groups for open source/data/etc.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [169] Local wiki 20 66 Safe places for women : consider learning spaces reserved for women where they can make their first steps and master the basics of contributing before embarking on the discussion with a community which is sometimes unconsciously aggressive. Nattes à chat
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 19 Build bridges and collaboration with other activists and communities in the free knowledge ecosystem like Open Knowledge International (OKI), Mozilla etc..
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 21 Do not foucs on all online communities, but focus on the the self-organized ones. Wikimedia chapters are no community managers, rather community enablers. That is the difference to communities like the Giga community with a centralized governance structure. For sure it may help to have an exchange with Facebook & co. but much more interesting would be the FOSS community, Mozilla, OKI, Creative Commons open data community etc.
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 5 Any community working towards opening up knowledge to a wider audience on a freely accessible basis is a potential partner - be it the Open Knowledge Foundation, the Cochrane Foundation, Open Data initiatives by governments etc. While there are myriad ways to partner with likeminded organisations, collaborations on topics we have similar views on in order to successfully create synergy effects would be a promising way forward. This process would also bring our communities together, making them more inclusive and at the same time offering a different perspective or approach to the movement.

While preparing the Wikimedia Hackathon in Vienna we realized that there is still a lot of room for impovement when it comes to integrating newcomers into our community. At the same time there are many great concepts out there – some of them we tested and implemented for the Hackathon – from other tech communities (Rails Girls, Jugend hackt, Ladies that FOSS), which have not been applied to the Wikiverse before, such as mentoring programs for young coders or tech events for women and non-binary volunteers only. We should become bolder when it comes to radical changes to our event formats so we can apply successful approaches from other communties and organizations.

French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [170] Local wiki 20 67 We need to ensure the protection of those who take risks to report what is wrong about society (ex: whistleblowers). Nattes à chat
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [171] Local wiki 7 15 There will always be editors who get hurt. We have to find solutions on how to deal with this. The way the theme is phrased will simply lead to the well known Jimmy-Wales-solution of excluding toxic users.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 5 Sociologists?--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 9 Specialists on workplace health.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [172] Local wiki 7 16 The Thanks notifications are a helpful software feature in regard to the question, as are the attemps of WMF to increase the number of editors, for example with the visual editor and GLAM cooperations. But unfortunately specific suggestions are unwanted in the strategy process. The text of this theme ought be be restructured, structured into single measures.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [173] Local wiki 10 20 Wikipedia will never be without dissent. As long as we have Wikipedia as an open system (and it should stay this way) people will get together here that have fundamentally different opinions. This will always cause friction and dissent. And we shouldn't pretend that this does not and will not exist. And there will always be people, now and in 2030, that are not compatible with what Wikipedi stands for. Now and in 2030 we will have to expel those.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [174] Local wiki 10 21 We had the project Grants:Project/Mental health within the community, but there's not much going on there anymore, small surprise. I am afraid that all these desperate attempts to make Wikipedia with its monstrous buerocracy somehow future-proof resp. sustainable will fail. Because they're only based on speculations and assumptions by the narrow view of the Wikimedia buerocracy. The term 'movement" alone is misleading. There is no Wikimedia movement besides a certain administration, functionaries and software technician circle, who are all without article contribution worth mentioning. Authors got nothing to do with that.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [175] Local wiki 17 28 Everybody should be more friendly to each other. You might have a controversial debate, but you should never offend somebody personally. If you treat each other more peacefully others will be inspired by this (hatred creates hatred). The thank you function is recommendable. Once could think of more functions like this. This would be interesting for theme 2 as well. I think competitions are very useful, like for instance the Template-Message-Cleanup-Competition (de:Wikipedia:Wartungsbausteinwettbewerb/Frühling 2017). Deletion requests are very demotivating. Something not notable should be deleted, for everything else we should help the writer. Before nominating an article for deletion we should talk to the writer of this article.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [176] Local wiki 17 29 For some it's a toxic user, for others just a troublemaker. Demarcations like that are difficult in an open project such as Wikipedia.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [177] Local wiki 2 12 Better communication and collaboration among the community.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [178] Local wiki 1 There is a virtual but also a real Public Domain: in the real world many volunteer with a "wiki spirit" (free, collaborative, etc.) and they could become truly wiki with a "Wikiworks" project (cf. images on Commons).
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [179] Local wiki 49 A problem of Wikipedia is that contributors don't put themselves in readers' shoes when they write. Since many of them write for more for personal motivations than for others, we give a lot of things for granted.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 10 Experts teaching emotional intelligence towards the benefit of overall good.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [180] Local wiki 50 We don't give much attention to readers, to the point that Italian Wikipedia "user" is used to refer to those who contribute to projects, and not to those who just "use" them readers. Many template messages are there for contributors but are of no interest for readers. We gave it for granted that it is easy for a reader to become a wikipedian, and that when one clicks "edit" he's able to do everything and he knows all the rules.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [181] Local wiki 55 Some message template could be hidden to the readers. Readers should be able to rate articles and easily comment them. We need readers to be healthy. Reading experience has to be satisfactory and enjoyable. (Yuma)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 11 Builders of special feedback tools on moral harassment (isolated incidents slip detection).
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [182] Local wiki 56 The possibility to rate articles (or similar) could give room to partisan people. (Bramfab)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [183] Local wiki 57 If fighting vandalism and similar activities took less time thanks to better resources we would have more time to write articles readers look for. (Bramfab)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [184] Local wiki 58 We write for the readers but they have no right to pretend we right some particular articles: we write about what we want to write about. (Xinstalker)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 12 Experts spotting disturbed personalities and group behaviors (based on feedback).
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 13 Experts spotting disturbed personalities and group behaviors (based on feedback).
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [185] Local wiki 59 If readers thinks an article is poor they can improve it; if they don't agree with it they can discuss it, but there is no point to allow them to criticize it in a potentially non neutral way and without sources. (Xinstalker)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [186] Local wiki 60 If we find out that readers would like to have articles about topics for which we don't have editors maybe we can do something about it. (Yuma)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [187] Local wiki 61 We need good statistics about readers. (Yuma)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 87 Glam professionals also have big impact and can help move towards a healthier direction in a stable and professional way.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [188] Local wiki 63 Our readers is humanity. People can be interested in every topic. Every article deserves attention because it is a little part of knowledge. We need to write clearly and to make our project more readable. We need to make our project easy to use and search. We need to give our best both to the student and to the professor. While we need to be free to contribute in whichever way we prefer, we could work better with better coordination. (Beatrice)
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 22 Collaborate with open government - policy collaborations for things like freedom of panorama - collaborate with those who work to change laws
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 5 We can cooperate within specific projects focused on teenagers performed by other NGO; for example project “pol-gra” about how children learn via on-line gaming; Wikipedia/Wikidata games for children as an outreach tool.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [189] Local wiki 69 Some users are more interested in pursuing their idea of what Wikipedia should be than the idea of an encyclopedia for the readers, sometimes using our rules against their spirit. We should try to serve most readers possible, giving them high quality information on every topic they might be interested in. Without feedback from readers we don't know how we are doing this. Many changes to policies, help pages or content are done without considering readers. (Yoggysot)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [190] Local wiki 71 Some message template should not be visible to every reader but just to those who want to improve the article. The talk page should be more visible and more easy to reach for readers who want to comment. (Pil56)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [191] Local wiki 72 Our way of considering the readers should be writing article of the best possible quality. We should ask readers their opinion whether small stubs are good articles or not. (93.46.221.130)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [192] Local wiki 73 A decline in the number of users is physiological and is not an emergency. (Carlomartini86)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [193] Local wiki 76 Some template message are useful both to the reader and to the editor. Hiding them would damage the encyclopedia. (Bramfab)
Meta B Meta [194] Local wiki 12 Emphasize that we are a living example of democracy - everybody is allowed to be part of this and the only demand is 'Stick to the rules'.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 6 In order to solve the problems with non understanding how Wikipedia works and that it is still unfinished a PR company and/or friendly NGO and/or education institutions could be partners to organize big scale campaign to explain this to the public.
Meta B Meta [195] Local wiki 65 71 Newbies have difficulty with meaningful participation because they don't understand how talk pages work.
Meta B Meta [196] Local wiki 34 76 Organizers of events for seniors will have knowledge of the obstacles faced by elderly newcomers.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 15 No any technical tricks can change the community attitude toward newbies, some internal work is rather needed such as real life meetings and trainings.[15]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 20 20 There is a problem with language used in Wikimedia projects which contains a lot of terms and acronyms knows only to devoted Wikimedians; therefore a project clarifying the language we communicate to each other is need as it is big barrier for newbies.[5]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 20 21 Community of editors won't solve such problems as gender gap. It needs support of professional experts in sociology and volunteer management who should sometimes even force needed changes from outside. This is a role for WMF [6]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 23 A new special role in wiki is suggested - an ombudsman for newbie editors, who can have a right and duty to protect them from angry actions of toxic users.[2]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 25 To solve the problem with newbie-biting there should be terms of office for admins, and the admins should be allowed to maintain the articles about which they have good knowledge/expertise.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [197] Local wiki 4 9 We need to pay attention to the documentation of the basic software features and of community processes; many users are afraid to edit, and those that do despite the lack of good documentation are reverted and get frustrated. An inclusive process requires a reorganization and simplification of the help pages. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [198] Local wiki 4 10 Harassment is a major issue in the process of creating power boundaries among contributors. We have been able to understand harassment in deep dimensions, including knowledge formation: some knowledge won't stick, as they do not fit the general, dominant epistemological perspective that runs through the projects. This knowledge bias is harassment as it limits the contribution of the marginalized. User:Joalpe
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 19 Non-Government organizations working to further the free knowledge movement could be entities with whom we might partner, since the Wikimedia affiliates are likely to be involved with such entities in their local area. Government agencies might be effective as well (to have partnership with) in some parts of the world.
Australian Community A Australian Community Sydney various 40 6 Variant voices need to be heard - divergence from mainstream popular ideas should not be suppressed in the name of political correctness
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 1 This is the most significant area to focus on. The marginalized communities that are most affected by some current policies and practices are the communities whose perspectives are most needed.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 7 The education program brings more newbies and they're more productive. They focus less on “fighting the good fight”. “Retention” is typically not a primary focus of an education program. We will see a rise because people have a positive experience.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 8 True inclusion only happens when minorities hold some kind of power. With better representation, the interests of new editors are served better, and new editor retention is not a problem anymore.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 9 More dispersed offices or less main office and more powerful chapters. Giving more diverse power base. More localized meetings.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 10 Students everywhere will learn how to research and to cite sources through using Wikipedia. Creating a world population that is accustomed to contributing. Wikipedia as a part of Science, History, PoliSci, etc. courses everywhere.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 11 More awareness, involvement and engagement with and from people of Asia, Africa and South America and they will feel welcomed in the community and the movement.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 12 Someone who comes onto the projects and openly claims their identity gets a majority supportive response. New editors are finding like-minded editors, but also are greeted warmly and asked for their perspective by editors who may not be like-minded as well.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [199] Local wiki 4 11 To be globally relevant and internally democratic is compatible with being exclusionary: only the few privileged who can play according to the rules are able to enjoy this restricted democracy, while this general structure marginalizes other groups. A key dimension is to be able to bring diversity and build bridges to empower the chronically marginalized.
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [200] Local wiki 16 1 We need more research and recommendations on the role of WikiProjects − whether they should help with work in articles, form a mini-community amongst themselves or somehow balance it out. Sunpriat
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [201] Local wiki 16 24 We need to treat newcomers and the content created by them more carefully. Vald
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [202] Local wiki 26 Universal non-negotiable criteria has to be set to rule the users (mainly editors) relations and the task definitions, which must govern all the language communities.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [203] Telegram 2 We have to improve language diversity, because it is difficult for non English-speaking communities to share data or engage new people if most of the information is only in English.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 3 We believe that we are (as a movement) the agents of change, so we don't identify a key actor/institution in the process.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [204] Telegram 15 A protocol should be created for harassment victims can know what to do. I don't think a committee could be so effective.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [205] Local wiki 4 We need more Wikipedia interaction in the social networks (e.g. Facebook)
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [206] Local wiki 7 8 Add a code of conduct, standards of practice, improve leadership, provide training in human resource management.
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [207] Local wiki 8 4 a code of conduct; a standard of practice. Slowking4
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 9 Striving for a healthy community may imply for some that there exists an undesired state, and people become defensive. We need to learn to co-exist.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [208] Local wiki 13 10 Strangely enough discussions about Wikipedia in closed groups of social networks like Facebook have a much less agressive atmosphere than discussions in Wikipedia. We should learn from that.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 3 Suggestion made to simplify the language of the theme description, so it could be understand by non-corporate people.[3]
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 16 There is a danger of cooperation with commercial entities. But beyond the dangers of such cooperation - does that fit in with the Wikimedia ethos?
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 17 Who else will be working in this field: All the major online communities.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 20 Schools, ministries, associations. Proposing them projects about the wiki world (open knowledge, free licenses, digital literacy, cyberbullism & harassment etc).
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 14 Wiki communities building should begin in schools.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 22 Cooperate with Universities to better understand problems and to find effective solutions
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 23 Also consider institutional partners in education, science and culture as gateways to new groups and demographies that will increase diversity and quality of content.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 14 We need to cooperate with academia to fight against fake News
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 4 We could use student’s practices and essays writing to ask them to edit Wikimedia projects instead of putting outcomes of their work into never to be read by others university archives and drawers.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 6 We can offer experts utilization of their conference papers in Wikimedia projects, instead of publishing them in post-conference materials, which are never read; it might bring them to Wikipedia as editors as well
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 9 We should visit and participate in academic conferences about topics which are very hot in Wikipedia such as contemporary history - so we can address our dilemmas with academic people and ask them for help/expertise/external conflict resolutions
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 33 Our movement needs to intensify the paartnerships with likeminded cultural, scientific and educational organizations, and to work for cultivating a more acceptable and accepting environment within our community. Spiritia (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 15 We need to cooperate with commercial technology companies that invest in Africa - in research and community mobilization
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 13 Offline legislation will have caught up with online activity and will no longer focus on what's legal, but also on what behavior encourages productivity. There will be one worldwide authority, holding transparency and community health as their mission, that will oversee activity and will help online communities effectively and expeditiously handle matters of abuse.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 14 Contributors will be protected from abuse and hate speech. They will have clear policies around behaviour to reference, and clear processes to rely upon if those policies are being broken. Contributors will feel that they are part of a movement that cares about people, not just content.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 3 This theme is the absolute first condition of the other 4 themes. Safe, healthy communities lay the groundwork for all future work on Wikipedia; it is the gatekeeper and the enabler. For example: Why will others in the knowledge ecosystem partner with us if we are unwelcoming, toxic, and exclusive? How will people respect Wikipedia if they only know it’s created by a small group of people? How can we be global if people continuously leave or never even join our community? Who cares if it’s an augmented experience if we have no users?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 15 Our projects begin to bifurcate based on culture more than language. We have pan-language wikis. It is easy to flip back and forth between these cultural projects, so no reader of a given topic is unaware of the other perspectives. It's easier to “see the world through others’ eyes”.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 16 Lots of people have friends they met while contributing who share an interest in some specific area. Language barriers disappear while working on the projects, although cultural differences are still seen and acknowledged. We don’t have homogeneity in a single monoculture, but instead "agree to disagree" with respect.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 17 Wikipedia’s importance decreases on people’s minds, because there is multiple new healthy collaborative projects of knowledge sharing supported by the WMF (leader on this field) and the massive community behind them.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 18 Contribute to free knowledge is something you do naturally, because it is a natural part of how you learn things. Share and collaborate is trendy. As so many people are part of our community, parts of our policy/essays like ‘be bold’, NPOV etc will become part of popular lingo, maybe even popular culture.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 19 Technical tools and AI agents increase efficiency and leverage so that the people who maintain content quality no longer have a siege mentality and are able to be more patient and thoughtful in their interactions with these new contributors.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 20 We [will] have finally figured out a way to include peoples who predominantly have an oral tradition.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 21 In 2030, we'll be a healthy community that crowd sources for effective change and content development. Wikimedia is a leader in global, collaborative environments. People are positive, happy, and helpful to each other.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 22 In 2030 we'll be a leader in how we run a lean, robust operation with positive global impact. We are innovators in every space of our work as a Foundation. We are an authentic model that and allows the practice, development and long game in how we lead and allocate resources in the world.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 23 in 2030, legislation in advanced countries will just be beginning to catch up with IP and copyright in relation to the internet in a realistic manner. A lot of the shields we have in community process will hopefully be rendered moot, lowering the barrier for participation.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 180 Hopefully, anyone who feels that they can contribute will be working in this area, as with other areas. As it is, the power structure of Wikipedia is too heavily weighted.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 190 The WikiSoCal group is working on including the Latino and the Blind communities, so that they can become volunteers for the Wikimedia projects. Here's the grant proposal that was submitted: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Grants:IdeaLab/WikiSoCal_2017
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 200 Within our wikis , you can easily spot the users who are taking care of other users and those who are pushing users out. At the border, half in / half out, you can find users and groups who are trying to bring people in
WikiDonne's User Group A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/WikiDonne's User Group [209] Local wiki 10 1 Healthy and inclusive comunities is our primary goal, all others depends on it
WikiDonne's User Group A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/WikiDonne's User Group [210] Local wiki 10 2 Monthly meetings online wiki / hangout, wiki monthly meetings in Rome (Literary Café)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 24 Wikimedia decisions [will be] supported by a higher quantity, quality and diversity of contributors thanks to a) well publicized opportunities to contribute basic pieces of quantitative feedback via microsurveys; b) good translation coverage of basic information and surveys, and c) good outreach and publicity of specific issues to contributors with expertise on that specific matter, inviting them to join in deeper evaluations and discussion.
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 2 This theme has the power to make or break our movement - without healthy and inclusive communities, none of the four other themes would be viable approaches and would heavily jeopardize our place within society.

Volunteers are at the heart of Wikimedia projects and will be in future. Hence, how well we will do in this regard has an impact on the other themes, as we need the man- and womanpower to come up with bold technological innovation, grow globally, partner up with like-minded communities and organizations, and to deliver high-quality information and knowledge. The importance of this can therefore not be overstated und should be of the highest priority. The fact that we already face severe challenges in welcoming new contributors and not too many good practices and working processes to change that also shows that this aspect within this theme deserves special attention and joint effort.

Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 25 The writers of Wikipedia are more representative of the readers and the barrier for low-level participation is lower.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 26 Sentiments on the use and distribution of resources worldwide, 'developing' worlds less in control, 'developed' worlds in control will impact on us most. How equity can be achieved, in doing so, the Wikipedia project can serve as a tool to do this by disseminating of information from a diverse range of voices. How to maintain that equitable channel of access is yet another challenge as resources are not consistent throughout the world.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 27 We should be considered the paragon of inclusion, modeling effective inclusion in all aspects of our work - particularly in areas that are historically not inclusive (eg STEM, especially open source software communities).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 28 New users have a support network when they signup: they are assigned three mentors that can coach them in the beginning and throughout the new user’s wiki journey. They have regular check-ins (once a week with a different mentor each time), to see how the experience is going, and to trouble-shoot through any problems or error messages the new user got. Depending on how often this person contributes, after a year or after two years, they become a mentor for someone else.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 29 New, good-faith contributors are recognized as such, and explicitly welcomed and mentored. A 'mentoring' wing of the community rivals the vandal-fighting and deletionist wings for size and enthusiasm.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 30 People in Wikipedias in big languages don’t reject edits from people for whom that language is not native, especially when they write about things that are unique to their culture. These edits are improved and published. Discussions about sources in foreign languages, about newbies’ contributions, and notability being limited only to certain countries, and about translation move from rejection to tolerance.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 2 It is the most important theme, since these are the future bases for the construction of all this collective effort.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 31 In smaller languages, people understand that they are working for the sake of their language. Those that are coming from larger languages to smaller languages are not trying to bring with them rules about notability.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 32 By 2030, we will have technical methods to connect patient/friendly/experienced editors, with newcomers and with editors seeking help. By 2030, we will have excellent technical communication systems, that allow everyone to get as much push/pull communication information as they desire, and allow many people to interact on a single topic, giving anything from long prose contributions to micro-endorsements (in order to not overwhelm signal-to-noise ratios).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 33 The growth of the communities to reach near-parity between the top 50 languages has been staggering. Chapters now exist in major cities in every country. There's an article from a journalist describing their experience as a new Wikipedia contributor. Friendly editor stepped in to provide feedback made them feel comfortable in continuing to edit. Instant-translate tools allow to work across barriers.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 34 A large and diverse group of users is able to contribute without fear of attack from other community members. They will also feel confident that when fights emerge on articles that other community members will come to defend them and work with them.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 1 It is the way to ensure diversity of content approaches for all voices to be represented. Everyone needs a friendly environment to enter the ecosystem and maintain collaboration over time. (original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 2 The greatest potential given by Internet is the diversity possibility -- to confront knowledge, ideas and perspectives different from our own, and which we would hardly have otherwise accessed.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 3 Without healthy and inclusive communities, content becomes irrelevant in the short term.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 4 [This theme] contains C, D and E themes. Tolerance, respect and diversity → link with theme D.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 5 Because without healthy communities all other themes become impossible, especially B --because the data are compromised now-- and C -- because it doesn't have the voices of the majority.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 6 [It is important for] social inclusion, immigrants, special educational needs.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 20 The theme is important, and it is similar in OpenStreetMap. How to grow the community? If there is no community behind, improving and curating, the content loses value because it is obsolete or replaced. (Julio Costa)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 21 Wikipedia pretends to be a source of knowledge, which can only grow from different visions. If there is only one specific group, it doesn't meet the goal of being a broad-based source of knowledge and to report different world views and linguistic diversity. (María Paz Canales)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 24 Any valid source of information has to include multiple points of view. I selected A and D because they are linked and include the others. (Daniela Schütte)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 25 Without theme A all others are impossible. You can't fix the data without including communities. (Trish Hepworth)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 221 English wikipedia could learn a lot from many of the smaller wikipedias.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 231 For each of the Wikimedia project websites those will be the individual editors, the individual functionaries, the user groups involved, and where those people live the local organization like chapters and thorgs. Make them responsible for community health.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [211] Local wiki 20 60 Create thematic debates and conferences and then set up working groups to exchange effective anti-harassment practices and build an environment of debate and non-violent communication.Nattes à chat
Meta B Meta [212] Local wiki 64 Partners able to address accurately to the community, listen it's feedback and provide actionable and attractive processes to achieve the improvement of friendliness and enjoyment of relevant Wikimedia contribution.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [213] local wiki 12 3 It is the responsibility of the community.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 101 There are many initiatives in the field of multi-lingualism. There are open translation communities in all shapes and forms, including dictionary builders and software programmers for machine translation.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 22 Linked Open Data is our potential ally in recognition of gender (and others) gaps in content and also potential source of new volunteers. [1]
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 126 maker, diy community
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 1 It's the community aspect that strengthen the Wikimedia Movement, the set of contributors who build something together. The greater the community is, the greater will be the weight and credibility of the movement. Credibility lies in exchanges and debates.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 2 The topic is important because it is necessary that the community has a large number of people.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 3 Wikimedia is first and foremost a strong community. The importance of this theme lies in one of the basic principles of wikipedia which is the inclusion of communities.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 4 Working in a tense atmosphere is not easy. An inclusion of communities, and therefore of individuals, will make community collaboration easier.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 185 World-Wide web consortium.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 236 Organizations that care for workplace health / online community health. Experts spotting disturbed personalities and disturbed group behaviors. Experts teaching emotional intelligence towards the benefit of overall public good. Experts reporting back. Builders of editor report tools on moral harassment.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 658 Not law enforcement, I hope. Instead I hope we will work with scientists in areas like psychology or sociology so that they help us choose solutions that work with online communities. There is a rather limited research on these topics as of know, it should probably grow by 2030 and we can partner by supporting such research and implementing the best ideas on our projects.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [214] Local wiki 12 We could attract more retired scientists.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [215] Local wiki 20 58 Linguists specializing in non-sexist or inclusive language, Amnesty, SOS racism. Nattes à chat
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [216] Local wiki 17 27 I can't think of an organization. But I'd say that the main topic here is psychologists. Maybe administrators could be aided by facilitators that are schooled by psychologists. The facilitators could be "normal" Wikipedians that get schooled in psychology. Like this the administrators' tasks would be rather technical while interpersonal tasks (editwars, nominations for deletions) could be dealt with by the facilitators.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [217] Local wiki 4 13 Human resources specialists could bring expertise and techniques to help deal with conflicts. User:Danilo.mac
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 547 Governments, to NGOs, to even entertainment (cultural production). I think we have a lot to learn from institutions that have been around for decades. Similarly, they might learn from us in how we get things done virtually.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 175 Public institutions, Governments, conglomerates, large and small. Partner with them by media, public relations, convincing argunment based on tangible evidence and statistics. Social networking.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [218] Local wiki 20 56 Institutions and associations working in the fields of diversity and equality. Nattes à chat
Meta B Meta [219] Local wiki 13 Actively engage motivated groups that are strongly motivated to contribute on a topic (e.g. students, societies, associations, academics, other volunteer groups and NGOs).
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 3 4 Oxford Internet Institute (OII) had made a very sophisticated study in 2013 to explore the motives of Wikipedia contributors from the Middle East. Wikimedia Foundation should also fund and host similar studies to better understand communities, especially emerging ones.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 170 potentially partner with feminist, race-inclusive, open-source, LGBTQ, etc orgs to bring in more of these users
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 216 There are so many non profits working with, e.g female coders, minority tech people, etc. Get them in early and let them guide the discussion. Accept that the current membership might need some new ideas.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 131 Historically members of Council of Europe on human rights in general and ILGA Europe and Transgender Europe on LGBT rights work and I hope your cooperative with United Nations and NGOs on human rights defending.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 106 I don't really know.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [220] Local wiki 20 57 Individuals like Sheryl Sandberg, public institutions as Ministry of Human Rights, research and training institutions. Nattes à chat
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 74 Outcome and process. In 2030 Wikimedia communities are larger and more global. Maintaining the high-quality bar but more global. More flexible policies as the communities grow.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 75 More pragmatic. How do we get to Wikimedia itself. There are diverse avenues of getting to it. Thinking about people who don't have / might have mobile phones, less electricity, barriers to access, challenges to consider. We're doing well with Wikipedia Zero.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 76 People can play different roles. They are interested in different things in different places. In 2030 there will be so many new roles for people to fill. Participation in the movement will be different than it is now. We need to be more supportive to new definitions of contribution which will make communities look very different - public policy, etc. These changes foster the diversity of participation.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 80 Editing Wikipedia can be a political act in the frame of Turkey - sometimes it's serious.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 11 We need to locate disadvantaged communities - battered women, Arab schools, Ethiopian immigrants, immigrants from the Soviet Union and people with disabilities
Wikimedia Community User Group Turkey (WMTR) A Cycle 2/Turkish Wikipedia email email 35 2 Healthy, inclusive communities would also would effect the other themes such as making it possible to become a more trusted source of knowledge. And this would be possible by promoting using/contributing Wikipedia among students and academicians with education programs.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 4 The Wikimedia movement is a community of different kind, it has a lot of room to enlarge, different places to go, different possible directions. It is an opportunity other movements dont have.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedia Community User Group Turkey (WMTR) A Cycle 2/Turkish Wikipedia email email 35 4 Healthy and organized communities should be the main theme that we should be focusing on because other themes such as becoming the most trusted source of knowledge and spreading the movement globally would only be possible if there is a healthy and organized community to work on those. All themes are related with each other; i.e to become a trusted medical source it's neccessary to include some medical experts in the community first. It appears that including people from every background is essential for other themes.
Wikimedia Community User Group Turkey (WMTR) A Cycle 2/Turkish Wikipedia email email 35 5 In the community it's observed that the amateur spirit is diminished; many experienced users left the platform and they are not being replaced by new users since the newcomers are being "bited". Therefore, the theme of healthy, inclusive communities theme should have priority.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 8 Wiki communities are workplaces. Workplace moral harassment is legally unacceptable.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 2 Without communities, there will be no Wikimedia.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 3 If we don't take care of our community our projects will be spammed and become insignificant.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 18 We still don’t have rules of behavior as affiliates - we are still figuring out how they behave and we need clear rules about conduct and how to behave - we are not thinking of a future where there may be so many affiliates in the same country and potential overpopulation of affiliates maybe
Australian Community A Australian Community Perth various 40 3 Strong community also comes from personal, social interaction in real life.
Australian Community A Australian Community Darwin various 40 3 Transient populations in some cities/universities/etc. make it hard for the wider Australian Wikimedia community to effectively support contributors.
Australian Community A Australian Community Perth various 40 6 Increase capacity for feedback from readers and interaction with new users.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 2 Generate protocols to identify and manage harassment scenarios.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 6 Promote the [Wikipedia's] 5 pillars.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 9 Proposal: admin accountable for events that affect the creation of contents and a formulation of more explicit/direct official policies.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 4 If we increase our effort in this area in the next fifteen years we should acknowledge that Wikimedians can contribute in several ways. Community members improve Wikimedia projects in many different ways: initiating conversations with new partners, training students and new users to contribute to Wikipedia, mentoring program leaders, speaking to outsiders about how Wikipedia fits into our existing knowledge ecosystem, being kind and inclusive to another editor (giving them a sense of community), etc.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 5 Volunteers should not be evaluated or valued by the number of edits they make to the Wikimedia projects. We must stop rewarding bad behavior. Even if an individual has 100,000 contributions to Wikipedia or founded a project does not mean they should be excused for harassment and toxic behavior or welcomed to conferences/participate in offline events.
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 4 A healthy and inclusive community does not exist in a vacuum. It interacts with the society it is surrounded by on a daily basis, influencing and learning from each other. Developing awareness in societies around the world for the Wikimedia projects being a shared responsibility of all humankind should therefore be an essential goal of of this theme.

What is implicit in the current statement is that an inclusive culture which makes contributing fun requires to fight toxic environments. This is a cultural shift as currently an indivdual’s amount of contributions to the projects or years of service weigh more than his or her behaviour towards others. The prefered way to do this is positive reinforcement: As a movement we should celebrate those who successfully manage to bring in and mentor newcomers. However, in some instances a tough stance against toxic behaviour will be necessary and should have the same importance and consequences as other violations of the core values of Wikimedia.

Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 10 Update the selection criteria for international meetings. Prioritize commitment and competitiveness, rather than seniority. In order to improve the quality of exchanges, a watchdog committee should be set up to sensitize and call disrespectful people to order. All communities must be represented in this monitoring committee.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 11 Build a more open and culturally representative community.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 5 Do we need "community management"? Do we need to actively take more care of our community?
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 6 Too many sub themes, the theme needs more focus. Suggestions – health, engagement, support.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 8 Different future scenarios might need different communities as we have at the moment.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 10 Social changes can also be prompted by technological improvements (link to augmented age) or through the terms of use (one example is the global ban).
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 2 If we want to establish and enforce values that foster a positive culture within our communities, these values have to be practised by community leaders (e.g. experienced users, power users, admins). We have to establish a "leadership culture" based on positive, shared values.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 3 We should acknowledge the creation of a safe environment as an essential task and responsibility of the Wikimedia organizations. We should not leave it up to the communities alone to find solutions.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 4 Should we enforce a zero-tolerance-policy against personal attacks and apply strict sanctions?
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 5 Controversial thought: Wikimedia should consider to work with paid community managers who enforce a safe and welcoming environment throughout the Wikimedia projects.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 8 We should integrate more positive feedback into our projects - not only by editors but by readers too.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 9 We should make it possible to rate the "friendliness" of postings on talk pages.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 14 Include a definition of “community health” aspects that does not focus primarily on fun but on being motivating, appreciative, inclusive, rewarding, non-discriminatory, non-racist, a positive experience.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 4 WMF has not been dealing with the toxic aspects of the movement effectively so far.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 6 We need to define what we mean by "inclusive", so that it does not cover people of groups acting in bad faith. We need to consider who judges this, and who says who shouldn't be welcome.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 8 We want to avoid the influence of the Silicon Valley "brogrammer" culture bleeding into the Foundation and the community.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 57 More breathing room for vandal-fighters and other quality-maintenance people.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 62 Distinctions between groups (WMF, chapter, project) should dissolve and not be a source of hostility.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 67 “Fun” doesn’t need to be there; “rewarding” captures this; perhaps “Safety” should be explicit instead; safety in balance with transparency (vandalism, etc).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 68 Moving to other geographies, languages, emerging communities; middle class contributor base may be harder to find.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 70 Groups taking responsibility for members’ edits may be one way to allow new types of contributions. Eg, Tor edits. Also possibly a way to mitigate harassment by having a larger group stand between the specific contributor and the “identity” revealed to the potential harasser.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 72 Group of diverse people who spend a lot of time - more diverse, more time on content. Helping to support a larger and more diverse group who feel comfortable contributing sporadically and randomly.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 77 There is a middle ground between "fun" and "rewarding" and we should fit there.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 12 There is currently an emphasis on editing in Wikipedia. One has to think about involvement in the community. Get closer to the community. It is something that can not come from above, but from within the community
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 8 There should be a semi-automatic system to list the most "toxic" users (for example by finding those who makes most reverts and deleting) and then screen their behaviour and asking community to remove their wiki-functions or blocking if needed.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 9 Instead of blocking toxic users some sort of organized "therapy" of them might be implemented
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 3 It is vital to organize contacts between current users and potential users of similar interests - for example workshops on selected departments of universities for both wikipedians, and potential newcomers - students and staff
Wikimedia Portugal A Wikimedia Portugal Grupo de Estratégia appear.in offwiki 4 2 To be an inclusive community to allow more collaborative and better participation.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 31 On one hand, we need to heal and strengthen our communities, and then to try to expand them. Live meetings can help a lot in this respect. There are vast opportunities for collaboration with many volunteering organizations, institutions (GLAM), NGO and civil organizations. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 4 Things that might help overcome challenges: More focus on conflict resolution. Ways of keeping people engaged while promoting discussion of different points of view. Getting experienced contributors to not scare off newbies as quickly. Shaping expectations that there will be a learning process to get good at making contributions.
Wikimedians of Korea User Group A Wikimedians of Korea User Group videocall video conference 3 1 We cannot develop healthier community with online activities any more. Current approach is not enough to diversify the community. We need to cooperate with outer organization to widen the range of knowledge. We also need to protect manorities more actively. Thesedays, discussions in the projects are too aggressive. Depending on volunteer will is not enough to solve this problem, so we need to search for other approaches ouside of the Internet.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 1 We should make use of artificial intelligence to amplify positive developments within the community (i.e. feedback loops) while still considering the human factor (apply empathy and social norms).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 78 Gamification has its place, but we shouldn't have everything designed for shininess etc. The black-and-white, newspaper style feels more newsworthy and rewarding. It's also important to be fun. As a volunteer your hobby is to edit Wikipedia. It's an odd thing. But it's "fun", not always - it may be a little more than "rewarding".
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 60 Include something about the makeup of the Foundation itself, potential to affect makeup of broader community.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 63 We’ll be more conscious about recognizing what internal forces set us back and set up governance functions to prevent it.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 64 Wikimedia Foundation struggles with a lack of minorities in position of leadership. In order to achieve better outcomes with inclusiveness, we need to elevate minorities into positions of leadership at the organization.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 13 Volunteer editors tend to stay in their comfort zone. Here it is the job of the affiliate - to initiate and continue the activities that the volunteers have started
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 11 Communities should be open to 'professional' editors, i.e. staff of GLAMs who contribute to the WIkimedia projects as part of their professional role (while adherring to all rules). Staff of GLAMS should be considered part of the community
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 5 Answering the above question it was found that: people are leaving projects due to problems to make progress inside community - such as lost admin elections
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 7 As this is a global movement, we need to avoid a Western bias as to what is "healthy" and "inclusive".
Australian Community A Australian Community Melbourne various 40 1 New users should be encouraged where at all possible.
Australian Community A Australian Community Adelaide various 40 1 Problems with dealing with new users, more appropriate help in starting editing.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 9 The Wiki movement must be less nerdy, and be more attractive. It should not be reserved to seniors with often difficult words to understand.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 12 Introduction of a mentoring system among community members.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 4 The theme description needs a stronger link to the movement (e.g. what does "we will welcome new volunteers to our movement" mean?).
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 11 One way to improve community health could be to recruit a significant number of new contributors.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 12 If improving community health in our existing projects turns out to be unattainable it might be more promising to focus on constructing new projects with healthier environments for new communities ("build it right and the right people will come").
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 12 The claim that people first and foremost contribute to free knowledge projects because they are looking for relations and networking, has been challenged in the past and should be dropped. Take a recent focus group analysis of newbie editors that has been commissioned by Wikimedia Deutschland: It strongly suggests that potential and actual new contributors are not “in it” for the community aspect. In fact, being part of a community is rather off-putting to them and leading to self-doubt or hesitation to contribute.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 59 Contributors, not consumers. More diversity of consumers, as well as channels for consumption.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 66 AOL summer; old timers insisted that the newcomers use the internet they way the old timers were used to; we don’t want to reject the influx of newcomers from new countries/cultures as internet access spreads.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 71 Everyone edits all the time, as though it were Facebook. We can't do this unless it's a welcoming environment. It's not something *you* do, but *we* do.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 7 This is the most important theme because the human factor is always more relevant than technology or processes. Thus, “Augmented age” (technology/means to an end) and “knowledge ecosystem” (process/how, working with others) are not as important, by definition.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 8 This theme is very important: If it is taken by its words, then the other 2 themes of acting globally and being respected for content follow logically from this first theme.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 9 It’s an underlying theme for all the other themes and a main asset for all of what Wikimedia can do to advance free knowledge in the world. It makes us unique, human-based, diverse and sustainable, thus it’s the most important among these 5 themes.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 10 This one is the most important theme. A positive communication culture on the internet is currently at stake and the Wikimedia spirit (which represents the description above) is the core of the idea of Free Knowledge. Both aspects must be actively nourished to keep up motivation of the volunteers.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 11 This theme is very important.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 81 There's an emphasis on new people. People coming are the first step. Is this something that should remain as a main focus?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 86 We decided to welcome newbies. This decision will be backed up by tech choices that support and enable it. We tend to reproduce the behaviors we participate in society online. It is up to the Community to decide which behaviors are acceptable, and which are intolerable. To go beyond the current results, we need actual training and capabilities development for all participants.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 2 Answering the above question it was found that: people think that Wikipedia already contains everything so why to add anything new.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 4 Answering the above question it was found that: editing is hard due to unfriendly and hierarchical community of current editors.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 10 There should be created a technical or social methods to give newbie users an initiation time during which they would be protected from toxic users' actions.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 1 We have to replace deletionism with human-friendly contact with newbies. More tutoring and mentoring is needed.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 30 Our community needs to become more tolerant, patient towards the newbie editors, especially those coming from likeminded educational and cultural partners. Inclusivity requires that we do not tolerate the old editors with hundreds of thousands of edits to mistreat the newcomers. Spiritia (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 32 Attracting more volunteers. Ilikeliljon (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 28 Perhaps it would be good to think of digitization of sources, which would add content, for example, about Chilean women. It is necessary to look for ways to promote the access of new users with other institutions. (Daniela Schütte)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 58 Access to the network? Ways to contribute without access?
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 6 New editors can be demotivated by automated, harsh bot notifications if they do mistakes without knowing better (e.g. copyright infringement notifications when uploading images). We should aim for a more friendly, constructive wording.
Australian Community A Australian Community Sydney various 40 3 Many former editors who have retired or edit less due to issues from years ago need to be encouraged to be listened to, and become active again
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 10 We should conduct studies to find out what really motivates or frustrates our editors.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 11 In order to strengthen transparency and trust we could highlight the authors of articles. This could also be a motivating factor for editors.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 82 Keeping people around begins at the start - if you can make them feel welcome immediately they'll stick around.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 83 We need a real willingness from real people to engage with people on reverts of good faith edits.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 15 People start to contribute out of different reasons (intrinsic and extrinsic). The community experience rarely is one of them. But it is a strong reason that people keep on volunteering.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 17 Participation from outside of our movement too.
Australian Community A Australian Community Melbourne various 40 4 Languages and culture of Indigenous Australians are open to be incorporated through relationships with partner institutions.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 4 Build bridges with networks that don't necessarily share our values.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 13 Teach the wiki codes to pupils and students from an early age and anticipate the 2030 projects.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 16 Learn the functioning mode of other communities to fit it within the wiki community.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 13 Tear down the wall between readers and authors. Turn readers into (co)authors.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 85 One of the things we need is to stop framing it as an issue or a problem that needs to be solved "by us" and instead framing it as something that we need to do with the partners and community members around the world.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 12 We should make the creation and evolution of articles more transparent and easy to understand - e.g. by providing new tools. At the momement, people would have to look up the history and every single edit to assess an article's evolution.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 61 In 2030, no one will make the “I tried that once and it was AWFUL” face when they hear the name of Wikipedia.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 65 Technology will bring people together to collaborate.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 3 Answering the above question it was found that: writing is hard due to templates, syntax of references and other technical obstacles
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 2 The current methods of contact of users is very poor and unclear to newbies; if they are contacted via discussion pages they quite often do not spot it, so other forms of contacts are needed - pop up windows, tailored to them banners, etc.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 84 If we stay static, we’re probably going to stay stable. If we don’t adapt, we’ll become redundant or obsolete.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 16 With the growth of Wikimedia communities, this is also crucial to ensure they are provided with sufficient knowledge and training to have adequate capacity to further the movement. We have to ensure that they receive proper skill-building training, so that they can be empowered.
Australian Community A Australian Community Sydney various 40 1 The world is a very complex place, 'one size fits all' material in content and categorisation does not reflect this complexity
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 2 Removing barriers to people participating increases the breadth and reliability of content we can get.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 3 Having a healthy community is an important base for working with global communities and other partners.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 5 Other projects already have overcome some of these problems, and we should learn from them. (For example, WikiHow, some hacker spaces, Women in Red, some Wikimedia chapters)
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 10 User experience and the ease of interacting with the interface is critical to recruiting and retaining newcomers.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 41 Some are looking to technological solutions to the community health problem, or to SUSA in the Wikimedia Foundation. These are good but not the only avenues.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [221] Local wiki 20 59 Organizations proposing mediation training, organizations offering non-violent communication training, civil society organizations: Nuit débout, Occupy. Nattes à chat
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 36 There are strong connections to the theme C. Capacity to contribute and use Wikimedia projects is holistically different in emerging and underdeveloped communities compared to more active regions. It is not possible to build a healthy and inclusive community without adapting to the circumstances of these regions.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 37 We will need to get people involved at an earlier age. Making Wikipedia a part of schools across the globe will help to tie all of the themes together.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 38 Theme B -- increased capability to remove language barriers. Theme D -- the idea of a “single truth” will be under increased pressure if we are successful in integrating diverse viewpoints. Theme E -- more diverse forms of organization/learning ecosystems will make it harder to engage and/or harder to ensure that engagement is not biased.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 39 If this goal isn’t achieved, it will be difficult (impossible?) to achieve other goals. Community health is the gatekeeper (and/or enabler) to every other achievement of the community. The other 4 statements can only happen inasmuch as this first statement has become true.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 40 Technology will allow us to scale up reception, mentoring, and recommendations to new people, helping them to find places where their particular background and experience make them effective and able to do good work. Having a healthy, diverse community is the necessary background to being a successful [theme C and E]. It’s difficult to get involved those who don't feel that they themselves are represented in doing the work.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 41 All the themes are not reflecting the needs for the future but the needs for the daily implication into the Wikimedia projects. We are failing technology which is not perceived as innovative, inclusivity with 13% of women, globalization and internationalization... Maybe the Theme B, as a way to remove the language gap, is the more promising and so the more independent - the connection to the current theme may not be that obvious.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 42 Link with Theme B -- more ways to engage with people can help to build a more diverse and inclusive group of volunteers. Difficult crossover with theme D -- we have to balance input from experts & input from a diverse set of contributors (ie, non-experts). In fact, we need both experts and non-experts working together, but we’ll need to shift our thinking away from “including more people lowers the quality” to “including more people raises the quality”.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 43 We can be [theme C and D] if we successfully foster healthy communities, who will then go on to create more partnerships with other key groups and create more knowledge, utilizing the tools at their disposal.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 44 The biggest interconnected theme is theme C. We're missing out on so many perspectives that could help shape our communities to be more healthy and inclusive.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 45 People from many different backgrounds need to feel welcome to fully participate in all aspects of the Wikimedia movement. (for example, people from the “global south” are not a problem to be resolved but people with valuable resources to share with the Wikimedia movement.)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 46 Inclusion both depends on and facilitates everything else. We need to be global to be inclusive to everyone, and we need to be inclusive if we want to have competent answers to the challenges of going global. We need to be inclusive to be free of systematic bias and so become [theme D]; we need to have respectable content to not drive people away in the first place.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 47 Theme B could play a role in increasing inclusivity, etc - improving tools for curation, cultivation, access, etc.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 48 Theme B can support this as well.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 49 [Theme B] can go either way: be better for inclusiveness or work against it.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 50 The themes are good for now, but maybe not for 15 years from now. Everyone wants these solved now. They may no longer be relevant in 15 years time.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 51 When we contemplate something disruptive, we sometimes have positive response from smaller wikis. The issue is with English Wikipedia, which is more unhealthy now (much more than other projects). We aren’t completely doomed if we can’t solve this.
Meta B Meta [222] Local wiki 14 Collaborate with any organization that works with people and intercultural transfers.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [223] Local wiki 4 12 World Social Forum, peer to peer networks and other institutions aligned with alternative traditions could be partners in this area. User:Joalpe
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 111 People, not technology. No tool will stop conflicts.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 79 Ask the help of Universities with department of Psychology
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 92 Academics who share some of the Wikimedia's values should be actively invited.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 114 Educational institutions, especially students working on class assignments to improve Wikipedia
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 207 Fan communities, academics, teachers,... ; Don't start with partnering, but make sure they actually want to contribute and get something back from it. ; Give them more rights to decide instead of the community for their area of expertise.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 252 Community leaders, so history tour groups, churches/faiths, schools
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [224] Local wiki 16 5 We should attract institutions to publish articles on science topics. Semis danbe
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 226 WMF could easily set up regular meetings with platforms like Twitter, Facebook, Reddit and al. to understand all the low-hanging fruits, meaning software features that allow a more healthy, anti-harassment community. Also, psychological support and proactive campaigns by WMF and chapters could help the hardcore community of editors to hone their empathy skills ;-) See for example what WM Netherland is doing.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 562 social media, other online communities, gaming
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 656 We are seeing Twitter, Facebook and Youtube also dealing with a requirement of overarching inclusiveness, bubbles etc.. We need to make sure we take lessons from these other global giants
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [225] Local wiki 2 13 We can collaborate with various social media platforms and education institutions.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [226] Local wiki 20 We can cooperate with media companies and Youtube to create and popularize Youtube videos that provide instructions on how to edit and create Wikipedia/media articles.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 157 reddit? We should implement the reddit social feedback system for all edits and comments. "revert" and "thanks" is to less social feedbakc and control mechnisms
Meta B Meta [227] Local wiki 15 Collaborate with WikiHow.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 74 any volunteer orgnization, social psychology
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 12 The Wikimedia Foundation should be the one who leads all the others to support all over the world.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 151 Technology companies work and will continue working on the social aspects of human lives. It is important to note that membership in communities might need to be protected in the same way the checking out of books is protected from government intrusion. This might complicate the infrastructure around communities and wikipedia would be well advised to seek guidance from some of the experts in the industry.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 88 weird internet
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 96 Probably no one. People have given up on the Internet being inclusive and welcoming.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 119 me, i'll call you
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 141 Everyone, via the internet.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 146 No idea
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 165 unsure
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 195 I have no answers to this question.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 247 Peace and love
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 555 Me, and I might partner with you.^^ But I need everyone to accept, that not every opinion is worth the same! Like Sokrates i have more trust in a Pilot than a Janitor, when it comes to Flying...
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [228] Local wiki 10 23 Because the title of this theme is 'healthy, inclusive communities ... in Wikimedia projects' I say that there is no other organization active in this field.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 6 The other themes looks a lot forward - you can't know what will be in 15 years. This theme is relevant today
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 7 The added value that distinguishes Wikimedia from other platforms in this community. The issue of technology refers to another 30 years. The issue of a real global community comes out of this issue. That's the added value
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 9 Healthy and diverse communities are preconditions for all the other themes.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 10 Dynamic and diverse communities are essential to maintain neutrality
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 8 The real threat is that there is very few young people starting editing; Wikipedia community is aging, therefore we should perform more studies to understand better why young people do not join
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 2 Second place (only to The augmented age), because people always need to be part of a community, of a society - it brings them hope, future, ideas, aim.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 28 I think that this is the most relevant goal in our strategy, because without a strong, large and healthy community, we cannot achieve any of the rest of the goals. A lot more can be done about our inclusivity. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 1 We suggest this revision of the current statement: - “By 2030, the Wikimedia volunteer culture will be safe, rewarding, and inclusive for both existing contributors and newcomers. We will welcome new volunteers to our movement and mentor them to ensure that they have a great experience and continue to participate in the projects. We will provide the resources and technological infrastructure to existing community members that enables them to welcome and train constructive new community members. People from every background will feel part of a network of groups and organizations with deep relationships. As a result, our movement will grow both in size and in nature, as our projects flourish under our collective care.”
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 7 Become clearer on the actual meaning of words – “health” for example.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 9 If we invest in innovations, it might be possible to produce more content with less people. So it's not clear that we need a bigger community.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 7 We should define more precisely who our communities are: online communities only or offline-communities / activists too?
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 13 Include (and differentiate between) the perspectives of online and offline.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 16 replace "healthy" with a better word
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 69 Open source contribution (or gift economy) is to some degree a luxury of the rich.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 6 All other themes naturally grow positively, except community health. This is a real threat, compared to 2,3,4,5.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 73 One thing that's interesting is that a lot of these are about processes. What we will have at the end? On all language Wikipedias, there aren't these content gaps that appear because there are a truly diverse set of contributors. How will we get there?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 79 You're not just here because you're altruistic, there's a factor here keeping people contributing even when it's difficult.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 29 In my opinion, this theme is fourth in priority. Ilikeliljon (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 8 No.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 37 This goal is of crucial importance, otherwise we risk lagging behind the others. Augmented reality will be a major part of the communication of tomorrow (within in the next 5 years), and it is unthinkable to leave it out of our projects. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 7 This seems like one of the most important areas of focus in terms of improving scale, reducing conflict, and increasing the global reach of Wikipedia. Very high marks.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 7 Most important. Technical progress is inevitable and Wikimedia must not be lagging behind.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 17 We considered Theme B to be least important. For the Wikimedia community and the Wikimedia projects to flourish and prosper, Themes D and A are more important. For our mission, Theme C is more important. Wikimedia should not lose touch with changes and developments in the technological world, and should meet expectations of readers and users. But we do not consider technological innovation to be a goal per se. We also think it is possible that volunteers will lose interest if 'machines' take over too many tasks,
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 26 Get in touch with bloggers for a better visibility of the movement and allow them to actively contribute to the Wiki platforms, as does UNICEF with the U-Report project.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 22 Ensure that new technology incorporation doesn't create an access gap -- and serve all people.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 28 We will never be technological innovators. Crowd decision processes are far too slow for that. But we can be innovative in the use of technology for free knowledge and digital social processes.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 6 We believe that the community must be a fundamental part of the change, since the construction of new tools will allow us to improve the way we edit and consume Wikipedia.
Australian Community A Australian Community Australia various 40 1 Improve audio-visual content, especially in more modern ways than are currently done.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 12 As a consequence [of this theme, we will achieve] greater self-knowledge.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 19 How to make technological progress translate into access to knowledge.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 20 Incorporate artificial intelligence in Wikimedia projects.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 6 This offers a completely different scale of change, frees the capacity of experienced contributors, and could indirectly reduce some of the friction getting new people involved by reducing the number of "rookie mistakes."
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 4 We will allow Wikipedia and other projects to be effectively consumed by new generations.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 26 Currently, advancing in technologies as AI and machine learning might boost quality and accessibility of content significantly and ease online contributions. At the same time it will also be important to become more adaptive to still unknown upcoming technological developments.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 6 We can lead technical progress, we can be a hub for technical ideas.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 35 Technological advancement is inextricably linked with Wikipedia. Ket (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 22 Make readjustments, not trade-offs, but improve what already works.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 40 Partnerships should be built with other organisations of the Free- and Open-Movement and Start-ups. Cooperation with big players should be handled very carefully and, if possible, avoided.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 41 Mozilla has much more pressure to succeed in this theme. They are an interesting partner. But also initiatives and even companies who are working with big data and artificial intelligence like Google.
Wikimedians of Korea User Group A Wikimedians of Korea User Group videocall video conference 3 4 These days, everyone has their own smart phone. Unfornately, it is sitll hard to contribute to the articles with the device. We should be able to use the same functions with all of types of devices.
Australian Community A Australian Community Darwin various 40 1 Potential partners need to have better introductions to Wikimedia and what individual projects are for.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [229] local wiki 9 3 In the augmented age we need to adapt, become more flexible and use technology for our benefit. The augmented age may be a threat to the existence of the movement.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 1 This theme is unnecessary. The technology should be easy and simple to use for humans. However, the alternative path for humans would not be easy. Nevertheless, with humans' better understanding of the developing world and rural areas, by 2030, we can make the Foundation's software easier and more convenient to edit. Of course, sister projects need huge improvements and should become edit-friendly and more inviting and well-maintained before reaching 2030.; If this theme is ignored, more projects will be proposed. Some of the proposed will become fully formed and established, but they can invite its own audiences and elites. Wikipedia can still attract general audiences.; I feel uneasy about the theme. I misread the theme and thought it's about creativity. However, I realize it's about artificial intelligence. The A.I. is... something I would not encourage as part of the moment. However, if the theme is followed by 2030, more A.I. machines would take over human production. However, that makes humans less creative than they should be.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 5 Easier contribution if done right; frankenstein if done wronge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 8 Something to change
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 17 Easy access to knowledge
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 21 I believe the impact would be similar to or even greater than the impact that Wikipedia had on the pre-Wikipedia world. The future of computing is semantic, and a Wikipedia adapted to that future would contain all of the world's knowledge not (only) in human-readable text, but in a semantically structured way so that a user with a semantic user-agent would be able to explore and consume it in terms of concepts and precise semantic queries, not in terms of natural-language sentences.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 26 We can persist as a source of information even in augmented reality.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 30 A Wikimedia-backed open-source machine translation initiative would, in the hopes of producing high-accuracy machine translations, would open the door to a far greater audience of readers, who, for example, may not have individuals who are interested in producing translations into their language or providing native content as opposed to translation. This does not preclude other scenarios, a particular case being areas of culture and history, of which there may be marginal interest in outside of its native tongue, and such no human translators willing to invest the time in producing an accurate translation.; By opening this project up to the community at large, it has the potential to not only improve machine translation in general, but also the potential for a "Wikiscient" system that can help guide people through topics and frame one topic in the context of another, which is another aspect of machine "translation", only one that remains within the same language. This suggests that a project must focus on machine translation that develops some form of comprehension of the subjects, potentially supported by Wikimedia content beyond the encyclopedia.; Of course, there is an inherent fear of bias creeping into a machine translation, perhaps due to something as simple as lexical ambiguity, or more worrying, such as actively or unknowingly fed "belief" - where the machine translation converts a neutral statement into a supportive or opposing variant, thus running counter to the nature of an encyclopedia. This means that this a project into machine translation must also develop tools with which to understand bias in machine learning and, where possible, counter it should it compromise the neutrality, and thus accuracy, of its translation.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 35 One that brings about a general association of cleanliness and professionalism with what is becoming one of the most trusted and accepted sources/collections of human knowledge in the world.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 40 Unknown advances! Peace for all mankind.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 46 * By making knowledge easier to access and use across languages, the technological, economic and social gap that separates people around the world can be narrowed. This in turn would help development, democratization and promote peace. ; Having diverse views for understanding the world, such as WP entries on specific subjects with computer-generated pointers to multiple points of view regarding the subject (for example the political right and left, competing academic theories, or different ethical and religious views), promotes open-mindedness of the issues, allowing readers to make up their own minds and have a broader world view. ; Technology could be used to cross check its articles with scholarly papers and provide smart reading lists of relevant material, making WP a more reliable source. * If technology can make it easier for the user to contribute, for example with editing wizards, we can expect a bigger and more engaged community which in turn would incorporate more readers and broaden WP's impact.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 50 I think this would be the most important theme - Technically efficient world
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 55 It depends. WMF can push for this without involvement of volunteer editors and effectively kill Wikipedia. WMF can empower volunteer editors to take the lead and provide power editors with the tools they ask for - and for which there is sufficient support in the wider community.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 60 learning will be fun
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 65 Advanced technology coupled with the breadth and reach of the Wikimedia content has an opportunity to become a unifying force for people of the world who value and desire learning.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 633 * We will need this in order to be able to continue to compete with the larger organisations as google and Facebook (who otherwise might out engineer us and take our consumers away from our platform).; * At the same time, it will allow us to bring more people into the mix, create better cross pollination between otherwise isolated communities etc.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 636 *With better translation algorithms, we can focus on improving the quality of the main articles and impact more people around the world. Often, translated pages are shorter and biases have been introduced. By focusing on machine translation, we will solve these issues and invite researches to develop more reliable translation technology.; *We can implement interactive graphs which would give enable the users to understand the data faster, easier, in a customized fashion. We can implement statistical data visualization similar to GapMinder.org.; *We can also integrate softwares such as Mathematica and Python to accomplish this goal. Plus, the capability of these languages (through the power of Manipulate for Mathematica and Interactive Plots for Python) can help science users to learn difficult concepts, visualize multi-variable plots, and learn how to communicate their own data by learning from examples on Wikipedia.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [230] Local wiki 13 With automation, we could drive out inadequately sourced content, provide better sourced content, and be more reliable.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [231] Local wiki 14 Allow people from all dimensions to access, add, and change the information, don't let "someone" input information into a computer/program and pretend that such information is objective.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [232] Local wiki 15 In 2030, our projects may be able to revise and update themselves in real-time, with or without the help of human editors.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [233] Local wiki 16 Given that we're on a course of accelerating change, in 2030, our model of producing content, our editors and programmers could be obsolete.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [234] Local wiki 17 If we don't keep up with the state-of-the-art, then some other organization will likely leapfrog Wikipedia.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [235] Local wiki 18 It'd be a bad idea to suggest that in possibly upcoming AI era, human contributors won't be needed, because for now, we're lacking manpower.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [236] Local wiki 19 We should be reliable and free to all rather than state of the art.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [237] Local wiki 70 "It is important to be aware that algorithms are not inherently less biased than human editors."
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [238] Local wiki 71 Given the speed of computational and AI innovation, a 15-year plan is impossible; we need to focus 1-2 years into the future on this issue instead.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [239] Local wiki 36 88 Far better to talk about "smart tools" to assist users to be at their most productive/accurate etc., instead of talking about AIs that could allegedly "write Wikipedia".
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [240] Local wiki 5 11 This theme, if developed in accordance with transparency can allow Wikimedia projects and wikimedians to evolve while remaining relevant. Lamiot
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [241] Local wiki 5 12 The tools and models of improvement of our wikis will themselves be open-source and therefore potentially reusable by other users of internet. Lamiot
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [242] Local wiki 13 40 Wikipedia will no longer be an important source of information in the future and will eventually disappear. Algorithms will be able to synthesize in real time information from a llarge number of structured or non structured sources in a reliable and neutral way. Jean trans h+
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [243] Local wiki 13 41 This is an important theme as compared to the others, especially regarding our goals in terms of extension of users, contributors or simple readers. Olimparis
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [244] Local wiki 17 30 Knowledge is part of humanity and under its control. Artificial intelligence is making use of this knowledge, which is does not have values. What role does Wikipedia play in this process, given the following premises: [1] Is H. G. Wells' statement still valid? "Human history only knows one direction: forwards and upwards. Mankind is destined to something greater". [2] Yuval Noah Harari: "To understand the world of today, an incredible amount of data has to be analyzed. (In the worldwide financial crisis even experts did not know what happened.) The only systems capable of processing all relevant data are big data algorithms. Humans will be replaced by artificial intelligence through better and superior algorithms." [3] Stephen Hawking: "Artificial intelligence can one day be able to improve itself and yield to an explosion of intelligence that will replace humans as a species, not being subjected to human moral concepts." (OpenAI)
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [245] Local wiki 17 31 The idea to create something superhuman that generates knowledge is even older than Faust. But I am afraid that we are not aware of the mephistophelian temptations that come along with it. Asimov was refering to some of them, and those can be scary. I think it is important that we start to distinguish between human intelligence, futher coginitive ability and mere algorithm. Lsjbo is just transforming data, placing it on the right spot; I would not dfine that intelligence. Yet the dangers by bot owners are not to be underestimated, although responisble for these are the humans running the bots. Additionally Wikipedians are becoming redundant by those. This progress is hard to stop as shown in the recent article Generation R. But thinking about it critically: do we need values for generating knowledge and article improvement or are they even disruptive in regard to accuracy and neutrality? So which role plays artificial intelligence in the Wikipedia? As humans it is our responsibility and nature to search for answers and to preserve nature. For this it is necessary to know about it. A bot writing articles about places, astronomical objects and animals is helping us more to learn about our environment than, helping us to better interact with it. If we really want to know "what holds the world or the universe together at its core" ... this is our only chance, apart from its utopian character. Hawking said that that we have to leave this planet within the next 100 years. This process would be hard to imagine withought artificial intelligence. But sociral issues are different in nature. And it will take a while until bots will be able to create complex articles. Another focus will be on the use of the computational complexity theory and the computability theory, for instance for the determinational of potential articles. Another critical point are the assistance systems, that demand less and less of the reader or control less what he knowns and vice versa. That is why we should continue not to rely on these answers, but should study the subject further. By this schematic structure the encyclopedic understanding as such can get lost, naturally leading to the question whether the Wiki as we know it will be still accepable if a bot can provide answers to questions directly. This all will have an impact on every day life and research. I cannot imagine that his complex will have an impact on education.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [246] Local wiki 17 32 If there's one thing that worries me about artificial intellegence is that it might work too well, especially the use of AI in image editing (see c't 11/2017). Take a daylight picture of city A and a nighttime picture of city B, total both up and you've got city A at nighttime. Pictures have always been altered, but it's a difference if you have to be an expert in that or if you just add up 2 pictures. This has an impact on the pictures that we are using.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [247] Local wiki 17 33 I believe that artificial intelligence makes sense for us. We could for example need an artificial intelligence that looks at Commons pictures and then creates and stores the summary resp. picture description in our future Commons-Wikidata. An artificial intelligence tool, so to say. But that won't be reviving Wikipedia, it's just another tool. It wouldn't be a strategic product, merely a userful tool.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [248] Local wiki 17 34 The theme is not talking about artificial intelligence, but rather tools to facilitate editing, especially a translation tool. With the translation tool Wikipedia could grow faster. And if the information transfer is improved, Wikipedia would be used more often. But what will be an increasing problem is a problem we already have: self-promotion of companies, politicians and other entities.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [249] Local wiki 1 Wikipedia is a product of technological development and technology promotion is the development of Wikipedia. This is the infrastructure of everything. The promotion of certain technologies will advance certain segments of the project: the promotion of technologies to identify the vandalists will enhance Wikipedia's immunity to vandalism, and the promotion of technologies to correct spelling errors will improve the standard spelling in Wikipedia.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 8 If we follow this theme then there will be an increase in our contributors as well as our articles. People will get know that Wikipedia exists in many languages.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [250] Local wiki 2 14 If we follow this theme then we will be able to understand the needs of the society and serve the society in a better way.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [251] Local wiki 25 More resources are need for filters and other tool to fight vandalism, so that users can spend less time fighting vandalism and more time working on content.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [252] Local wiki 17 If we are able to improve the mobile interface, we could be used every day, not only as a source of information, but also as a tool exchange information and knowledge: from this point of view our first target should be becoming used as Facebook.
Meta B Meta [253] Local wiki 16 Automation is not the primary goal for human resources that create content in collaborative wikis, so keep in mind simplicity for editors without technical knowledge.
Meta B Meta [254] Local wiki 17 There will be a larger impact relative to de-emphasizing the theme, as it seems clear that modes of knowledge discovery will expand.
Meta B Meta [255] Local wiki 18 Leaving the work up to learning machines would make the system and computing more complicated than it should be; we should make computing more simple and easy to edit instead.
Meta B Meta [256] Local wiki 19 The theme will impact on us, since we are only a group that uses the technology, that's why we need to deal with it to maintain our impact on the world.
Meta B Meta [257] Local wiki 65 We should augment our front-end, cross-projects interaction, and knowledge with skills, including communication tools for maintaining "healthy and inclusive communities".
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 30 This is key theme, especially going in the direction of better multimedia support. Otherwise we will become boring walls of texts in the era of multimedia world.[7]
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [258] Local wiki 4 14 The development of learning tools and smart technologies will contribute to improving the quality and reliability of our content in a large scale, increasing our use as an unavoidable reference for all relevant matters. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [259] Local wiki 4 15 While companies innovate to placate market needs, we have the potential to innovate in well being processes and collective content production processes, allowing for these innovations to resonate in other processes, connected or independent to ours, due to the open nature of our licenses and collaborative dynamics of development. User:Joalpe
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [260] Local wiki 16 11 The main body of information is already in Wikipedia, so to increase its practicality for society we need to simplify the search and perception of information. Ivan Pozdeev
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [261] Local wiki 16 19 Using the machine learning algorithms can drastically change aggregating and searching in information, especially in Wiktionary, Wikiquote, Wikidata. We need to give editors of those projects powerful tools for content analysis. DonRumata
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [262] Local wiki 16 31 In 2030, in my opinion, the progress in translation automatisation will allow us to turn Wikipedia into one global universal encyclopedia, in which a lion’s share of work would be given to bots. 192749н47
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [263] Local wiki 2 With the Wikidata development advances, I don't have a doubt that by 2030 it can be achieved a notable advance in the possibilities to apply Wikidata to education, while I am slightly skeptical about achieving quality automatic translations in the same period.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [264] Local wiki 17 31 Wiki[p/m]edia is an example of how freedom of knowledge enriches the internet ecosystem with free and open premises, which contributes to create a healthy and necessary counterweight to the data growth and accumulation model that leads the Internet "big players", which record, accumulate and monetize the people's data and human knowledge for the purpose of economic exploitation.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [265] Telegram 20 The movement should try to embrace a bit more technologies and platforms other than MediaWiki. Interesting things could be made if we open ourselves to new ideas, for example, gamification
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [266] Telegram 21 Tools and software need to be improved to facilitate the guiding process from the moment of account registration. IRC is very useful for solving problems quickly and we could take advantage of it.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [267] Telegram 25 By 2030 the smartphone as a device will be on the path to extinction. The devices will be something like Google Glass, and the goal is that Wikipedia will be the favorite information provider.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [268] Telegram 26 For the augmented age I think we should get to places and objects with new technologies like augmented and virtual reality, and loading content on demand (or using physical tags).
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [269] Telegram 27 I don't know where technology goes, but we must make sure that our content always will be machine-readable by using free formats.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [270] Telegram 28 We have to make sure that current contents remain valid and adapt them to the new medias without losing the old ones.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [271] Telegram 29 Wikimedia has remained in time, perhaps a little disagreeable to aesthetic parameters, thanks to the open construction of its internal processes.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [272] Telegram 30 31 We must aim to maximize Wikidata to ensure that the information we publish is as accessible as possible (to AI and humans).
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [273] Telegram 30 39 Eradicating vandalism in an free editing environment - even by IPs - is impossible. The vandalism is also used to test.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [274] Telegram 30 42 The use of technology to help newcomers has already been done with the Visual Editor. We have to move in the same direction.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [275] Telegram 30 43 ORES is the future regarding the vandalism detection and also other metrics related to the articles quality. I believe that the technology proposal has to go in the sense of appropriating these tools, develop them and reduce manual work.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [276] local wiki 12 4 The technical development is a factor the Wikimedia projects have to follow, in order not to be irrelevant.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [277] local wiki 12 5 Wikipedia should not be a playground for experiment with new technologies.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [278] local wiki 12 6 Better compatibility between existing content and modern platforms, e.g. infoboxes on mobile devices.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [279] local wiki 12 7 Without an advanced technical development, primarily through database and serach technology and new presentations, the wiki projects will decommission themselves.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [280] local wiki 12 8 Are we prepared for a situation where more people are searching via audio instead of text?
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [281] Local wiki 11 The youth will play a large role in the future, and they are using technologies to access the world everyday
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [282] Local wiki 35 We will be leaders in the development of those technologies that will define this new age. Electing not to make a concerted effort within this area leaves development of these technologies entirely to entities who would use it to serve their own interests. [2]
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [283] Local wiki 36 We will be a counterfoil to those who actively spread disinformation, propaganda and fake news. There are many entities that will use machine learning to shape the knowledge landscape to their own ends. [3]
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [284] Local wiki 37 If we are to ingest and integrate the firehose of data that's produced every hour, including government and archival material, we simply cannot operate at the pedestrian pace we are. The only way to do that is to automate and augment. [4]
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [285] Local wiki 38 We have to be internally consistent between projects. [5]
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [286] Local wiki 39 Our encyclopedic base has to be radically extended to non-English wikis. [6]
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [287] Local wiki 40 Our claims should have a high degree of external validation and the latency in updating claims should be lowered substantially. [7]
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [288] Local wiki 8 5 If our voices with the supports of reasonable knowledge can be assembled to a sea of our own, our expressions can be heard one day, which will contribute to the sustainability of globalized civilization in many channels. Jason M. C., Han
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 23 The theme can benefit from focusing it on "truly global reach" rather than the movement.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 21 Do not give full power to the machines. This could cause defections in the editing process. It is therefore important to find the right balance between man and machine.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [289] local wiki 9 7 People comes to wikipedia because of the content mostly which makes them mostly consumers rather than contributors.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 17 By having new technology actually helps the issue about Human Resources, which means that the Foundation does not spend so much time and money to work for them, but technology helps the work be done in a more easy way.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 24 By studying the development of technology nowadays, we can see that the role of technology will be more and more important to us in the future, and it is necessary for us to invest more time and resources to develop technology.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 2 This theme is the least important of all five themes. "Healthy and inclusive" was second most important until I reread the "augmented age" theme, so "Healthy and inclusive" becomes the most important theme. Without making the community and the Foundation "healthy and inclusive", how else do we achieve the "augmented age"?; Back to the question, the theme reflects how outdated, buggy, and inefficient the technology of the Foundation is. It should welcome tech savvy people who should connect well with the general population, i.e. average person who know very little about technology.; Relying too much on the theme and A.I. doesn't resolve difficulties between humans and machines. Rather it makes humans too dependent on A.I. If the A.I. becomes dead, how would humans relearn how to use the technology that A.I. would know about?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 6 Probably low, robotic automated w/o programming seems not that impressive yet.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 9 It's is amazing
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 13 Mid pack at best
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 18 wanted
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 22 I would say that it's most important, because having information/knowledge is the core of Wikipedia. Technical advancement will mean less busywork for volunteers, thus in a way lessen the need for volunteers, and likewise it will improve accuracy and reliability, while also enabling the increase of Wikipedia's scope and reach.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 27 [To lesser extend,] so far we do not know, in which direction augmented reality will develop.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 31 This is very important from an educational standpoint, as the continually growing user-base of the internet, as well as its encapsulation of modern life, means that many users turn to it for assistance in lieu of nearby human aid. By providing provably accurate machine translation, education and self-education can be improved thanks to access to accurate, neutral material in a format (language and then reference-frame within said language) that is most suitable to the reader.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 36 Users will find the concept of Wikimedia being a reliable and trustworthy source of information, data, and historical documents more believable if the content is streamlined and accessible, and that fits this theme into the others relatively well.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 41 My initial thoughts come from my experience. Limited to 2 themes I had to choose.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 47 * This theme is one of the prerequisites to accomplish the other themes:* In order to foster healthy, inclusive communities, technology can help users connect with others that have similar interests/points of view; it can also help identify discussions and issues where they could contribute. * To make it a global movement, technology can make WP more accessible so that users with little technical skills can contribute. * For reliability, technology can provide WP readers with mechanically generated references with ratings for credibility, relevance, readability, technical level, etc. It could also scan the Web for new content that may be relevant for certain subjects helping WP authors to maintain contents current and well referenced. *Knowledge ecosystem engagement will require smart technology to automatically bring in to WP suitable content, such as photographs and other media. Also to interface seamlessly with external sources of knowledge so as to extend the scope of the contents in WP and make it the preferred point of entry for study and research.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 51 All the themes are equally important.But this is ,in my opinion,the most important theme .It would make something extra ordinary invention in near future.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 56 Not at all. But you are allowed to follow Lila Tretikov on the way out.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 61 Wikipedia is already good at other themes. But just thing how will we be able to learn by seeing atoms bonding, mechanics working in front of our eyes, and seeing places without going there.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 66 The themes themselves are too interdependent to be prioritized or presented into a hierarchy. However, the other four themes are about inclusiveness and expansion of the reach of the projects, whereas this theme has the ability to be the most transformative in truly delivering knowledge in accelerated manners fueled by technologies that we can barely articulate in 2017.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 632 * We cannot afford to become the MySpace or Geocities.. It is imperative we stay close enough to the forefront that we remain relevant. Anything extra is a bonus and might be used to achieve any of the other themes.; * We are recognising here that technology is important part of our DNA, that it created us and will continue to nurture us in the future.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 638 Very Important, because we need to keep the quality of our knowledge on its edge or we will loose interest and our users might get scattered. What made Wikipedia what it is today, was using the technology of the day, the internet; now, we must stay up to date.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [290] Local wiki 13 11 This theme could be one of the most important for the coming years. We could need a new interface with focus on simplicity.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [291] Local wiki 20 Following this theme could allow us to be more effective in the other areas.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [292] Local wiki 21 Now, the technology is the main driving factor, thus it will drive development in the other 4 areas.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [293] Local wiki 72 Not engaging with AI progress would be nearly impossible given the state of the world's focus on it.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [294] Local wiki 36 89 We need more smart tools today and, unless we can grow our community of active contributors, we will doubly need smart tools in the future. We need to have better tools and more upskilling of willing contributors. Without a massive increase in tools, Wikipedia articles will descend into a morass of out-of-date information citing deadlinks.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [295] Local wiki 36 105 The technology theme is a third priority - as a support role to the Community and Knowledge themes - to help us achieve these primary goals. User:Powertothepeople
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [296] Local wiki 5 14 This theme can be transversal to others, in the sense that it can accelerate their implementation, but it must have its own ethical safeguards. Lamiot
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [297] Local wiki 13 42 This is the most important theme as it threatens the existence of Wikipedia. Jean trans h+
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [298] Local wiki 17 35 Together with 4 and 5 this theme is important (theme 1 as very important and theme 3 as not so important). This theme forms the basis of expanding Wikipedia more quickly and improving the distribution of knowledge.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [299] Local wiki 2 More than 50% of Wikipedia entries come from Mobile.The use of Mobile apparently caused a decline in the number of editors. What is the basis for this assumption and what is the source? Wikimedia's difficulty in dealing with this new technology has hurt it, and new technologies in the future may harm it further. In addition, Wikipedia is in competition with network giants for the attention of Readers, and without the support of Google it probably did not exist.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 7 This theme is important because better tools will enable users to contribute easily.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 9 This theme is important because better tools are necessary to ensure that contributing to the movement is easy and also to ensure editor retention.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 17 This theme is also somewhat important as better input tools and better interface will make it easier to contribute.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [300] Local wiki 2 15 This theme is important because we won't be able to move forward until we keep evolving continuously.
Meta B Meta [301] Local wiki 20 Data technology is only a means to help accomplishing goals described in the rest of the themes.
Meta B Meta [302] Local wiki 21 Technology is a means to an end, and our principal goal should be to provide quality content that is accessible in both high-tech and low-tech ways.
Meta B Meta [303] Local wiki 22 This theme is very important if Wikipedia is to remain relevant as newer technical media with more personalization and interaction come to dominate.
Meta B Meta [304] Local wiki 34 77 If the technology must improve, then communication and relationships must also improve. If offline communication is not desirable to others, how about audio and/or video communication?
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 20 18 The future technology directions are non-predictable, so rather shorter 2-3 year strategies are needed in this field.; we should first respond to the real current technical problems and try to resolve them step by step than thinking about Wikipedia on the moon.[3]
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [305] Local wiki 4 16 Technological processes determines the way content production organizes itself. The global content production in a collaborative manner is only possible due to web 2.0 tools, and MediaWiki especially. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [306] Local wiki 4 17 Every technological change will have effects in how editors interact with the projects and we should always ponder how much each innovation facilitates, substitutes, or qualifies the volunteers human work. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [307] Local wiki 4 18 At the edge, we run the risk of technical advances transforming our projects into a space for robotic production of articles; a scenario that does not seem beneficial to me. User:Joalpe
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [308] Local wiki 16 8 This theme is the top priority because we need to abandon old encyclopedic format and do interactive learning courses. Semis danbe
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [309] Local wiki 16 20 This theme should be the top priority. We need to use computational linguistics for the goals of our project. DonRumata
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [310] Local wiki 3 The other themes are important, but this is the most relevant, because it not only aims to increase the reach of Wikimedia, but to introduce (artificial) intelligence and semantic management.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [311] Local wiki 17 46 This theme is more important than the others, since the evolution of technology is being discussed here, which affects both Wikipedia and Wikidata.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [312] Local wiki 12 Low priority than other themes. People comes to wikipedia because of the content mostly
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [313] Local wiki 41 Healthy communities is in total synergy with this theme. Community tends to be splitted into many smaller communities that may not work together. This theme can work if Wikidata breaks the language issues. [8]
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [314] Local wiki 42 More integration with MediaWiki, more easy to use tools and more communication around learning is a must do before any prior work. [9]
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [315] Local wiki 43 It’s definitely NOT opposed to the other subjects. We can build connections between communities by establishing a common vocabulary, and inferring statements from other language Wikipedias. [10]
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 13 More support for free software.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 14 Inclusion and decision on new technologies.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 23 New technology should facilitate horizontal participation.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 15 Wikidata is a core asset that we can use to play a role in the augmented age.
Australian Community A Australian Community Melbourne various 40 5 Relationship between wikiprojects needs to be more clearly signed in projects for new users and irregular readers.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 17 Analyze trends on new consumers use to incorporate ideas.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 7 We need the foundation to take ownership of programs and allocate resources (dedicated manpower & money) to develop technical tools that will help support and sustain all programs (EDU, GLAM, Med, Women, events, contests, etc)
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 18 WMF should spend more time and money for the AI development. It will help us with correcting the new entry on Wiki.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 21 It might be difficult for us to predict the development of technology in the next 15 years as the it is developing very fast, maybe it is more reasonable for us to predict the situation for the next 5 years.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 3 * We can't tell whether the Foundation's projects will survive by 2030. Wikipedia needs sister projects for balance. To combat imbalance, the world needs those projects to survive by 2030. Without them, how else will Wikipedians address poor quality, bureaucracy, and lack of creativity? * Wikinews needs a huge revamp to be more productive and inviting to original reporters. Its technology is old, its rules are becoming stagnant, and its community is very limited. Very little is published every day. Nevertheless, people complain every day how dead and useless the project is. One person has stood up for the project and worked hard every day to help the project survive. The limited community of Wikinews felt offended by the negative statements about the project and found them mostly inaccurate. Wikinews's stale editing doesn't ease but increases tensions between Wikinews and Wikipedia communities. If Wikinews starts to become more edit-friendly and newbie-friendly, maybe Wikipedians can stop complaining about Wikinews. * People should stop preventing creativity, stop hostility, and stop honing rules. Instead, they should reduce burdensome rules and start becoming more creative with ideas and content. * The theme does not resolve civility. Rather it prevents editors from collaborating well with others. This theme has premise but does not help people stop tensions among existing communities.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 10 Yes
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 14 We would need to stop thinking what to write. That's not good.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 19 focus inside this scope
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 23 I am honestly not acquainted enough with Wikimedia operations to answer this. I suppose any activity that would inhibit Wikipedia from improving in this area would need to be stopped.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 32 Hopefully, little is sacrificed so long as the project utilizes an open-source framework that is mediated in a manner that supports the various interests and conflicts within a democratic system. By providing clear goals and resources, as well as clear communication and mediation between sub-projects, a collective project can be formed from the community at large where individual abilities and developments can be pooled into the collective project without sacrificing the benefits of small-team or personal development.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 37 Increasing moderation to streamline might mean making contributing to projects more difficult or less accessible at times, but I can't make that determination as I have little experience in related fields, so to speak.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 42 No. Technology is our road. Technology comes from informative personal growth.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 52 All what is done is good currently but a new way should be approached for this .
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 57 No, stop doing this theme in favor of other themes
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 62 no, you must do the same things as you do with an encyclopedia, but also create a learning environment that if fun and exciting.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 67 If the themes of inclusiveness and expansion are successful, there will hopefully be sufficient numbers of volunteers added to the project base to allow for additional work to be undertaken without the need for sacrificing current projects.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 637 This is a very important theme, however, we must never compromise our principles, free knowledge for all! No ads, no biases! Never! If we focus on the infrastructure and recruiting volunteers and educating them how to contribute, this would not require a focus trade off.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [316] Local wiki 13 13 We need less hobby projects from the technological WMF staff. Necessary features are developed, sometimes asked for by the community, sometimes unsolicited. But we need less failed projects like especially Wikipedia Zero, and Flow and Cross Wiki Uploads, just to name a few. These were not developed for the users but for the tech staff. It would be nice in the coming years to have a more communicative tech staff so that they can work better with the communities. Wikimedia Germany for example manages that quite well. We need to stop the hobby projects of the WMF technicians, because they are and unnecessary burden for the communities.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [317] Local wiki 13 14 These machine translations: kill them with fire.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [318] Local wiki 22 Manual editing is obsolete in comparison with programming, and programming is obsolete in comparison to AI.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [319] Local wiki 23 Don't allow AI edit Wikimedia projects, because it can outsmart us.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [320] Local wiki 5 13 Ensure that the projects keeps their humanized aspect, at the service of its users, and not robotized and automated to excess. Lamiot
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [321] Local wiki 5 15 If the community organizes and continues to grow, it seems possible to move forward simultaneously on all these major themes. Lamiot
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [322] Local wiki 17 36 One shouldn't exaggerate the automation so that the expenditure doesn't get to vast. Technology is useful, but don't lose sight on 'knowledge'.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [323] Local wiki 3 The main resource needed for technological development is technological manpower, which usually requires the payment of high salaries.As in politics, everyone will say to reduce things that are less important to Them. We can cut projects funding aimed at directing Wikipedia content development, leaving the field to volunteers, and focus on budgeting for what volunteers usually can't do.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 10 I don’t think we should stop doing anything but just lay more stress on technical development.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [324] Local wiki 2 16 We should avoid simplistic presentations.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [325] Local wiki 51 The community appreciates innovations if allows improvement of content. Innovation is not an end in itself, and new tools (e.g. media viewer) should not be imposed over the old. There should be different tools for reader and for editors. Software against vandalism would be useful but they need to have a very low percentage of false positives. We need to be able to create ebooks onwiki.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [326] Local wiki 52 Users are not against innovation. If something that is good for contributors is developed they use it. If they do not use something (e.g. visual editor) it is because it is not useful for them.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [327] Local wiki 53 The fact that something is new does not necessarily mean that it is an advancement.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [328] Local wiki 54 Developers something don't understand the need of the community, but the community is "luddite". It is normal for websites to change the user interface without discussing it with the community and ignoring protests. There is a significant technological gap so that now it is difficult to innovate, because new features don't work with everything that exists, or work just for someone.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [329] Local wiki 81 If AI were able to write articles we should welcome them. The purpose here is sharing knowledge, not our personal satisfaction. (Retaggio) (95.239.3.184)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [330] Local wiki 82 Even if robots were able to write articles human intervention will still be needed to check notability, relevance, reliability of sources and NPOV. It is possible that human editors will spend more time in talk pages and less time writing articles. (Valepert)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [331] Local wiki 73 84 AI improvements will result in great development for Wikisource. Archeologo
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [332] Local wiki 73 85 AI development will result in more uniformity between different language editions of Wikipedia, or we will just translate and adjust English articles. Archeologo
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [333] Local wiki 73 88 Old users often do not welcome technological innovation. (Alexmar983)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [334] Local wiki 73 89 We need to explain technological innovation also to users who write content but are not computer experts. (Geoide)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [335] Local wiki 73 93 Computers are better than us in repetitive tasks, they don't complain, don't sleep and should be easy to use. They will help us in contributing to Wikimedia projects. (Ilario)
Meta B Meta [336] Local wiki 23 Rigorously review and reduce all formatting related markup on all projects, since reformatting for new media will render such markup useless and anachronistic.
Meta B Meta [337] Local wiki 24 The new technology will surely be harder on the bandwidth, so we need to cut down on gimmicks and concentrate on economy and reliability.
Meta B Meta [338] Local wiki 66 We should not reduce effort in human communication even if we are willing to increase effort in technology.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 20 19 We must focus on real issues such as anti-vandal tools, instead on focusing on secondary details such as shape and color of buttons [4]
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [339] Local wiki 16 12 If we plan to actively interact with other language editions, we need to have a cultural expansion so our cultural distinctions can be blurred out for productive collaboration. Ivan Pozdeev
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [340] Local wiki 16 21 Instead of build-up in the size of communities we need to give practical tools for automatisation of search, aggregation and analysis of information. DonRumata
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [341] Local wiki 4 We must continue what we have already done. Only if the plans have a stumbling block in terms of funding, specialists recruitment, or other shortcomings, the new projects could evaluate to slow down, restructure or adopt alternatives.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [342] Local wiki 29 New technology will appear and we will have to apply it -- The only thing we can do is to have an open mind.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [343] Local wiki 17 32 Wikimedia does its best as far as its resources and possibilities in adapting its platforms to technological changes, considering that the advance of the Internet is strongly determined by the markets, whose actors will have a study and technological development substantially superior to that of a voluntary community.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [344] Telegram 22 IRC is not friendly at all, so features more similar to social networks should be implemented, which are familiar to different target audiences.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [345] Telegram 30 30 It is necessary to watch over the net neutrality, because it is related to access, knowledge and affordability barriers for Wikipedia consumption.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [346] Telegram 30 33 The social media use is vital to attract new people. If there is low retention it is precisely because we expect newcomers to adapt to an unfriendly platform, rather than adapting the interface to the new times.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [347] Telegram 30 34 Saying that the interface is outdated is not exaggerated. Monobook started in 2004 and Vector in 2010 -- We are talking about 13 years with almost the same GUI and 7 years with the same GUI.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [348] Telegram 30 38 The user sandbox use is not sufficiently documented, because it is relatively recent, and the tutors system could also give a turn around.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [349] Local wiki 22 We may have to spend less on Wikipedia grants on highly and mid-developed countries.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 36 We need to establish an 'agile crowd thinking and decision process' to cope with constantly changing environments.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 37 It needs a discussion if the system has to be absolutely intuitive or if volunteers need to learn new skills or both.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [350] Local wiki 5 Both closed and open training, supplementary or extension activities should be developed, and a scholarship program for students to achieve a continuous training.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [351] Local wiki 6 We must bet to improve education with a mix of orientations, technologies, and organizational methodologies, using the Wikipedia contents and the collaborative focus.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 10 It could be convenient to create a video channel for Wikipedia that hosts documentaries and summaries of Wikipedia's content, which could target audiences that are less interested in written material.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 11 I agree with creating a video channel, it has a great potential of spreading Wikipedia's informative content and accessing a wider audience.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 4 Nothing other than "artificial intelligence". That's it.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 15 Technology should be a tool to make the things we want. We can't let technology do things for itself, as it would decide what to do, and that's is a bad idea.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 28 Question is, how the access/path to augmented reality is imagined by WMF representatives. To me personally, so far there is not much to plan. Perhaps just allow the Commons 3D objects to be ~embedded into WMF projects, and you can use the mouse to rotate them. This would allow for a new, for many certainly interesting model studies. For example, in articles about Baroque sculptures you will be able to turn and shoot/film various statues to understand the field.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 33 Focus on inter-language machine translation to present accurate and neutral translations and the potential for intra-language machine translation to allow material to be framed within a desired perspective (eg. translating one area of mathematics into another, such as geometry in terms of algebra, or vice versa, should such a translation be possible)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 45 An integrated bibliographic database (like WikiCite) is essential and is currently lacking
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 48 WP should become the central point for research on the Web for all levels of users, from someone who is a novice in a field of study to the professional researcher. With this aim it should incorporate a specialized search engine that would have two goals: (1) complement WP entries by providing relevant Web resources such as media content and educational resources (or links to it) and (2) provide bibliographic recommendations that are the most relevant background reference material as well as important recent developments in areas of interest.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 63 Virtual Reality-seeing this in front of us as they ARE.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 68 There likely needs to be some thought put into humanizing any technological increases.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 635 * Wiki is not a site for programmers. It easily can be. We should focus on that.; * Mathematical equations are just low quality images, we can fix that and make them interactive. I would be glad to help with the latter.
Dutch Email Survey B Dutch Email Survey email email 2 1 It must become much easier to upload pictures to Wikimedia Commons. It nowadays works only for those who are often doing that, but not for myself. I am a senior citizen and was inactive for 2 years because of illness.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [352] Local wiki 13 8 Red links could be explained by linking them to Wiktionary.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [353] Local wiki 13 12 If we want to have more non-technical content we will have to have more tools that are easy to use for users. The Visual Editor is one step, but it has to be improved.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [354] Local wiki 25 Provide a place to talk about the issue and eliminate meaningless chatter from those who have no understanding.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [355] Local wiki 26 Better hardware more space for WikiBrain.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [356] Local wiki 74 Improve site design so it fits better within the modern era
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 14 The Foundation technology staff should be accountable to the other parts of the community.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [357] Local wiki 5 16 Integrate automatic and easy-to-use means to ensure transparency and neutrality of content. Lamiot
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [358] Local wiki 15 Wikimedia projects are becoming glowingly more difficult for blind and visually impaired people: we need to work to solve this as best as possible.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [359] Local wiki 19 Google Maps ask you if you want to take and upload photos of monuments around you: Wikimedia should do the same.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [360] Local wiki 26 We need to work on spoken articles and/or text-to-speech technologies for the visually impaired.
Meta B Meta [361] Local wiki 26 Prepare our user facing interfaces if we want to stay relevant.
Meta B Meta [362] Local wiki 34 78 The searches could be temporarily saved, organized and utilized for educational purposes.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 31 More automation is needed. As many as possible work should be automated. Not only simple cleaning and editing tasks but also maching people of similar interest or having appropriate skill for needed tasks, so AI could find them and ask for help.[8]
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [363] Local wiki 16 17 Give attention to tools for reusing content from other language editions (both by readers and editors), for automatisation of routine tasks, for removing duplication of efforts (share existing tools amongst ourselves). Ivan Pozdeev
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 38 Who else will be working in this area: Everyone targeted in major theme 5.
Australian Community A Australian Community Australia various 40 2 Attract people (contributors and editors) who don't engage so well with text-heavy content.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 34 Wikipedia has always been a technological model for sharing, and it is good to have this preserved in future. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [364] Local wiki 16 22 We need to turn attention to automatic creation of spoken articles. DonRumata
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [365] Local wiki 17 34 Automatic tasks and innovation should also be promoted to more actors who wish to support the improvement of the experience for those who write and maintain Wikipedia. WMF's speech in the search for innovation and automation is usually read-oriented, but the editing work is the other half of the project.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [366] Telegram 24 I propose to directly use social media like Facebook and Twitter. If we are realistic, people use them more than anything, and they know how to use them. If we implement communication channels managed by volunteers there, people would have it much easier.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [367] Telegram 30 40 ORES, an API that uses artificial intelligence to catalog editions on Wikimedia is invaluable for combating vandalism.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 24 There should be a voice control feature on the Wikimedia platforms for people with disabilities such as blindness and eventually for anyone interested.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 25 Put an emphasis on audio content to diversify access to content.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 22 Expanding to other media is most important and should have a more prominent position.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [368] Telegram 30 41 The vandalism and technology issue is complicated. Bots don't detect the same thing as a human and often reverses good editions. That is something that technology and AI should aim at -- improving the level of vandalism recognition.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [369] Local wiki 7 9 Develop tools that would provide data mining in our sources and check compatibility between sources and content.
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [370] Local wiki 8 6 redesign the interaction with the site; the barrier to participation is just too high. Downtowngal
Wikimedians of Korea User Group A Wikimedians of Korea User Group videocall video conference 3 3 More people will require non-text content incluing music, voice, and video. It taks too long to upload vedio files on Commons. We need faster and more convient envirnment for mutimedia files.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 34 Let's abandon any explicit or implicit depiction of volunteers as “optimizable assets”. People do not need help to be creative. It will not be wise to make a 10-15 year prediction of what we think editors will need to be more productive. As a movement, we may be of service by providing ever more options to pick from or better invitations to contribute, but that’s about usability and service – not about getting more and better results from people. Optimizing people’s output is what the Matrix is about, not Wikipedia.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 20 Wikimedia must become a model of investment in the field of technological research.
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 1 Big data and internet of things is more readily apparent to us at the moment. Wikimedia has to give the interfaces to augmented data.
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 3 People should all see the same version at Wikipedia, and be able to use the same tools
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 7 Idea of a "wikipedia that adapts to the learner" (e.g. slider that determines complexity of content shown)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 43 This question delves deep. Future growth depends upon education and challenges! My own life experience is that these areas are diminishing outside Internet connections.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [371] Telegram 30 44 It is important to preserve anonymity, it is easier to avoid some prejudices and the tracking the online activities that happens in many places.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [372] Telegram 30 45 Wikipedia is one of the internet projects that demonstrate how anonymity is an enabler of freedom and knowledge. It must be preserved and defended in the coming years.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [373] Telegram 30 46 Wikipedia should, in the next 15 years, defend the anonymity election of his/her collaborators and editors. It should also further ensure the privacy issues in difficult contexts or in issues that an independent community body could consider that jeopardize the integrity of some contributor.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [374] Telegram 30 47 Anonymity also limits liability. The WMF is one of the most transparent and accountable internet organizations and details of the processes behind a probable release of information from judicial authorities that need it.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [375] Telegram 30 48 We put at risk our encyclopedia's advantages which is the contribution of divergent visions and versions that would be difficult to contrast/visibilize in a physical space, if we end up repeating only the official truths for fear of local censorship -- That is why anonymity is so useful.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [376] Local wiki 17 33 Accessibility should be an element to be considered permanently in Wikipedia's technological development, both in its reading and editing phase. Maintaining the right standards for the most common reading software for people with different abilities is substantial to keep it available to more people.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [377] local wiki 9 6 Geodata is important. there should more integration between OpenStreetMap, Wikidata and Commons.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 24 I suppose the theme should emphasize Wikimedia's current efforts in this, such as Wikidata, and the need to unify all Wikimedia projects on a common semantic foundation.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 53 We should integrate it with all the others concept that may be reality as shown in science fiction movies.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [378] Local wiki 27 There should more integration between OpenStreetMap, Wikidata and Commons.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 58 Don't do anything in this area unless formally requested by a community
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [379] Local wiki 5 17 Ensure that the "augmented" aspect does provoke an enormous consumption of electricity. Lamiot
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [380] Local wiki 5 18 Wikipedia and its sisters projects should be able to be fully powered by clean, safe and renewable sources of energy. Lamiot
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [381] Local wiki 17 37 You will work most effectively using well established technology. Immature technology will just burn lots of time and money.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 19 We should also mention mobility in the next 15 years. What will it be like in the next 15 years? Mobility will definitely increase and we should be prepared for it.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [382] Local wiki 18 There should be a Wikipedia mobile fever as there was a Pokemon go fever.
Meta B Meta [383] Local wiki 25 Add concept development and hardware manufacturer partners.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [384] Local wiki 13 2 For the English Wikipedia there is a nice solution for comprehensibility of articles: alternatively providing articles in Simple English. Laymen should be able to understand an article. Placing a red link is not a replacement for explaing the term within the article.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [385] Local wiki 13 3 There should be a way to integrate a Simple Wikipedia into the normal Wikipedia, that shouldn't be 2 completely seperate Wikimedia projects. When clicking on a blue link for explanation you just open another article that's difficult to understand. There should be more overview articles / tutorials.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [386] Local wiki 13 4 Articles about mathematics are too difficult to understand for non-mathematicians. They should be written so that non-mathematicians can understand them.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [387] Local wiki 13 6 For historical and political articles timelines and maps would help. Those are difficult to make, so it's more like a mid-term or long-term project.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [388] Local wiki 13 7 There should be more featured articles, but not all articles are suitable for a featured article status.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [389] Local wiki 24 Automation will allow us to make massive quality improvements and drive our talent to where it can add the most value.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [390] Local wiki 35 Make the content more dynamic and facilitate translation by active contributors. Zaxiphyvaxe
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [391] Local wiki 73 Make sure to give adequate support and PR attention to AI projects like ORES
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 11 Some Volunteers
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 20 Focus more
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 38 It'll take a lot of work and time, so we'll have to be patient and gather feedback in the time it takes to make progress with these aspects of Wikimedia.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [392] Local wiki 13 5 As a non-mathematician you are not interested in a mathematical article anyway, so there's no need to improve the comprehensibility.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 11 I don’t think we need to add anything else in this list.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [393] Local wiki 13 1 A very important but often underestimated subject is comprehensibility. Wikipedia articles are often written by semi-experts that write in the language of experts. A lot of articles are difficult to understand and put into context. What can we do about it? Raise awareness that many Wikipedia articles are difficult to understand Implementation of possibilities for feedback when an article is difficult to understand and incentives to do something about it Training to write more comprehensibly Invest in articles in tutorial style that will help articles that are difficult to understand Invest in in good visual material for explanation, like for instance diagrams, maps and animations, etc. All this could be done together with universities and secondary schools that often face the same problem.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [394] Local wiki 2 17 More and more dialogues and workshops for different sections of the society.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [395] Local wiki 64 Projects like Wikisource could make use of some sort of "time capsule" to host in some hidden way content which is now copyrighted. This content will be made available when copyright expires and it enters the public domain. (Silvio Gallio at Italian Wikisource Village Pump)
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [396] Local wiki 16 6 Create a visual system in which people could understand a chronology of development of different spheres with different branches. Semis danbe
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 27 Set up a research team, collaborate with specialists, universities and the academic sector in order to transform the difficulties and needs of Wikimedia into research subjects.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 39 We need to proactively convince partners to bring their technological developments into our movement and make them available free and open for all.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 89 The augmented age refers to digital assistants that will “be there” for you, and how they will help us navigate the world. The question then is: Will Wikipedia be a content provider for these assistants, or will it have its own (encyclopedic) assistant? What does it mean to edit/improve contents in these scenarios? Sharing pictures and videos will be much easier, while voice recognition will be greatly improved, facilitating dictation. But getting sources together will still take work.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 10 cooperation with independent developers and IT companies, including big ones.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Australian Community A Australian Community Brisbane various 40 4 Continue automation and improve bots etc. to take the load of robotic edits away from humans
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 18 Expand the admission of free formats in Commons (3D)
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 21 Importance of developing and promoting Free Open Source Software.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 24 Explore the possibility of improving machine translation.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 23 Develop tools for reading and to be guided in learning on the platform.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 19 We shouldn't look at technological aspects exclusively through a technical lense, it's important that we take a user-centric approach (e.g. deep search, individual learning environments).
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 20 Technological changes are not only a challenge to the consumption of the knowledge Wikimedia provides, but also to the creation of knowledge. We have to make sure that participating and editing remain important and visible while technologies are changing.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 21 It's not a sure thing that text-based knowledge will be outdated and other forms are superior. It's about the visibility of knowledge, different formats suit different contexts (or different regions of the world).
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 13 The Wiki technology has worked well for Wikipedia as an encylopedia but we shouldn't tie our projects to it if other technologies suit other projects better.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 35 If we want to be truly innovative, we need to think beyond the technological options that are already present today (machine learning, browser, apps, technical devices) as technology will look radically different in 15 years time. For this, our movement needs to be open to adapting to these technological changes, and willing to make changes to our current technological infrastructure as well as our general technological strategies.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 11 Wikipedia's early success was because the wiki format was easier to contribute to than a Web-1.0 website which needed domain/hosting/HTML setup. But it's harder than Web-2.0 technologies. There are now many other crowdsourced projects or social media platforms people can contribute to if they get frustrated by Wikipedia.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 12 The statement as written focuses overly specifically on machine learning and translation. This is perhaps overly specific and controversial for a high-level strategy statement. It also omits clear mention of usability.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 9 We can invest time and resources in new tests and innovations - AI, interaction, voice-reading, voice-editing, etc.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 40 We should not restrict ourselves to Augmented Reality only, but look around for other novelties. AR, together with the Internet of Things and the Virtual Reality will become the new forms of knowledge sharing. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 41 The dissemination of technological infrastructure and individual gadgets facilitates the contribution. But it enables vandalisms, too. Ket (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 24 None that wouldn’t be covered by the first of the major themes. Also, this is more of a HOW proposal, less a WHAT proposal, meaning that it describes the means necessary to achieve an end. And the end here is “more creative and productive volunteers” – which is in line with theme 1’s claim that a healthy community will lead to flourishing projects under collective care.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 27 New target groups, keeping the traffic of Wikipedia high, good user experience.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 14 Potential for high impact and a great chance on a global scale for all knowledge cultures.
Wikimedians of Korea User Group A Wikimedians of Korea User Group videocall video conference 3 2 Machine translation cannot solve everything. We should also consider how to improve human translating ability.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 25 "Augmented age" is unnecessarily narrow compared to the more general theme of "advancing with technology". The latter is rather close to what we already do.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 5 It is important, but we believe that the technology advancement will force us to work for adapting to the future, so it is not worth spending time in this right now.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 7 The content presentation in formats different than text seems fundamental to reach users other than traditional readers. (original note)
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 17 Technology is in a constant evolution. It is important for Wikimedia to take this into account and to start adapting its content to other media such as videos, audios that could be used by blind people.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 18 We have to adapt to technological changes (e.g. voice) or people will stop to access the knowledge we provide.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 33 Learn from the recent experience with the Wikimedia Foundation leadership crisis - technology is a way and a path and a set of tools, and it influences culture, community and function. It is not a reason for being. So it is important, but only in context and in service to everything else
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 88 Technology is getting more and more important. It's also getting resource-intensive. We need to "outsource" our technology needs by building a partnership of organizations needing a collaborative knowledge production platform, and evolving our current technology to be that platform.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 16 If we’re not part of the augmented age, we’ll vanish.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 17 The internet is changing with new technologies and platforms emerging (mobile trends, Siri etc). Wikipedia as a "conventional website" has to change if we want to survive.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 32 Not as important as the other themes but still crucial and should be part of the strategy to have a focus for technological developments
Australian Community A Australian Community Brisbane various 40 8 It would be good to be able to update lists and tables in Wikipedia with bots that pull data from Wikidata.
Australian Community A Australian Community Adelaide various 40 8 Automation and bots can lighten the load on human editors; this should be done where possible, to improve the editors' experience.
Bengali Community A Bengali Community [397] local wiki 6 To ensure the quality of our contents technological improvement is unavoidable. If we don't keep up with the world in terms of technology we will be left behind. We should also create awareness among the users to produce quality contents.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 5 This theme would enable us to achieve goal C (truly global movement) faster by increasing the scale of what is possible and reducing barriers to entry for new contributors from poorer regions of the world. Having more "starter" content increases the perceived value of the resource, addressing the "awareness" concern raised above, too.
WikiDonne's User Group A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/WikiDonne's User Group [398] Local wiki 10 3 Automatic monitoring system of the state of articles, user group's website, system of sending messages to all participants in the project
WikiDonne's User Group A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/WikiDonne's User Group [399] Local wiki 10 4 Event monitoring system Outreach. Okay the tool, which is, however, amended to only monitor activity on the entries recorded for each event (not as it is now, which manages all the activities of registered users among the participants)
WikiDonne's User Group A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/WikiDonne's User Group [400] Local wiki 10 5 Asana - a collaboration tool. Need to know better Phabricator
WikiDonne's User Group A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/WikiDonne's User Group [401] Local wiki 10 6 Polling system for distribution to participants
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 8 [The movement has to work in] technological upgrade, Wikipedia semantics, machine translation, local alphabets. (original note)
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 18 Wikimedia should fit the technology to enable new users, particularly those of Generation Y, to better use it.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 19 Wikipedia should invest in technology to improve the living conditions of men in terms of health and education.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 30 Technological developments in the Wikimedia movement will have to take into account the people/ community factor, it needs partnering with innovators in technology and a thoughtful handling of our resources.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 31 Advancement in technology should be means to an end and help us achieve our vision in the other four themes.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 35 Technology development may be too large a problem for it to be fully volunteer-driven.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 38 Some aspects of the Augmented Age are like double-edged sword: they can potentially bring equal and even bigger harm than benefit. For instance machine translations are still very far from perfect (and, frankly, I believe they will never be), especially in languages from different language families. However, to the people with less knowledge of languages and/or technical abilities (with less understanding of machine translations), this heavily promoted opportunity creates false sense of security, and also contributes to decrease in critical thinking and willingness to make efforts. Spiritia (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 39 The introduction of machine translations, as good as they may be, is wrong. Coverage of a variety of knowledge areas, and speed of contribution, are important, but not at the expense of quality. Writing an article is a creative process. The machine translations hinders this process ("Why shall I study a new language, if I can use a machine translation tool?") Ilikeliljon (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 36 This goal is of crucial importance, otherwise we risk lagging behind the others. Augmented reality will be a major part of the communication of tomorrow (within in the next 5 years), and it is unthinkable to leave it out of our projects. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 29 Technological developments are tremendously important to the future of this movement.
Australian Community A Australian Community Melbourne various 40 3 Rapid change in social and cultural areas requires capacity to include adequate coverage and perspectives.
Australian Community A Australian Community Australia various 40 4 MediaWiki has clearly been written by programmers, and its editing mode not appealing to non-tech contributors.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 16 There's many types of tasks: content production, content search, content delivery, and technology development. Wikimedians should produce content, not others. Also we should control how to search content within the projects. I'm fine of others get to devlivery our content and develop technology. But the first two should be controlled by the Wikimedia community.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 64 perhaps nobody can create a vast encyclopedia like Wikipedia, and those who are trying may never achieve it without sourcing from people around the world.
Meta B Meta [402] Local wiki 28 Partners that could help implement some easier way to edit rich media on wiki (e.g. directly on Commons)
Meta B Meta [403] Local wiki 65 72 Partner with other providers of on-line knowledge and cultural content and become the entry point into a linked world where various sources are accumulated and several different views of the same topic may be presented.
Meta B Meta [404] Local wiki 34 79 Cooperation with developers and academics in field of automated translation, data handling for improving Wikidata. Development of Wikimedia Commons App and other mobile apps.
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [405] Local wiki 16 7 3D modelers, visual engineers, VR developers. I would’ve hung up in 3D Wiki, what is more bedazzling than 3D encyclopedia? Semis danbe
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [406] Local wiki 36 90 Definitely no major tech companies. More transparent (and smaller) companies or non-profits who would not seek to harm the project would be better.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 634 We already have strong connections in Open Source, but sometimes we don't seem to interact with the rest of the Open Source movement too efficiently. It might be wise to see if we can have a bigger role as a leader of open source development (Firefox/Mozilla is doing a lot of this [not always successfully]).
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 49 The Public Knowledge Project could provide current content.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 639 Wolfram Research company
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 69 The main proponents of this work will likely be the partners identified in the "Engaging the knowledge ecosystem" question.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 34 University have significant potential thanks to their high-throughput of a variety of different perspectives onto the various challenges involved with machine translation, as well as expert individuals, projects and companies, whose experience, comprehension or knowledge help provide a deeper insight into the challenges and implementation of machine translation.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [407] Local wiki 5 20 Academics and educational communityː we could collaborate on designing, prototyping, testing solutions, etc. Lamiot
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [408] local wiki 9 8 We should learn from Facebook and other social websites to increase the interaction and comments in Wikimedia sites
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [409] Local wiki 18 We can learn from Facebook/other social websites to inscrease our interaction and comments in Wikimedia sites
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [410] Local wiki 18 We can learn from Facebook/other social websites to inscrease our interaction and comments in Wikimedia sites
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [411] Local wiki 23 Wordpress and Blogspot can help us in making a good editor.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 7 Technology experts and organizations that share Wikimedia's values.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 25 Technology corporations active in this space, such as Google and IBM, as well as universities.; Other than financial sponsorship, companies could support the development of the technology through programs such as Google Summer of Code, or having employees work on the development part-time or full-time. Universities could have students doing relevant coursework participate in the development as part of their respective courses.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 54 Tesla , Google and other companies might work in this field .
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 59 Google, for example. They can and do spend billions of dollars each year in this area. They are far ahead of Wikipedia in machine learning. There is no way Wikipedia will ever catch up. Now people and Google love Wikipedia. We could partner with them to give volunteer editors access to tools by Google. for example.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [412] Local wiki 27 Tech giants, academic research leaders, and graduate students could help us.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [413] Local wiki 28 Partnership is essential, because help from people proficient in AI would save a lot of our time.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [414] Local wiki 13 43 Applications designers and developpers. Olimparis
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 12 It will be very useful if we work with organizations like Google, Bing and Microsoft. We should integrate tools developed by other organizations and also improve some aspects when Wikipedia is being searched via search engine.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [415] Local wiki 2 18 We should collaborate with mobile manufacturers and service providers.
Meta B Meta [416] Local wiki 27 Collaborate with device manufacturers and makers.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [417] Telegram 30 32 Wikimedia should remain as a complement to search engines rather than trying to replace them -- The trend is working on standards that work in the most common solutions, rather than exhausting efforts and resources to add something already existing to the ecosystem.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [418] Local wiki 19 We may try to integrate Google Translate to Content Translation to quickly translate Wikipedia across languages
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [419] Local wiki 19 We may try to integrate Google Translate to Content Translation to quickly translate Wikipedia across languages
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [420] Local wiki 7 10 Develop a software like ZygoteBody, BioDigital Human, and BodyParts3D that allows browsing 3D data, and display it in virtual reality.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 12 My Brother
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 29 Např. 123D Catch vytváří efektivní nástroj na vytváření 3D objektů, které lze vytvořit z mobilních fotek. Zde by se mohla navázat spolupráce, ve smyslu začlenění jejích výstupů do projektů Wikimedia. Pokud bude potřeba nastavit nový formát 3D objektu jendat i s patřičnou organizací, nebo komisí (jako třeba komise pro HTML apod.).
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 39 Frankly, I'm not sure. I'm not too familiar with Wikimedia yet, but the more allies the better, I suppose.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 44 I don't understand this procedure. At this time I can name no others as partners.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 11 Decrease bias in Latin American content.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 15 Proposals for the development of technological advances in editing tools and use of projects should be given in a much more consensual way, without one point of view weighing on another.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 16 Changes in the interrelation of Wikipedia with other tools that allow free-licensed content are necessary.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 6 This statement was rated at the bottom as far as the group was concerned, not because we do not consider technology important --on the contrary; but because the way this statement was phrased, it seemed to the group as the focus was on things like machine learning, the translation tool and other mediawiki tech developments. Had this statement been phrased to include embracing *all* technological advancement, including tools *the community* needs for its programmatic work, then this would have definitely been one of our top priorities.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 13 Technology development is a core strength of other organizations; the community's strength is in volunteers creating content. We will be able to adopt tools made by others.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 15 We should ensure that machine translation efforts do not overwhelm native speakers, which makes those communities less healthy.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 299 Wikimedia tools understand the world around me and know what my interests are to select the right things for me at the right time.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 300 Structured data makes it nearly trivial to tie together information, media, and editors
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 301 I can find the information when I need it in the form I need it.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 302 Wikipedia presents me the content I should read. Everything I read/see is customized personally (by personality/localization/friends/etc)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 303 I can find detailed information about the interrelation between any topic, on multiple levels, with insightful auto-generated diagrams/maps/charts/fly-throughs.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 304 Our biases are now in our code :(
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 305 A danger is that the core values the Wikimedia movement (openness and transparency) become meaningless, because civic control over the process of knowledge construction is impossible and whoever writes the AIs determines reality.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 306 A danger is paid channels and walled gardens isolating people and limiting their access according to their nationality, income, and biases
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 307 Wikipedia is under threat by much more powerful, hybrid knowledge bases
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 308 Specialized AIs exist which can perform knowledge aggregation and answer extraction tasks
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 309 AI will detect and correct and protect the content, reducing, greatly the work admins, patrollers, and others
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 310 People who contribute will more easily know where the gaps are in the content, and be able to add the knowledge they can contribute much more easily
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 311 Citations will be more easy to find across languages
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 312 (almost) automatically selecting the best examples of information and media to represent a topic
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 313 They’re using their holographic data pad to make quick updates to Wikipedia 2030 using a series of ‘game-like’ edits (instead of the now archaïc wikitext-for-everything process). These edits are short, quickly accomplished tasks that improve the reliability (say adding a quick citation) and quality (adding metadata to an image) of the content in the projects. The interface, regardless of being holographic, looks nothing like what we think of in 2017 as ‘editing’.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 314 Intimidating backlogs are a thing of the past. The machines do that work. Copyright violations, vandalism, … Contributors can now spend 99% of their collective time improving and creating articles.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 315 An editor [has] unprecedented productivity in creating and reviewing articles
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 316 Natural language search.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 317 Search will be picture and voice driven, not text.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 318 People will be able to access and contribute to our projects from all online/offline platforms.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 319 The Matrix style learning, you ask what you need to know, it takes a couple of seconds and now you’ve learnt that skill/knowledge.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 320 The most parts are completely automatic:...evaluating the quality of articles’ content (with instantaneous feedback to an author of edits)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 321 editing via mobile devices is much more common than with desktop
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 322 holographic pics and 3-D printing (may be some educational model/samples) from wiki will be there
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 323 The primary role of editors will be to direct the machines and preside over controversial issues.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 324 children and teachers learn things by fixing Wikipedia, Wikidata, Wiktionary, and Wikisource, together, from any place, using any imaginable device.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 325 direct connection to sources
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 326 algorithms to verify sources and reference alignment
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 327 easy to explore and add needed content
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 328 The barriers between languages wikis will lower
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 329 Most translation tasks do not require much human intervention
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 330 For our readers this means access to every article in their language. They can find most information in the language of their choice.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 331 Manual translations may not be a thing anymore because of advanced language translation technologies.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 332 All the projects are connected, so that all contributions are shown in all languages.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 333 transparently and with explicit accountability mechanisms built in.
Australian Community A Australian Community Perth various 40 8 Improve the way in which licensing information and choices are communicated, to most fully capture as much contemporary and recent-historical material as possible.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 30 We still have important gaps and biases in the projects, strategies, decisions and many other conceptual tools that doesn't allow us to observe ourselves as a world-based movement. We still look like an American-based organization.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 31 We are an international movement.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 32 Because we need to be one body with infinite souls. We need to work with each other, especially now that our projects are opened to the other languages. We can share experience, we can ask for help on those things we don't know what/how to do. Together we can become a force that can change many things (partnering with institutions, fighting for free knowledge, changing laws)
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 33 This is closely related with our vision, therefore it's critically intertwined with the other four themes.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 34 Is important because we have much things to do for inclusivity (gaps, bias, language and cultural obstacles).
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 35 I think that this is the most important theme although it is important to ensure good community health.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 36 This intersects with the healthy communities theme as we cannot be welcoming to diversity in a world wide movement without being inviting and kind to each other and to newbies. Also with Augmented Age and Trusted Source of Knowledge - bringing on all this content and contributors will require adequate tech tools for scaling with assurance of quality.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 16 Spread the wiki way of healthy online collaboration, the prerequisite that allows growth of projects, in places where online culture is not properly cultivated.
Australian Community A Australian Community Melbourne various 40 7 What is Wikimedia's status and position within Australian online media and educational projects?
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 25 In some regions, people don't access online platforms in their local/regional language but in the former "colonial language". Whether this is a problem or not should be evaluated by the affected people themselves.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 43 This would be a theme with great impact, if the Wikimedia movement would understand itself and act like one, increasing collaboration and dialogue.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 17 Global participation is a particular strength of the Wikimedia movement; not all organizations can or want to do this.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 10 There are attractive alternatives for our content such as YT or KhanAcedemy, so we have to fast change our methods of spreading knowledge if we really want to be global
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 24 We can ensure that people all around the world have access to a shared compendium of knowledge, erasing barriers and promoting understanding and collaboration across borders.
Australian Community A Australian Community Darwin various 40 4 If we're truly global, people will find it easier to stay in touch with and belonging to the community, even when they move to new cities or countries.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 34 Efforts to reduce gaps.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 8 Embracing this goal would enable the movement to fulfill its awesome global potential.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 31 On the subject of global movement, if we have more global participants, it is easier to have a better understanding of notability and not to generate deletion problems. (Denisse Hernández)
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 42 Great impact, because the listed regions of the world are currently at a disadvantage when it comes to freely accessible knowledge.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 45 Following this theme would increase our impact a lot, reinforcing our political stance and bringing together all our different skills and resources.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 16 Emphasizing a global movement helps us have content that is diverse and broad, representing the world as a whole.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 18 Collaboration between cultures is a major global need. Some global trends are making international collaboration difficult, such as government crackdowns and an emphasis or borders, but Wikipedia is dedicated to overcoming these challenges.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 20 There is opportunity to help bring digital "have-nots" into the digital age.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 18 We need to listen to people from other places
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 26 We need to display information in a different way - videos. Reading articles in spoken languages
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 12 Encyclopedic knowledge is an westernish idea, therefore there is a problem to overcome basic cultural barriers especially for Arabic countries and provide a knowledge in other than encyclopedic formats - story telling, movies, how-to-do instructions?
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 11 We can be an example, a model to follow.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 42 Wikipedia must reach each part of the world and be available to all people. Everyone needs access to knowledge; this may be valuable information about oneself, or about the others. Ilikeliljon (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 43 In these regions (Asia, Middle East, Africa, Latin America) lives the biggest part of the world population. It is important to include them. Спасимир (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 14 Reach to knowledge, to places where it is difficult to reach today.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 39 Provide the opportunity for the peoples to represent themselves.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 40 Incidence in political discussions to support Internet access. Copyright Reform and Free Internet in all countries.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 24 Ideas for leveraging global reach could be - establishing projects that have a global reach with a wider audience and new readers

- creating technological solutions to overcome the struggles of establishing small language communities / content in different languages.

Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [421] local wiki 9 14 Wikimedia should not simply increase the basic social conditions but be a transformative force to improve access to culture for small cultures. source
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 13 Then more and more people will use Wikipedia, and the contents may be professionalised at the end. (For academic purpose). People can actually use it for academic references one day.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 14 Global movement is always one of the goals the community wants to achieve. Some regions are not familiar with Wiki right now, and supporting the groups from the mentioned regions can help us spread the knowledge.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 21 The Wikimedia movement can help push against copyright limits, unwarranted surveillance, and authoritarian leanings across the globe.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 253 The Foundation would not influence oppressive governments. Recently, Turkey blocked Wikipedia from the internet, and the petition to appeal the ban is ongoing. China is still wary about the information, such as the Tian'anmen Square massacre. Instead, the Foundation would impact just more open, developed countries.; This year, the Foundation lost its Hong Kong and Philippines chapters. ; Also, there have been cases of administration abuse occurring in smaller Wikipedia language sites. ; I don't think this theme would impact many countries except the Americas and Western Europe.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 257 single universal reference
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 261 A global movement would impact the projects, and these would impact the world. It's an indirect impact
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 266 People in underdeveloped are enabled to make the world better
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 270 Intelligent people are not that easy to suppress. We could counteract some political movements (Turkey).
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 17 As a global community we can change the world and influence legislation and politics in the movement's goals
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 276 It's impossible to know, as this "theme" is too general to have any definition. Wikipedia stay honest and stay true to its wiki roots, which entails recognizing that different cultures have different dominant practices about cultural expression. Wikipedia exists as a product of Western, pluralistic culture. It could not exist in cultures dominated by other values, whether they are statist or Islamist. It would be absurd to deny that such regimes pose an existential threat to Wikipedia.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 282 Correct systemic bias in Wikipedia, improve access
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 286 Free shared knowledge is important for progress, especially from as many varied regions as possible. By making sure Wikipedia is equally accessible and usable among all people, we create a shared history that is representative of all people.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 289 We as a community would expand globally and get more more accurate translations on topics already created and would most likely gain some region specific information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 293 I have a concern about this theme's impact on donations.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 296 Potentially very significant, but only if knowledge on these parts of the world is primarily generated by by people living in those areas who should not only be users of information which presently does not always reflect their values and understanding of their own past and potential.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 301 It would increase the usage of Wikimedia projects by those in Africa. It would change the woefully inaccurate perception that social media is all the internet has to offer.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 19 It is necessary to act in favor of preserving local knowledge in local languages, and also to allow European languages to integrate local knowledge
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 306 More easier access to free and reliable knowledge, all at one place
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 311 Immense.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 316 Wikimedia would become the go to encyclopedia for the world.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 319 enhance knowledge access to monolanguage user
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 20 Create a wiki tool for language preservation. Instead of opening Wikipedia for languages to preserve, open a new tool in the Wiki for Language Preservation
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 568 This would be a great initiative to enhance the unaware and unprivileged people with the touch of knowledge to the greater truth of their existence, life and the world.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 599 We greatly help the democratization of knowledge and education. Partially pre that we will help the people of all the world to receive information to which they previously had no access. However, due in part to the fact that we will provide the knowledge and education in a language which these people perceive "their own" - as said Nelson Mandela: "If you talk to a man in a language he understands, that goes to his head. If you speak to him in his language, that goes to his heart. " This is a strong thing about education, because makes it easy for a man to integrate the new knowledge through rational and emotional intelligence. So, more extensive, understanding of the information will help people to remember the information, and therefore to transform his way of thinking. So far we have concentrated on provision of education by the Western way with a focus to western languages; now that focus more go to new communities, we have to take advantage of additional ways to make it easier acceptance of the knowledge. If we, as a movement, provides social structures for global social change, we adapt the content and the form to a whole world. This must also include structures for global participation in the organized Wikimedia movement for people who natively speak not Western language.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 601 Provide reach to knowlegde where it had been difficult to reach. Save cultures, using their primary language and wording. Spread the wiki way of healthy online collaboration, the prerequisite that allows growth of projects, in places where online culture is not properly cultivated.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 607 The theme of global knowledge has been truly amazing to those people who actually want to know about various things like ... what happened in the past, present and future. wiki will lead the whole world in sharing knowledge and becoming equal as google search. the knowledge that share by wiki will helpful to providing information about many things.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 21 Good translation software will create knowledge. The editors will only edit the knowledge that has been created.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 608 A more global representation creates a better insight to knowledge. Our species' differences and commonalities. We will all be better for it.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 616 Very mixed feelings about this. There are basically three parts of impact: 1) scientific knowledge in these regions (e.g. universities in Asia). Those are areas that have tons of knowledge that are not used or integrated to our movement, they probably know how an encyclopaedia works but probably don't know Wikipedia, thus if we have enough resources we will probably make a significant impact by getting and sharing with the entire world a deeper information on these areas.; 2) traditional knowledge in these regions (e.g. tribal knowledge in Africa). We will have huge troubles working with these communities and integrating their knowledge. If we succeed we will make an impact by successfully integrating "Northern" encyclopaedia with "Southern" traditional knowledge. If we fail our major impact will just be another news item about ambitious white people who wasted a lot of efforts and money in Africa.; 3) scientific knowledge outside these regions (e.g. Eastern Europe). It will probably suffer a lot. Our main impact will be probably a sort of white hole there: these regions are not fully mature yet to advance without our support but they are not immature to get full support either.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 620 Wikipedia spreads knowledge and is a great educator. I truly believe that I am really smart because of Wikipedia. If we spread Wikipedia globally, it will educate the world, a very important cause.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 626 you would harness a power no-one has ever harnessed before
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 22 Wikipedia should be subdivided into sub-languages
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 628 Inclusion
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [422] Local wiki 29 Accelerate the development and coverage of areas on Wikipedia greatly deprived of such coverage
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [423] Local wiki 30 We'll be the light that shines in the Cosmos.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [424] Local wiki 75 China wants global collaboration with more countries
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 23 We need to think of virtual universities - not just an encyclopedia. On the basis of knowledge to produce an international learning system
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [425] Local wiki 5 21 We will be much better implanted in the third world, where education is not well developed. CreativeC38
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [426] Local wiki 17 38 Pictures on Commons should have a better protection against deletion requests by having more editors explaining rules to new users. The project should provide a better support for photographers.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [427] Local wiki 4 Many changes are being made in the world to make technology and information accessible to parts of the world where technology is not available (Global south). The media companies are planning huge constellations of satellites and balloons to make Internet and communications accessible to everyone.Companies think of a smartphone that will cost $ 1 to distribute in Africa. How does Wikipedia see itself fit in? Perhaps enable offline editing, perhaps connect with media companies to make Wikipedia information available and accessible as part of the service plan. These are grandiose plans, but some of them will come into effect and should be taken into account.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [428] Local wiki 5 We should think about how we can extend and expand Wikipedia to include the diversity of opinions and information, and to preserve local culture in every language? As we can see, what was not uploaded on the Internet and Wikipedia, comes to less people and slowly disappear.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 24 We need to show at the same time a number of languages - a number of narratives of one article
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 2 We should focus on becoming a truly global movement by engaging more and more communities.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 12 If we focus on this theme then the world will have a better encyclopedia.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [429] Local wiki 2 19 Following this theme will help in actual globalization of knowledge.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [430] Local wiki 8 The respect of all the five pillars of Wikipedia is to be pretended always.
Wikimedia Morocco user group A Wikimedia Morocco user group 2 If you continue projects such as Wikipedia zero, more people will be able to get the information and be aware in this world.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [431] Local wiki 9 We are here to write and defend an encyclopedia and nothing else.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [432] Local wiki 10 The community of editors sometimes seems to be missing, particularly in wikiprojects.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [433] Local wiki 28 Making Wikimedia truly global would have a great impact and would well well received, especially where information is scarce.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [434] Local wiki 31 We should encourage translation of good and notable content from English Wikipedia to big-but-not-so-big Wikipedias (such as Italian Wikipedia)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 15 Save cultures, using their primary language and wording.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [435] Local wiki 33 We can support the knowledge ecosystem by citing best sources but sometimes they are expensive and we do not have access.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [436] Local wiki 34 In the end we are probably becoming substantially a primary sources.
Meta B Meta [437] Local wiki 29 Many people in West would enjoy wiki editing but have never had the idea of doing it.
Meta B Meta [438] Local wiki 30 A few more projects are needed as the Foundation's current projects are challenged by global factors.
Meta B Meta [439] Local wiki 31 If we follow this theme, the biggest revolution in education, ever.
Meta B Meta [440] Local wiki 32 Make the culture and knowledge of Global South noticeable and more accessible.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 46 In the best version of this scenario we would encourage emancipation of these regions from the Western world.
Meta B Meta [441] Local wiki 33 Reconsider the stance of supporting only "self-starting volunteers and communities".
Meta B Meta [442] Local wiki 34 Understand what knowledge do people need in the areas where we don't have active communities yet.
Meta B Meta [443] Local wiki 35 Adjust to significant differences in infrastructure, culture, language, lifestyle, and information consumption needs.
Meta B Meta [444] Local wiki 36 Provide better translation software and infrastructure around it so that users of the smallest languages could learn encyclopedic information in their language.
Meta B Meta [445] Local wiki 37 Collaborate with ethnographers, anthropologists etc. who could help us with writing down the unique knowledge of the Global South cultures.
Meta B Meta [446] Local wiki 38 Let's do another Enlightenment, for the whole world.
Meta B Meta [447] Local wiki 34 80 We would end up with poorly- or low-managed small wikis. Must more low-managed local wikis be created to achieve diversity?
Meta B Meta [448] Local wiki 34 81 The fact that many wikis are not growing and not well managed is a problem that must be resolved.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 28 We are also not yet thinking of those who are not in the digital world - we need to make alliances and partnerships with movements for social justice and working with these folks who are not connected to learn how Wikimedia can reach them
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 29 This theme is not that important. The creation of encyclopedia is a kind of luxury for which only people in richer areas of world can afford. Therfore focusing efforts on poorer areas in hope to find volunteers willing to edit is meaningless. Wikipedias without communities of real, devoted editors will turn into bilboard with local adds or free space to keep personal files.[6]
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [449] Local wiki 4 19 By establishing a truly global movement we may establish a social globally connected society, possibly becoming a viable, desirable alternative to a increasingly polarized and unequal society. User:Joalpe
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [450] Local wiki 16 4 We should abandon from wiki globalisation and idea of ‘impacting the world’. Esp
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 25 If we aren't a truly global movement, we are excluding someone, and that will lead to our irrelevance. If we are a global movement, we’ll have additional participants who are able to assist with the other goals, e.g. shared workload
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [451] Local wiki 7 This aspiration is very attractive at a theoretical level, but hard and slow to achieve in practice, due to the existing (and future) inequalities in the world.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [452] Local wiki 9 We must get people to explore Wikipedia and not just for task-related uses. For this, communication between users, photos use and reach should be improved.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [453] Local wiki 28 The impact would be the gaps reduction, such as gender or geographical ones, which we inherited from traditional encyclopedias but, unlike these, we are aware of and we are working to reduce those gaps.
Australian Community A Australian Community Australia various 40 3 Don't get involved in political arguments. The projects are for education, and campaigning compromises this.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [454] Telegram 6 It is perfectly possible to have simultaneous translation in several languages on the Wikimedia global conferences.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [455] Telegram 13 We must have, as a movement, a minority languages preservation role, and we should appoint language ambassadors to achieve representativeness at the organizational level.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [456] Telegram 30 49 Focus our efforts to communities that we haven't yet reached don't mean imposing our criteria/history, but fundamentally listening to them. That all the voices are represented in articles.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 29 Affiliates also provide infrastructure support to help scale our shared strategic work - working as nodes in our worldwide movement network.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [457] Telegram 30 51 The movement is quite inclusive, with certain exceptions. It seems to me that it reaches quite interesting extremes trying to get people to participate regardless of their particular characteristics.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [458] Telegram 30 54 I think the movement is global, and if not is not because of the movement itself. WMF or volunteers can't avoid the social and economical inequalities existing in the world -- I just hope that this gaps will be reduced by 2030.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [459] Telegram 30 56 I think that from forms to conferences help the WMF tries to make visible that we are different but we can work together -- without it being perfect.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [460] local wiki 12 9 We have to spread knowledge not only in our neighbourhood, but also in areas of the world where it isn't so easy to create their own language versions.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 25 We need to hold conferences divided by regions
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [461] local wiki 12 10 The strength of Wikipedia is many language versions, the global focus and readers all over the world.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [462] Local wiki 8 We get a more balanced viewpoints from many languages and people
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [463] Local wiki 7 11 Seek metrics that measure global impact.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [464] Local wiki 7 12 Improve our lobbying and political outreach, contact people with power in more countries.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [465] Local wiki 7 13 More people who are not American in the top of our organisation.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [466] Local wiki 7 14 Support translations and remove multilingual barriers so that different people could communicate more easily.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 29 Inclusion for the community.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 7 We will add the voices who still don't have voice or representation in the projects, and this will allow the inclusion on the Internet era of people who are in the gaps which we haven't worked yet.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 23 Aggregating communities, overcoming language barriers, so "every single person on the planet is given free access to the sum of all human knowledge"
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 26 We would actually become able to get closer to our vision to provide free access to the sum of all human knowledge.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 27 The primary focus of the Wikimedia movement is to enable every human being to access knowledge and this theme is directly related with it. We haven't reached all part of the globe, we still need to better spread across Middle East, Africa and Asia to leverage the contributors community as well as have enough resources to serve them. Without this, we wouldn't be a truly global movement that we aspire to become.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 44 Openness to a broader variety of contributions and new forms of knowledge is essential to come closer to our vision as a movement and not limited to currently ‘not well served’ regions. If we follow this theme for all regions of the world, we might be able to increase the diversity and depth of knowledge available to all, everywhere.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 15 Including the minority can bring us new knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 254 Not as important as "healthy and inclusive" but more important than "the augmented age". Being a global NGO isn't easy as it may not please oppressive regimes, like those in Africa and the Middle East and China.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 258 as important as the others
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 262 A lot
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 267 high but not first
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 271 About the same
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 277 What are the themes, other than "A truly global movement"? That's the only "theme" I see here.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 283 More important if Wikipedia wants to grow and diversify its editors
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 287 Worldwide representation allows all people to test knowledge. More people discussing knowledge leads us closer to the truth. As Wikipedia's usage expands, its factuality increases. Increased factuality and representation leads to more users of all backgrounds excited to work towards an equally shared database of information. Access to information for all people allows everyone to share knowledge, but also gives us a first hand look at truth which allows people of all nations to understand and help each other.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 290 this might be the most important theme in the short and maybe even long term
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 294 na
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 297 Extremely important. Due to ease of access, in the developing world Wikipedia has potential to become a source of information that is far more influential than it is already elsewhere.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 302 Most important. The future of a global and neutral internet is at stake, so we need to prove its value worldwide in order to preserve its worldly nature.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 307 It is probably the most important, because there are many people out there that don't even know they can contribute, don't know how to do it, or simply find it too difficult. Loosen the ring of internal workings (the network of admins etc.) that now looks like a closed secret society, make the system more transparent to outsiders. Demistify the internal system, and make it harder for persons to gain too much power that they easily misuse, as they do right now destroying the efforts of the honest ones, and demotivate them.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 312 This comes next to healthy community
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 317 extremely important
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 320 relatively high importance, as knowledge accessibility is what wikipedia is about
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 567 This theme seems to be more important to me because it seems much engaging to the people who will be greatly helped.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 597 * Tiu ĉi temo havas grandan potencialon por multobligi atingon de nia misio por disvastigi kvalitan liberan scion al ĉiuj homoj.; * Ni povas imagi la atingo de nia scio per 2-dimensia matrico: je la akso X estas kvalito (inklude de kvalito de komunumo, teĥnologio, respekto por niaj informoj kaj engaĝiĝo kun eduka ekosistemo) kaj je la akso Y kvanto de homoj al kiuj servas nia scio. Ni povas multe peni por pligrandigi kvaliton kaj plibonigos atingojn de dekoj da elcentoj; sed ni povas (multe) peni por plibonigi tutmondecon de nia movado kaj ni pligrandigos atingojn kelkoble.; *Ankaŭ grave, fokusiĝante al komunumoj kiuj ĝis nun ne multe utiligas nian scion, ni helpos demokratigi distribuon de scion, dum fokusiĝo al aliaj temoj pligrandigos la abismon inter modernaj komunumoj kaj tiuj evoluiĝantaj.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 603 Sustainability of the movement is maintained by small projects, when the primary big projects (like english Wikipedia) are saturated in content and search for new ways to stay productive
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 606 information is most important and requirement in 21st century people ...people do not want to remember they want to search for everything.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 611 This is part of the ultimate goal, but directly working on it is likely inefficient. In my point of view all other themes can work as a catalyst for this goal. So we should stimulate this theme with smaller projects, to test the bigger projects of the other themes. If we do the rest correctly, and keep measuring and evaluating them based on this theme, then we will get there.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 614 Probably in the top-3 but ont the first one (Health for me). It is important enough so that we cannot live without it (or at least we will not be that successful) but the wording is too hard to put it higher.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 617 All of these themes are about education and learning.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 623 more important, the power of wikipedia comes from allowing random volunteers to be productive
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 629 It is the spread of wiki along with implementation
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [467] Local wiki 31 This should be the last priority, because there's too many people who don't know what Wikipedia is.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [468] Local wiki 32 We should become a free web search engine and a free web host.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [469] Local wiki 33 This should be the top priority, because exposing Wikipedia to more people around the globe is the single best way to attract greater coverage.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [470] Local wiki 36 91 This theme is the most important themes of all because it is the best way to cover more articles from around the world.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [471] Local wiki 36 114 This theme should be last in priority. If we can't get these basics right amongst the current editors who at least primarily all use the same language and have some similarity of culture, how is Wikipedia going to handle the additional complexity of hundreds of languages, cultures, ideologies, etc? User:Powertothepeople
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [472] Local wiki 12 24 This is the least important thing, because Wikimedia can't fix the world yet, and it does not have the resources to connect half of the world to the Internet, certainly not free internet. One should also be wary of exploiting free surfing in Third World countries, as happens in Angola and Morocco, where dozens of trolls exploit Wikipedia zero to share illegal files, including porn. In order to stop (or rather reduce) this phenomenon, a very large global range was required. Therefore, with experience from what happened, one has to be very careful about the subject.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 3 I think this theme is important because our movement will grow faster if we focus on this theme.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 15 Theme C is the least important of the 5 themes.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 3 Indian community should focus on all the Indian languages to make it a truly global movement. It is easier for community members from India to work for Indian languages.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 11 Focusing on all the language communities according to their needs will help all the language communities.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 14 I think Hindi Wikipedia will grow faster if we help in growing communities in other languages.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [473] Local wiki 2 20 This theme is important because the global dissemination of crucial knowledge is necessary.
Meta B Meta [474] Local wiki 34 82 This is utterly the most important of all themes. If the Foundation wants to achieve all themes, it should consider its global influence as one of top priorities. We should be less dependent on the highliest-developed areas.
Meta B Meta [475] Local wiki 34 83 If the Foundation wants to achieve theme "A", it should travel all over the world learning about different cultures, backgrounds, languages, and values.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 1 International, multilingual nature of Wikimedia project is an asset that may help to overcome current separatist tendencies in the world, by bringing knowledge to more people, so they can better understand others and the world. [1]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 2 Wikipedias in local languages should not focus on translating from English but rather create their own input to the knowledge, which should be translated to major languages, so the local voice can be heard globally.[2]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 10 Suport for emerging communities in underdeveloped countries is important, but there is the issue how to do it; if there is no good idea, all efforts, including financial will be wasted. [10]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 11 It shouldn't be a strategic goal, as putting resources for this theme artificially doesn't produce any good results, rather it should be part of some other general strategic goals and maybe achieved together with other efforts.[11]
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [476] Local wiki 4 20 The challenge is to assume a vision that in fact the sum of all knowledge in the world should adopt an inclusive practice and with groups and individuals from areas and backgrounds that are not like our current members'. To achieve this vision, the process of globalization and generalization of our community is an unavoidable condition, we need to open ourselves to the conditions of participation of those who are not in our movement so that these groups and individuals are accepted and can participate. User:Joalpe
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [477] Local wiki 16 13 In Russian Wikipedia we are too focused on our own survival in the modern world to worry about some Africa. Ivan Pozdeev
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [478] Local wiki 8 This is the least viable among the five themes, so it should have less priority.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [479] Local wiki 21 49 Perhaps this subject alone is not so viable, but all of them are viable together.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [480] Telegram 30 50 This theme is central to Latin America and our community. I believe that many of us don't agree with the movement being inclusive for a variety of reasons.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [481] Telegram 30 57 The movement is inclusive in its foundational basis, and it is strategically important to defend such characteristics in a changing environment as internet, which tends to the closed models and excessive monetization. Defending the "anyone-can-edit" openness and anonymity should be a non-negotiable principle.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [482] local wiki 12 11 This is important when we disseminate the funds, so that development is done for all languages.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [483] local wiki 12 12 Not important for everyone to feel to be part of an international community.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [484] Local wiki 10 Important. Emerging communities will be expanded and more active in the global view in the future
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [485] Local wiki 7 15 Don't stop doing things, but change how we do things.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [486] Local wiki 7 16 Allow more personalization for readers, allow themselves to improve their UX.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 37 There is nothing that we are doing today would get stopped if we focus on this theme. But there might be some alternation in programmatic requirements or certain areas of our movement in order to achieve this, i.e. we have to consider the needs and issues of those communities while designing programs/projects and managing the increase in budget if required.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 38 Is an issue we never have to stop.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 39 We might need to stop laying too much stress on conferences like Wikimania and focus more on regional conferences
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 40 We will expand our partnerships within and outside of our movement so that more people who are good at doing things like technology, grants, talent acquisition, so that more folks can fill those spaces.
Australian Community A Australian Community Melbourne various 40 6 Understanding where Australia sits (as far as the Movement is concerned): in Oceania? Asia? Developing? Emerging? Still part of the British Empire? Australasia? What is our perceived geopolitical context?
Australian Community A Australian Community Melbourne various 40 8 Lack of clear relationships with neighbouring countries. Australian Wikimedians should have more of a relationship with neighbouring countries
Australian Community A Australian Community Sydney various 40 8 The importance of understanding global/regional miscommunication. For national and regional voices to be adequately represented in the global movement, and understanding the trade-offs that come with this.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [487] local wiki 9 9 We should import (translate) content from small Wikipedias to big Wikipedias, for better coverage and to fight cultural colonialism.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 16 We should stop focusing on English Wikipedia only. Right now the Foundation is spend way too much time and money and resources for the development of the English Wikipedia. Some other groups need resources as well.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 255 Stop supporting oppressive government. Boycott oppressive governments. Defund unneeded chapters and determine whether creating chapters around the world is necessary.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 259 stop anonymous editing of non politiical/journalistic/activistic articles
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 263 We would stop building luxury skyscrapers next to similar skyscrapers. We would stop changing out 8-month iPhones for new ones.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 268 be harder on vandals and scooll scribbling
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 272 When more people will have access to Wikipedia more people will suport it financially. Because of that it is not necessary to scale back anything at all.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 278 Yes, focusing on honestly would entail stopping pandering to Islamicism which means to enslave all humans to a particular subset of human's idea of God, and entails stopping calling racist any and every honest effort to understand Islam.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 284 Wikipedia Education Foundation needs to stop limiting its support only to North America
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 291 I don't think we have to stop doing anything we are already doing just hold off on less important future projects
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 298 A difficult one, but if wikipedia is to b e truly relevant to user in presently under-represented regions it needs to discourage/disincentivise people from outside of a region from writing about it. Only in this way will Wkikpedia become truly useful and relevant in areas of present low penetration.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 303 We need to re-prioritize what makes the front page in terms of news. Too often do I see elections being overshadowed by sports.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 308 This comment concerns mostly Wikimedia. Be more flexible as far as photography goes. People are willing to contribute photo material but some of them will ask for basic respect concerning rights. It is hard to make good photos and it is unacceptable for some to give them away just for others to make profit out of them, while the photographer (may) live in poverty. There is a need for just a little bit more space for basic copyright respect. Change and loosen a bit the copyright policy (don't treat to delete work that the uploader signed as copyrighted but willingly contributed for educational - and not for commercial - purpose) so that these users can contribute their professional work of art in a way that keeps it safe from misuse. It is hard to understand why would a free encyclopedia insist on commercial use of all its material.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 313 Stop restricting the growth of the number of chapters, stop restricting the growth of chapters, reduce the size of the central organization
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 318 i have no idea.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 321 Stop merging communities of wikipedia even if they speak same language, as people living under different political environment might not actually understand the way how people on the other side describe the world.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 575 Yes..that's proper knowledge without the false claims
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 600 Build emotional intelligence / soft skills of new area contributors, before editing skills.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 605 I don't think that
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 615 Supporting initiatives in Global North (basically Europe, US, Canada, Oceania)? I would prefer not to see this happen. These regions are still far from being fully covered, and some European countries require significant attention.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 621 Yes. I was banned from editing Wikipedia for 4 months, and it was awful. While Wikipedia is great, this was outrageous. Stop banning users from editing unless you have a legitimate reason please.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 625 not really
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 627 Editing without feedback
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [488] Local wiki 13 15 A Wiki in all languages and dialects is not possible because of the reality of life of some tribes (lack of internet, electricity).
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [489] Local wiki 13 16 Oral history as a source does not improve the quality of Wikimedia projets.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [490] Local wiki 2 21 Actual access to different communities at the international level.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [491] Local wiki 5 In order to become a truly global movement we should absolutely and showily invest more resources in emerging countries and less in rich countries.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [492] Local wiki 11 We need to be more welcoming towards new users, by changing the mentality of experienced users.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [493] Local wiki 12 We should remember that Wikiquette is a pillar, and - while some mistakes can be pardoned - we have to grant a relaxed working environment for our volunteers, so serious and repeated violations cannot be tolerated.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [494] Local wiki 13 Users should stop talking by themselves and start really discussing.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [495] Local wiki 14 Wikipedia should become an enjoyable and fun place again. We are here to write an encyclopedia, but it should be also a good social experience.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [496] Local wiki 29 Failed projects like Wikinews should not receive resources and should be closed.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [497] Local wiki 30 We should not waste human and financial resources on very minor projects.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [498] Local wiki 36 Consensus should be based on in-depth study of sources.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [499] Local wiki 42 Nearly 10% of personal attacks seem to come from experienced users: in order to have a more welcoming community we need to stop this.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [500] Local wiki 66 Every wiki project is important and precious, has value and positive sides. We should not concentrate all our resources on some projects and abandon the others. We should not close projects but understand what can be improved. (Samuele2002)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [501] Local wiki 67 Resources are scarce. (Nicolabel)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [502] Local wiki 73 90 Flagged Revisions should be adopted as in German Wikipedia. (Xinstalker)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [503] Local wiki 73 91 We need to deal better with innovation in the platforms. Many good ideas didn't succeed because they weren't handled in a good way or because of the opposition of the community (e.g. visual editor). As wikipedians we need to more active and proactive in asking for technological changes taking into account the needs of new users. Developers need to be able to discuss and realize propals in a short time. (Marcok)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [504] Local wiki 73 97 We should import (translate) content from small Wikipedias to big Wikipedias to fight cultural colonialism. (Marcok)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [505] Local wiki 73 98 If we want a significant impact on global knowledge WMF should spend at least half its budget in developing countries. Remaining money would be enough for the others. (Marcok)
Meta B Meta [506] Local wiki 39 Reduce various projects that only target content addition in languages that already have an active community, like GLAM and Wikipedian-in-Residence projects.
Meta B Meta [507] Local wiki 40 Reduce the relative weight of projects that address problems that are irrelevant for small or not-yet-existing communities, like "anti-harassment" initiatives
Meta B Meta [508] Local wiki 34 84 Harassment and availability of art images are not a priority for the greatest majority of Wikipedias' communities.
Meta B Meta [509] Local wiki 34 85 English Wikipedia community has been using the non-free content criteria to anglicize multimedia content on non-English topics. Editors should stop using "fair use" rules and rules limiting non-free content to westernize or anglicize multimedia content, especially images.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [510] Local wiki 4 21 To became a truly global movement we need to establish a system of parity in decision-making positions for editors from rich and poor countries. This may create uncertainty in the projects, however. User:Joalpe
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [511] Local wiki 27 To be truly global, we must combat localism (as the establishment of peculiar norms according to language versions) -- There should be no excluded topics for language reasons, because we have to recieve (and be able to distribute) all knowledge.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [512] Local wiki 17 48 To be more global and incorporate knowledge from all over the world, we have to be less local. Projects like Wikisource and others should be multilingual as Wikimedia Commons.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [513] Telegram 1 User retention metrics can not be only for English projects, because it is a biased view. This causes many people to find difficult to identify with the Wikimedia achievements because these appear to be exclusively those of English speakers.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [514] Telegram 3 Today, those who speak better English in the movement have more representativeness and greater privileges than the others. This has to be changed.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [515] Telegram 4 It is pretty unfair that the information on meta has to be first published in English to be translated to other languages later.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [516] Telegram 7 English remains as a de facto language because that is comfortable for many First World participants who are in a privileged position.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [517] Telegram 9 There must also be a greater effort from the WMF staff to speak plain and simple English, so all those who speak medium English can understand without feeling intimidated. While it is understandable that the language of communication is the English, this attitude does not help those who do not have English proficient skills.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [518] Telegram 10 Even when affiliates make the effort to request grants in English, the WMF staff sometimes has criticized the writing, especially for being "too metaphorical".
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [519] Telegram 11 Although English Wikipedia is the most developed one, it is a mistake to assume that all of its contents are superior to other languages.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [520] Telegram 30 52 There is a very strong implicit exclusion for different reasons, mainly for linguistical and technical skills (we assume that we all understand the intricacies of wiki navigation). Other are more obvious issues, such as discrimination against women or minorities. This movement is anglo/eurocentric, white, masculine, and people with high levels of digital literacy.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [521] Telegram 30 55 I don't share the idea that exclusions are due to reasons unrelated to the movement. In my experience discrimination is permanent and is not the fault of a group of "rotten apples". The most paradigmatic case is the gender gap. Wikipedia is sexist and in many occasions -not always- misogynistic.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [522] Telegram 30 59 Just as English can be an enabler of a great movement and an effective vehicle of communication, it can also be a big reason of participation's exclusion/inhibition, in both face-to-face and online events.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [523] Telegram 30 61 I also consider as a priority to create a program of equity promotion in the Wikimedia movement. I have done a list of how many women and men have leadership roles in organizations. As you can see, much remains to be done.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [524] Local wiki 9 We may have to spend less on technical improvements.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [525] Local wiki 7 17 Be more international, less US-centric.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 27 Don't reinvent the wheel: it is necessary to improve and adapt the wheel.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 28 Generate / share documentation.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 32 Strive for balance between established and new points of view.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 30 Share the realities of each country.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 33 Look for new, unreached niches for active inclusion.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 36 Reduce language barriers: hire translators or volunteers.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 38 To demand greater efforts in the projects to confront gaps of lack of (geographical, gender, age, idiomatic) diversity.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 41 Flexibilize criteria for the use of oral sources.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 34 Breaking border and language barriers, especially at international meetings.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 35 Aim for young age readership
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 36 Be fully open
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 37 Go beyond the elitist contributor, target the not yet served populations.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 124 Focusing on features that are only useable by a small segment of our user base.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 13 Political issues - especially in countries like Sudan, Ukraine or Russia creates problems that covering themes which are taboos for local governments may end up in blocking - just as it happened in Turkey; so a trade-off of omitting some content is need in order to reach such places or we must be ready to leave these places in order to stay 100% NPOV
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 13 We can stop trying to "help". Help doesnt work - we can show and teach, but not "nursing" all the time. We can advise, but we dont have time to wait for the slowest vessel in the convoy. Whoever want to be part of it, should keep up to the pace. --Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 18 Build emotional intelligence / soft skills of new area contributors, before editing skills.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 9 Lack of awareness of Wikipedia is still a big problem in many regions. If we want the movement to fulfill the promise of its potential, this goal seems critically important.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 10 This is important: I want to see knowledge be a "commons," not a commodity restricted to the elite.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 44 To become a global movement, I think we need also collaborate close to communities that have our same vision.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 57 Different communities within the movement should be partnering with each other and the internal capacities for sharing and learning from each other should be greatly increased.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 58 Instead of focusing on external partners, we should focus on the need of appropriate internal structures.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 197 To go beyond the "knowledge anyone can edit", we need to change mindsets around "Who has the right to write knowledge down". This means offering training, and making sure educational systems modify their approaches to knowledge to enable every individual to see themselves a knowledge generators.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 59 United Nations, Mozilla (who's already active in some of these regions)
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 56 Governments, Open Knowledge, humanitarian aid organizations.
Wikimedia Morocco user group A Wikimedia Morocco user group 4 Collaborate with institutions and governments that make efforts to add access to Internet. Joint work can be done to make Kiwix and Wikipedia zero spread all around the world, especially in our continent. Africa.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 43 We have seen Wikipedia Zero, being vital in some parts of the globe to disseminate the Wikimedia projects. Areas in Africa and Latin America might also be benefited with Wikipedia Zero, where there has not been any efforts to spread Wikimedia projects. Apart from telecom service providers, schools or educational institutions, NGOs might be involved in these efforts. So we can consider to partner with them.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 45 We should partner with other organizations and institutions working to preserve linguistic diversity.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 9 Working with organizations devoted to inclusion in various fields: indigenous, women, migrants, etc.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 20 Work together with missions who already have good work there. Train them first and make them feel everything is for the human, not wiki metrics, they can be our ambassadors
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 43 Involve national authorities, education/training sector (high schools, colleges and universities), publishing sector (journalists, publishers, and writers), telecommunications sector (mobile telephony, Internet) and CSOs (Civil Society Organizations).
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 15 Social media and platforms.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 6 Good machine translation system but always screened finally by humans feeling well their mother tongues is the key for expanding Wikipedias in less popular languages; we need better machine translations.[6]
Bengali Community B Bengali Community [526] local wiki 7 7 Wikipedia has already proved the trustworthiness of it's contents now it's time to make sure that evry human being with necessary device can access our contents.
Bengali Community B Bengali Community [527] local wiki 7 8 If we can inform everyone about the importance and usability of Wikimedia projects, then the knowledge discrimination will be greatly reduced.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 256 Fighting oppression and suppression of information. Also, activism and advocacy are needed.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 264 Having different social groups in the projects doesn't mean that there should be ghettos. A truly global movement should be integrated, not segregated.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 269 local participation
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 273 There should be something like training courses to learn to circumvent government censorhip (China, Turkey)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 279 What the hell is this, Linked In?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 288 Preservation of all people's history is important for the most accurate information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 292 try to get more minorities in the world to use wikipedia so we can have as close to full cultural diversity as possible
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 295 My question is, are we in danger of getting ahead of donors on this issue? ; Do we have research into current donors' motivations? Do donors in the countries where we have the most financial backing understand that the are supporting efforts elsewhere? Most people I know who donate do so because they use the encyclopedia and want to improve it—primarily for themselves. They are unaware of our international efforts. I'm not saying donors in North America and Europe will object to transferring their dollars and Euros to other parts of the world. But there might be a point, a percentage of expenditures, beyond which they would object, and it seems like an issue we need to anticipate and take seriously. This could be an issue our critics might exploit, and we don't want our support base to feel like they've been the victims of a bait-and-switch.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 299 It needs to encourage locals to generate local content that is relevant to their region and takes a local perspective.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 304 We should also aim to work with Amerindian groups, especially in the Amazon. They have exclusive books about the local flora that would be prime WikiBooks material.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 309 Please, do all that is possible to stop the internal misuse by people with bad intentions, such as anarchists, leftsist, faschists and other element destructive for society. Especially the topics history and geography are littered with personal unscientific views and "alternative" politics that do harm local communities. Even the discussions in such themes hurt many people. (In talk pages everybody is allowed to say what they believe is right but the rule by end is that who yells harder wins, or the issue remains unsettled and confusing.) Too much freedom is a curse. Develop more efficient ways to filter the destructive out, and limit their ability to alter healthy content with speculative one, with intention to cause divisions and internal conflicts, edit wars etc. There are many (of these from the dark side :) that reached admin level, just by being tricky and more clever than the ones that confront their destructive views. I believe there is a war raging inside Wikipedia between good and evil. The lines must be kept and clearly drawn. Wikipedia must describe evil, but also warn of consequences. It is unacceptable that this source become a channel of destructive views.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 314 Work towards having a local organization in every country in the world, and in every State in the US, for example. Follow the lead by Amical: a local organization that actually organizes the majority of Catalan speaking editors. Don't do anything in SF what can be done by a local organization.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 322 Increase the visibility of incubator.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 569 To convey people about the presence of itself through different media and et cetera
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 598 Mi aldonos mian personan sperton: Mi laboras (aŭ almenaŭ estas en kontakto) en vikimedia movado en kelkaj lingvoj. Ĉiam kiam mi provas kuraĝigi homojn al partopreno en internacia movado mi ricevas respondon, ke tio estas "tiu anlgalingva komunumo" kaj homoj bezonas transiri la baron de la fremda lingvo. Specife forta tio estas rilate al internaciaj / regionaj renkontiĝoj. Pluraj homoj diris al mi, ke ili pripensus veni al konferenco, se ĝi estus en lingvo pli facila por ili ol estas la angla. Mi mem, kvankam kapablas paroli en la angla, sentas min ne komforta parolante tiun lingvon kaj mi jam evitis laboron en iu strukturoj, ekz. la Lingva Komisiono, ankaŭ pro tiu kialo.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 602 Satellites or other ways to achieve internet reach over large underpopulated areas
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 610 I'm missing accessibility in this picture. It's about people of skill, ability, capability AND location.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 612 * Add that this will not be to the detriment of other areas. It is very important that we don't want to see other areas lose chances they have now.; * Ideally one can also integrate other diversities that are not yet covered, especially language diversity
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 618 N/a
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 622 increase support for wikipedia pages in different languages to be interlinked
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 630 More communication
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [528] Local wiki 34 Make policies like OR more friendly to regions where oral tradition is much stronger than any publication coverage.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [529] Local wiki 35 Encourage editors in the Indian Subcontinent to create articles in their native languages.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [530] Local wiki 36 Don't omit relevant geographic links so that our content could be more integrated.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [531] Local wiki 83 We should look into revisiting the oral citations project
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [532] Local wiki 32 Broaden the dissemination of knowledge to low awareness regions in order to make knowledge and make it accessible worldwide. Zaxiphyvaxe
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [533] Local wiki 17 39 The Content Translation Tool is very important. It should be improved. That would improve the communication between the different languages of the world.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [534] Local wiki 18 45 A big step forward for my needs as a technician working internationally could be a visual encyclopedia, such as the visual dictionary by Merriam Webster (http://www.visualdictionaryonline.com). We should have this new Wikimedia project in many different languages.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 4 I don’t think we need to add anything else into in this theme.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [535] Local wiki 2 22 Collaborations and negotiations at the international level.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [536] Local wiki 6 Some users are scared by empty articles: with help from Wiktionary and Wikidata articles from major Wikipedias could me imported on minor Wikipedias, then encouraging people to translate.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [537] Local wiki 32 Translation tool is complex and should be improved.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [538] Local wiki 73 92 Mobile devices are an opportunity and not a threat, if we as a community are ready to face the challenge. (Marcok)
Meta B Meta [539] Local wiki 41 Create a collaborative global, multilingual effort to identify not just knowledge, but how to ask questions and ways of asking questions.
Meta B Meta [540] Local wiki 42 Provide private read-only access to Wikimedia projects with Tor Hidden Service, I2P Eepsite or InterPlanetary File System, which could help us to avoid the establishment of countries' borders on the Internet.
Meta B Meta [541] Local wiki 34 86 Allow people to write more than one article on a given topic on a given wiki in order to allow people to write on various POVs.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [542] Local wiki 4 22 The movements globalization process should be accompanied by deep institutionalization of democracy. We need to foment a diverse, polycentric community for deliberative processes incorporating smart mechanisms for the production of an e-democracy system. User:Joalpe
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [543] Local wiki 16 32 The geographical distribution is wrong − the global movement is not about continents, its about rare languages and endangered cultures. Hunu
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [544] Local wiki 16 33 The quality of Wikipedia as an encyclopedia is priority. More users means a better project, while ‘cultural and linguistic diversity’ is a secondary goal. 192749н47
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [545] Local wiki 16 34 I don’t think it is a goal of Wikimedia movement to support endangered languages, especially if all they are writing about are local customs. MBH
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [546] Local wiki 16 35 Professional chauvinism and deeming writing about local customs as ‘unimportant’ is unacceptable in international encyclopedia which strives for having the sum of human knowledge in it, not having ‘Theory of relativity’ translated in as many languages as possible. Ле Лой
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [547] Telegram 8 We should establish an "English Friendly Policy" which recommends speakers at the movement conferences to speak slowly, not using local words, gags and jokes and explaining the complex concepts.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [548] Telegram 12 If we want to improve the language exchange, we need to improve the translation tool, which is currently infamous.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [549] Telegram 30 53 It is necessary the WMF to make a differentiation in which different types of actions and efforts are made in certain parts of the world rather than others -- not in a "colonialist" (global north/south) way, but something it comes from the roots.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [550] Telegram 30 60 We should replicate the on-screen transcription in real time used on international conferences, also transcriptions, etherpads or simultaneous translation into four or five languages.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [551] Local wiki 24 We can incorporate many cultures' wisdom and knowledges into Wikipedia by being open, humble and acquisitive.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [552] Local wiki 7 18 Run empiric experiments to find out whether specific strategies work.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [553] Local wiki 7 19 There's a bias in our approach towards various languages - stop caring about our own.
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [554] Local wiki 8 7 There is an important connection between this theme and "The Augmented Age" theme, namely with regards to multi-language unification. As the technology of machine translation and understanding progresses it may well be possible to automatically compare those articles and provide tools that would allow volunteers who do not share a common language to collaborate in developing a consensus interlingual article. agr
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [555] Local wiki 8 8 The foundation should consult more on the community before doing some of the developments. i.e. ideas should come from community (IRC)
Wikimedia Commons B Wikimedia Commons [556] Local wiki 8 9 machine learning: statistical method does not solve everything. what you get is a false positive rate and a false negative rate, although by a lot of training they could be reduced to a tiny rate (IRC)
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 8 It is one of the most important themes since listening to all non-represented voices we can build a better encyclopedia for everyone.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 198 We need to avoid that if we want to healthily contribute to the larger information ecosystem, especially in parts of the world that don't have thriving publishing ecosystems.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 93 Wikipedia awareness will be high across all countries and it will include sections full of rich oral history for all to consume.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 9 The production of a diverse knowledge is subject to the possibility that (almost) all participate, or at least have the possibility to participate. (original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 10 If Wikipedia is only based in the North, it is not open knowledge and much remains to be done. (original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 11 Make room for contributions related to local contexts. Free and inclusive knowledge focused on accessibility in languages and support for disabled people.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 12 It is important that Wikipedia make room for cultural diversity of the world. This can only be achieved with a truly diverse group in the editing work. It is important in the movement legitimacy.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 13 A truly global movement allows, but doesn't ensure, the generation of specific local content that even foreign experts may not know.(original note)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 94 Education will happen largely online. Wikipedia will be source of truth behind it.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 28 The theme is important because it suggests a dynamic, progressive and non-static movement.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 29 Developing countries are not sufficiently represented within the movement; the theme presupposes that they will be better represented.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 30 The topic is important because it fits into the vision of Wikimedia.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 31 The theme fits perfectly with the universal principle of data diffusion.
Wikimedia Community User Group Turkey (WMTR) A Cycle 2/Turkish Wikipedia email email 35 6 It is of utmost importance to ensure that everywhere in the world people from all socio-economic status will reach free knowledge in every language.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 26 The importance of this theme directly arises from our vision: A world in which every single human being can freely share in the sum of all knowledge.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 27 This theme has the biggest potential impact on the world.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 28 The fact that we have been trying to reach out to new regions with little success casts doubt on the assumption that we can have substantial leverage in this field in the next 10-15 years.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 47 Quite important.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 48 It is an important theme – being truly global and working together will be always better than a fragment chart of national organizations.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 49 Very important, if being expanded to collaborative actions and mutual learning across the world, south and north, west and east.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 50 Very important
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 150 Lack of Wikipedia in many languages is due to lack of internet presence in that language. More content in the language in other sites would aid Wikipedia growth. There’s a question: do we wait? Do we push for more internet culture in other languages? We may also partner with organizations that help the growth of internet usage in different languages: encourages people to blog, news websites to start in different languages, localize social networks, etc. (And if there are no such organizations, we can start them!)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 161 Not just about consuming, but how people contribute. Particularly non-written languages, or where access to the internet is challenging, figuring out novel ways to get folks from all over to contribute. Particularly in ways that don’t rely on internet access.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 162 Internet is textual. How do we manage access to people who don’t have access to text or non-written languages?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 196 Language matters a lot. Hard to encapsulate anything in a single paragraph. It’s a perpetuation of the status quo. True disruption comes down to facing the challenge - there are people for whom our projects aren’t accessible and we need to make it accessible to them.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 19 Satellites or other ways to achieve internet reach over large underpopulated areas
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 193 Our core is aging. As people get older and live longer, it has to go beyond accessibility too.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 128 The phrase “sum of all knowledge” is often interpreted in the enlightenment mindset. There’s an assumption that any small group of individuals could produce that if they worked hard enough. That’s not true. The sum of all knowledge can only be created by the sum of all people.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 194 talking about inter-dependencies - this goes into Communities too. Frame of truly global is not just global. If we mean everyone everywhere, then it goes beyond this.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 14 It coincides with the idea and spirit of Wikimedia movement - everyone can be part of it.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 130 Audio talk pages. Connect viscerally with people wherever they are. Terms like global north/south will disappear. People will want to be connected to the point that they want to hear what each other sounds like.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 55 It will be a huge challenge for the movement, as we're currently phrasing the current identify of the movement. These regions will / might have a different understanding of it, so we might end up just repeating a "digital colonization" process.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 129 More a congress of knowledge than an archive of knowledge. Living, breathing. There is a bias towards printed material. Let’s be radical about the formats of knowledge. Maybe oral history.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 148 “We’ll make space for new contributions that reflect these regions (references, citations, and more)” - particularly the parenthetical - is very Wikipedia-centric. In order to be welcoming, it may be the case that Wikipedia isn’t necessarily the place where there are new joiners - it may be new products or sites.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 149 The movement is strong beyond Wikipedia and leverages other, complementary projects to support the world’s learning and documenting histories that are kept in other types of sources, such as oral histories, paintings, and other expression.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 151 We can’t be thinking only about us, we have to rethink some of our commitments, and pay attention to the fights others are fighting for getting people access. We need to ask whether Wikipedia is the right vehicle for things like oral citations, low connectivity, and so on?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 152 Is Wikipedia even the right format to be getting information? Long form is valuable in many contexts, and it’s the wrong in other contexts.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 33 Institutional partnerships is a good way to pursue the global community theme.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 158 The project(s) makes people able to connect instantly. The long form encyclopedia may be appropriate, using the analogy of it being something that people circle and discuss.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 181 The "identity" is Wikimedia but free knowledge as a concept. We need to inherently value free knowledge, not necessary Wikimedia. IF that’s true, does our work continue to focus on Wikipedia and other free knowledge projects? Do we move onto hosting free knowledge in other ways?
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 37 Generate a Wikimedia project focused on traditional knowledge to link it to other Wikimedia projects.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 159 Wikipedia literacy about who creates it, what’s behind it, what’s a good article, the human connection and humanity is all pretty crucial.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 126 Our mission is best served by providing sufficient coverage of medical topics in all languages than by focusing in extremely in-depth coverage of medical conditions.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 13 Real globalisation means the willingness to invest in the development of local Wikimedia-organisations. These will be mainly involved in GLAM and Education programmes in their countries, as this cannot be realised in a centralised approach.
Wikimedians of Korea User Group A Wikimedians of Korea User Group videocall video conference 3 6 Thesedays, all of us, esepcially Koreans, count on only English Wikipedia, because it is so huge. Local wikis like Korean Wikipedia would grow when it strengthen its own capability. Localization could be one of solustions. For example, we can collect informations about Korean local plants and monuments in cooperation with local history researchers. We don't need to develop partnership with only governments but also private organizations.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 25 We must improve communicationally.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 40 Encourage ambassadors in countries where there are no affiliates.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 180 In general increasing awareness is a *must*. Having the guts to say that we're going to increase awareness. adding more about the shared value of contributing.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 51 It might benefit the argument if it was backed with strong data/evidence. Is there evidence for the claim that people in the above-mentioned regions of the world need different products than people in the rest of the world? If so, please explain.
Australian Community A Australian Community Australia various 40 6 More is required in Latin America; books are expensive there and not so easily obtainable, so a digital knowledge system is even more important.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 26 [More] multilateral events.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 125 This describes a characteristic of how our community should act, its not framed in a direction at the moment: the question of how we do this, and what kinds of core tooling we use to maintain that focus. Any of the other themes should include a component of going in this direction: several of them are missing explicit calls on this diversity of engagement.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 132 We have mapped people back into their internet speed rather than helping them overcome that. FB/IG are giving them the full experience; they’re full members regardless of their device/internet speed. It’s something really powerful because people relate to one instagram community around the world rather than one part of it. We’ve let ourselves down on by having this highly stratified set of membership.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 133 People can create their own space / language wiki / group. But that causes some wikis or communities to seem more important / noble / complete.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 143 “Regions/cultures” are interesting. People who have been excluded aren’t really regions; e.g. diaspora of Nigerians in the US. Cultural flows rather than regional flows. Also true for socio-economic strata, regardless of the region.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 144 “Who is marginalized today” isn’t just a discrete geographical thing.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 145 The first draft of this was very PC and people in Africa had no idea what it was about. The people we’re talking about should be the ones writing about this. We can only write from that perspective so well.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 147 There are groups that we have underserved and have been marginalized for various reasons today. Those groups don’t exactly map into just regions; we might be thinking in terms of regions because that’s how we organize today offline. But there are many ways to intersect, slice and dice these various groups. To be a truly global movement, there is a balance we need to strike between what we can do (i.e. where we want to focus our attention and resources) and how inclusive we can be.
Wikimedians of Korea User Group A Wikimedians of Korea User Group videocall video conference 3 5 Western social system or freedom is not common all over the world. Developing or underdeveloped contries fall behind in copyright laws, nonprofit activities and freedom of speech. People from developed countries should understand this. In addtion, we should understand different cultures, and the Foundation should reflect this when making decision. For example, many Koreans are not used to active and continuous discusion or speach, due to history and education.
Australian Community A Australian Community Australia various 40 7 The WMF needs to broaden it's global footprint to counter the perception it is 'American' cultural imperialism. It should do this by having a greater percentage of employees outside the USA and establishing data centers outside the USA.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 35 Diagnosis of countries/groups to move towards a global movement.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 41 As the number or size of the communities will grow, so the number of affiliates. This might result in more complications or inter-affiliate issues, i.e. non-cooperative relation, lack of trust or communication, geographic rivalry etc. As a movement, we need to address these issues while we welcome and include more communities or affiliates.
Affiliation Committee A Affiliations Committee virtual video call 7 42 We must not only give directions, write good guidelines, but be present (not invasive) in each our affiliates "life", knowing their needs and problems.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 135 Hoping for a more permeable movement. If machines translate everything we lose the cultural nuances. Imagine a world where being a community member may be annotating knowledge, celebrating cultural differences while still having a common base
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 9 Revise what it means to “Make Space” - “Make space” is not universal terminology, and does not translate well. Small voices in a big global community get lost, we should enable all to participate. This means not identifying regions, but identifying marginalized communities all over the world.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 33 Accessibility issues for disabled people must be improved. Images should have a description which can be used for audio formats, and different font sizes, image formats, etc. (Denisse Hernández)
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 30 To become a truly global movement we have to find ways to listen also to the quiet voices.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 22 The theme is worded to emphasize developing countries, but we should not leave behind people in rural areas in developed countries, who often also lack access to quality education and the opportunities that come with it.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 142 The “we” feels exclusionary, e.g. “we will turn our attention to…”. Move to inclusive we.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 146 In cycle 1, a keyword was “information justice”. It was about removing all barriers in participating. Not just region and class, but also age, disability.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 157 Users should be able to keep in touch with people everywhere around the world. They should be able to talk to them in real time and understand their nuances and demystify their otherness.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 163 Solve social issues with communities to open them to the idea of having different ways to share knowledge.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 164 Involve local people, not foreign people to describe things, or define what is important. Have other cultures to perceive a culture as equal.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 167 We will want to welcome all people, love the focus on VIBRANCY and INCLUSIVITY.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 175 partnering with regions "we have not yet served well enough" - some of them we haven't served at all. We need to be honest with our progress and recognise that we've missed some people out.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 183 Breaking down the barriers of isolationism - Reforming policies of the more prominent communities, facilitate access for all people, to all sources of knowledge
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 190 Regional aspect could change - don’t limit to these geographies.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 192 Maybe it should talk to segments not served - to broaden and capture those without privilege (less socio-economic, impairments, illiteracy, etc.).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 195 We shouldn’t limit ourselves with just geographies. Also literacy rates, genders, races being oppressed, etc. Such a wide array of things.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 44 We should support the equal access to our resources. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 42 Encourage experience sharing among communities in terms of editing practice and organizational standard
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 41 Involve national/local authorities.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 53 I would suggest to not start every sentence with "we". This sounds more like "us" and "them" than like a truly global movement.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 134 Because English is so ubiquitous, people are sometimes told to participate in their local language even though it may not be what they want to contribute in.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 166 Folks should get the information in their language without the laborious nature of translation from English.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 169 Is Wikimedia a place for language preservation? We can help with cultural identity.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 187 Most covered - we will see that resources are there - their language, their environments. One single source of truth that is translated out. One meta article that is fed into many language speakers. People in their languages can contribute much easier. Goes far beyond language. When we consider interfaces, there is a huge gap we have to overcome.
Wikimedia Morocco user group A Wikimedia Morocco user group 3 Not only accessing to Wikipedia is a goal, but also to have the content available in a maximum of the languages of the world. It is important to add it to the theme to make access stronger. Being able to browse Wikipedia zero, and then find that everything is just in English is useless.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 165 Support leadership in these areas to collaboratively bring forth participation.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 191 This discussion seems very broad. You can forget illiterates in US (south for example). We don’t want to expand into new countries but we have to be careful about gender and class. We don’t want to perpetuate the same issues.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 178 We should emphasise capacity development more. It can be viewed in terms of taking initiative. People can follow initiative and grow that. With penetration increasing, more people are coming online and don’t know how to use the smart phones. Need more respected orgs and movements away from private sector and government to lead this, and people will follow.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 172 It doesn't talk about affiliates, only "partners". It doesn't explicitly name the infrastructures.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 176 Previous WMF-led programs in India and Brazil didn’t work and created large problems for our existing ocmmunities. How do we actually build these communities?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 186 We need ‘smarter/more’ meetups - not defaulting to English. Maybe much less content if there’s a restriction that it has to be in 20 languages. In person meetups are so critical for shared understanding.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 131 Connects to the idea of us vs. them. Personal connection to Wikipedia; it’s where people go to learn and we want to contribute to that. Even more apparent in 2030
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 137 There’s less soloing; you have a sense of your space and place relative to something much larger. And we’re facilitating people knowing where they are and the larger thing. Sense of belonging to a global movement. Sense of something greater and you can contribute to it. Also like how we went from diversity to unity, greater collective. It’s not just for the sense of diversity, but building something bigger
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 171 We need some kind of shared North Star.
Wikimedia Community User Group Turkey (WMTR) A Cycle 2/Turkish Wikipedia email email 35 3 Opening regional and/or country offices would make this theme stronger. Having official agencies would be helpful in establishing healthy communication with future formal partnerships.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 52 It is not only about connecting existing communities with emerging communities, but also working together as readers, contributors, affiliates and partners from all regions of the world we would improve existing and develop new forms of contributions.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 32 It would be good to encourage the training of new users, leveraging with education activities. There should be more global work, not just on communities. You have to work on good tutorials that allow to form new users, facilitating the work for many interested parties. (Fernando Gualda)
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 39 Make wikimedia platforms, especially wikipedia, available online and offline.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 154 The matter of “oral citations” can be resolved nicely if we help universities to have programs that document the oral history of different cultures for which there are no such programs now and encourage the professors and the students in these programs to upload their work to Wikimedia projects.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 155 There does seem to be agreement that oral citations can become acceptable within an academic context. But there are some It would make sense to focus upon cultures where academic programs that accept oral citations are non-existent.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 136 When Wikimedians start becoming community organizers, they start getting a better sense of the global movement. Each reader, contributor etc. should have a sense of the global movement.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 177 Once the word is out and we identify what we want to focus on, we can work on partnerships and provide as much help as we can.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 173 We need to find ways to make sure this statement is something all will identify with.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 174 the use of "we" is problematic here because people may assume that the WMF is the "we". People are identifying with the "we", the community doesn't assume the "we" is "the WMF".
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 179 We will build awareness of the power of free knowledge and overcome barriers to access - I wouldn't phrase it like this, but we do need to think beyond Wikimedia. We're not going to be focusing on the identity of our movement as a series of websites, but beyond that. This statement doesn't really speak to that right now.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 182 Make Space? Make space is very jargony and western centric: Enable, Invite, Welcome
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 54 This theme should focus more on public policy and change of legislation, as just working on awareness would be a bit weak.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 168 Focus on high-priority communications - we will need to make high-priority decisions. Someone will need to make a call on how to prioritise languages.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 170 We've seen in so many communities strong support from e.g. the governments of these countries. In reality we need to make decisions about where to prioritise, and these decisions might be painful.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 184 thinking about prioritization and resources… put money behind this. Paid translations, pay for the infrastructure that enables global conversations.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 29 We think the theme can benefit from focusing it around reach rather than the movement. In its current form the theme appears to be heavily community-centred, readers are very important too and should be stressed.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 141 First step is being seen as a source of knowledge used for research, then getting people to contribute.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 38 Initiate training sessions in high schools, colleges and universities.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 140 By actively going through institutional channels, you might be forming behavior of creation of knowledge; not just getting but also contributing information.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 156 We need to rethink our relationship with academic institutions - pivot to instructors. Awareness is not only about brand recognition. We need to and grounding in the values and nonprofit aspect of Wikipedia is important; awareness is shallow today, and need to go beyond current state.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 160 A little bit more “how” we accomplish this particular theme would be welcome. Not clear how we get from here to there.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 31 Promote criticism of technological development.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 153 Translation tools have evolved to the point that they support humans to more easily share knowledge across languages. Small and medium sized wikis, are able to more rapidly grow because these barriers have been reduced. Machine translation is a more effective assistant. Oral history referencing is officially acceptable on Wikipedias across languages.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 188 Technology will be the solution for fixing this. Not only translations but accessibility. Better integration of tools for those impaired or for those with lower access or literacy skills. Technology will be a way to bring these people in - beyond just language. Looking at other barriers as well.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 8 We must facilitate interpretation and translation - Language ability does not correlate to technical skill, and both need to come together to enhance the participation of non-English speaking communities. The Language Barrier is a major challenge. Interfaces, localizations, and translations make tools accessible. They should not be an afterthought, but part of the main build and design process. We should learn from existing models like TED, where every video has at least two volunteer translators. One idea is to create a separate or new translation team. The foundation can and should pay for translation and interpretation.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 127 We need 1) Availability Across languages Via automatic translation and editor outreach) and 2) Accessibility in emerging communities (via providing an experience that works for readers with poor connections and/or poor devices).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 185 Where English isn’t the filter by default. Professional translation is something we do by default. Simultaneous translation. Also see the movement taking less traditional sources of knowledge.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 138 The more people we are, the more unity we should have. Paradox.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 106 Efforts regarding "giving contributors better tools to contribute" will not really expand our content in places where no contributors exists because the community is not aware of the existence of Wikipedia. [Theme D] assumes there is a variety of sources and in many categories/areas/languages that is just not the case.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 107 If we focus on being the [theme D] it is likely we lose focus on being broadly available is a wide range of topics in languages/regions and collectives in which Wikipedia is not known.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 108 A truly global movement is mostly interconnected with how we are [theme E], how we're adapting [theme B] to use new technologies to bring in those outside our movement (digitally illiterate, visually impaired, non-English speakers, minorities (race, gender, others), etc.).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 109 Becoming a global community is the ultimate goal. We will need [theme B] to help us scale the editing work globally. We will need [theme A] to scale the human network globally. We will need [theme D], so that we can be taken seriously at the global level. And we can't operate in a vacuum as many have said, we will need [theme E] to enable us to reach everyone and include them in our movement.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 110 We are one of the main player in [theme E]. We are not engaging with it, we are leading it. We need to boldly go to places where there's no school or library, partner with organizations that are experienced with going to exotic places. We need to create cultures of knowledge in places where no such culture exist and not just wait for it to get created. If we don’t do this, these cultures might just disappear before we get the chance to document them.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 111 [Theme B], to provide state of the art and accessible technologies is paired with [theme A] (to welcome any kind of knowledge, no matter who supports it in which language or in which communication channel) will allow is to achieve our goal of creating a truly global movement. Those three will push [theme D] we have forward.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 112 New communities need more support than just an incubator wiki. They need process and programs to encourage leadership and to support others to join them. If we are not culturally and emotionally aware and sensitive that other cultures around the world are different, then we will create friction and disappointment as we try to become more global in our participation.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 113 Augmented translation and automated seamless language tools will also accelerate any progress in this particular theme.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 114 A "truly global movement" relies on [themes A, B, E] to support the growth and accessibility as a [theme D]. Keeping our vision grounded in the *why* of reaching people in the rest of the world will allow us to choose which tactics (whether that's product, partnerships, policies, etc.) will best serve us getting there. Our 15 year strategic direction should be focused on the impact - not the means to get there.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 115 Theme D - we need to better understand how different cultures and regions treat the core concept of open knowledge - is there censorship, or just disdain, around the concept? Theme B will become more relevant as translation tools become better, which we may be able to tap into as a movement to allow for much easier communication across borders.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 116 [Themes B and E] are systems that support [theme A] to create,curate,contribute and consume [theme D] in support of a truly global movement. Ability to integrate and include many language and cross cultural respect and awareness are crucial, so AI will be a tool for humans, not a replacement.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 117 All the themes are interdependent, and [theme B] and "fun" are two of the more important things that may help attract more readers in countries who have been less present on Wikipedia. For years, Wikipedians debated about the introduction of a visual editor, and wikitext. Wikitext was seen as a kind of badge of honor. As more people get involved from around the world, technology innovation is even more important.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 118 If we want everyone, everywhere, to be welcome, it circles back to our theme A. Theme A is still the top priority, but this theme may inform how we prioritize that work. Similarly, theme B can break down barriers to being “truly global” through machine translation, better telepresence options, etc. We can prioritize our [theme B] investments by thinking if this makes us more [theme A] and more “global”.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 119 We will not be able to bring in new knowledge without bringing in new people. People will not want to join our movement if they see it as an unhealthy place. Some of the knowledge gaps we have on WM exist in other forms and on other platforms. The most respected source of knowledge will be extensive, vast, and vibrant. We will need to address these knowledge gaps to fulfil this goal.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 120 This intersects with themes B and D as bringing on all this content and contributors will require adequate tech tools for scaling with assurance of quality.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 121 [Theme A] is the prerequisite to a truly global movement. This theme is the one that will require a great deal of time, energy, and resources to achieve, and must be purposefully pursued. It’s far too easy to maintain the status quo than to make sure that marginalized communities have the opportunity to contribute to and learn from Wikimedia projects.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 122 This is very related to [theme E]. Wikipedia’s quest for knowledge does not exist in a vacuum, we do not (and should not) have to lone wolf this. Finding our place in the “family of knowledge” will help us do more, with more people.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 123 2 and 5 are means to an end. They would be tactic that we could be employed within the theme of creating a global movement. 1 is kind of a universal good – not sure it is a 15 year theme though. 4 could be at odds with a global movement at times.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 189 This goes beyond language. People bring up the point about socio-economic - you need leisure time to participate in our projects now. This is a barrier - others have knowledge to share as well.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 139 Readership challenges in emerging markets. You’ve got to pick the right place to do it. Strategy that’s been employed a lot; reaching people when they’re young and making them lifelong users. People teaching 14-18yo don’t have textbooks. It gets us the readership we’re looking for, and it gives them resources
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [557] Local wiki 16 We should cooperate with well defined groups such as Lincean Academy, Italian Geological Society, Club Alpino Italiano and Doctors Without Borders.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 323 every local wikimedia organization
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 631 New wikipedians
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 16 There should be a plan to foster collaboartion among Indian language Wikimedians.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 260 translators to widen the scope of a "native-language" article
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 274 Maybe some good network engineers that know how to circumvent government censorship
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 305 Anthropologists work in this area, along with USAID (United States Agency for International Development).
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 310 Museums. Schools. Faculties. Academic organisations. NGOs. Ministries of education. Official approach only. The Foundation to directly assist users in know-how. As a trusted representative of the Community if I am to come to an institution, I must have a legitimacy. Sometimes they say "Oh no, here are they from this Wikipedia thing!" Build the reputation of the encyclopedia and help users be legitimate. As simple as that :)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 315 There are many partners locally in every country. For example GLAM, Education and locally living volunteer editors. Assemble partners locally to establish a local organization where there is none yet.
Meta B Meta [558] Local wiki 44 Approach more universities, museums, libraries, and alike institutions.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 609 I think it would be interesting to cooperate with UN bodies and organisations that are allied with those bodies.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 613 Governments, telecom companies and Internet.org. We can work with the first two to ensure better coverage but we probably should not work with the latter
Meta B Meta [559] Local wiki 43 Convince governments and institutions about the positive impact Wikimedia (could) have on national development with the improvement of information about countries.
Meta B Meta [560] Local wiki 45 Work with governments and change public policy towards devices and keyboards (set localized language support as default), and schools (teach writing in the local language on computers).
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [561] Local wiki 21 United Nations Development Programmes can help us to have contacts within underdeveloping countries, where Wikipedia can increase significant awareness and perception in their population
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 300 My experience in South Africa is that there are NGOs are interested in raising funds for outreach and expansion of the Wikipedia contributor footprint. Have been involved in outreach projects by NGOs funded through national lottery, initiating young Africans into the workings of Wikipedia and short workshops on how to determine what is relevant content and how to generate it. Some of these operate in other parts of the continent as well and could extend such work to other countries using local 'trainers'.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [562] Local wiki 5 22 We need to teach NGOs how to access, use our resources and enrich them in their local languages.CreativeC38
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 265 Underprivileged social groups. Poor, undereducated, rural, third world, disabled, LGBT.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 604 Work together with missions who already have good work there. Train them first and make them feel everything is for the human, not wiki metrics, they can be our ambassadors
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 619 We may need to work with humanitarian groups in areas that we are trying to make Wikipedia a thing in.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [563] Local wiki 14 24 Wikivoyage and/or Wikiversity should work together with www.part-up.com .
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [564] Local wiki 36 115 Oral history organisations and projects which may partner to capture and translate information from around the globe and put the information on wikipedia. User:Powertothepeople
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [565] Local wiki 4 23 Participatory budgeting networks may have practices and contacts that might help us. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [566] Local wiki 4 24 The alternative globalization movements, such as the World Social Forum, with its "another world is possible" motto, might have experiences and capabilities to help us. User:Joalpe
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [567] Telegram 30 58 To achieve this theme, dialogues with both other social movements and international organizations must be expanded to distribute funds for projects that take effective action to change the situation.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 25 We should invite academic institutions to cooperate with us, to seek for the partnership.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 285 Hundreds of universities outside of North America
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [568] Local wiki 16 36 I think this theme would develop if we get wiki activists to work with educators from national schools and indigenous communities and to show them an incredible educational tool that is Wikipedia. Hunu
Meta B Meta [569] Local wiki 67 Support universities outside of North America.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [570] Local wiki 2 23 We should collaborate with social media.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 576 You can partner with different mobile operator and with the free learning organizations like Troubleshooters in Bangladesh and 10 minute school
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [571] Local wiki 25 Globalization can help us to promote Wikipedia in the world naturally, along with Internet and international companies
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 280 This is the most absurd question I have ever seen. I thought you were asking about suggestions for Wikipedia. ; Are you asking for suggestions about whom Wikipedia should invest with? I'm sorry, I'm not a multibillionaire venture capitalist.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 596 * Evoluaj organizoj, ĥaritoj: Tiuj organizoj helpas provizi strukturon kaj eduki homojn kiel ĝin uzi. Ili povas uzi ekzemploj de vikimediaj projektoj por instrui homojn. Por provizi scion ili povas disdoni Kiwix aparatojnkaj OLPC.; * Subtenantoj de lingva kaj kultura diverseco, do ofte pri / en minoritata lingvo / kulturo: Tiuj organizoj ŝatas vaste distribui materialojn en / pri sia lingvo / kulturo. Eblas ili subteni por instigi siajn aktivulojn al uzado de vikimediaj projektoj por tia distribuado.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 624 no idea, just try to avoid accidentally standing in their way.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 5 I can’t think of any organizations who will be working in the same direction.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 27 We can't give up on the other themes
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 28 Prosperous communities will strengthen small communities
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 29 Technology is a key tool for a truly global movement
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 30 We need to create a reliable knowledge that people from around the world can use as a basis for joint projects
Wikimedia Morocco user group A Wikimedia Morocco user group 1 The movement needs to be global. Wikimedia should make access to its projects easy for everybody especially in the countries having issues with Internet connection. Everybody should be able to access to knowledge.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 12 We consider Theme C to be of slightly lesser importance than Themes D and A, in the sense that it will be impossible to realise without addressing Theme D and A.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 11 This is important issue, however global north will probably remains as the main source of content for Wikimedia Project so we should rather focus on translations of at least basic, common knowledge to as many languages as possible than hopelessly trying to find editors in poorer areas.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 12 4th place, not so relevant to me. --Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 45 The theme of having a truly global movement is important but unfortunately, we do not start from the same starting point. In many regions of the world there is not enough understanding of what encyclopedic (neutral, fact-checked, referenced) content is, because before producing it, they need to have been exposed to it as end users. Efforts and resources have to be invested in overcoming this difference, but in some regions of the world, this problem are more urgent problems that need to be solved first. Spiritia (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 46 In promoting the Wikimedia movement globally, we also have to keep into consideration the issues of the net neutrality. Spiritia (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 17 Sustainability of the movement is maintained by small projects, when the primary big projects (like english Wikipedia) are saturated in content and search for new ways to stay productive.
Australian Community A Australian Community Perth various 40 1 Being the most trusted source of knowledge is the most important thing.
Australian Community A Australian Community Brisbane various 40 1 Engendering trust in the projects is most important.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 60 This theme, together with theme 3, is dependent and follows for theme 1.
Australian Community A Australian Community Australia various 40 5 Being the most respected source of knowledge is most important.
Australian Community A Australian Community Darwin various 40 5 There are limitations to how good we can be. Some types of content, and some content creators, do not have a place in the Wikimedia universe.
Bengali Community A Bengali Community [572] local wiki 5 This theme is also an important one because if we can ensure quality and trustworthiness we could also be able to bring researchers and experts into our readers' ecosystem. That will eventually help us create a better ecosystem of knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 324 This theme would make the Foundation a monopoly if outside sources are found not as reliable as the projects themselves. Not all projects are reliable, yet people trust and rely on Wikipedia too much. Wikinews is barely read, and some courses of Wikiversity need updates. Wikiversity has permitted original research, but information needs changing. Commons has a lot of photos but is severely backlogged; so is OTRS.; Wikiquote, Wiktionary, and other projects would not have much impact as other materials that collect quotes, dictionaries, etc. If they do, however, that would impact other competing materials.; Wikijournal is currently developing with just Journal of Medicine. If this becomes a full-fledged website, other academic journals would be impacted. NonFreeWiki, even when established per consensus, would be influenced by copyright laws.; In short, the theme is futile and pointless.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 327 Wikipedia would allow anyone with an internet connection to access summaries of reliable sourced material and help them gain key understanding of things that have positive impacts on their life. This is key especially in areas such as medicine: free information about health sourced to quality academic sources can radically change someone's life.; Beyond the practical, it would help individuals researching at lower levels (secondary and beginning of undergrad) find quality sourcing for their education in a way that is more accessible than many academic databases. This should not strive to replace it, but to be a starting point for their research.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 332 Most authoritative source of knowledge in the sea of junk information. Lights in the world.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 337 The impact would be the largest, most neutral internet-based source of information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 342 Providing a respected source of neutral information on so many items will foster a sense of stability in the worldwide population, which may foster peace by reducing misunderstandings
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 347 A lot
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 352 we will be a counterbalance to all fake news being spread
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 357 great impact
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 360 If Wikipedia became universally trusted, it would become the ultimate, universal source of knowledge. It would be easier for everyone to focus on one single project that is recognized as trusted.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 363 Help create a unified initial source for serious research, with further sources only being required for more in depth study.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 366 A universal multimedia encyclopedia.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 371 Schools would not be restricted by a rudimentary block of using wikipedia for sources.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 372 Fake News and "Alternative Facts" are common words in the 21st century. Wkipedia can fight this and reveal the truth. The Wiki contributor community can continue to act as Data integrity checkers to make sure Wikipedia only contains real information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 377 The way research is done for k-12 Education as well as Higher Education, will change. While there will be resistance from those who have worked in K-12 and Higher Education for years, this will bring about a necessary change to how we view the accuracy, and relevancy of sources found here.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 382 Centralised virtual library, a go-to for self-education for everybody
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 385 Probably arouse suspicion as having a monopoly on knowledge
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 390 TRUTH in the ability of correct information to exist even if people wish to perform a cover up. JUSTICE in preventing untruths being used to deceive others for either harm or profit. ACCURACY in information so that people learning things will have Wikipedia not only as a summary of info but a bibliographic source to continue further researches. TIME SAVINGS results from having a practical "one stop shop" for the common person to look up information. This savings in time allows people to not waste time.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 395 Wikipedia is clearly not neutral in its articles about people and certain places. This is due to public relations firms and "online reputation management" companies being hired to edit and re-edit articles to remove some or all negative information even though that info is proven, documented, and part of the established public record. This is discouraging to me and reduces my incentive to add info both positive or negative to articles because "Why Bother When Some PR or Reputation Company or Foreign Government (eg. China) Will Edit The Article?".
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 396 massively wiki is just good
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 402 Strong correlation with copyright issues, politics
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 407 Knowledge for all - unlimited, yet it won't be easy - example of the Chinese "Wikipedia"
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 410 better marks
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 415 we would have one source, easily accessible, just like google is the go-to place today
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 420 We will gain loyalty of the encyclopedia as a reliable source of information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 425 Free knowledge which is open to discussion and available to everyone would serve the spirit of time in 2030 as well as today.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 429 life simple
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 434 Wikipedia would become a reliable source, one that people would consider to be objective and useful.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 439 Help freedom and human rights! Free access to facts-based, verified and as much as possible unbiased information is fundamental to help people defend themselves from any form of manipulation based on false information. Free access to all the knowledge accumulated by humanity across history should be a fundamental human right.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 444 Further expansion of the free knowledge base already available online.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 449 We would have more people using this website if it the "most reliable" we have to make sure the website doesn't crash and we have to have reliable resources used.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 454 Become a more trustworthy source
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 459 The fact that Wikipedias cease to be not entirely trustworthy sources and become the most reliable ones will impact on alternative corporations of knowledge, such as scholars and academicians. Other sources like official outlets of information --e.g. national or supranational organisations in charge of regulatory policies-- will also resent a freer, more inclusive and independent knowledge aggregator on controversial issues, which might include climate tendencies, historical revisionism, social and religious understanding, investigative journalism, etc.  ; Nevertheless, attaining such a status implies not only clear policies on contents aggregation but also fair use and distribuition of such contents. Therefore, there is an intrinsic issue to solve if we are to follow. ; The most critical of those challenges faced to become trusted, is the divide between theory and practise. Take Wikipedia, for instance, where despite current efforts, the freedom to contribute is often met with a rigid paradigm which includes counterproductive practices (e.g. edit wars). Should the word 'free' need some restrictions derived from expectable behaviour? Should referencing tools not be treated as a priority given how dependent on verification the project is? Is Wikimedia research effectively oriented? What is the nature of leadership (unintendedly) fostered in the Wikipedia environment and is it compatible with 'the most trusted source of knowledge'?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 464 Half a billion or more people who consult Wikipedia every month for leisure, study or work.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 469 A better source of information where anybody could have access without concerning about its truthfulness would have a positive impact in my opinion.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 43 A cultural struggle: collective creation versus classical creation. Overcome this barrier.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 474 It would be possible to resolve the negative aspects of copyright manipulations that are in play today for the profit or enrichment of a few. The need to protect knowledge as an asset is harmful when investments in book, academic and historical archive collections all stand in the way of improving published works becoming outdated. Too often new material is lost or hidden away.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 479 Quite a lot, including possibly getting major institutions to accept Wikipedia as a reliable source.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 484 If the current idea that Wiki-anything is unreliable, then it does not matter what content is actually available, true or otherwise. I think that this is perhaps the most important initiative because without basic trust in the verity of the content, no one will want to visit Wikipedia in the first place. One major effect would be use in schools which is currently intentionally prohibited. Wikipedia could become a powerhouse home of educational content, which is at least at the current moment presented well, and leads deeper throughout different articles, until the reader has learned however much they want to learn.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 572 Wikimedia projects will forever be regarded as unscientific unless a greater effort is made to ensure the correctness of the content.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 574 Wikipedia would be the go-to for research questions
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 593 This will enable people to learn how to interpret information on their own, free from commercial incentive or insular viewpoints. If we do this right, it's not us telling people how it is, but people understanding our processes and respecting those processes because we keep delivering every single time, and they keep coming back for more.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 594 Provide a single source for information for many different fields
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [573] Local wiki 13 23 There are governments (for example Turkey) that forbid the entire population of a country to use Wikipedia. What can we do about it? That's an important question. How can we convince governments that this is bad for their country?
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [574] Local wiki 37 It would move the world towards the dream of a universal library of information.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [575] Local wiki 38 Wikipedia will become an acceptable, respectable form of tertiary literature, and its editing will be prestigous.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [576] Local wiki 39 Trying to chase after the top position will demoralize us, when simply providing the best information that we can will get us acceptably close.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [577] Local wiki 40 Wikipedia could be sorted into topics, because many times pages can get overlapped.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [578] Local wiki 41 We need to improve the quality and reputation of Wikipedia so that Wikipedia will become accepted as a cited source.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [579] Local wiki 42 By 2030, the whole world should understand the value of Wikipedia's role in the alleviation of thorny topics.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 1 By making available reliable, neutral and relevant knowledge we support individuals in self-development and making well-considered choices. This will inevitably bring us into conflcit with authorities.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [580] Local wiki 43 Our societies are increasingly divided and they need a source of unbiased knowledge.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [581] Local wiki 36 93 Our challenge is how to maintain this status, rather than achieving it. Readers should have a way to tell us about missing content.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [582] Local wiki 36 101 Wikipedia needs trustworthy information to survive and thrive, and to further become "where facts go to live" for the benefit of our entire species. User:Cnewmark
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [583] Local wiki 24 Effective impact requires a strong support and emphasis on projects other than Wikipedia, for example Wikiversity which remains a vast parcel unexplored. TgH
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 31 Current social and political situations around the world show us that knowledge and information itself are under attack. Wikimedia is a product that supports and strengthens reason and independent knowledge.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [584] Local wiki 7 18 Wikipedia has to become a reliable source. There is enough fake news even in scientific publications.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [585] Local wiki 6 The subject of fake News has recently hit headlines. Wikipedia must preserve knowledge and make sure knowledge is reliable. In addition, Wikipedia has the ability to be a bridge to information found in scientific articles, some of which are hidden behind a payment wall, and make them accessible to the general public.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [586] Local wiki 7 If Wikipedia succeeds in positioning itself as a reliable source of high standards, which is acceptable to quote and use in the academy, we will also be able to promote information and knowledge, while simultaneously struggling with false data and truths.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [587] Local wiki 8 In recent years, more and more scientific journals have removed the payment wall, while more and more journals and articles are published under an open license. In such a situation, Wikipedia can and should be the main body that mediates between scientific literature and the general public. The mediation should be reliable and accurate on the one hand, and accessible to the general public on the other.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 32 This is our biggest challenge, with huge urgency and of utmost importance for the movement.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [588] Local wiki 9 We need to recruit academic editors who are knowledgeable enough not only to understand the technical issues, but also to review an entire field. For this purpose, students who write articles in the framework of courses and seminar papers are not enough, and there is a need to increase the recruitment of senior editors (at the doctoral level and above)
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [589] Local wiki 10 There is a need for a friendly and automatic mechanism for standardized citations of articles in scientific databases such as Google Skuller and Pubmed
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [590] Local wiki 11 We need to create a friendly and automatic mechanism for importing free illustrations from scientific articles
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [591] Local wiki 12 We have to decide on the criteria for selecting articles for a quote on Wikipedia, for example: Should we prefer more cited articles? Of authors more quoted? In more prestigious journals? Review articles? Open articles? Peer-reviewed articles?
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 14 Wikimedia will be the most respected open and accessible platform for knowledge products: We filter the most relevant and reliable content out of the constantly growing information supply and make it accessible in a consumable form.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [592] Local wiki 13 Guidelines and mechanisms should be devised to ensure that sources cited in articles do contain the information quoted
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [593] Local wiki 14 We need to establish a way to ensure that all the articles cited do indeed fairly reflect the scientific consensus as well as the relevant scientific controversies.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [594] Local wiki 12 15 Regarding citations, it is important to reflect to the readers what consensus is on each topic, as well as what are the different alternatives, and what is the source on which they are based. Even if we can not accurately reflect each one, we can faithfully reflect the sources within the text.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [595] Local wiki 2 1 Our primary goal is to make a good encyclopedia and by following this theme we will ensure that we strengthen our primary goals.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [596] Local wiki 2 2 We will be able to ensure credibility, better consumer satisfaction and Wikipedia will be used as a source of reliable citations.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [597] Local wiki 2 24 It will be in our best interests to follow this theme as we will not be able to attain our objectives until we make Wikipedia credible.
Meta B Meta [598] Local wiki 34 87 How reliable are the footnoted references without help from experts? Not following the theme well would illustrate how lacking our expertise is and how we may be driving out experts who are very knowledgeable at topics.
Bengali Community A Bengali Community [599] local wiki 4 If we follow this theme Wikimedia will be the simplest and the most trusted source of knowledge.
Meta B Meta [600] Local wiki 34 88 This theme seems to be too focused on Wikipedia. Probably a revised or changed theme is needed/desired to reflect how the projects operate differently.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [601] Local wiki 10 If we follow and focus our efforts on this topic, we would make Wikipedia and its sister projects to inspire more confidence towards the rest of ordinary people, and they could help us to encourage others to participate and trust in Wikimedia.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [602] Local wiki 23 It is fundamental for Wikipedia being the most respected source of knowledge, not only because it is the most famous one but also because of the impact it has/will have on our future generations, being the most precious tool of our future.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [603] Local wiki 17 36 Vandalism is something common in a website that allows free editing, even allowing anonymous IPs doing so. I agree that it is necessary to eradicate it but without affecting the philosophy of free editing and a potencial censorship.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [604] Local wiki 17 39 I think we would have a great impact, by becoming the world leaders in reliable information.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [605] Telegram 30 37 I'm concerned with the attribution issues, or rather the lack of it. I have seen whole articles in the media and even academic theses and published books that are textual copies of Wikipedia.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [606] Telegram 30 62 This theme is important because it is the basis of the reason of being of Wikipedia. For this, editors must be well trained. Therefore the key would be in the creation of didactic materials that teach the encyclopedic writing keys and the selection of reliable reference sources as main axes.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 10 We will have an information repository that has a superior quality, neutral and possibly verified by experts in the different areas of human knowledge.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [607] Telegram 30 63 It is impressive how the content improves gradually without guidance, and I think it would be much better if everyone received some tutorial, with the possibility to ask more questions and learn more. This is directly related to "the augmented age".
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [608] local wiki 12 13 Wikipedia and the other projects will be sources in other more complex clusters of information.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [609] local wiki 12 14 We need a clear mission with very strict and high standard of quality and content.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [610] local wiki 12 15 There is a contradiction between high quality and low barriers for newcomers.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 31 Wikipedia's human-curated, crowdsourced approachseems to be a good counterweight to the "fake news" that other online platforms have been prone to.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [611] local wiki 12 16 There are risks with inviting experts to contribute, as they might not accept that amateurs change their texts.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [612] Local wiki 5 We give the world neutral view on everything, make misundertanding less likely to happen and therefore reduce violence in global scale.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [613] Local wiki 7 20 Become the most respected source of broad-based knowledge suited for the general public.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [614] Local wiki 7 21 Bring people from all language backgrounds together to work out consensus in a centralized knowledge repository.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 36 We must stress the importance of sources, and neutrality.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [615] Local wiki 7 22 Host high quality knowledge instead of focusing on relative respect in comparison to other sources.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [616] Local wiki 7 23 With Wikidata, we can promote the networked model of verification, and confront inconsistent factual claims more easily.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 16 Really the first place for everyone to stop, when searching information. The impact of it will be tremendous.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 47 The reliable information will help people: researchers, students, teachers, to get attracted to contribute to Wikipedia, rather than avoid it. The trust and the usage of Wikipedia will increase with the reliable sourcing of the information. Спасимир (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 49 With objective and fact-checked information, Wikipedia can fight the dissemination of rumours, false news. Ket (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 24 Having quality content is perhaps the most obvious of the themes, but it is our core deliverable and all the other themes are in support of this.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 34 It has also been proposed to improve the Wikipedia interface so that it is clear where the information was taken from. An interface that will show readers how they can add information and how the mechanism works.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 48 Expand the editors number and train them.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 50 To strength Wikipedia and other Wikimedia projects as an object of academic studies.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 52 Increase the existence of open and free access sources.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 35 Experts must be recruited.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 37 Encouraging writing contests can help add editors to the editors circle.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 39 Some Wikipedians in the group have raised the issue of Prohibiting anonymous editing. But there were also Wikipedians who opposed the proposal.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 42 Look for strategies to engage our critics (and that they don't stay in criticism).
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 49 Greater connection between Wikipedias in different languages.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 31 Reliability is critical to Wikipedia. This is usually the first argument against Wikipedia.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 38 It is very important to continue to maintain how Wikipedia works. The mechanisms the community has are critical to maintaining credibility, and are more important than a specific project to encourage writing.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 18 Wikipedia in general is already a great platform containing lots of useful and good quality content which is well structured and linked; there is no any other such platform in Internet. This is the biggest advantage of Wikimedia movement which already has great impact on knowledge dissemination; it is enough to simply continue the current progress.
Wikimedia Community User Group Turkey (WMTR) A Cycle 2/Turkish Wikipedia email email 35 1 Wikipedia is not being regarded as a reliable source by some internet users, especially by academicians; by focusing on this theme our projects would be respected more and therefore both its usage and contributions to it would increase.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 32 Technological collaborations should be established, both within the community and with external companies
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 33 Mechanisms should be established to identify the Vendals. And we should use AI for the identification of curses (etc).
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 61 If ‘we’ or rather ‘we together with the wider knowledge ecosystem’ have to be most respected and trusted, remains an open question. If we could provide the most high-quality content and increase the depth of knowledge together with partners as part of a knowledge ecosystem, then the impact would be limitless.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 30 A perception of legitimacy helps us to engage institutional partners.
Wikimedia Ghana User Group A Wikimedia Ghana User Group Discussion Ghana Whatsapp 9 6 The most respected source of knowledge because that will lead to more confidence from the general public in the Wikimedia Foundation.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 21 Promote online reliable sources
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [617] local wiki 9 10 Wikipedia should be The most trusted source of knowledge in the world
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 3 1 Naturally, this should be the most crucial theme to our local wiki. Arabic Wikipedia's content is terribly bad, what use for us are the new technologies and institutional partnerships if the articles themselves are on such a low level of quality, reliability and neutrality?
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 8 This is the most important theme, because it focuses on what the people are actually looking for.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 325 Not very important. There have been efforts to make the projects more reliable and useful. However, information can change rapidly, especially Wikiversity. Articles from Wikinews can become old news and stale and less attractive. Wiktionary has been influenced by multiple dictionaries, and its information may also change. Wikipedia has gone through so many changes, yet it's the most reliable of all projects.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 328 This is the most important theme. If Wikipedia is not reliable and trusted it has lost its purpose. Who cares about any of the other themes if our information is junk or promotional?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 333 Most important, junk knowledge requires lots of resources and time to filter out/to correct.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 338 Once people realize how "safe" (for lack of a better term) Wikipedia actually is, it will start attracting people to the website, who will help in the other four themes.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 343 Most important because when educators say "No Wikipedia sources" what people hear is that Wikipedia is not to be trusted. For the vast majority of articles, that is not the case.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 348 A lot
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 353 most important
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 358 very important
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 361 In my opinion, it is the most important, because if we focus on making Wikipedia worthy of everyone's attention, other changes will be able to come more easily.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 364 Possibly the most important theme. One of the key stumbling blocks for Wikimedia is a lack of general acceptance of the Wikimedia projects as trustworthy and consistent sources of information. Once Wikimedia is perceived as a viable source, the other 4 themes can be addressed as necessary. The theme "Engaging in the knowledge ecosystem" will be easier once organisations and institutions recognise more fully the increased value of Wikimedia at that time.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 367 High-quality information is much more important than all the bells & whistles.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 373 The most important. Without data integrity and reliability, wikipedia will no longer be a valuable resource for humanity.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 378 I see this as one of the most important of the 5 themes. If we are going to rely on this for global knowledge, we must be able to trust its accuracy, reliability, and relevancy. Knowledge is only as good as the truth that it bares.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 383 This theme is equally as important as the other theme of the most importance- a truly global community, as together these themes ensure access to relevant, accurate, well-sourced information on all subjects for everybody who could possibly want it
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 386 It's the most important theme, but to be trusted, it needs quality control
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 391 Completeness of information is important. Very often, negative information is not available or even scrubbed in order to hide it from public scrutiny. Except for entertainment purposes, having untrue information opens the door to many other problems including cover ups, fraud, deception, misrepresentation, incorrect conclusions, and bad decisions created by use of incorrect information. Because many people make decisions based in part (or wholly) upon info contained in Wikipedia, it is important that Wikipedia not eliminate material that is negative in nature. Very often, it is the negative information that is the most important factor in decisions.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 397 yes there are important too but not this one
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 403 Free photos are important for building the wiki, other consideration rely on the question.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 408 Several aspects contribute to success - all equally important
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 411 good
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 416 I think it is the most important
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 421 Source of information is the pillar of an encyclopedia. Hence the theme emphasize on research compared to other themes.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 426 Reliability is the precondition of Wikimedia survive and serve even more people.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 430 its looking unique in comparison to others
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 435 Although the first theme overlaps this one, I believe this is perhaps the most important. However, there are steps that need to be taken in order for Wikipedia to be trusted.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 440 The most important. It should be the ultimate goal to make all the human knowledge freely available to everyone.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 445 The purpose of an encyclopedia is to store and distribute knowledge. Without that, the other themes become irrelevant. Expanding into areas of the world under served by Wikipedia will not matter if the content on Wikipedia is not accurate, trustworthy, unbiased, and free. Any other goals are secondary to the primary purpose of Wikipedia, which is to spread knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 450 If wikipedia is the most trusted we should have an encyclopedia entry on all of the other themes.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 455 This one would expand Wikipedia by being known as one of the more trustworthy sites on the internet.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 460 Becoming the most trusted source of knowledge necessarity includes all other four. Otherwise, trust will not be acheived in a world increasingly placing value on inclusion, participation and technology-oriented development at a global level.; The future will define reliability on all those four basis.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 465 Continue what we are doing. This has been accomplished. Wikipedia is now quite academic. There is a lot of vocational knowledge absent.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 470 All themes are important but knowledge is something that deserves attention -- Knowledge is what has made humanity come so far, so we have to improve its access and truthfulness.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 475 All four are needed for our global future. A Wikipedia that we can trust to guide our learning based on technologies is going to inspire our desire to learn and raise our endurance for contributing. Trusting the knowledge contained inside the systems is the most difficult goal to achieve. Defining a trustable knowledge has not even been accomplished yet but I see a future for trustable knowledge here with Wikipedia because global paper archives are opening up to Wikipedia now and that invisible knowledge is going to get added to what we already have to learn from. We will have more empathy for mistakes our historical figures made from knowing how they were challenged or controlled much faster than today. Knowledge is power.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 480 I'm not sure
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 485 I think that this theme is the most important, because without trust there are no visitors.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 549 I feel that this is the most important theme in the long run, but the other themes are also good.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 570 Very important. Without Wikipedia being seen as reliable or trustworthy why would it be used?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 591 Critical. It's the thing that currently set us apart from so many other venues. We need to capitalise on that unique selling point. If we are able to exploit this unique trait, then many of our other themes will almost certainly fall into place.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 595 This is the most important, as Wikipedia's primary aim is making knowledge free
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [618] Local wiki 44 Something must be changed for our audience to admit that they use Wikipedia as a useful jumping-off point for research.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [619] Local wiki 45 This theme may impinge upon the themes of "Healthy, Inclusive Communities" as the demand for prestige shuts out less educated or capable editors.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [620] Local wiki 46 Wikipedia must be reliable, that's why people read it.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [621] Local wiki 47 This the highest priority, however, many of the five themes are interlinked.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [622] Local wiki 48 This is the most important theme, and ff our information is useless, then we are useless.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [623] Local wiki 49 This is by far the most important theme, because it proves our legitimization and effectiveness.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [624] Local wiki 25 It is important put a strong emphasis on credibility of our information in order to preserve projects against communication and political propaganda. Alexfouch
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [625] Local wiki 26 Relevancy and credibility of information is the key to the success of Wikipedia and its sister projects. Alexfouch
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [626] Local wiki 27 This theme is complementary to others for what can be done if we are not reliable? Fuucx
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [627] Local wiki 7 17 "most trusted, high-quality, neutral, and relevant source". Is this self-irony? A trustful prognosis for 2030 is not possible, especially if Wikipedia has never fulfilled a single of those points. Furthermore this is contrary to one of the basic principles of Wikipedia. Wikipedia cannot be a source.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [628] Local wiki 7 19 I think that the first sentence ("Wikimedia projects will be regarded as the most trusted, high-quality, neutral, and relevant source") is too ambitious. But because of the rest of the text of this theme, which is desirable and achievable, it is the second most important for me after theme 2 ("The Augmented Age").
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [629] Local wiki 17 42 I think that this theme is the most important. It contains the original goal, while technical improvments and getting new editors are "just" means to improve the content. Getting from very good to almost perfect is a smaller step than getting from bad to good. I think that we still have lots of articles that are bad.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [630] Local wiki 12 16 This is the most important issue. Cultivating the editorial community, expanding it and making technology accessible are important, but if the source of knowledge is not credible all articles will carry a suspicious label.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 7 I think our main focus should be on the quality of our content as properly written and referenced content will give satisfaction to our readers.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 8 Focus on content will create a more engaging environment for our readers.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 9 Quality content will help in establishing faith in Wikipedia.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 10 Becoming a trusted source of knowledge might help in bringing more editors.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [631] Local wiki 2 3 This theme is more important than the other four because this is more inclined with our primary goal.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [632] Local wiki 2 25 I think this is the second most important theme because until we become a reliable source of information, all other objectives will be futile.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [633] Local wiki 73 100 D is the most important theme: it is the reason why Wikipedia was born, developed, succeeded over other encyclopedias and people donate. If we stop being respected, experienced wikipedians would leave and readers would abandon us for other encyclopedias that will able to grant a certain quality, (Bramfab)
Meta B Meta [634] Local wiki 46 Respect and quality is most important, because a despised Wikipedia would not be read and would be quite useless, however it's not clear what precisely 'quality' means.
Meta B Meta [635] Local wiki 34 89 Maybe the slow development of online communications via wiki is related to the quality of content. Without adequate communication, quality would suffer. High quality is possible via solo work, but that lowers chances of improving communication skills. If communication is concentrated too much, how would we improve quality of content?
Meta B Meta [636] Local wiki 34 90 Cross-project communication is very essential and important because it helps improve quality of projects. Without such communication, and without enough sister projects, Wikipedia would suffer from imbalance.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 12 Encyclopedia shouldn't be the only prophet on knowledge market, but rather starting point for further studies, therefore it is not necessary to be the "most respected source" it is enough to be "good source"; "the most" sounds like a kind of "knowledge imperialism", which we should rather avoid, therefore this topic shouldn't be a strategy goal.[12]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 13 This goal is impossible to combine with NPOV - as there always be people criticizing Wikipedia for not following their POV and trying to discredit Wikipedia, so there is no chance to be "the most respected" by all.[13]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 20 16 Experts will never comes to edit Wikipedia as they have different habits, attitudes and expectations than are needed to collaboratively create a knowledge, so engaging too much effort to this theme is waste of time. WMF should rather focus on technology and support of existing community [1]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 20 17 Another user disagreed with the above statement claiming that experts are very important and Wikipedia community should rather follow the habits of main-stream academy people than pushing strange and non-welcoming regulations which in fact do not support quality but are rather an unnecessary obstacles for newbies.[2]
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [637] Local wiki 16 15 This topic is not that important, because reliability of information in Wikipedia is already one-of-the-kind and we can’t be more reliable than our sources. Ivan Pozdeev
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [638] Local wiki 11 Although all themes are important, this is especially important because it is a recurrent topic for people who do not know the movement, since many of them ignore the policies that rule the content (notability, neutrality).
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [639] Local wiki 16 It is an important subject — although I believe that, to some extent, this matter has already been attained, at least partially.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [640] Local wiki 17 37 This topic is the most important of which have been raised. We can not be satisfied with providing knowledge in a free way, we also have to make sure that the knowledge we give is accurate and unbiased.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [641] Local wiki 17 40 Wikipedia is a source of references where to find a summary about a topic and the sites to find more information about it, rather than a (more respected) "source of knowledge", which is inconsistent. How will I respect a source of knowledge whose compilers are anonymous? And although the "editors" are multitude, knowledge is not democratic. It seems to me that is a point to ignore.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [642] Local wiki 17 41 The wiki is a source of references, is what it should be, but I don't think its obvious subjectivity is something negative -- Everyone has seen how "prestigious" journalists and locutors commit spelling mistakes, how they don't know using verbs and having a tiny view of reality.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [643] Local wiki 21 51 The neutral point of view is one of the great challenges of Wikipedia in its search for quality. The proliferation of paid accounts and the post-truth phenomenon of the future jeopardise the neutral point of view proposed by Wikipedia.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [644] local wiki 12 17 Scientists and scientific publications should be the most respected sources of knowledge, not Wikipedia. But we should come close and make the knowledge more easily accessible.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [645] local wiki 12 18 We shall give an overview in all topics, not replace scientific litterature.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [646] Local wiki 6 This theme is the second most important, only after the community health. This is what attracts new editors to Wikimedia sites.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [647] Local wiki 7 24 Focus on fighting with fake news.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [648] Local wiki 7 50 Being a respected and reliable source of knowledge should be the most important theme. Without this one, the other four are of no use. User:Lymantria
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 10 Most important because it directly impacts millions of readers every month
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [649] Local wiki 73 96 Registration is easy and there is no real reason for people not to register. Most edits by IP are destructive. To give privilege to quality (as dewiki does) means to give privilege to the reader. If we don't favor quality over freedom to edit quality will fatally decline. (Xinstalker)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 326 Stop suppressing inaccuracies. If inaccuracies are inserted, then someone else must replace the inaccuracies with more accuracies. Make everyone welcome to add any information, accurate or not. Inaccuracies can be fixed by either removal or replacement, or they can be left alone.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 329 We need better quality control of pages, which means restricting the ability of new users to create pages. Full stop. ACTRIAL as it has been called on the English Wikipedia is a necessary first step to achieving this theme: a look at the current new pages created by users shows spam, poorly written content, and even worse: copyright violations and defamation. ; We should find a way to encourage new users to use the draft name space, while also making sure published pages in the main space are up to snuff. This is absolutely essential to recruiting new users, but cannot be prioritized above maintaining the quality of the knowledge of Wikipedia.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 334 Admins sometimes focus on forms more than the contents. Content is not everything, but it is perhaps the most important things.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 339 Probably the slowing down of new articles. When we focus on trying to get people to understand our importance, that will start to slow down the creation of new, minor articles.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 344 Limit frequent edits of controversial pages; give controversial pages professional paid editors to filter content
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 349 We would stop discussing page names, punctuation, American vs British spelling, and navitagtion template size.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 354 let everyone contribute, without a seriosity drivning license
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 368 Less time for look & feel design, organizational events etc.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 374 Edits from "anonymous" users or users with a "low trust score" would need to be vetted before going live to the internet. This means each contributor would have a "trust rating" associated with their user name. The wiki community would need to decide how to grade a user's "trust rating". Accidental redundancy or broken links should be seen as day-to-day accidents. Trolling and "wiki graffiti" should lower someone's trust rating.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 379 I believe that this should come before global accessibility.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 387 Stop including just any kind of article in the encyclopedias. Stop ignoring the importance of quality control. Stop spending money on needless research. Stop hiring paid staff whose skills are the wrong set for the positions they hold.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 392 I'm not familiar with all the specific areas you are focusing upon, so if I said something, my answer could be wrong.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 398 information exchange i mean this is just communication you have self-confidence and just go! never stop
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 404 Copyright laws must be adjusted to a brave new world
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 409 Organise more workshops/projects, involve governments, BUT oppose institutions' control
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 412 more language options
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 417 not sure
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 422 No
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 427 It may not be necessary (?) if work could be divided between the volunters accurately and in an entertaining way
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 431 Communication will increase
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 436 As it is right now, decision making at Wikipedia is heavily dominated by people with a decidedly leftist political agenda. They may truly believe that anything to the right of their far left agenda is not objective or reasonable, but they are deluding themselves. As a result, Wikipedia is viewed as leftist propaganda, to a large extent. Whatever the current power structure is, Wikipedia will have to begin letting its content contributors have a voice, rather than having someone at the top overruling anything to the right of Karl Marx.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 441 Being this goal so broad I don't think we're doing things against it. The hard part will be to decide what exactly we want to do to go in this direction, and there will be tradeoffs.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 446 I encourage Wikipedia to take an "inclusionist" stance to prevent loyal contributors from giving up on Wikipedia. Deleting articles because they cater to a specific interest group decreases the knowledge base, and that knowledge base is the primary purpose that Wikipedia exists. Do not destroy Wikipedia by trying to make it better, by deleting good articles, often not available nowhere else.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 451 Letting little kids make accounts and messing around with this website.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 456 I don't believe so.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 461 Leaving referencing or attribution to editors' will alone. New tools must be developed from already available analytic tools.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 466 Get away with delitionists. Get away with the whole 'Articles for Deletion' system. Focus on Wikipedia, Commons, and Wikidata. Migrate the other projects to wikifarms outside Wikimedia.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 471 No, I like the system you manage but there are still people who distrust Wikipedia, so you have to show them that it is not improving the page veracity.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 476 We would surely have to stop using Wikipedia as a personal image management and competition reducing system. There can be no more users with special access to advanced University, charity and private publishing to bully and edit competitors of their side businesses. If someone in beverage, vehicle sales or publishing would like to avoid revealing identity then the user should never engage in altering a winery or a new model of a rival brand car. If newspaper articles that are true to history and news exist and get posted no anaonymous usuers, IPs from govt or arts and business financing societies should be removed or edited Simply because they embarrassed. Newspapers and news broadcasts have their limitations in audience reach but there is also a trust deficit that we face with our mainstream media to deliver accurate and trusted knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 481 Editor behavior may be less focused on, instead disputes may become large scale
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 486 The CSS currently in use looks fine to me, so perhaps just ignoring it unless it somehow stops working.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 552 Make sure ideological groups are kept in check. They must prevented from forcing their ideologies on the project. This is especially true of ideologies that are currently popular or trendy, many of whose precepts seem to have been incorporated into some Wikimedia projects (Wikipedia and Wikinews come to mind).
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 561 Perhaps not publish changes right away, increase in pending changes use.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [650] Local wiki 13 18 Often enough even the scientific literatur is an original ressource although it calls itself a secondary source. The accusation 'original research' comes too quickly.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [651] Local wiki 13 19 The most desirable strategy is to significantly reduce amount of current policies that we have. And we should focus on more traditionally encylopedic subjects. In 2030 nobody will be interested in some flashs in the pan from the entertainment world that are forgotten a year after they were famous. We should focus on making the articles better that we have instead of always getting more, more and more articles.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [652] Local wiki 13 20 Really improving articles would be a full time job. But it should not be done by radically pruning, not with a 'blunt axe'.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [653] Local wiki 13 22 We should even have more patience for newcomers. That would increase the quality.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [654] Local wiki 14 25 Wikipedia is supposed to be only a first step to knowledge. The most relevant source of knowledge should be in specialized encyclopedias, written by professionals. That will not happen, but we should have only good summaries of specalist content.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [655] Local wiki 50 Invest less in mobile search.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 48 The reliable information will help people: researchers, students, teachers, to get attracted to contribute to Wikipedia, rather than avoid it. The trust and the usage of Wikipedia will increase with the reliable sourcing of the information. Спасимир (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [656] Local wiki 51 Less openness towards editors, more protectionism, vet editors more scrupulously.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [657] Local wiki 52 Lack of contribution is more of a problem than low-quality contribution, which causes the patchy and inconsistent coverage that can be bad for our reputation.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [658] Local wiki 53 Create a workflow for new users so that they feel welcome and get acclimated to Wikipedia.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [659] Local wiki 54 Openess and reliability are incompatible, so we need to stop anonymous edits and review first edits before we let a newbie to edit articles.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [660] Local wiki 55 Some types of bad articles are worse than no article, that's why we should be more liberal in semi-protecting and let only extended autoconfirmed to create articles.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [661] Local wiki 76 "Stricter controls are now urgently needed, not only to maintain quality and standards, but to reinforce and retain the very reputation for quality and accuracy that Wikipedia imagines for itself."
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [662] Local wiki 77 Article creation should be made as hard as possible, to ensure that only those able to produce good articles can produce articles.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [663] Local wiki 36 94 A way to gain credibility used in academia is to publish unanonymously. We could eliminate anonymous editing, and restrict article creation (along with discussions like AfD).
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [664] Local wiki 36 95 Restrict some sort of editing to those who passed a relevant training (e.g. how to cite). Wikipedia skills could have pre-requisite structures and people can choose which directions they will follow. Restrict editing of higher quality articles to higher certified users while allowing lower certified users to work on lower quality articles.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [665] Local wiki 28 We will have to put an end to translations made by users who do not master the languages or the subjects their edit as they repulse people in need of quality. TigH
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [666] Local wiki 12 17 We have to stop relying on a single writer. There is no doubt that the purpose of every writer is good. But cases of bias (deliberate or not) and inaccuracies should be avoided. In my opinion, every page or update must be reviewed by another Wikiped, knowledgeable in the field, independent of the first.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [667] Local wiki 2 4 We should stop creating articles using unreferenced content.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [668] Local wiki 2 5 We should also stop focusing on quantity and rather focus on quality.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [669] Local wiki 2 6 We should consider the quality of the encyclopedia and community health as two different aspects.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [670] Local wiki 2 26 We should stop writing unreferenced and incomplete articles.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [671] Local wiki 24 In order to become more reliable and trusted we would have to become less open, e.g. by introducing flagged revisions everywhere.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [672] Local wiki 35 If we want to become more respected as a source of knowledge we should be less inclusive.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [673] Local wiki 41 We should cooperate with schools and universities to develop critical thinking in readers.
Meta B Meta [674] Local wiki 34 91 Stop doing nothing, and start updating everything in all projects. Stop letting information go outdated, and start improving information and keep things up to date. Stop treating Wikipedia as if it's the only project to invest in, and start getting into other projects. Stop relying too much on websites, including ones providing page previews, and start using offline and/or inaccessible sources more often.
Meta B Meta [675] Local wiki 34 92 Stop making too many local wikis, especially ones using very obscure languages, and start revising the closing projects policy to make closures easier. Poorly-run wikis and/or poor-quality wikis should be either closed or improved.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [676] Local wiki 12 It is possible to achieve this theme without leaving aside the others, since it can be easily treated if there is willingness to do so.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [677] Local wiki 21 The ability of any reader to edit Wikipedia should be limited, in order to become a reliable, high-quality, and neutral source of knowledge, by giving more control to the admins.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [678] Local wiki 22 It is necessary to exercise greater control over contents, by limiting the edition of some of them to the people with the enough experience or studies to do so.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [679] Local wiki 17 38 This theme is not necessarily an alternative to the others but goes hand in hand with some of them. For example, a way to improve the quality of our content is to involve more and better to individuals and groups that don't currently contribute (theme E), as well as to extend the editors community to people from underrepresented communities in terms of gender, profession or geography (theme C).
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [680] Local wiki 21 50 The public and press interest for the number of articles of certain Wikipedia versions has made the community forget about the quality and maintenance of the contents that already exist.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [681] Local wiki 7 We may have to spend less on technical improvements.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [682] Local wiki 7 25 Simplify our language, "short academic book chapters" should be deprecated.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [683] Local wiki 44 Simplification, micro-edits, and a retreat from writing academic book chapters are good, but readability will be dramatically affected if the whole article can no longer be read as a coherent series of "sentences" but must be read as a list of interconnected "chunks". [11]
Australian Community A Australian Community Brisbane various 40 2 Technical improvements (e.g. Visual Editor) should take priority in order to make it easier for more people to contribute.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 12 I think this outcome would emerge from focusing on some of the other themes -- particularly theme #1 (Healthy, Inclusive Communities), theme #3 (A Truly Global Movement), and theme #5 (Engaging in the Knowledge Ecosystem).
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 13 Engaging with and being validated by the scientific community is important. Science is not the only way of knowing, but it is a powerful one, and has a huge amount of pragmatic success.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 14 If the goal is to increase the credibility of the Wikipedia as a source of information, then we need to do a much better job of engaging the scientific community.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 69 In the future, data providers will be the most important ones, therefore governmental institutions/agencies should be a natural partner.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 12 We should partner with educational institutions that have masters and doctoral programs to carry out a comprehensive validation of content.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 20 Experts in their own areas can be involved to improve/provide sources.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Australian Community A Australian Community Perth various 40 7 It is important to collaborate with external partners to help find and fix incorrect content.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 27 The most natural partners for content quality improvement are GLAMs; however cooperation with GLAMS may create POV both directly and by thematic bias, especially in case of state owned ones.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 68 This theme is strongly related to theme 5, as the wider knowledge network will be our natural partner. All together providing the highest quality knowledge and content for everyone to access should be our goal.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 28 Cooperation with academia is safer as they have less interest to force their POV but there is a problem with Wikipedia poor reputation.
Dutch Wikipedia B Dutch Wikipedia [684] Local wiki 13 17 More original research should be allowed. It is frustrating for new users that they often get reverted, because they don't know how to supply sources. Experts could add lots of detail to an article, that works in Wikinews and Wikivoyage, but not so in Wikipedia. 2 to 3 users could confirm the original research of the editor. Like this it becomes reliable as well. This will show a lot more involvement with the subject which will increase the quality.
Bengali Community B Bengali Community [685] local wiki 7 9 We could increase wiki contents with technical developments and by automated tools, it should be kept in mind though it does not have any negative impact on the quality.
Bengali Community B Bengali Community [686] local wiki 7 10 It is better to take expert's help in special cases. In some practical cases, various projects can be made with the help of experts.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 20 The community should seek for cooperation with other organisation, which share the same mission and value as Wiki.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 330 A focus on expanding the Wikipedia Library and access to quality academic sources for the volunteers is a must. For BLPs this is less of a concern, but for anything that is not a BLP, academic sourcing remains the most reliable and highest quality material, and is needed to help improve the quality of the articles.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 335 Automation of fact checking ?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 340 Propaganda. We could do this in more peaceful ways, but it might not be effective. Practically anything to support our cause will be fine. Small posters across the website (or even the internet) that say things like "We will make a stronger Wikipedia" or "We will destroy the 'fascist' database" will surely help our cause...maybe...
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 51 Reduce the influence of conflicts of interest with commercial entities.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 345 Publicize efforts and promote Wikipedia as a true encyclopedia and a trusted source, "Better than Brittania", "More Worldly than Worldbook"
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 350 By definition, Wikipedia should be independent from sources, therefore paid editing should be completely forbidden. Also, Wikipedia should focus on facts. and the only completely verifiable fact is that someone said something.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 355 All data in all versions should be available on all other
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 359 seen as being reliable,
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 365 A valuable asset would be the involvement of recognised professionals/academics in the creation of content. This of course in addition to the existing "unrecognised" editors/creators.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 369 More good editors (contributors). More free sources.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 375 The academic's need to contribute more. Maybe building the capabilities for better collaboration among higher learning institutes is valuable?
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 380 We need a way to run better query on the data that is provided. It would also be beneficial if there were a way to begin including published articles that can't be edited, but can still be accessed for easy, all in one location, research.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 384 A GLOBAL effort- subject specialists are needed from everywhere, according to different perspectives on a topic
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 388 Something that convinces the world that the WMF will really do it and that will instill confidence in the encyclopedias.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 393 Consistent effort in making sure information is complete by not having articles scrubbed or edited by reputation management firms. I am not just talking about biographical entries, but about geographical places with severe pollution, companies that have released products containing proven carcinogens, and scientific information which may have political opposition.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 399 humanity
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 405 Kind of super mediation (forum) for heavy subjects to discuss
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 413 don't know
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 418 not sure
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 423 Updated information
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 432 Fine readable
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 437 Wikipedia needs to include people who represent different or diverse world views, and content contributors need to be made to feel as if their time and effort is valued.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 442 Make efforts to increase the participation of experts that will improve the quality of the information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 447 Improving the Wikipedia search engine, and improve editing on the mobile app.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 452 Get a gargantuan amount of information to get people across the world to trust us.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 457 Fact checkers.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 462 Research, research and research.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 467 Have a Wikipedia Education Program in each country. Involve not only universities but also colleges and places for vocational training
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 472 Improve the monitoring of articles editions or the people who make these.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 477 Race and economic inequality affects the access to education and knowledge for too many of us. Wikipedia's accessibility for almost all users has made the world taken notice. This accessibility needs to keep widening and the results from the knowledge retrieved needs to be very rewarding on the most individually motivating way.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 482 Sources, lots of sources
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 487 Gaining some core group of editors to go through articles flagged with problems.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 553 Making it globally inclusive
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 563 The "engaging the knowledge ecosystem" theme would have great synergy with this theme. Use the ecosystem to make more source material available to Wikimedians, which in turn helps improve the content.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 592 I'd focus a bit on making it possible for anyone to participate in quality, trust, expertise (what it is, building it etc). It's a little bit in there in the form of "public understanding", but we should emphasise that everyone can and should have the possibility of learning about and participating in this process
Dutch Email Survey B Dutch Email Survey email email 2 3 Creating Bot articles breaches Dutch copyright law, so all editors of nl.wikipedia are criminals. That should be forbidden.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [687] Local wiki 56 Collaborate more and expand partnerships with GLAM.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [688] Local wiki 57 Focus on educating the common man to be a better editor.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [689] Local wiki 58 Welcome and encourage new editors more regularly, give them attention of more people.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [690] Local wiki 59 There's no easy path to the learning path, getting to the documentation is more of a random discovery.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [691] Local wiki 60 Encourage using open-access high-quality peer-reviewed sources, and discourage unsourced or "self-sourced" information as much as possible.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [692] Local wiki 61 Encourage short quotations in footnotes, which will give readers much greater confidence on controversial topics, and will make verification easier.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [693] Local wiki 78 Provide optional identity verification, so it is clearer who is responsible for an account's work
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [694] Local wiki 36 96 Educate re-users on how to re-use (cite) Wikipedia.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [695] Local wiki 36 102 Work with partners who are already facing the challenges of trustworthy sources and information. User:Cnewmark
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [696] Local wiki 23 Being the most respective source of knowledge seems enough. Aiming for more is risky and hardly achievable since we will always face detractors and eventually make mistakes. Fuucx
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [697] Local wiki 29 Contributing should be the coolest thing you do at least once in your life. It is therefore necessary to open other possibilities for people to share knowledge ː genealogy, tutorial, etc. Trizek
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [698] Local wiki 33 Motivate and engage users in order to increase the amount of information shared. Zaxiphyvaxe
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [699] Local wiki 20 68 Wikipedia must succeed in convincing these people, the complotists to name them, of the relevance of its content and the processes of its elaboration. Failing to do that will leave a growing part of skeptics who are sooner or later likely to harm us (Euloiix). However a conspiracy theories supporter is appallingly difficult to convince. He is an irrational believer (Cedalyon)
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [700] Local wiki 20 69 Wikipedia is as simply an encyclopedia would benefit greatly from being coupled with an efficient and lively educational system. Cedalyon
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [701] Local wiki 20 71 Perhaps it would be necessary to encourage seasoned and specialist contributors to engage in Wikiversity. Cedalyon
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [702] Local wiki 20 72 Interested contributors, if they benefit from a certain mentorship can produce adapted and quality pedagogical contents on Wikiversity. Cedalyon
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [703] Local wiki 17 40 If we just could reduce the theme to „We will work toward ever more accurate and verifiable content. We will increase the depth of knowledge available and maintain our standards for verifiable and neutral content. We will invite experts to join us. We will help people understand how our processes make us reliable“ the Wikimedia projects will stand a realistic chance to become the „most relevant source of knowledge“ beyond all scientific literature and respectable press by 2030. At the same time we would be "respected" as a "source of knowledge".
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [704] Local wiki 17 41 For 2030: Stay down-to-earth and recognize the complexity of reality. You are not more than one brick and your purpose is probably to teach and enable media competence.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [705] Local wiki 12 18 We should monitor the creation of new articles or updates to existing articles, the monitor will be done by another Wikiped, which is a focus of knowledge in the field.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [706] Local wiki 12 19 We need to add a control mechanism to each article that will bring the sources of information to the article
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [707] Local wiki 12 20 We need to collaborate with wikipedia scholar - a summary of entries written there will be added to the general Wikipedia for wide use
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [708] Local wiki 2 7 We can add some aspects from the knowledge ecosystem into this theme such as educational collaborations.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [709] Local wiki 2 27 As many workshops as possible.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [710] Local wiki 37 We need more users to be more reliable.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [711] Local wiki 38 We need better tools to be more reliable.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [712] Local wiki 40 Wikidata should be more reliable: every statement should have a source, which should not be just Wikipedia.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [713] Local wiki 80 Editing Wikidata could be limited with a dedicated flag. (Archeologo)
Meta B Meta [714] Local wiki 47 Well-designed contests could add a lot of well-written articles comparatively easily.
Meta B Meta [715] Local wiki 48 The rules need to guard against propaganda (mass disinformation, disruptive editing, ad hominem attacks).
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 32 Wikipedia will be trusted when articles are based on trustworthy sources, therefore teaching wikipedians which sources are trusted and which one are not is the core task.[1]
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [716] Local wiki 16 28 This is important because right now Wikipedia is not regarded as a respected source. Pavel Suvorov
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [717] Local wiki 13 One way to promote our projects as reliable information sources is by teaching (either through editatons or workshops) our policies related to the content created and published, such as reliability, NPOV, copyright, notability, etc.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [718] Local wiki 15 Wikimedia should be a much more respected organization but it is not, largely because of traditional media which criticize and blame Wikimedia with false affirmations (superficiality, anarchy, etc.) by ignorance or simple snobbery. They probably see it as a threat.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [719] Local wiki 17 In my opinion, one of the most important shortcomings is the recurrent vandalism. Efforts should be made to cut off (or at least minimize) vandalism.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [720] Local wiki 17 35 I don't agree that the media misrepresents Wikipedia, in fact I rarely hear the media mention WP in USA. I think the best way to combat these poor perceptions is to admit that we have reliability issues and make it more reliable. With the exception of encyclopedias, we are not in competition with the other media -- on the contrary, we need them as sources of information.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [721] Telegram 30 64 I think a deep discussion about what is a reliable source and which sources should Wikipedia accept is needed. There are always discrepancies about reliability and verifiability over sources and no agreement.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [722] Telegram 30 66 The topic of use of the sources is important, considering that Wikipedia is a tertiary source. This means that you should not write about things published only by a primary source, but should wait for a secondary source to address it.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [723] Local wiki 7 26 Separate citation data from its presentation, and attach references explicitly to text areas.
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 2 We need to better understand how we compare to other trusted sources, and why people use other sources, so that we can improve where possible.
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 4 Search gives answers right now. Whereas we want to "educate" which involves giving answers as well as tangents and alternative angles - things you didn't necessarily want to know, but are important/relevant context.
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 5 Articles and talkpages are an important combination, because you can see how the article developed. It's an equalizing system, where everyone has the same status and possibility to contribute.
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 8 Knowledge is created when multiple sources of information are compared - e.g. 5 sources discussed and prioritized, structured and filtered. Readers then treat Wikipedia as information (not knowledge) and re-filter/judge for themselves.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 27 Due to increasing political divisions across societies all over the world the most important thing is to keep very strict NPOV; Admins should use strong measures to stop changing Wikipedia into political debate, there should be concise code of conduct, how to deal with POV, there should be a "black list of un-trusted sources" and finally most prominent members of community should stay away from political declarations in social media.[4]
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 25 28 This theme is the most important; Wikipedia should seek the true, as the true is currently very rare, and people are looking for it, especially in countries with semi-dictatorships such as Russia or Turkey; therefore stronger control of quality of content is needed and in most important topics the external experts should be asked to write articles under their names, and that names should be put in articles.[5]
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 46 Introduce a validating process for contributions prior to publication or reducing post-publication verification time (less than 24 hours).
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 47 Submit any new publication to a preliminary committee via a background platform in order to make verification and amendments before validation; Ask for experts to be part of this validation committee.This process, in addition to bringing credibility, will allow more user-friendliness and collaborative work on wiki contributions.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 48 Enforce quality models and criteria (form and content) for any contribution.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 49 Establish a gradual and continuous evaluation (1, 2, 3, 4 or 5 stars) of the articles by the validation committee which will be visible to all users.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 50 Introduce checking before publication of articles.Show names of contributors who give credibility, such as experts in the topics.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 51 Educate contributors to source and use especially good sources.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 222 Processing the project content into something usable, probably through ML/AI, is probably involved in becoming more respected.
Wikimedia Ghana User Group A Wikimedia Ghana User Group Discussion Ghana Whatsapp 9 7 There would have to be experts (additional editors) going through all edits before they become live – which might make Wikipedia lose its flexibility but definitely make it more credible.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 4 If we want to maintain high standards for quality and relevance of information, we should reassess Wikimedia-projects to determine whether or not they can be maintained
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 90 Readers must remain critical, despite our great reputation. A more sleek polished interface would convey a different message; some advocate the current "stuck in the 90s" design, because it hints at the amateur-participation, and perhaps reminds people to distrust. - But, how could we balance both extremes?
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 11 It is very relevant, because if we generate a source of knowledge that has validations in its contents and format, we can be recognized with an additional value by the community and the people who access the projects.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 91 There will be a greater availability of research materials in free or open ways, both cultural heritage organizations and publishers are getting increased pressure to be more publicly available (Open Access, Institutional digital archives, etc).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 92 There will be broad need for ways to verify quality of information outside of our more traditional ways of deferring to expertise and institutions (more formats for publishing, less peer review, and greater desire for attribution of information across platforms).
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 14 Relevant knowledge, educational use (training of people), gain respect (strategies). (original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 15 [Theme] E is a consequence of D, or [rather] D is a requirement for E. In certain communities it is linked to theme A. (original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 16 Project sustainability depend on the quality positioning of it.(original note)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 95 Transparency and verifiability continue to be core parts of our identity in our platforms and infrastructure and culture. There would be several healthy parts/places/actors that support each other. We want to make sure we have people who remain critical consumers of content. Need external influence (in and out) to keep the ecosystem of input healthy.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 96 Wikipedia has become the entry point to knowledge, not simply a destination. We shouldn't replace or supplant other sources of knowledge. We should be the place everyone considers to start that journey as they explore.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 11 At the current state of contributors' communities of Wikimedia projects it is hard to engage experts due to egalitarian methods of decision making; therefore current contributors should somehow resign from part of their normal "editing powers" to make room for experts.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 97 Since the medical textbook companies closed access journals, medical professionals have turned their focus to improving freely-available medical information via Wikimedia projects.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 14 We need at least 2 experts in each field as otherwise there is a danger that one expert can force his/her own POV; when there is only one available he/she should be very carefully screened towards pushing their own POV.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 17 Too strict editing control is based on fear that Wikipedia can be destroyed by trolls and hoaxes - the trust and assuming good faith should be re-established as it was in early days of Wikipedia; that could attract also experts and in fact increase the quality of content; doing anything due to fear is always counter effective.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 98 The Wikimedia projects will be widely praised as one of the few places on the internet that balances news coverage and outlets. It becomes a place where journalists and publishers are proud to be cited, and photographers are proud to have their images hosted. Creative Commons licensing becomes a new norm for information publication, allowing for Wikimedia projects to cover more topics and areas.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 99 When looking for information or knowledge the public both looks to Wikimedia projects directly and looks for the sign that our information is used elsewhere as well. Reusers not only want to advertise that information comes from us in order to show it can be trusted but compete with each other to update their content faster when changes are made directly to Wikimedia projects.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 100 In 2030 the Wikimedia projects will be a core pillar of bibliographic instruction for librarians, teachers and students. Researchers, students and media consumers will expect and demand verifiable and neutral sources and citations.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 101 The processes for creating content will be more easily understood (via better documentation and communication), and will inform and draw from similar processes elsewhere.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 18 We have to improve tools and efforts for anti vandalism and we need to improve our reliable sources. All unreliable information should be deleted/marked/tagged and action should be taken to handle it.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Korea User Group A Wikimedians of Korea User Group videocall video conference 3 7 Requring references too srictly could drive new comers out and demage heathy community. We should not force to cite source. We should provie more convinient envirnment to find reliable sources and make footnotes technically.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 102 The world is a more stable and peaceful place, because young people everywhere have access to a respected and credible resource that helps them to evolve as job opportunities evolve, and to research and understand any topic they need to. This undermines the trend of youth unemployment leading to political instability. Integrating the projects with education will help give info literacy.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 103 Wikipedia knowledge is presented in virtually all contexts of the internet. It is presented in a way which conveys not only its authority, but also its dynamic and editable nature. Almost in the same way as this google doc… but with the ability to see its improvement and refinement over time. It will be easy to see the most reliable content as well as see the only the newer and less reliable content. This will encourage users to update and verify those less reliable areas.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 104 Wikimedia projects are the gold standard for truth and neutral knowledge in the world. All content distributed by others – including content generated through AI sources – is based in high-quality, reliable resources that are cited.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 105 Teachers and students alike recognize the value of a decentralized, collaborative knowledge resource with global scope. Vandalism and misinformation become less frequent and more easily corrected.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 44 An important theme to defend the movement against its detractors, those who express reserves, those who are reticent and those who don't trust on Wiki platforms as reliable sources.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 45 An important theme for valuing the efforts of contributors.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 33 For millions of people Wikipedia is the first and most important source of knowledge.This creates a special responsibility and we have to act on this responsibility.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 15 If we lose society's trust in the neutrality/reliability of our content, this would be Wikimedia's end.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 62 In my opinion, we have already achieved this – at best this theme is a "preserving status quo"-thing
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 63 If it’s mainly about the image of Wikimedia’s sources, it is of inferior importance. If it’s about the real usefulness and accessibility of Wikimedia’s content, it’s of high importance.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 64 This theme is the less important one.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 8 Searchability and presentation are essential components in providing access to knowledge
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 229 Might be an opportunity to facilitate more element here of the anti-expertise sentiment here
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 232 There is a tension between including experts, and the superlatives that supercede the experts (“most reliable”).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 246 Does the expert part matter? The good current parts are independent of expertise. It may or may not have been written by an expert, but that isn't highlighted anywhere. Would changing that be harmful? Would expertise be linked to blind-trust?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 238 Add awareness first
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 240 It’s not just passive - part of what we need to do is make the projects better AND promote that as such.
Australian Community A Australian Community Adelaide various 40 5 Improvement of sister project relationships, for greater collaboration and cooperation.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 47 Communicate Wikipedia mechanisms to avoid fake news. Reinforce these mechanisms.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 241 Make privacy policy easy to understand.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 244 We could be better messaging that this is a priority for us and part of our process.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 249 Demystification is a core part of what we do, and needs expansion.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 225 The most understandable source of high-quality knowledge.
Australian Community A Australian Community Melbourne various 40 2 Support is needed for under-developed content areas to encourage work on these.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 247 Completely change it to "We will show related information to people everywhere, to place it within larger contexts".
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 231 Needs to include a commitment to diversity of contribution and environment for access.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 235 Multiple POVs represented and discussed to show how the most accepted content was derived. Not only just experts, but everyone’s POV.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 250 This is a key topic, and the biggest barrier (besides technical skills) in the conversations with educators. The bet on open has had a great return. We are already a key component of the knowledge ecosystem, but there is no question that eternal vigilance to deliver the best quality of knowledge is required.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 12 Expert's role might not be necessary absolute decisive; they might however play a role of external advisors or reviewers, but this roles should be somehow defined and organized to be really useful.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 13 Experts can be attracted by doing common projects with their mother institutions, so they can be slowly and gradually transformed into wikimedians during cooperative work with regular wikimedians.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 15 We should first recognize the most important content gaps and then focus on finding and engaging experts in these fields
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 16 Once found and engaged important experts should be under special care preventing them from community hate and harassment.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 22 The editing process should be changed. The content gaps should be first found with help of experts and then all efforts should be focused on filling them.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 53 It is necessary to have a strategy for attract expert knowledge (universities, educational institutions), which is relation with Theme E. Wikipedia can be considered the sum of all knowledge, i.e. the scope and the depth of its content have to be increated, to attract more experts and educated people. Ket (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 67 We should work towards free knowledge. Wikipedia and the other projects are (currently) the way to achieve that, not the end goal.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 226 We’re the gateway to any knowledge. We’re the first place anyone goes to start learning about anything. “Most high-quality, neutral, and relevant source of knowledge” seems more critical than “respected”.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 28 One of Wikipedia's strengths is its tolerance for being a "good enough" source of knowledge, rather than requiring all content to be authoritative.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 223 "Most" respected is problematic. We can have our conventions and structure of knowledge, and we can be respected, but we shouldn’t tell people we’re the “most” respected.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 236 Removing all barriers to entry to join Wikipedia
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 227 Language - across all languages - should be added as implicit.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 34 Thinking outside the box: Differentiated rule statute to generate content that is more difficult to create. Don't apply the same levels of exigency for people who want to include and not demand the same level of sources for subjects that are not represented. (María Paz Canales)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 242 I want to make sure we still allow for low-quality articles as starters. So anyone can begin. Maybe have quality ratings that people can use to see the state articles are in.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 34 We should continue to focus on freeing knowledge (not only on the content). How can we make new sources of knowledge accessible in a smart way?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 239 More accurate and verifiable content. By 2030, Wikimedia projects will be seen as the most high-quality, neutral, and relevant source of knowledge. We will increase the depth of knowledge available and maintain our standards for content. We will invite experts to join us. We will help people understand how our processes make us reliable.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 52 Anyone specialized and reknown in his field: archivist, librarian, teacher-researcher, scientist...
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 234 Neutrality within single-language societies have a major divide between what is seen as reality.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 233 There are going to be new channels (e.g. spoken) that we need to be present in. if it doesn’t exist in a way people want/expect, they won’t use it.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 199 This theme is dependent on the diversity engendered by [theme B] of true inclusivity. The augmentation elements will be a natural result of providing relevant, high quality knowledge in accessible formats. Placing augmentation as the priority over these other sources of movement direction, would displace (and at times), hurt our potential for impact, where augmentation is not yet an opportunity or reality.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 200 We aren’t curators, we aren’t librarians, we aren’t researchers. We are not the expects in every field. Without those people we cannot achieve what this theme sets out.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 201 [Theme B] could be an aid to this topic by using better technology to find the areas that need work and the expertise that people have and match them up. This topic is a prerequisite to being [theme C]. We can expand without being seen as accurate and reliable, but it’s much harder to explain our value in new places without that reputation. By working to ensure that the projects are a trusted source of knowledge and are seen as such, we make the case for becoming a truly global movement much stronger and easier to share.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 202 Wikimedia projects will probably never be totally "respected" by everyone if only because different countries and cultures treat the concept in different ways ([theme C]). It allows for a neutral source which to many means not focusing on the "correct" side (e.g. Turkey situation).Theme B applies here as well, since this goal speaks about finding the information that's relevant to certain people at certain times which would require more work on machine learning and content discovery.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 203 The one that stands out the most is Theme E. There’s a bias toward Wikipedia from old guard academics. How do we approach and work with more traditional organizations? How do we help them adapt for the future on the way to 2030?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 204 This theme is more of a byproduct of the other themes. The goals of the other themes need to be achieved in order for this theme to be true.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 205 The demystification part of this (external communication/explanation, highlighted transparency), will help all the other themes to succeed. It will: make the actual editing work easier (clearer documentation, and identifying problems with workflows); make onboarding newcomers easier; reduce editor confusion; make external outreach smoother; make interacting with sister communities (who differ in subtle ways) easier.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 206 This theme is a goal to work towards on its own but in many ways is also something that is naturally worked towards through many of our other themes. This is especially true for the theme A and E.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 207 Further engagement with the existing knowledge ecosystem will push us towards greater respect as a knowledge source. "Serious" publications give us more clout by association, while we in turn can help those organizations to find new ways to gather and share knowledge. Fostering healthy and inclusive communities is also critical, since people will avoid contributing if they do not feel welcome or if there is too high of a barrier for entry to begin improving the projects.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 208 All themes are prerequisites to being the most respected source of knowledge. In order to be up top (#1), all remaining 4 must be true and existing.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 209 People do not trust a source because it is accurate; they trust it because they see that they have a chance to fix errors (and so they know it’s not a POV that’s outside of their control and being forced on them by some external power).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 210 This theme is dependent on healthy community and global community, but doesn’t account for those. It depends on those.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 211 This theme has two components: (1) gotta use reliable sources, and (2) gotta convince readers it’s reliable and so are the sources. (1) requires theme E (2) requires inclusivity.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 212 Endorses the knowledge ecosystem, but when we say “we want to be the most respected source of knowledge”, it seems to supplant knowledge creation in other spaces. But if you think about the projects as a platform for accessing relevant and high quality information, you don’t have to supplant the knowledge ecosystem and you risk alienating people in the other knowledge creation zones (experts, indigenous knowledge, etc).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 213 Accessibility and understandability across all languages came up a lot.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 214 Be the middlemen of knowledge.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 215 The most important part was helping people understand how it is reliable… highlighting transparency will help the others succeed. That will make interacting with sister communities easier, as well as external outreach. Need to demystify what makes us us. This is the first place we start the conversation, so a good starting place.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 216 This theme links into the final destination of sum of all knowledge. This is connected to all, lynchpin. Whether that’s ensuring knowledge ecosystem or healthy diverse community - all these result in our being able to provide the most neutral.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 217 Global movement might come after this. We have to be able to explain what it is, and that it is trusted, accurate knowledge. If we can get to this place, then we can complete the global movement goal. This is more of a circular loop - process gets us to the sum of human knowledge.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 218 It is a process loop, we are already at a place. Out of western context, where people don’t know us, we can’t reach this goal until we move up. This is one that others feed into. Healthy and diverse community will push to more trusted, better content and people feeling more safe. Without that, having trusted reliable content would be harder to reach. Need breadth of knowledge and partnerships (ecosystem). If we are at the center of the ecosystem, then we would be trusted.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 219 There's a filter bubble. Democrats see their content, republicans see theirs.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 220 AI could help with of this. Moving things forward. Better translations, better analysis for healthy communities. Connecting to other knowledge bases. So much knowledge available, not to downplay the potential power of this.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 221 One of our other goals is [theme E]. Degree more institutional respect. Points to trust by education issue. Help us be more nimble. Knowledge ecosystem is a means to this end.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 16 We should develop mechanisms to remain an open system while we will have to resolve the conflict between reliability of our content and openness of our content creation processes, e.g. through application of quantitative quality indicators (quality rating, quality ranking).
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 29 A preoccupation with "legitimacy" in the eyes of others is damaging to the community.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 44 Expansion of Wikipedia Library, and more regional alliances with allied organizations/universities.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 36 Drop/replace "most respected" - respect is gained, will be achieved implicitly by providing quality content

- add thoughts on how to make new sources of knowledge accessible.

Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 37 Change the title to “Becoming the most respected source of knowledge” in order to stress that this constitutes our goal (which is not already achieved).
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 38 "Reliability" is not a criterion we can set, it has to be judged/awarded by the people who use our platforms.However, we can establish the framework (infrastructure, rule-setting) for securing reliability.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 39 On a more critical note we feel that this theme is too generic in its current form. It works more as an umbrella for a wide array of topics and opinions. While it’s an important theme as such, it also has an air of self-praise about it.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 23 The wording of this theme emphasizes others' perception of us rather than the actual quality of our content.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 25 Wikipedia is not a "source" of information strictly defined, since we are indexing rather than creating knowledge. A better working might be "most comprehensive general resource for sharing knowledge".
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 26 The theme seems to emphasize competition, when we should focus on absolute measures of our quality,
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 27 The theme compares us with a very broad range of content providers, including news outlets and academic journal publishers, but we have different goals and strengths than these classes of publishers.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 230 The headline has unclear/unintended implications. We recommend headline revisions, that could look like: -Provide access to high quality and relevant knowledge to all people who need it. -The place for high-quality, neutral, and relevant knowledge in any language -Accessible, high-quality, neutral, and relevant knowledge in any language
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 224 We should not be the source, but rather a platform for understanding the experts and communities that create this knowledge. There’s an opportunity to clarify our movement is about verifiability. Rather the headline be focused on the idea that we are the “Most effective platform for providing access to high quality knowledge” -- this is where we can get experts engaged in our project.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 237 Incorporate primary sources directly into articles to show how the facts were arrived at - provide the scientific community a way to communicate to the public
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 35 Two possibilities for further focusing the theme: while maintaining the parts about sources, there should either be an emphasis on quantity/reach (the "most used source of knowledge" because people think it is the best) or the quality of knowledge ("quality as the new big challenge after the encylopedia is almost completed). If it is focused on reach it might better fit into theme C.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 243 When we focus on quality, some of the smaller wikis don’t have processes for quality standards. Also have different cultural influences. Also - the time in the US right now is a focus on verifiability. This desire to cite things is an added behavior right now. Do we want to call this out explicitly as part of getting to this end point? To be a cultural norm?
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 248 Challenges around: soliciting new types of knowledge. Types of sources, formats of content. New processes and policies will be needed.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 5 Setting standards for quality of content can also impliy setting standards for quality of contributors
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 6 Knowledge should be distiguished from a Wikipedia-article, contributors should be distinguished from editors.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 7 Reliable and verifiable data are a cornerstone of all our projects
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 20 The issue is the gradation of importance of content, more important topics and people should have longer and better written articles than the less important.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 21 The above was denied by other experts expressing problems who and how should decide what is more and what less important; there is no universal points of reference to decide it.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 19 It coincides with the idea of Wikimedia as well - an independent, reliable and neutral source of all knowledge.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 245 Needs accurate and verifiable resources that aren’t just known sources now.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 45 Filters and controls to have more and better content sources.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 46 Bifurcating paths with educational centers and integrating new ideas (1 lib-1 ref).
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 17 Wikimedia's trustworthiness could be measured against the TRUST criteria: Transparent, Reliable, Unselfish, Safe, Two way communication.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 228 Reads this as a major part of trust, and component.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 66 The focus should be on the high-quality content being useful for people, even despite being a respected or relevant source. Wikimedia projects should not just been seen as the most relevant source of knowledge, but actually contain the most high-quality and neutral knowledge there is.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 65 The volunteer aspect in “working toward more accuracy and verifiability” is missing in this theme.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 346 Special topic wikis
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 394 Past editors that contributed information that was scrubbed or removed might not be aware that their info was removed. The editors that remove the info are familiar with how to avoid being detected by bots or other editors. Thus, info is removed in steps.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 424 Work group and prospective workers we can partner with them through online and offline marketing.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 438 If content contributors were made to believe that their time and effort was valued, several other people might be working in this area. I no longer wish to waste my time putting together an article only to have it rejected by a clique.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 448 Other online wikis.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [724] Local wiki 20 70 Empowering Wikiversity can surely increase the visibility and seriousness of the movement as a whole. Cedalyon
Meta B Meta [725] Local wiki 49 The continued activity of WikiJournal User Group (and WikiJournal) is very beneficial for this purpose.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [726] Local wiki 14 To put this topic into action, I think the Wikimedia chapters would be good allies, since they can organize different workshops or sessions where these aspects could be explained both to teachers and other common users who are not familiar with our projects.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 336 Technology experts, content experts and organizations that share Wikimedia's values.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 341 Anyone who knows a good portion of a certain subject that we have on the website could advocate for us.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 406 Free lance lawyers specialising in copyright fields of law
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 473 I suppose with specialists who improve, update and correct articles on a particular topic, and giving other articles more accurate information.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [727] Local wiki 2 28 We should collaborate with scientists, authors and students.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [728] Local wiki 7 27 Reference librarians, archivists, fact-aggregating scholars, metadata mavens.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 331 Academic libraries are key here. Try to find partnerships with them to help improve access to information and help people gain access to their information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 443 Encyclopedia, national libraries and such primarily. In some way also web search engines like Google are working to make the information easily available, but focusing on different aspect of it.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [729] Local wiki 36 98 There is a shortage of volunteers for GLAM projects because of - among others - motivation issues. We need to have a way to apply for funds to pay people to do the boring stuff.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 2 For us Theme D provides the foundation for all the other themes. Wikimedia projects are as strong as the information provided and our reputation for reliability
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 3 If we want to be a truly global movement, we will have to determine criteria for reliability and quality that are relevant for types of knowledge we do not cover at the moment (e.g. oral history and traditional/non-academic knowledge systems)
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [730] Local wiki 62 Collaborate more with GLAM institutions.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 468 Universities, colleges and schools. And GLAM institutions.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 376 Journalism and "some" government agencies are constantly fighting fake news and trolling online. These groups need to contribute as well.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 414 Welsh Government
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 419 there are other online sources often wikipedia knockoffs
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 453 Some websites we should recomend is National Geographic, Science for Kids, and ductsters.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 483 Smaller, more specific encyclopedias may be able to contribute information to Wikipedia.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 428 It's important to find reliable international organizations(?) for representing both sides of the controversary in controversial subjects.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [731] Local wiki 36 100 The News Integrity Initiative and related efforts, like the Trust Project and the International Fact Checking Network. User:Cnewmark
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 356 universities, Glam sector
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 362 The scholarly society, various universities and science centres. Publish various papers.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 381 If you can get Higher Education to begin accepting you as a credible resource for research, then partnering with colleges and universities will be able to grow this site exponentially. Currently, most professors tell their students to not trust your content. I am one of those professors. When students are told by 5 adults on almost a daily basis that your content cannot be trusted, you lose a great deal of trust and respect as a source of knowledge. I believe the key to becoming a respected source of knowledge can be found in a partnership with Higher Education.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [732] Local wiki 63 Collaborate more with academic institutions.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [733] Local wiki 79 "How can we persuade universities to recognize editing Wikipedia as a high status public service contribution?"
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [734] Local wiki 30 The millions of teachers around the world who use Wikipedia for practical purposes, we could perhaps tell them that there is more than just the encyclopedia but also the sister projects. TigH
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [735] Local wiki 31 Researchers too. Allow them individually to use the Wikiverse as a kind of cloud for them. This would bring fresh sets of knowlege. TigH
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [736] Local wiki 12 21 It is worthwhile to collaborate with academic evaluation committees: their ability to validate the quality of information can lead them to remove reservations about using Wikipedia as an academic source
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [737] Local wiki 2 8 It is possible to collaborate with people and institutions related to education.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [738] Local wiki 39 We need to cooperate with research and education institutions to verify content, adding reliable and verifiable sources, monitoring and evaluating articles more severely.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [739] Telegram 30 65 I think a good idea is to do something like the Educational Program, but oriented to higher-education institutions (research institutes, councils). In Mexico we have worked with these institutes, where they learn that a) the writing model is different, and b) it is difficult to learn it, then they become aware and change their perception.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [740] Local wiki 26 We can work with universities to make student assignments of checking sources and correcting information in Wikipedia articles where the students have good knowledge about
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 478 Facebook is fantastic and I allow for my profile and pages to be available for new tests. Google reflects good innovation and a lot of the fundamental inequalities of copyright exploitation and combined with YouTube I think it's unconscionable how many artists and musicians are not being paid for their work while some sub par accounts at YouTube earn income for both users and the platform. Working to make the YouTube and Alphabet harmonious with Wikipedia, Facebook and good development at Google would be a step in the right direction. Combing my social and educational searching with my life habits has been so good for my learning process. I hope to see a complete package.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 370 Google Books, Internet Archive: share the processing of free books and other medias.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 458 Google.com, Facebook
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 463 Partnership with freemium web analytics providers, and shareware, plugins, addons and gaming developers should be sought in order to achieve the development of referencing tools.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 351 Not sources. Being a partner and a source is a conflict of interest.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 389 Don't know.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 400 application scale is so massive so.. i can't say anything sorry
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 433 society
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 559 No idea
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 19 Good quality content is more important than community producing it. There must be natural selection of editors and there is nothing wrong if only good writers and devoted correctors finally survive. There is no other way if we want to have higher quality content.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 24 For younger generation well sourced content doesn’t matter; they rather expect that trustworthy content is the one which is not manipulated, so the more important is to keep NPOV than verifiability; Wikipedia can resign from being very accurate but not from NPOV.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 25 The poorest part of Wikipedia content is its graphical side. Wikipedians seems to be reluctant in producing good quality info-graphics, charts and schemes well coordinated with textual context which make the overall content less useful in education; therefore we should think about outsourcing creation of graphical content; we can cooperate with paid professionals and NGO which specialize in such creativity.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 17 Middle.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 50 This is the most important theme, because if there is no trust in Wikipedia, all the rest is irrelevant. Ket (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 51 Reliability is the most important topic. Спасимир (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 52 This topic is closely related to Theme 1 with respect to the importance of attracting more new editors, especially with scientific backgrounds, and make the environment tolerant and attractive for them to contribute. Spiritia (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Australian Community A Australian Community Darwin various 40 8 We need to have better systems for keeping up to date with what is going on with partners and potential partner institutions, so we can react to changes in their processes, collections, etc.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [741] local wiki 9 4 To compete time we will need to increase the quality of the resource, and this will make us more reliable, and the central point of online knowledge.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 3 5 Wikimedia Movement will be able to reach thousands of students in universities and schools who are able to contribute valuable content to Wikipedia.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 13 Theme E's impact on the world will be in increasing awareness through spreading the knowledge to a new, wider audience.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 488 Hard to say. Diversity of topics is hard to achieve. Wikipedia has strict notability rules. Wikinews is not as competitive as its media competitors. Wiktionary is already diverse with a bunch of definitions. Wikiquote still has copyright issues. Wikiversity is struggling to catch up. Wikijournal, if established as a website, would invite diverse range of topics, though it would be written by mostly academics. Overall, the theme is just a theme, ain't it? If it's more than that, the theme would not impact the world much. Rather the theme is influenced by sources used to cite information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 492 Providing free knowledge and information for all
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 496 a bigger knowledge base giving people mor opportunities
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 500 Easier acquisition of knowledge, easier life for pupils
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 504 Many people have financial crisis giving free access to a pull of knowledge along with trusted sources providing free knowledge is a plus.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 509 This theme would have a global impact. It could help everyone to access any type of knowledge wherever a person or user wants . It would be like the the largest library in the world
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 513 We could be a leading organisation of the knowledge ecosystem and make free knowledge the default way of sharing information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 518 Quality work
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 523 In given four Sub-Themes (Education, Institutions, Educators, Existing programs) of above Knowledge Ecosystem Theme includes all section of knowledge ecosystem. These Sub-Themes can have impact on the world mainly young generation and people who love to gain and upgrade knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 528 It would mean knowledge has a position different from the position it has had earlier. To get knowledge people have to enroll with institutions ,when wiki is in the picture people will be able to learn and know depending on the limitations they may face.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 533 change in plus the number of contributors, editors, develop me and people in my sounding, the world will discover a new art
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 538 Wikipedia will continue to be self sustaining, embedded in the local infrastructure of knowledge, with minimal support of a central global organization. The way Wikipedia works will gradually transform the way other organizations work. Eventually hunger will be eradicated and peace will prevail on earth. Networking with partners is the final phase in the Greiner growth curve.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 573 Wikipedia will continue to be self sustaining, embedded in the local infrastructure of knowledge, with minimal support of a central global organization. The way Wikipedia works will gradually transform the way other organizations work. Eventually hunger will be eradicated and peace will prevail on earth. Networking with partners is the final phase in the Greiner growth curve.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 577 Following this direction would serve to connect multiple existing knowledge institutions with a global audience and a community oriented toward open access to all forms of human knowledge, while making Wikipedia content richer and more accurate.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 585 This will allow us to spread the roots of our system into more elements of society. Goals like global reach would be much easier to reach with this.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 590 Wikimedia would not only pursue its own goals, but also make the strategically excellent and smart choice to help other organisations fulfill theirs. We can't do this alone - we'll never manage to fill our knowledge gaps if we don't embrace, respect and work with partners.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [742] Local wiki 36 86 The impact might be negative if we are not careful to keep the democratic principles of Wikimedia projects. User:Leowikardo
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [743] Local wiki 36 106 This theme is not a "goal" in of itself so much as a support action to achieve those other goals User:Powertothepeople
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [744] Local wiki 36 116 Under this Ecosystems banner we need to think about how we persuade more organisations to be more "open knowledge" friendly, whether that be CC licensing, being archivable, mproviding Wipedia citations, or whatever. Kerry Raymond
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [745] Local wiki 13 47 More outreach, a better understanding of academic, journalistic, etc., better recruitment. Tpe.g5.stan
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 13 If we follow Theme 5 then after 15 years students will be able to study directly from Wikipedia in their desired language.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [746] Local wiki 2 29 If we follow this theme then we will become more contemporary.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [747] Local wiki 20 There is no risk that other actors of the knowledge ecosystem (such as Britannica and Elsevier Press will close down in the short term because of the competition of Wikipedia.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [748] Local wiki 73 94 Academics are not motivated to contribute to Wikipedia because it doesn't add to their CVs. In order to engage more academics we should change this. (Ilario)
Meta B Meta [749] Local wiki 50 We can be the integration point between the expert communities and the general public.
Meta B Meta [750] Local wiki 34 93 This theme would be futile and ineffective if most organizations center on Wikipedia, Commons, and Wikidata and give sister projects very little attention. The theme should be revised to suit sister projects well, so organizations would give other sister projects greater chances and more attention.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 5 Wikipedia is a source of knowledge no more, no less that that, therefore we should concentrate on providing good knowledge, so we naturally will become a part of ecosystem, and in fact we are now, although informally, so no any special partnerships with education institutions are needed for this. [5]
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [751] Local wiki 4 25 The impact will be big and positive; by being massively used in schools the students would pass their knowledge as part of the work of remembering the class content, helping Wikimedia projects to develop it's content on scientific and academic matters much more quickly. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [752] Local wiki 4 33 If we engage deeply in the knowledge ecosystem we will have to review the the intercultural rules in the projects and in among economically unequal societies, now on equal footing in the knowledge realm. User:Joalpe
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [753] Local wiki 18 This theme will have a big impact, because the pattern is already tested. The only thing to increase is our reach scale, by having more and bigger on-line and offline Wikimedia activities.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [754] Local wiki 30 It is the simplest theme, because we have things in our favor. Eliminated the other general sources, the user ends up in Wikimedia. Therefore we are a dominant factor on knowledge and we have to consider how to play that card.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [755] Local wiki 17 43 Like the French encyclopedia was one of the icons of the Enlightenment in the 18th century, Wikipedia should be ambitious and to become an icon of the 21th.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [756] Telegram 30 68 I think that Wikipedia is a widely used resource in the classroom, and its use will increase over time. However, this will be linked to the previous theme of "The most respected source of knowledge".
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [757] Telegram 30 69 Education can be a driver of change, schools are a niche to combat inequality and gaps. I think Wikipedia can be a vehicle for developing skills, especially soft ones, and developing critical thinking for the future of children.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [758] Telegram 30 70 The focus of future education is that the student should be able to correctly identify the sources, and Wikipedia can cooperate with that rather than being a repository of information.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [759] Telegram 30 71 This topic is not tied to Wikimedia's role in education exclusively. The "knowledge ecosystem" involves a variety of actors: not only academic entities but sectors of civil society, governments, and leading institutions in art, culture, science, and technology.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [760] local wiki 12 19 This will also in the future be the consequence of our quality.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [761] local wiki 12 20 We can play a political role for spreading information, by our attendance we contribute to hollow out national and traditional barriers for dissemiation of information, e.g. freedom of panorama.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [762] Local wiki 13 We make everyone in the world to be an active learner and a curious researcher
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [763] Local wiki 7 28 Wikidata can't play a significant role in education, because it has no space for explanations.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [764] Local wiki 7 33 Produce more educational materials for unbiased readers who don't learn easily by reading long, scrolling web pages.
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 6 We could have a cultural influence, a political influence, and a didactic influence, just by BEING a neutral source of information.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 45 Wikimedia projects that are not Wikipedia or Commons generally tend not to rise. It seems best to try to embed content in layers within Wikipedia
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 40 Free(ing) knowledge needs collaboration with other institutions.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 41 Wikimedia is one of the last resorts of non-commercial knowledge. This is a unique position that we have to defend.
Albanian Wikipedia B Albanian Wikipedia [765] local wiki 9 5 This will bring us even closer to the teachers, schools and research institutions.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 3 6 This is the most important theme for the fact that it has the potential to combine the other four all together. It has to do with the “truly global movement” since educational institutions often involve people of diverse cultures and backgrounds, it is also related to the health of the community since it encourages a wide range of group activities and projects, and it could even benefit the “Augmented Age” theme by obtaining useful technical suggestions from new participants (e. g. university students).
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 14 I agree that theme E is the most important theme, because it is going to help in spreading knowledge in ways that are unique and positive for the society.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 489 For now, "healthy and inclusive" is the most important theme. The "knowledge ecosystem", however, does not reach that level but is more important than the "Augmented Age". Still not important because various communities control and limit the information.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 493 The most important
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 497 very wanted but not top
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 501 About the same
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 505 It deals with a theme that concerns all and everyone associated will gain something.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 510 it is important than other theme as it help many people and gives access any kind of knowledge which they require
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 514 Wikimedia has been focusing a lot of its energy inwards, which not only doesn't contribute to social change, but also generated conflicts. Important for both our mission and internal peace.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 519 This theme increases confidence of the encyclopedia environment.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 524 This is an Ecosystem of Knowledge and In all other theme in which promoting worldwide volunteer contribution (Healthy, inclusive communities, include), The augmented age (Advancing with technology) through machine learning, this ecosystem provide platform to world wide knowledge sharing and expert of sub-themes can contributors and experts of all over the world give effort to make knowledge trustful
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 529 The theme is key on the other themes esp the first one, Since it awards an opportunity to diverse personalities to engage in an activity of growth and upliftment.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 534 my idea is to create electronic music in which I can express my own feelings and impose these feelings in the audience
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 539 Necessary for growth, comes after healthy community and global movement
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 578 It's the 1st or 2nd most important theme, in part because it enables Wikipedia to become the most trusted source of knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 584 Much like technology, I see this as a tool to reach other goals honestly.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 587 For me this theme is the most important one. We need partners to be able to fill the major content gaps we currently have.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [766] Local wiki 36 92 It encourages the new gen to help the world, and as our youngsters are very much into gadgets, why not use it for a better cause? Also, it is an all rounder promoter more than just focusing on one thing User:Supdocious
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [767] Local wiki 36 107 I have prioritised this theme as fourth (after Community, Knowledge, Technology) because I see it as a "support" theme rather than a primary goal in it's own right. User:Powertothepeople
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [768] Local wiki 12 22 If the other issues are addressed and promoted well, this issue will require relatively little effort and resources. It is important that we nurture people who can interact with the knowledge system (institutions, etc.), but we do not have to make an effort to lead the system itself, we are supposed to be the gate to all its knowledge and its diverse forms of consumption that fit each person / community. Obviously. Knowledgeable entities will approach us in a variety of ways and we will just have to be there for them.
Hindi community one on one discussions B Hindi community one on one discussions virtual teleconference 3 14 I think this is the second most important theme after Theme B.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 4 Hindi has been sidelined and perhaps partnering with like-minded organizations will help it gain the status it deserves.
Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion B Hindi Community Whatsapp discussion Whatsapp off-wiki 26 15 While one person says this theme is important, another person think that partnerships within the various communities is more important first than partnering with other organizations.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [769] Local wiki 2 30 This theme is really important and Wikipedia's survival might land in a crisis if we don't follow this theme.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [770] Local wiki 46 Theme E is more important theme A. This is the reason of the Wikimedia world. Wikimedia ecosystem, including readers, is far bigger than it community, which is just the 1%. Wikimedia projects have a place and a role and can start working involving schools, future users.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [771] Local wiki 73 99 An encyclopedia is obviously part of the knowledge ecosystem: this is a fact, not a strategy or an end. The problem is how we are a part of it, and that depends on the other themes. (Bramfab)
Meta B Meta [772] Local wiki 51 This is one of the most effective ways of achieving the Respected Knowledge goal, which could be achieved without augmented content and global reach.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 14 The most important thing is to keep and follow NPOV understood as fair relation of various POVs in the controversial themes, including minority POV proportionally to its importance. [14]
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [773] Local wiki 4 26 This theme is the one with the most potential to impact the world, with a change in education; however, although of great importance, this theme should be of lesser priority than the others for without an welcoming environment and clearer processes and documentation we will not create the contagion effect necessary for this theme to develop in the needed pace. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [774] Local wiki 4 27 We have to ponder that many tries to involve Wikimedia projects in education have happened and it is still an objective of many offwiki activities. None, however, have managed the viral effect of making this involvement pass from educator to educator. Until such effect is attained it is impossible to reach a significant portion of the educational systems, this effect is probably dampened by the difficulties and rule complexity educators find in the projects. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [775] Local wiki 4 34 There will be a leap of quality in the projects if we act decisively in the knowledge ecosystem User:Joalpe
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [776] Local wiki 16 10 Knowledge right now is stored in Google and different chat bots, written encyclopedia is an analogue of oral tradition, because knowledge is carried over from person to person. NOwiking
Russian Wikipedia B Russian Wikipedia [777] Local wiki 16 16 We need to give more attention to improving orientation and search of right and interconnected information than to collaboration with external systems (although it might be necessary for this goal). Ivan Pozdeev
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [778] Local wiki 19 This issue has enormous importance, as it could allow us to reach a large population, with resources that are already being tested.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [779] Local wiki 17 44 This theme is closely related to its prestige -- If Wikipedia does not have good reputation, no serious institution will associate with it.
Spanish-speaking Telegram group B Spanish-speaking community - Telegram group [780] Telegram 30 67 It is the most important theme.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [781] local wiki 12 21 This is where Wikipedia has its place, among all other, if not necessarily free, but at least open knowledge sources.
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [782] local wiki 12 22 This is very important and our primary goal.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [783] Local wiki 14 This theme is rated third, behind A and D, because vision attracts devoted contributors.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [784] Local wiki 7 29 To be a reference for education, we have to provide a coherent knowledge and not a collection of facts without references or contradictions.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [785] Local wiki 7 45 Wikimedia does not have a view on didactic, let alone that materials have been developed upon such a view. For a lot of people the gold mine of Wikimedia facts, data and images will remain closed, simply because it is not that easy to handle. User:Lymantria
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [786] Local wiki 7 46 Our volunteers mainly create and improve static elements: data, texts, media. Interaction with users, for instance in person help, may be a very important element that is missing. An example of how that could be an addition is a project like Ask Dr. Math User:Lymantria
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 54 New voices are represented.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 16 This has a huge potential for impact: This should create synergies that add content, functionality, and awareness, while also increasing the number of people who engage directly with content as well as contributing.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 10 Education, GLAM, and Library Programs are a way to systematically offer opportunities to new users to participate in the movement. This is a crucial way to engage with the Knowledge Ecosystem.
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 6 In the network of the knowledge ecosystem we aim for an outcome that benefits society. Creating and spreading Open Knowledge together with our partners in the knowledge society, our movement will have an impact to any individual participating in that system. It will improve the access to knowledge and provide participation in the creation process.
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 13 We will engage with new institutions in order to preserve knowledge and improve preservation mechanisms.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 20 Collaborative aggregation of knowledge will be a cultural technique that is learned, widely spread and acknowledged by all.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 70 We are always stronger together than alone. Having impact would be easier and faster if we partner with “leading institutions/orgs”.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 71 We need to work together with partners in crime to strengthen our work, to learn from others and to complete our ideas. Very Important!
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 32 Institutional partnerships allow us to reach people who won't come in through taking the initiative to click the edit button in isolation. While contributing to Wikipedia is a solitary activity for most of us, we should also reach out to those who are more socially oriented.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 38 The Wikimedia movement can integrate existing digital knowledge projects from many institutional partners.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 39 An emphasis on institutional partners would expand our community by bringing their staff, patrons, and other affiliated individuals.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 41 Collaborations are needed to diversify and expand content. In matters that the editors' community does not know so well
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 42 Making new partners is a product of future growth
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 57 It is possible to form Cooperation with knowledge producers interested in increasing accessibility of content rather than placing barriers to accessibility in order to maintain exclusivity
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 58 It is possible to form cooperation with knowledge producers interested in adding additional content to existing articles
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 21 We can be a leading movement, an example to similar organisations. --Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 54 Our influence on the world is enormous. Education nowadays is facing huge challenges and I believe that Wikimedia is capable of providing great solutions. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 53 Reduce digital illiteracy.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 57 Promote thematic diversity (more topics, if all Pokémons have an article, female writers should have one too).
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 60 We would achieve a significant improvement in contents quality and quantity, as well as their sources.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 19 In addition to providing Wikipedia (the encylopedia), Wikimedia will be the hub for scientific and scholarly knowledge based on open access. We will provide a platform for publicizing academic knowledge (e.g. primary sources). We will work towards a world where all primary sources and scientific papers are freely accessible and useable. We will strengthen our ties to partners ranging from education to academia and further an alliance of players working with open access (but won’t be creating the content itself).
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 21 Knowledge is no more created in closed shops or silos. It’s common practice that Wikipedians and scientists collaborate. We will work towards a default where all/most of the relevant sources being referenced in Wikimedia projects are freely accessible.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 43 In the present age it is easy to feel lonely. Wikipedia has community, discussions, conversations. Through partnerships with civil organizations working in this field, Wikipedia can play an important role in creating a social network around common interests, helping to fill this void
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 44 Promoting cooperation will enable us to create an integrated and interdisciplinary knowledge base that will enable us to learn about a particular topic easily and from different angles
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 46 Early childhood education projects, even before students can edit, are also important, because Wikipedia literacy provides skills to evaluate information that is becoming important in the present age
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 56 Building relations with various organizations and institutions will popularize the good practices and interesting approaches of Wikipedia. Спасимир (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 22 Like NGOs, give solution where the official education cannot or has not yet succeded
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 40 Educational projects create a reserve of editors (and therefore the subject is related to the theme "Healthy, inclusive communities"), which is important since there is naturally a departure. If there were no Wikimedia collaborations, the community would be smaller
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 37 Bringing in institutional partners can help create a healthy community by reinforcing our values.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 55 Different generations have access and offer their contribution to the increase of human knowledge. The precise and verifiable knowledge in Wikipedia helps completing the textbooks, and helps the cultural institutions become more accessible. Ket (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 72 Working together with partners is the most effective way to create systemic change and have a large, long-lasting impact. This theme should be a natural aspect of our work and incorporated in absolutely everything that we do.
Wikimedia Ghana User Group A Wikimedia Ghana User Group Discussion Ghana Whatsapp 9 2 The wiki becoming a trusted source of knowledge can happen through engaging stakeholders in the knowledge sharing institutions that already exist. We should establish healthy PR environments with them.
Wikimedia Ghana User Group A Wikimedia Ghana User Group Discussion Ghana Whatsapp 9 3 Partnership will help get access to information/content for our pages to become the most respected source of knowledge. Our partners can campaign/speak towards us being authentic.
Wikimedia Ghana User Group A Wikimedia Ghana User Group Discussion Ghana Whatsapp 9 5 Engaging the knowledge ecosystem will ensure us becoming the most respected source of knowledge
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 18 Wikimedia would be the entrance and guide to a world of knowledge. We would have opened as many doors as possible to enable all human beings to freely share in the sum of all knowledge. In order to achieve that goal we would collaborate with partners who teach and cultivate a culture where knowledge can transform into education.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 14 Cooperation with GLAM and education institutions means that the Wikimedia mission (providing free access to knowledge) sets down firm professional roots worldwide and becomes integrated into organisational culture
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 3 7 I do not believe we should abandon other themes, but I rather see this as a way to achieve them all at once.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 15 Theme E needs a great deal of attention, but not so much as to overwhelm other themes.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 490 Stop suppressing creativity and stop endorsing bureaucracy.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 498 mass courses to teach how to enter in Wikipedia
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 506 I don't think so
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 515 Stop fighting each other internally. WikiNews.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 520 No
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 525 Nothing
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 530 Perhaps offering or providing an orthodox web based platform.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 535 the thing you do is awesome, I am happy, I can benefit and use this knowledge in order to develop myself
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 540 This is the strength of local organization like chapters. The WMF should stop restricting the growth of the number of chapters.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 566 This is the strength of local organization like chapters. The WMF should stop restricting the growth of the number of chapters.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 583 Maybe we need to let go of some of our chapter focus if we want to do this. The thematic usergroups might become more important instead.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 589 We would need to stop always putting our communities of (individual) volunteers first. They have laid the foundation for our work until now, but a volunteer community will always be limited in covering knowledge gaps.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [787] Local wiki 36 108 There's the risk of attempting too much change at once, and spreading Wikipedia resources too thin. Better to do one thing well than lots of things poorly.User:Powertothepeople
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [788] Local wiki 36 109 Potential conflicts of interest when working with governments and other organisations. User:Powertothepeople
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [789] Local wiki 36 Stop pretending or make people believe that contribution is easy or without difficulty. TigH
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [790] Local wiki 37 We will need to stop confronting human against machines : intelligence against algorithm. TigH
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [791] Local wiki 2 31 We should avoid complexity whether it's related to articles or Wikipedia administration.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [792] Local wiki 21 Generalist encyclopedias such as Britannica are in danger because of Wikipedia, specialist encyclopedias are more safe.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [793] Local wiki 22 Scholarly publications often cites Wikipedia as a source and this is depressing and dangerous for us.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [794] Local wiki 23 Wikipedia should continue not to accept original research because there is not and editorial control which is capable of dealing with it.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [795] Local wiki 44 Our competitors (such as Britannica) will stay relevant if they differentiate from us: by having complete, professional, stable, and balanced articles written by authoritative authors, guaranteed without vandalism. They could also become a portal for a critical mass of data from various sources.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [796] Local wiki 45 If we fail our mission and become full of original research, fake news, non neutral point of views, recentism and little insight, then people would go back to traditional encyclopedias.
Meta B Meta [797] Local wiki 52 The majority of the established knowledge ecosystem is biased, and greater engagement with them makes the movement less dedicated to the Global South issues.
Meta B Meta [798] Local wiki 53 It risks tradeoffs with community health, in that it is important not to accidentally alienate the core of dedicated, but amateur contributors.
Meta B Meta [799] Local wiki 34 94 Business, institutions, organizations, and universities should stop treating Wikipedia as the central prize, possession, and network. Instead, they should refocus and restructure their own goals and then instead shift to other existing wiki projects that suit their own needs.
Meta B Meta [800] Local wiki 34 95 I hope the Foundation's projects don't monopolize their own competitors. ...Actually, if editors found their own interests not well-treated in Wikipedia, they should stop editing Wikipedia, stop treating Wikipedia like the only encyclopedic resource, and start creating their own encyclopedias, print or online.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 7 The problem with official knowledge ecosystem is that it always support currently dominant scientific theories represented by majority of experts, diminishing the less popular ones, but Wikipedia should be neutral and cover these less popular even if it is not liked by experts; therefore for Wikipedia is more important to follow its own values and rules than trying to join mainstream education system. [7]
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [801] Local wiki 4 28 Our efforts should be focused in correcting, improving and simplifying projects to create an welcoming environment to allow this theme to be developed with more success. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [802] Local wiki 4 35 If we invest in fundamentally altering the knowledge ecosystem, the proposal of this theme taken to an extreme, we will have to modify the dynamics and practices associated with the project. This means our attention and investment focuses would change User:Joalpe
Swedish Wikipedia B Swedish Wikipedia [803] local wiki 12 23 With more focus on theme A, it will also be easier to disseminate our common leisure time, so that we get time to take care of the various ways of collaborations when they occur.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [804] Local wiki 15 We may have to spend less on technological experiments and improvements.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [805] Local wiki 15 We may have to spend less on technological experiments and improvements.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [806] Local wiki 7 30 This area is potentially more important than the "Augmented Age", where for-profit companies are likely to cover much of the ground.
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [807] Local wiki 7 31 To become an educational reference, we should start controlling in a more strict way our content and its modifications.
North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians A North Carolina Triangle Wikipedians User Group north carolina Local wiki 2 15 This theme is the most likely to create quick synergies in terms of engaging with the scientific community, which should be an important goal if we want to increase credibility.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 298 Any learned society or professional organization with global scope should be allies with WMF, and our local communities should be more deeply embedded in their local communities of practice.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 56 It is possible to form Cooperation with knowledge producers interested in the desire to offer a community integration and an end to loneliness within the Wikipedia community
Wikimedia Portugal A Wikimedia Portugal Grupo de Estratégia appear.in offwiki 4 1 Know aspects of community participation through specific technical resources, both owned and developed by others.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 79 The Open Source Movement or the Movement for wireless community network (freifunk).
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 69 Build win-win partnerships.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 60 From the listed areas of collaboration, I would remove the 'entertainment' (as I don't see it relevant to the knowledge ecosystem). Also, w.r.t. the 'government', not in every country collaborating with government is a good idea. :) Spiritia (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 25 Political figures, visionaries, economical organisations.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 28 NGOs for sensitive and special social groups.
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 13 We may partner with: University systems, OER groups, Ministries of education, Scholars organizations, Research organizations, Knowledge sharing organizations such as not-for-profits, UNESCO and other international policy generators, other like-minded organizations
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 15 Work with institutions that have information of common interest to the humanity.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 54 It is possible to form cooperation with knowledge producers interested in giving representation to a field that receives problematic representation in the media / improving image / raising awareness of a subject.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 55 It is possible to form cooperation with knowledge producers who are interested in offering an innovative way to learn, especially with adult learners who have exhausted the "regular" learning methods.
Wikimedians of Korea User Group A Wikimedians of Korea User Group videocall video conference 3 8 In Korean, although central government have a lot of useful works, we can't use them, becuase of limitaition of law. We need to develop partnership with organization for legislative activities. We need to share common goal with them, and develop efficient scholarship programs.
Australian Community A Australian Community Darwin various 40 2 Potential partners need more encouragement, and provision of metrics etc., to help them see the value in getting involved.
Australian Community A Australian Community Sydney various 40 2 In some cases a single person creates and cooordinates relationships with partners - more support should be given for vital links in complex networks of relationships
Australian Community A Australian Community Adelaide various 40 3 We need better systems for monitoring and identification of paid editing.
Australian Community A Australian Community Sydney various 40 4 Potential partners need clear partnership explanation material for ease of access to background information
Australian Community A Australian Community Adelaide various 40 4 Sustaining positive contact with partners and potential partners, to build relationships.
Australian Community A Australian Community Perth various 40 5 We need to make our metadata available in industry-standard ways, so e.g. Trove can index our material.
Australian Community A Australian Community Darwin various 40 6 Some potential collaborators do not want to engage because they do not see Wikipedia as 'serious', or see limitations on what they'll be able to contribute.
Australian Community A Australian Community Sydney various 40 7 Partnership relationships need regular re-contacting and updating due to staff changes etc. (at the partner's side).
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 10 There are many organisations inside and outside the educational system and wider open culture ecosystem aiming to improve knowledge. They all are partners in a dialog where we are sharing our experience looking towards a knowledge society coping with future challenges.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 61 Educational institutions, universities, research organizations, governmental institutions. Knowledge as a bridge between international relations. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 27 Educators of adult educators, who build the new ways of learning.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 25 Builders of tools and interfaces who have intelligence to focus on less computer-literated people, who are still a lot in education.
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 26 Builders of handy tools that can indeed do a lot, like charts, math, drawing, 3d etc tools, suitable for education, better and more good-looking than others..
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 11 Top importance - We need to ensure the best experience for new users (which is very much tied to Healthy communities). Technology (Augmented age) has to support the building of the partnerships, and is part of what we have to offer. Engagement is made possible by the global reach of our movement and it is motivated by making a global knowledge source respected and qualified in terms of content coverage and quality. The knowledge ecosystem becomes stronger when its actors are working together. UNLESS, the community is not healthy enough to receive that influx of energy. Community health can be a powerful (negative) gatekeeper.
Arabic Community B Arabic Community Arabic community village pump Local wiki 9 16 We should try to enhance our efforts on reaching and engaging all individuals and underrepresented groups around the world in the knowledge ecosystem.
Chinese Community - Individual interviews B Chinese Community - Individual interviews off-wiki off-wiki 10 22 The community needs to think about the role of Wikimedia movement in the knowledge ecosystem.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 491 Not only information, welcoming everyone from different cultures is important to strengthen the theme.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 494 The modern knowledge ecosystem seems to be moving more and more to online accreditation's, Wikipedia would be ahead of its time if it were to start providing accreditation's for users that learn from Wikipedia, tracking the articles that they read, assessing their knowledge base. Accreditation is a huge barrier for those seeking employment, many people may be knowledgeable but lack the accreditation for their knowledge, by providing accreditation you will alleviate unemployment and barriers to employment.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 499 a common aim for this broader scope
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 502 Good collaboration with Google (Knowledge Graph)
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 507 Certifications of what people learn
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 511 try to involve small institutes and enraging people who have the knowledge and are eager to share that knowledge with others
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 516 We need a refined mission.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 521 Increased online and offline interaction.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 526 Involvement of maximum of volunteer from all over world of every field
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 531 Establishing trust with high profile education institutions. e.g. universities
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 536 as far as now I observed small number of people using this knowledge
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 541 Have a chapter in each country
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 548 Have a chapter in each country
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 579 There need to be clear strategies to engage both students and researchers in a global knowledge ecosystem that is open access. This includes deepening Wikipedia-based education programs and linking Wikipedia to other open-access efforts among academic disciplines and the humanities.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 582 I think we focus too much on ourselves here. Just fostering this relationship, and organisations that build it (like Wiki Edu) seems more important to me.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 588 We need to listen to, and address, partners' needs and not just push our own perspectives and wishes upon others.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [808] Local wiki 36 97 Thinking academics will take time out of their working life to write on Wikimedia is naive. First, academic institutions should take Wikipedia contributions into account in their internal processes. Retired academics are more achievable. However, Wikipedia does not operate in a way academics understand.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [809] Local wiki 36 99 Wikipedia has developed a bizarre operating culture which tolerates mediocrity, supports bullying and militates against people with expertise. User:BronHiggs
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [810] Local wiki 38 Modesty, wisdom and patience.TigH
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [811] Local wiki 2 32 We should improve this theme by focusing on collaborations and meetings among Wikimedians and promotion of Wikimedia projects.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [812] Local wiki 47 Wikipedia projects have a role in education which is not just to provide an already-done-research, but also regarding soft skills.
Meta B Meta [813] Local wiki 54 Develop protocols, tech, support, and possibly grants for making it easier to interface with other ecosystem communities.
Meta B Meta [814] Local wiki 34 96 A bit more focus on other parts of the knowledge ecosystem besides Wikipedia would help too. Encyclopaedias are a small part of the knowledge ecosystem.
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [815] Local wiki 4 29 Instead of focusing on attracting students we should focus on attracting teachers, each new teacher will bring all his students to Wikimedia projects. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [816] Local wiki 4 31 One idea to advance this theme is to do surveys with teachers, investigating the roadblocks that stop them from using and recommending Wikimedia projects. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [817] Local wiki 4 36 Involve education institutions; these institutions face the challenge to integrate new technologies in the learning processes daily. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [818] Local wiki 4 37 There is not enough research on the cognitive and sociological processes associated with the use of Wikimedia projects in education. User:Joalpe
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [819] Local wiki 4 30 Teachers who successfully use Wikimedia projects in their classroom may convince other teachers to also use Wikimedia projects. This "contagion effect" is essential for the use of Wikimedia projects in education. User:Danilo.mac
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [820] Local wiki 20 Knowledge seekers specialized in the handling of Wikipedia entries will be trained -- our hope is to build a new generation of knowledge suppliers and seekers, who will take care of the growing knowledge body that is forming.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [821] Local wiki 17 42 I prefer to say "cultural context" to "knowledge ecosystem", which sounds strange to me. I think Wikipedia is more focused on the university system, I certainly do not see any utility in the preschool level since those children still don't know how to read.
Spanish Wikipedia B Spanish Wikipedia [822] Local wiki 17 45 I agree that we should develop knowledge seekers specialized in the handling of Wikipedia entries, as sometimes forgetting a single accent spoils the Wikipedia search engine.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [823] Local wiki 16 We can ask many partners in different aspects of life: sport, culture, communication to join us to update news and have specific research in their fields
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [824] Local wiki 16 We can ask many partners in different aspects of life: sport, culture, communication to join us to update news and have specific research in their fields
Wikidata Community B Wikidata [825] Local wiki 7 32 Provide software support for open and reusable educational and training material.
Wikimedia Hackathon B Wikimedia Hackathon Vienna in-person 17 11 A lot of things are changing, and will find their own truth, and it might require a change in the way we communicate, be better at explaining our viewpoints, and what a scientific viewpoint is
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 7 Free Knowledge is the core of our engagement in the Wikimedia movement. Our idea can be maintained best in a growing and developing knowledge ecosystem. We can influence the development successfully creating networks. This does not mean that we do not need strong support by the other themes (e. g. community).
Wikimedia Chile - interviews A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) offwiki in-person 5 14 It is less important, since the work developed so far allows us to keep working on the content itself, instead of forging new alliances.
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 17 Participate in the knowledge stystem, especially in school education, to sow the interest and value of collaboration, community, and find/motivate future volunteers.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 18 As an access-to-knowledge source its usefulness lies in its use and that the readers can later be integrated as publishers into the ecosystem. This is essential to make knowledge sustainable over time.(original note)
Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup A Wikimedia Chile - Strategy meetup in Santiago (June 6, 2017) Santiago, Chile in-person 14 19 Provide educational projects attached to Wikipedia. Promote educational use. Conduct lectures, workshops, tutorials and create educational materials for use in the school system.(original note)
Australian Community A Australian Community Brisbane various 40 5 Wikimedians involved in collaborations should be supported in finding balance and consensus in the work they do between external partners and the internal communities.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 251 Nations of the world will measure, in addition to their Gross Domestic Product (GDP), their GDK: Gross Domestic Knowledge. This is the knowledge that they have contributed to Open Knowledge.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 252 Every browser, phone, and tablet plays content from Wikimedia projects using free formats. The movement actively works with other parts of the knowledge ecosystem to make this possible.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 253 The debate in academia about “Is Wikipedia reliable?” is over, because people have developed a more realistic understanding of reliability and verifiability.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 254 The development of the technology framework Wikimedia uses for knowledge curation is funded by a wide coalition of partners, and Wikimedia can direct most of its technology funds to features specific to the movement. Use of our technology (and the associated legal and social plumbing, such as free licenses) has become commonplace.
Australian Community A Australian Community Darwin various 40 7 Wikimedians can be intermediaries between the projects and external partners, and they need support in this (even if this means they're doing less of their own contributions).
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 255 It will be common knowledge among researchers and scholars as well as their professional organizations that documenting themselves in Wikimedia projects is critical to their own success in disseminating knowledge.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 256 Wikimedia hosts a set of wiki-like technologies that make it easier to produce and share knowledge broadly (Original Research). This disrupted the current closed/paywalled system/culture through broad adoption by educators.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 257 The majority of Wikimedia community members [will] have some experience or understanding of how to talk with other communities beyond the Wikimedia community. Now, many Wikimedian's don't understand how their work interacts with and affects the work of others.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 258 Most knowledge professionals understand how to participate in and access. Professionals don't fully realize what some of our organizing principles, such as "open content" and open contribution environments, mean for advancement of their own efforts.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 259 Community members, subject matter experts, and professors have come together to pool resources in creating curriculums that integrate Wikimedia content. Content is contributed, edited, and curated in such a way that students regardless of geographic location, can consume this knowledge, progress their learning, and be awarded recognition for their efforts.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 260 When we reach out to partners, we can offer them a healthy and safe space where they can make meaningful contributions. We have emphasized places of mutual benefit, where people gain skills by participating in our spaces, and we gain with more diverse and global contributors/contributions.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 261 Wikimedia, GLAM, schools and governments have banded together to make a freely accessible library of texts and digital media representative of what school aged children need to learn and succeed. Wikimedia and its partners provide tools for individuals and institutions to digitize, store and describe their materials. The library is available in all languages and can be accessed freely.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 262 In 2030, when people talk about the public domain, they will think immediately of the Wikimedia projects as the central source.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 263 In 2030, we help collate, define, and demonstrate, many best-practices to like-minded partner organisations. Less insular, and more bi-directional.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 264 The structure of formal education looks different because educational institutions and knowledge bodies have been connected. Less people are kept out, more people have a higher education level.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 265 In 2030, free knowledge will have grown dramatically in quality, quantity and diversity. It will be accessible across formats and contexts.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 266 In 2030, we will have responded to serious threats to the free and open internet, in concert with a coalition of like-minded organizations. We will have raised awareness for the ideals underpinning free knowledge and increased the sustainability of our ecosystem.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 53 Get involved in the ecosystem of knowledge because it is the best legacy we can leave to our descendants.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 54 This theme is also important for the recognition of Wikimedia platforms as a tool contributing to access to knowledge, by actors in the education system (teachers, researchers, laboratories).
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 55 The transmission of knowledge uses several tools and means including encyclopedias. And wikipedia is an excellent platform for disseminating knowledge.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 56 Knowledge is lost if it is not saved. So, wikipedia (wikimedia) should not stop sharing knowledge. It should not be selective in the choice of topics. It must be able to diversify the subjects and deepen actions in several areas.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 267 There is a clear series of paths from knowledge archives to knowledge users, and a confident path for hailing knowledge “consumers” into knowledge “makers/participants”
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 268 Wikipedia and our sister projects have become accepted standard in knowledge. Our content, both of the creation side and the distribution side, will be well integrated with the latest creation and delivery platforms. Other organizations will have a good understanding of how our projects and model works and have well established workflows to provide content for them based on their expertise and speciality.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 269 Every knowledge organization will find a suitable project in the Wikimedia movement which becomes their natural platform for knowledge production, consumption and dispersal. These projects evolve a set of tools and practices that are typical for the needs for each of these players. It will be a galaxy of many wikis.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 270 We can develop partnerships with technology organizations (part of the Theme B) and then serve as a bridge between those partners and others who may not have access to those same sorts of resources.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 271 We're increasingly acting as a structured data hub, which allows for different ways in which our knowledge can be baked into other projects, materials and structures. Structured Commons, Wikisource, and Wiktionary are going to be increasingly more valuable as structured data kicks in.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 272 Allowing for better scaling beyond the current dynamic. A lot of our community is very much dependent on the goodwill of external organizations, whereas if we were more oriented towards the network: its about win-win collaboration. It also better describes the landscape of the work our projects do beyond Wikipedia.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 22 Very important: If we define our role in the knowledge ecosystem we will have a better understanding of what communities we need and where we should focus within the community theme.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 73 This theme is more of a HOW proposition, about how to best achieve something, in this case becoming a central part of worldwide education. Education would be a if not the most important WHAT theme. But as is, this theme is about the framework and not abput the objective, and as such not very important relative to the others.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 74 Pretty important: We need to collaborate within our Movement but also with Partners in Crime to be stronger and engage e.g. in politics. We need the exchange to widen our view of the world and to learn lessons from others. We need to support those who are innovative, even if they might fail.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 75 This aspect has the highest potential to take Wikimedia’s impact in the world to the next level.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 19 We may not want to invite in global/institutional partners until we have a healthy, functional community to begin with.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 56 Diversity of content: fight intrinsic bias.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 273 This theme supports the theme B. For example, we should work with other free knowledge organizations on open source machine translation, rather than just relying on what's already out there, or trying to do it ourselves.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 274 This theme is the most flexible and independent. It's required for us to create a truly global movement, but it hasn't hard dependencies on anything else. Because we can partner at so many levels, with so many different types of entities, we are free to do so at any level of our strategic progress. But it's imperative that we do find and maintain good partnerships.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 275 Engaging the knowledge system allows us to conscientiously engage in both the diversity focused themes (A and C), bring value to us as theme D, and ultimately create more actors willing to engage with us through automation and tooling to unlock our knowledge.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 276 Theme D seems to go hand-in-hand with this theme. Part of getting other organizations to work with us is to engage with them in a professional manner. Partners have some clarity and understanding on what the Wikimedia movement is - and why that is valuable. When members of the movement reach out to new orgs that they are empowered to speak with confidence about movement, it's values and value, and how/why that is alluring to them.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 277 It will require work that falls into some of the purview of the other themes.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 278 This theme needs the most momentum behind it, with long-term sustainable work in both directions (inward and outward), hence is not the most urgent near-term priority. However, Short-term, it would be good to organize/improve/refine the details about existing partnerships and existing best-practices, structured in a way that best allows for (expected) growth patterns.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 279 This theme could be interpreted as a tactic -- how to get where we want to go -- as well as an outcome. As a tactic, it could support our ability to achieve all of the other themes.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 280 Choose our partnerships wisely - somewhat consistent with the values, but we don’t have to agree on everything. Each has a different worldview and focus.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 281 There is more focus on working within and among the ecosystems that could be benefiting from what we are doing. The mix of "formal and informal" education speaks to the bulk of the motivations and reasons for engaging in our projects.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 282 To what extent are educational institutions currently built on an assumption that knowledge and learning are difficult to access, and those institution’s business model is to provide that access? When those barriers to access are lowered, what does that mean for the institutions?
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 78 Movement players need to practice and learn working with our communities and with institutions and 'external' partners at the same time, and to navigate the diversity in cultures and resulting tensions towards collective impact.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 290 Many Wikimedians don’t know who’s affected by their work. Would like contributors to become aware of knowledge groups. Would also like knowledge groups to know how the community(ies) works.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 286 A sense of coalition - work closely together to preserve the free and open internet.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 289 Wikimedia as a place for producers of knowledge would be nice for, for example, researchers to be recognized and findable.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 293 Would be nice if ecosystem would get more involved in knowledge production. Technology like PAWS makes stuff open and collaborative by default, in opposition to the closed research model. Educators love stuff like PAWS - it’s just easier to have common infrastructure.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 295 We should get into the business of knowledge production. Take for example oral citations: it’s knowledge production. In a way, we’re producing something that’s cite-able. Would like us to make open, collaborative knowledge production space. Lots of evidence that people who work on things like Wikipedia might like knowledge production. We might be able to organize events, although not necessarily funding actual knowledge production.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 68 Scientific community (researchers, teachers-researchers, students, universities, etc.); Higher Education Councils; Libraries and documentation and information centers; Information relay structures and organizations (press and audiovisual).
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 77 Already quite strong, but maybe we all will work with allies we did not know we had instead of just “the communities”.
Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) A Wikimedia Deutschland (discussion at the general meeting of members) Bamberg, Germany in-person 15 23 Wikipedia - the encylopedia - is our core asset. We should focus on the encylopedia and shouldn't aim to include every form of knowledge (like manuals, recipes...) in Wikipedia. However, different forms of knowledge can be gathered in other Wikimedia projects.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 36 Having too much structure could dampen volunteer enthusiasm.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 283 We need a system to understand how we do best. This is difficult, as things are changing so quickly. For instance Chat - our articles might be too heavy. Voice might lean toward speak. No one besides Google wants to map this - and that’s to put them in orbit. - if we understand this larger ecosystem, we will be able to engage in it much better.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 287 Revised theme: We will build bi-directional relationships with a wide variety of organizations and communities dedicated to the ideals of free knowledge. Wikimedia communities will work with allies that they didn’t know they had. Our content and technology will become a central part of formal and informal education around the world. We will partner with leading institutions in education, arts, entertainment, civil society, government, science, and technology. Wikimedia will pull its weight in these partnerships, strengthening the broader free knowledge movement and reaching out so free knowledge can impact the wider world. Together, we will provide platforms for a new generation of people who learn, create, and care for a growing library of free knowledge for all.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 288 Revised theme: We will build relationships with a wide variety of organizations dedicated to the ideals of free knowledge. Wikimedia communities will work with allies that they didn’t know they had. Our content and technology will become a central part of formal and informal education and knowledge production around the world. We will build strategic partnerships with organizations with shared infrastructure (same/similar software, legal) needs. We will partner with and learn from pioneering and diverse leading institutions in education, arts, entertainment, civil society, government, science, and technology. Together, we will invite a new generation of people who produce, learn, index, create, and care for a growing library of free knowledge for all
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 297 We have been missing a movement-wide commitment to this. That it’s focused on working more as a movement and network to accomplish things together: something that has grown out of existing partnership strategies/programs.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 52 In the context of commercialism, our entire essence is based on non-commercialism, and if we become flexible here we will owe it to others. we can't compromise on that
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 24 It is not our aim, it can be dangerous, but it can bring a lot of resources to Wikimedia - impact, influence.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 296 We’re humbly engaged with communities. Trying to figure out how to frame this correctly...Many of our best partnerships can help inform the way in which our ecosystem is actually improved and so is that of partners. Sometimes people interpret GLAM as merely ingesting content; benefit could be more bidirectional.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 44 The important political work Wikimedia is doing can be added to this theme.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 66 Implement an efficient communication strategy to promote wikipedia and wikimedia.
Wikimedia District of Columbia A Wikimedia District of Columbia Washington, DC in-person 9 34 Institutional partnerships run the risk of being perceived as elitist and top-down, if not framed properly.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 294 We should be thinking about facilitating as many institutions as possible to collaborate. 1-on-1 partnerships may not necessarily scale. But public institutions might be able to enact or pioneer change.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 43 By working with institutions we can make new content available and free knowledge. If we focus on this aspect the theme could be made a part of the theme "The most respected source of knowledge".
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 9 Coping with technical innovations and facing evolving challenges to the knowledge society we need to cooperate with institutions and likeminded organisations as well as with governmental officials.
Australian Community A Australian Community Perth various 40 4 Reinforce Wikimedia's place in the wider world through more communication to readers (e.g. in libraries).
Australian Community A Australian Community Brisbane various 40 6 It is important to understand the focuses of potential partners, to most effectively work with them without frustrating their goals (or our own).
Australian Community A Australian Community Brisbane various 40 7 Learn the social, financial, academic, etc. contexts of partners, in order to better worth with their material and not waste time on things that aren't important to either side of the partnership.
Australian Community A Australian Community Adelaide various 40 7 A clear outline or map of sister projects, chapters, etc. is required, displaying where things are and where things belong in the whole WIkimedia universe.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 285 What does partnership mean? Perhaps that is working with allies - the examples we are using need to be more clear and evocative. What we are doing and with whom?
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 47 The subject of cooperation is not as basic as the issues of Source of Knowledge, communities and The Augmented Age. In the last three Wikipedia is conditional. But, for 10-15 years we have lived "within ourselves", and we may have exhausted the inner resources of the community and the movement. Turning to new partners is a product of future growth
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 48 The issue of "A Truly Global Movement" is less important to me because it will require resources from another, more fundamental or more important place, and this development can even happen without our push
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 49 It is impossible to give up on any theme, because all themes are like tools that are intertwined and connected. For example, on "A Truly Global Movement" - if non-mainstream population groups can not be represented - Wikipedia may be perceived as a site that represents a specific group and therefore unreliable
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 58 "Reliability" through alliances with reliable organizations.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 64 Invest in scientific writing standards.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 284 Many ways the cost comes into play. How strong is the “free” held? This is the ultimate debate. Economic free versus liberated. What does “free” mean? Some of our references aren’t free.
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 50 Collaborations enable the production of quality knowledge by experts, but in return sometimes the Wikipedia rules need to be adapted to the needs of the body of knowledge with which they cooperate and to find a golden path
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 18 However the Wikimedia project's content can be used as a good example how to recognize good knowledge from fake information by analysing the quality of sources in a process of teaching critical reading and thinking.
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 15 We ranked this Theme as fourth in importance. We believe that focussing on Theme A (community) and Theme D ( Most trusted source of knowledge) will of necessity lead to integration of the Wikimedia projects/communities in the knowledge ecosystem
Wikimedia Nederland A Wikimedia Nederland Utrecht, Nederland in-person 5 16 Institutional cooperation is one of the last phases of organisational development
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 14 Wikipedia is a useful tool for scholars - but not as as source of trustworthy knowledge but rather as as source of materials about everything which must be critically read; good place to teach how to recognize valuable knowledge and suspicious one; an importance of sources, phrasing etc.
Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting A Wikimedia Polska 2017 meeting Bydgoszcz/Poland in-person 14 17 In order to be really useful as content provider for mainstream, official education processes, we first need to have most trusted content, therefore theme D goals must be achieved first then we might think about theme E.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 537 Tom and friends not immune to the knowledge, we can cooperate
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 63 Involve large structures such as teachers' unions and universities.
Wikimedia Deutschland staff A Wikimedia Deutschland (staff) Berlin Local wiki 11 76 Stress the ultimate goal, education.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 581 I'd say we should make sure that we do as much as possible to foster startup activity in house, but with a focus to off load it as soon as possible. The WikiEdu model seems very important to me. English
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [826] Local wiki 39 Including Wikimedia in the broader knowledge ecosystem requires above all a legitimization, legitimization in substance by demonstrating more reliable information, and legitimization in form by bringing the institutional actors to acknowledge the skills acquired when contributing to Wikimedia. Pilou Tgy
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [827] Local wiki 80 We should direct resources to developing nations that probably want to collaborate with us
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [828] Local wiki 34 Involve experts to improve the verifiability of content. Zaxiphyvaxe
Wiki in Education A Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Outreach/Wiki in Education various various 20 12 We don’t see negative tradeoffs: as we engage with the knowledge ecosystem, its actors will appreciate how powerful and deep the Wikimedia Movement’s methods are, and will dedicate more of their energy to it. A benefit of focusing on engaging the knowledge ecosystem is that more resources (people, reputation, money) can be brought to the movement. That said, partnering with other internal stakeholders of our movement is also vital for our participation in the knowledge ecosystem.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 291 The movement can help to support, for example, universal higher education. More partnership would be needed in curriculum building.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [829] Local wiki 13 46 Wikipedia can not substitute for a higher university education just as one can not compare courses made by renown specialists and neophytes full of good will. Fagairolles 34
Meta B Meta [830] Local wiki 55 Make hybrid platforms that bridge the gap between Wikipedia projects and possible partners (scholarly publishers, communities of experts, academic societies).
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [831] Local wiki 27 We can make many Wikipedia projects about local cultures and landmarks to attracts local contributors
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 23 The language and level of complications of many articles in Wikipedia is too high - for education it is more important to create content which is easy to understand than too strictly correct; therefore we should rather focus on readability than formal quality of content.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 542 Their are global associations of Libraries, Archives and Musuems. The WMF could partner with them to spread the word that chapters do effectively collaborate with GLAM which might help increase the number of chapters by starting with GLAM partners. Don't forget Educational institutions. Think about CC, OSM, OKNF
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 565 Their are global associations of Libraries, Archives and Musuems. The WMF could partner with them to spread the word that chapters do effectively collaborate with GLAM which might help increase the number of chapters by starting with GLAM partners. Don't forget Educational institutions. Think about CC, OSM, OKNF
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [832] Local wiki 36 113 Research institutions - many are already aware of an issue related to dissemination of the research knowledge to professionals and the greater public, and wikipedia could help with this. User:Powertothepeople
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [833] Local wiki 65 Projects with GLAMs (galleries, libraries, archives and museums) are great but there are some problems with images: they are not well categorized on Commons; search tools on Commons are scarce; no way to adequately to appreciate quality images on Wikipedia and thus really improve Wikipedia; sometimes images by GLAMs or WIRs are used in a random way in articles. (Bramfab)
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [834] Local wiki 79 GLAM partnerships take time. We should choose target institutions between those that work in topic for which we have content gaps. There should be "kits" to help WIRs and institutions to work in autonomy. (Archeologo)
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 60 Establish "wikimedia" centers in universities, in information and documentation centers, in audiovisual information organizations, etc.
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [835] Local wiki 73 95 There will be more demand by GLAM for wiki-education, less demand for WIRs. (Ilario)
Meta B Meta [836] Local wiki 34 97 GLAMs, universities and EDU, Academy, TED, Open Street Map, CC network, EDU Groups, GreyNet.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [837] Local wiki 36 112 Government organisations may have funds for a team of wikipedia professional editors to create high quality pages rather than always relying on volunteers. User:Powertothepeople
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 24 Wikis can be thrown out of primary and secondary education system, if harassment surfaces. Education is hand to hand with community health and fun and has a rore in it.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [838] Local wiki 81 Focus on micro non-profits such as Partners in Health and the American Refugee Committee
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 512 Mostly partner institutes or organizations that provide knowledge for free, and also the organizations that provide long distance education
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 532 Various web site knowledge portals which offer knowledge on particular topics.They can be partnered with through linkbacks and support portal which would create information media.
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 59 Work in the relationship with the educational system, media, free knowledge-advocacy organizations, libraries, museums, archives, and traditional knowledge movements .
Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) A Wikimedia Austria (Board and ED) Vienna, Austria in-person 8 8 As a chapter of the Wikimedia movement we should set up programs to engage teachers, students and other participants of the educational process. We should not try to send our present volunteers and community members to schools and universities doing everything on their own.
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [839] Local wiki 36 110 The 'ecosystem' is vast so there are countless potential partners! Khan Academy, MIT OpenCourseWare, FutureLearn, university of the 3rd age, publicly funded government bodies (in countries where governments aren't corrupt), hackathons, etc. User:Powertothepeople
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [840] Local wiki 4 38 At a macro level, we need to connect ourselves with the global, supranational, and national networks of change in the knowledge ecosystem. We are not the only ones with this problem, and we are even a little behind in relation to other initiatives. User:Joalpe
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 59 Without involving the institutions and educational organization, Wikipedia risks self-restricting itself. Justine.toms (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 57 Wikipedia (wikimedia) should not be limited to contributors.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 495 Khan Academy has already started trying to do this, as well as Alison and some others sites, but none are as large and successful as WIkipedia.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 503 Google. Wikipedia pages and content should be more easy to access for machines (Knowledge Graph) to accelerate machine learning
Iberoconf 2017 A Iberoconf 2017 Buenos Aires, Argentina in-person 36 55 Development of free software for minority languages growth.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 22 Lowest, that's not our goal.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 58 Wikimedia platforms must no longer lack information about certain topics.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 508 Organisations like udemy, redwhy, lynda. We need to make them realize the platform we are offering will help their business also.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 517 Amnesty International, Transparency International, Creative Commons, OKFN, OpenStreet Map Foundation, FSF. We need to play a lead role in bringing to conversations/communities together.
Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) A Wikimedia Deutschland (Board & ED) Frankfurt am Main, Germany in-person 8 42 The theme seems to focus on GLAM institutions / the text is not clear enough. For the most impact we should aim at a variety of collaborations ranging from politics to tech to big player companies, including tech giants. Reach will only be possible in the long run if you don’t exclude those.
Wikimedia Foundation staff A Wikimedia Foundation staff various virtual conference 90 292 We’re more focused on community dynamics for knowledge creation and production, perhaps having provided software that everyone simply uses for getting work done in knowledge generation. Hopefully we’d be spending less money on non-technical things as a result of well established tech.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 580 Wikipedia-based education programs are adding valuable content to Wikipedia on an ongoing basis, and greater infrastructure for deepening that process should be a priority. The entire field of digital humanities enables greater online sharing of knowledge. Medical researchers and research funding bodies (NIH, NSF) increasingly require researchers to publicly disseminate knowledge.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 155 586 Cultural institutions, NGOs, transnational organisations like UNESCO...
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [841] Local wiki 36 111 Minority rights organisations: Wikipedia can actively address diversity issues by reaching out to organisations that stand for underrepresented groups User:Powertothepeople
Italian Wikipedia B Italian Wikipedia [842] Local wiki 73 83 Partnerships with cultural institutions will increase in number, improving content quality and reliability. Wikidata will probably be more directly involved than Wikipedia. Commons needs to be improved from the technical point of view. The community also needs to change the attitude towards cultural institutions, e.g. with simplified procedures, and to be more engaged. Contributors and experts/professionals from cultural institutions will both have to me more open and humble. Together we can become the greatest learning resource ever conceived. (Marcok)
English Wikipedia B English Wikipedia [843] Local wiki 82 Wikipedia needs to create partners out of its user base
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 53 In the field of technology, commercial companies have the potential to contribute a lot to us. Such as Google's translation tool. Insisting on the current rules regarding the prohibition of cooperation with commercial entities can interfere with our growth
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 61 Intensify training of contributors.
French Wikipedia B French Wikipedia [844] Local wiki 13 48 If we could get involved in the knowledge ecosystem, it would allow us to build a relationship between Wikimedia projects and what should make Wikimedia projects easier to understand, but also to attract new contributors. Tpe.g5.stan
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 527 Education, Institutions, Educators, Existing programs
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 62 Organize practical workshops to arouse contributions and organize contests around wikimedia activities.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 65 Have a motivation and encouragement policy for contributors, both nationally and internationally.
Dutch Email Survey B Dutch Email Survey email email 2 2 The Dutch chapter should partner up with universities. The professors should tell their students to cover in Wikipedia uncovered topics, with theses written for homework.
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 67 Train, raise awareness and increase actions about the use of the content of wikimedia platforms (articles and their various sources).
Wikimedia Israel A Wikimedia Israel Givatayim, Israel in-person 23 51 In order for educational and training initiatives to create a reserve of editors, a model should be created in which the project is not necessarily translated immediately into articles. This protected environment and training will enable them to have a positive experience and gradually become regular editors
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 15 We should learn about the process of editing Wikipedia in schools. Children can start with simple language errors correction, fact-checking using cited sources etc.
Hebrew Wikipedia Village Pump B Strategy/Wikimedia movement/2017/Sources Cycle 2/Hebrew Wikipedia village pump [845] Local wiki 12 23 I am in favor of joining colleges, universities, high schools and even divisions (under supervision and close monitoring) to Wikipedia. I think it will bring here regular editors who will enjoy the very act of doing + alternating editors who will donate their own and leave when they want.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 26 Younger generation sees Wikipedia as a part of “official system”, not the area of their natural creative activity (such as Snapchat or Instagram) - therefore the teaching of internal editing processes of Wikipedia is crucial if we want let them understand that they can also create knowledge, not only social and entertain content.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 57 Again, this topic is closely related to Theme 1 with respect to the importance of attracting more new editors and making the environment tolerant and attractive for them to contribute. Spiritia (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 58 This is the second most important theme after Theme E, due to the outreach to wide community related to science, education and culture. Ket (comments at the offline wiki seminar on 10 June in Sofia)
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [846] Local wiki 4 32 One idea is to reach out to teacher associations and other groups that congregate teachers to and discuss teaching methods. This might be more efficient as it reaches teachers and organizations already willing to discuss innovations in teaching. User:Danilo.mac
Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump B Portuguese Wikipedia Village Pump [847] Local wiki 4 39 At a local level, the painstaking small work, we need to contact teachers, act in classrooms, improving point by point the work done in schools and universities. This will demand an enormous effort from our community. User:Joalpe
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [848] Local wiki 17 We can coordinate with universities and education institutions to improve some specific articles as student assignments.
Vietnamese Wikipedia B Vietnamese Wikipedia [849] Local wiki 17 We can coordinate with universities and education institutions to improve some specific articles as student assignments.
Hindi Wikipedia B Hindi Wikipedia [850] Local wiki 2 33 We should collaborate with social media and websites like Youtube.
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 522 Global environment
Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire A Wikimedia Community User Côte d'Ivoire Strategy meet-up Abidjan June 10, 2017 Abidjan in-person 27 59 Involve and educate scientists, knowledge field's actors to make wikipedia and other wikimedia platforms credible in the eyes of users. For example, approach the teacher-researchers, to integrate wikipedia into scientific research works.
Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner A Wikimedia Polska Strategy Dinner - Warsaw June 5, 2017 Warsaw in-person 17 16 However, the current Wikipedia editing control is too strict. It should be made less aggressive to let children experiment; several school projects in Polish Wikipedia failed due to to aggressive adminship.
Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG A Wikimedians of Bulgaria UG Sofia, Bulgaria in-person 23 We can receive access to new level of influence, and we should be careful with that.--Vodnokon4e (talk) 12:09, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece A Wikipedia Community Schools Association Greece Athens, Attiki, Greece In person, telephone, social media, Wikipedia 17 23 Education is strong roots, has the most value as it builds for life
Cycle 2 Survey Collectors B Cycle 2 Survey Collectors Survey (English Version) Google Form 135 401 in my heart 위키를 배신하진 않겠소 i never betray wiki
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [851] Local wiki 7 1 These themes are not the result of the discussion on de.wikipedia.
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [852] Local wiki 7 2 "Healthy"? "Augmented"? "Truly global"? "most respected"? "Ecosystem"? Really? Good night.
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [853] Local wiki 7 3 Certainly. For someone having problems with writing articles he can find alternative facts themes here.
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [854] Local wiki 7 4 The phrasing used for the themes is disgusting advertising language. That's ironic considering that hardly a Wikipedia is more paranoid regarding advertisment than the English Wikipedia. The text chunks are bordering illegibility. The whole project is designed in a way that finally only a few bureaucrats will be interested in the result, because most real Wikipedians who want to write articles won't be interested into digging through this mass of unpleasant clutter. The WMF is proving once again that all attempts at involving communities are just a fig leaf. The message is that they don't want to be disturbed by editors. So it doesn't matter finally that the problems of the communities that were voiced did not make it into this high gloss advertising text. I feel taken for a ride.
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [855] Local wiki 7 5 Interestingly once again the criticism about the power structure has been entirely kept out of the strategy process, although it has been voiced many times. It doesn't seem to fit, they don't want to hear it. Would disturb the high gloss presentation.
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [856] Local wiki 7 6 The wording got improved, so it is not the blather it appeared to be at the beginning. One could think about one of those themes if one felt addressed. On the other hand the entire opinon-forming-process looks like brainstorming for young businessmen. Well, the whole thing is no concern of mine.
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [857] Local wiki 7 7 Even the discussion pages are pre-structured. In politics you call that a procedural ruse. This is a strategic discussion manipulation. The WMF staff is acting like apparatchiks of the CPSU. Nothing is supposed to disrupt their narrow-minded world-view.
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [858] Local wiki 7 9 The goals of WMF are primarily aligned to the reputation of their projects, which can be transformed into reputation for their functionaries and fundraising. And for this reputation conflict is less presentable as these inflated advertising messages. What makes me sit up and take notice is a certain abandonment of the encyclopedia as the principal medium. Are that really suggestions by a movement that mainly consists of communities? Or rather something that the WMF is reading into the process?
German language Kurier B German Language Kurier discussion [859] Local wiki 10 Healthy, advancing, truly global, most trusted, engaging. This is the vocabulary of modern exploitation. You are supposed to burn for your project and slave away voluntarily(!) until you drop. Such treates are best ignored.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [860] Local wiki 7 2 Our discussions of cylcle 1 are not represented in cycle 2. Insted we get exposed to an absurd list of themes. I support a Norwegian user who said "I don't see any relevance at all for me in this. It reads like something from a cult/fringe political movement (been there, so I know) or internal company promotion." ([1]) That is exacly my impression.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [861] Local wiki 7 4 The most important question: How do we change the balance of power within the Foundation so that communites actually will have a say. That would be a task for the next years.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [862] Local wiki 7 5 I am sceptical about the significance of the communities. In those cases where it really counts we as a community don't manage to get a consensus for necessary changes. So why should we be able to take part in Foundation decisions? In the real world we have political parties with election programs and voters chose from those. We need something simliar. Only that way we can distill one voice from thousands of voices.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [863] Local wiki 7 6 We do not need one voice in WMF and de.wp. At the moment WMF completely finds itself in limbo. It does not have any legitimation in the communities and elsewhere. It would be a giant step if this could be recognized as a problem even once.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [864] Local wiki 7 7 I could imagine a membership vote to transform WMF into a membership organization. Like this we'd have procedures of negotiations and decisions, of votes and elections. This is common in many organizations. But that WMF fears that like the devil fears holy water I can understand.
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [865] Local wiki 7 8 We could be asked which computers WMF will buy or who to hire. But a membership organization causes problems as we can see with Wikimedia Deutschland. A solution could be to have communities as members, meaning that each community has 1 voice. But this would not work without a corresponding structure (election programms, elections).
German language Wikipedia B German Language Wikipedia [866] Local wiki 7 9 As long as this problem is not seen we don't need to discuss further. The WMF is happy that it can do whatever it wants, although it does not produce anything by itself. For that it needs the free and self-driven work of the communities. Since it is proven that the communites are not able or don't want to transform this dependance into threat and pressure potential, WMF is acting just according to its own interests and does not care to a large extent if people care about that or not. You can see this in the strategy process. Although many contributors voiced a legitimacy and democracy deficit, that was not inlcuded into the allegedly participatory strategy process.
Polish Wikipedia B Polish Wikipedia Wikipedia:Strategia Wikimedia Polish Wikipedia 17 4 Long, general discussion about the complex and "pompatic" style of theme descriptions, which disappoints people because they are written in prohibitive, hard to understand, corporate style language and are too general and abstract to enable discussion about real issues.[4]