Gennemgang af administrator aktivitet

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page is a translated version of the page Admin activity review and the translation is 57% complete.

In a request for comments from April-June 2013 it was decided to establish, for administrators and other advanced right holders, a maximum inactivity time without community review of two years.


A steward-conducted review of the activity of bureaucrats and administrators on all wikis (concerning both editing and administrative actions) had shown that there are significant numbers of bureaucrats and administrators

  • who have never used their rights,
  • who may have used their rights in the past, but are no longer active on the wiki where they maintain such rights.

Furthermore, through anecdotal review of "steward requests for username changes" there is an indication that at some wikis these requests are either left unfulfilled by the local bureaucrats, or fulfilled only after an extraordinarily long time passing.


  1. Den maksimale periode med inaktivitet uden gennemgang fra fællesskabet for brugere med avancerede administrative rettigheder bør være to år.
    Til orientering, dem der har avancerede rettigheder defineres i dette dokument som
  2. Inaktivitet i denne sammenhæng defineres som overhovedet ingen redigeringer og overhovedet ingen administrative handlinger udført på den wiki hvor rettighederne opretholdes.
  3. Forvaltere vil regelmæssigt revidere aktivitetsniveauerne for dem med avancerede rettigheder.
    Revideringen vil enten være en årlig eller næsten-årlig proces, i følge beslutningerne af alle de nuværende forvaltere.
    This review process will examine all public wikis. However, wikis where stewards will not perform notifications nor removal actions include:
    • wikis with an active Arbitration Committee, e.g. English Wikipedia, as such projects can decide about their inactivity removals;
    • wikier med nuværende igangværende gennemgangsprocesser, så som Commons Wiki;
    • special wikis designated by the Wikimedia Foundation, including private wikis, fishbowl wikis and wikis operated by Wikimedia chapters.
  4. The following outlines the procedure for contacting inactive rights holders, the expected response from these rights holders on their respective wikis, and the process for removal of rights.
    On wikis where no formal advanced rights review process exists locally, the stewards or their delegates will:
    1. notify those advanced rights holders who have exceeded the maximum allowed time period for inactivity. Such a notification (notice of maximum inactivity) will be sent as a message to the user's talk page on the wiki where they hold their respective rights.
    2. The notified users should then post information to the local community about the notice of maximum inactivity they received from the stewards in order to discuss the matter. If the community then decides to manage these inactive advanced administrative rights holders on their own, they should contact the stewards at the stewards' noticeboard, where the messaged user could provide evidence to the stewards about the local community's decision.
    3. If the stewards do not receive a suitable reply as outlined above after approximately one month, they will evaluate the responses and decide whether to refer the management decisions back to the local communities for comment and review, or to remove the advanced administrative rights from the inactive user. The aim of this process is ultimately to leave each decision to local communities if there are any, which will be upheld and supported by the stewards.


  1. Some WMF communities already have processes to review holders of advanced administrative rights. Examples of such processes currently in use are:
    • minimum activity levels by number of edits or administrative actions;
    • maximum inactivity by time period;
    • a recall process;
    • a confirmation process.
  2. Most of these wikis with such processes also use an approximately twelve-month time period as part of the processes for reviewing activity levels of advanced administrative rights holders.
  3. This policy does not override the authority of any currently existing review processes of any communities, including any such more restrictive systems currently used by the communities. For example, stewards are currently confirmed on an annual basis by the global Wikimedia Foundation community; whereas checkusers and oversighters are currently subject to a higher standard of inactivity policies.


  • Den første omgang af gennemgangen startede omkring juli 2013. Den blev organiseret på Admin activity review/2013.
  • Den anden omgang af gennemgangen startede omkring januar 2015. Den blev organiseret på Admin activity review/2014.
  • Den tredje omgang af gennemgangen startede omkring januar 2016. Den blev organiseret på Admin activity review/2015.
  • Den fjerde omgang af gennemgangen startede omkring januar 2017. Den blev organiseret på Admin activity review/2016.
  • Den femte omgang af gennemgangen startede omkring januar 2018. Den blev organiseret på Admin activity review/2017.
  • Den sjette omgang af gennemgangen startede omkring januar 2019. Den blev organiseret på Admin activity review/2018.
  • The seventh round of review started in January 2020. It is organized on Admin activity review/2019.
  • The eighth round of review started in January 2021. It is organized on Admin activity review/2020.
    Besøg venligst disse sider for oplysninger om tidslinjerne og fremgangsmetoderne, og hvordan du kan hjælpe til med den nuværende gennemgang.